4 ms·
It seems like a lot of the most well-known pseudo-legal BitTorrent "groups" (PopcornTime, YIFY, ISOHunt, now Kat) turn out to be one-man shops, and as such, jus
by derefr 10y ago
It seems like a lot of the most well-known pseudo-legal BitTorrent "groups" (PopcornTime, YIFY, ISOHunt, now Kat) turn out to be one-man shops, and as such, just completely dissolve as soon as their owner crosses paths with law enforcement. In some cases, these services are integral enough to the "scene" to be brought back by others. But other times, everything just stops for a while.
This seems like a bus-factor problem. Why does it keep happening? Why aren't these sites being run by multi-national teams that can survive a loss like this?
Even The Pirate Bay is "just" Swedish, so a sufficiently-motivated Swedish Government could shut TPB down. Meanwhile, there's no single country that could shut down e.g. Wikipedia.
- toomuchtodo 10y ago> This seems like a bus-factor problem. Why does it keep happening? Why aren't these sites being run by multi-national teams that can survive a loss like this? Trust. You have to be sure the people you're working with are diligent, careful, and won't turn you in (and likewise for them).
- drawnwren 10y agoI'd also wager more communication makes more vulnerabilities. Thinking back to lulzsec and dread pirate Roberts, both were caught thanks to communication.
- DSMan195276 10y agoTo add to this even more, Lulzsec got outed by a member who chose to cooperate with the FBI, and in doing so got a reduced sentence. So in many ways, your security is entirely dependent on the security of everybody else - if they don't hide their identity well, then your identity can be in jeopardy too. If someone starts cooperating with some type of law enforcement you're screwed, and if anybody gets caught and is facing a 50 year charge unless they cooperate, you can probably bet on which one they'll choose.
- Jach 10y agoAt least one CP group managed well: https://web.archive.org/web/20130119025623/http://dee.su/uploads/baal.html https://web.archive.org/web/20130119025623/http://dee.su/upl... "PGP & alt.anonymous maildrops, rotating keys regularly, where the bust only happened because a member was busted for non-ring-related problems and the only busted members were violating the Hushmail lesson by using a third-party service."
- derefr 10y agoIt feels like you could factor off the trust requirements into a much smaller kernel, though. For example, you could operate (your instance of) your pseudo-legal service yourself, but open-source the codebase (sticking it on GitHub even) and accept patches from anyone. You could also implement a simple replication architecture for your service, where at any time one node (yours) is considered to be the 'canonical master', and then other nodes can join the network as slaves, receive replicated state, and run as mirrors. Sort of like Linux package repository mirrors. With such a setup, arresting the original maintainer just means 1. a codebase fork by a new maintainer, and 2. a (probably manual) network master-node election. And that's just a setup that lets you stay in complete control without having to trust anybody (since you still "own" the codebase, and the master node, until you disappear.) If you are willing to relinquish control to the system itself, you could just build your service on a DHT or a signed store-and-forward hierarchy or a blockchain or whatever. There's no reason that things that are essentially "a BitTorrent tracker exposed through a website" need to have their canonical state