7 ms·
This is the perfect example of what happens when a programmer (or in this case a mathematician) thinks that the law operates like a computer. It doesn't. The
by nl 10y ago
This is the perfect example of what happens when a programmer (or in this case a mathematician) thinks that the law operates like a computer.
It doesn't.
The law is interpreted by humans, based on case law, and attempts to understand the intentions of the law as written.
Many programmers don't like this, but that is how the law operates.
(If the author would like to go down another rabbit hole, perhaps he should consider if encrypted information is actually published at all. After all, well designed encryption renders information quite close to random noise in the absence of a key. Perhaps making encrypted information available isn't actually publishing - maybe it is the act of posting how to decrypt it that is the act of publishing.
Note that here, the law would answer "it depends", and that is fine.)
- pliny 10y agoMore on this distinction is available here: "What Colour are your bits?" http://ansuz.sooke.bc.ca/entry/23 http://ansuz.sooke.bc.ca/entry/23
- Analemma_ 10y agoAnd the follow-up article, which discusses the usual objections that programmers have to the original article: http://ansuz.sooke.bc.ca/entry/24 http://ansuz.sooke.bc.ca/entry/24 . Particularly noteworthy is a comment from a lawyer that a key misunderstanding among programmers is that in law, the humans and their social interactions are the first-class entities of the system, not second-order distractions as they tend to be in engineering. This was a very enlightening moment for me in my journey towards understanding why the law seems so absurd from a mathematical perspective.
- haasn 10y agoIndeed, the only absurd thing about the law is when people try to flirt with it by treating it mathematically.
- haasn 10y agoI think this article does a fantastic job of illustrating why legal problems (determining or enforcing the Colour of something) can never possibly be solved through the use of (colourless) technology - the two are fundamentally incompatible. This is, for example, the reason why DRM has never ever stopped people from sharing copyrighted works - because DRM is trying to solve a legal problem (the Colour of bits) by using a function of those bits (technology), it is destined to fail.
- tedunangst 10y agoExactly. With a sufficiently powerful telescope, I can read an SSN printed on paper through the window bounced off the reflection from your watch from a mile away. But we wouldn't call that publishing.
- PhantomGremlin 10y agoI don't think that's true. I think there are phenomena like scattering and the diffraction limit that come into play that keep you from doing that. Unless you're watching one of those stupid TV shows where they make this look easy. Just call up something on the screen and say "enhance". Then zoom in again and "enhance". Until you get the result you want. The problem is those scenes are written by liberal arts TV writers who didn't even pay attention to science in grade school. It's not real world physics as I understand it. But, as Dennis Miller used to say, "I could be wrong". I'd welcome a pointer to some scientific explanation of how it is possible.
- tedunangst 10y agoPossible to resolve an arc second, though unless it's large text, a mile is a little far. Across the street for sure though.
- posterboy 10y ago> This is the perfect example of what happens when a programmer (or in this case a mathematician) thinks that the law operates like a computer. > It doesn't. It's illogic, inconsistent and incomplete, is that what you are trying to say? Or is there some higher order logic that computers can't calculate? > and that is fine From your description of what the law should be, "fine" could mean anything. Should I attempt to understand the intentions? Perhaps you are saying, you yourself don't have an issue with it, but that is not generalizable. In my own terms, that's an opinion. And that's a matter of fact. Albeit, I'm bad with maths and computers, so I can't prove it a fact.
- rhino369 10y agoFormal logic can only be applied to precisely stated prepositions. Formal logic would lead to bad things, for example, imagine a state bans sex with animals. You'd be guilty of having sex with your wife because she's an animal. The law isn't precisely stated so formal logic is the wrong tool. Law uses different sorts of logic. If you are curious, take a look at LSAT questions. That's the sort of logic and reasoning lawyers value.
- alphydan 10y agoSounds to me like a perfectly reasonable application or the law. Put all the citizens in that state in Jail. What were they thinking!?
- posterboy 10y agoNo, only those breaking that law are animals.
- posterboy 10y agoFormal logic is taught in law school and humans cannot but employ it, it's encoded in our brains. The lack of definitions, the fuzzy logic is the problem. Yet, I am often amazed by accurate law codes, and I am far more astonished by how wrongly I and others use those words contrary to their original usage. I accept that words are defined by their usage. I cannot accept competing definitions. Point in case, I wouldn't say humans are animals, and historic usage proves me right AFAICR from reading on free will etc. At best, a human is a mammal. But you seem to want to use the word differently, so, I agree that this doesn't really work.
- derefr 10y ago> if encrypted information is actually published at all Given the arguments surrounding searches of "private papers", I'd analogize 'publishing' an encrypted SSN to be somewhat like putting a document in the public square... in a safe.
- bradleyjg 10y agoIt's the same instinct that leads to things like the sovereign citizen movement that thinks they can avoid going to prison for tax evasion by referring to themselves as JOHN SMITH, INC. in court documents. It also has something in common with the well known xkcd comic with the punchline "why does your field need a whole journal". It is possible to for clever legal arguments to do fairly amazing things. When Richard Covey invented the Grantor Retained Annuity Trust (GRAT) he all but repealed the estate tax for large estates. But it takes a hell of a lot of knowledge, hard work, and luck to come up with something like that. It's not the type of thing that's at all likely to happen when you haven't even bothered to study the area of law and learn the terms of art or read the case law and instead just google up some statutes and apply "common sense".
- sandworm101 10y agoClever legal arguments win individual cases. They don't change things very much. Change comes when those cases are adopted or, in the the case of GRATs, not immediately shot down by the legislature. It is not the lawyer that initiates the change. He or she provides the option and the larger society either adopts it or not. GRATs (and similar schemes) exist because they are tolerated. Covey's real innovation was in convincing the right people not to move against GRATs, and in gauging the mood of the country at the time. I wouldn't recommend going out on such a limb without appropriate backing. Politics isn;t meant to influence individual cases, but any widespread change beyond the single case is nothing but.
- gech 10y agoI'm sure if GRATS somehow empowered the least of us they wouldn't be a thing. But because they serve the established
- amelius 10y ago> The law is interpreted by humans, based on case law, and attempts to understand the intentions of the law as written. So what you are saying is that "loopholes" in the law actually don't exist, because those loopholes run counter to the intentions of the law? Interesting!
- epistasis 10y agoYou're going to have to explain that jump quite a bit more. Oftentimes loopholes are from being overly specific on certain terms, rather than specifying intent more broadly.
- zyxley 10y agoGenerally speaking, "look! I found a clever loophole in the law!" - as performed by any layman who doesn't actually understand the legal system - leads to getting smacked by a judge for being an annoyance.
- tedunangst 10y agoThere's more to finding a loophole than choosing to deliberately misinterpret all the case law that comes before.
- geofft 10y agoThe term "loophole" doesn't refer to what we programmers would think of as implementation bugs; nobody is, e.g., dodging taxes by saying "these rules are for salaries under $100K, these are for over $100K, I'm making exactly $100K so I don't have to pay anything nyaah." It refers to what we programmers would think of as design bugs: the intent of the law does not cover the situation at hand, and it is not a judge's place to say, "Hm, I guess they meant to write a law about this." A good example is the backdoor Roth IRA, which lets you exceed the Roth contribution limit by transiting your money through a traditional IRA (which has no limit) and then converting it to a Roth IRA (which has no limit). It's well-known that you can do this, and the legislature has had plenty of opportunities to put a contribution on either of these two steps. But they haven't. It would contradict the will of the legislature for a judge to say, "Look, obviously they didn't mean that," because at this point if they meant that they would have said it.
- agumonkey 10y agoexcluded middle somehow. That said law is still a system with capacity and limited "power" that is not very different from a computer.
- sandworm101 10y agoI would add the concept that the law, unlike software, is capable of openly defying logic. Courts are permitted to dismiss case law and rule in a completely new and unforeseen direction. That's how caselaw evolves. Someone breaks the pattern and, should others agree, that new thinking is adopted as new law. All the important case, all the ones lawyers rely upon in arguments, began with a court or judge breaking from the pattern. That's why they progress up to higher authorities. That's why they supersede previous caselaw.
- trentmb 10y agoSorta like rejecting the parallel postulate?
- roywiggins 10y agoIt's not like you have overturned the parallel postulate, the old mathematical system where it is true still exists, so it doesn't seem similar at all.
- hobbyjogger 10y agoLegal rulings and statutes, etc. are pretty far removed from the type of deductive logic that can be "openly defied" in the sense that busted math calculations or if>then statements can be self-evidently wrong. For example, the case Olmstead v. U.S. was a big deal in the 20s when the Supreme Court said the fourth amendment protection for "persons, houses, papers, and effects" didn't apply to taps on telephone wires. I disagree with that result not because it "openly defies logic" but because my understanding of the underlying importance of privacy is at odds with those of the justices. That's not a dispute about logic, it's a disagreement about values.
- int_handler 10y agoI don't think that is the exact intention of this article. It could very well be that the author knows that law is interpreted by humans and does not function like a computer. The purpose of the article is to present a fresh interpretation of the law taking into account advancements in technology, of which many people in our judicial system lack sufficient understanding.
- AnthonyMouse 10y agoThe argument that programmers are ridiculous pedants who don't understand anything and should leave the law to The High Priests Who Really Understand These Things seems to get more than its share of support, but is that what's going on here? Suppose there is some thing the law says you can't publish. You encrypt it with AES, throw away the key and then publish the ciphertext. It's not at all clear that the law is going to punish you for that -- nobody can read the information anymore, so whatever evil the law was intended to prevent is not occurring, and anyway the government is going to have a hard time proving their case since without the key they can't actually prove what the ciphertext is. Now suppose you do the same thing but instead of AES you use 40-bit DES, which anybody can easily break with modern hardware. Now you're arguably publishing the thing, and the government can prove what the ciphertext is, so the outcome could be different. But that wouldn't have been the case in the 1970s when computers were slower. So what is it about the conclusion that the law could depend on the state of computing power and algorithms that you find so implausible?
- tedunangst 10y agoThe focus on computing power misses the forest for the trees. It's not about available computing power. It's about the intent. If you know decryption is possible, then "wink wink, it's encrypted" is a poor argument that the data wasn't published.
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago> It's about the intent. And now you've got yourself some trouble, because the intent for publishing the free speech flag can reasonably be as criticism of laws purporting to make certain information illegal. Then you're publishing political speech which is a whole different ballgame. But the better point is that people have become quick to dismiss the math, as if facts and logic and reality are irrelevant to the law. The law has to live inside the universe. It has to do something when the problems the math proves can happen actually do. So for example, the xor situation is interesting. If you xor with random bytes, the result is indistinguishable from random and is capable of encoding literally any information of equal or smaller length -- at the same time -- by changing what you xor it back with. So A xor B is the Declaration of Independence while A xor C is DeCSS, C xor D is the Bill of Rights and C xor E is a trade secret document. Now suppose there are some websites allowing anyone to publish xor-encoded data (or arbitrary data). Somebody uploads A to one such website and C to another. Anybody who asks about A, you can show them B and it encodes the Declaration of Independence. Anybody who asks about C, you can show them D and it encodes the Bill of Rights. So now A and C are being published by separate sites, each is indistinguishable from random, but xor them together and you get DeCSS. DeCSS is being published, but who is publishing it? Who can be forced to remove their half, when doing so would also delete arbitrarily many instances of lawful speech that require the same random bytes (and could be the only copy)? What is the status of B and D, given that you can xor them with public documents to get back A and C? What if you can prove that A is preexisting and C is derived from DeCSS and A? What if there is no way to prove which existed first? If somebody does this, there has to be an answer better than hand-wavy dismissal of inconvenient math.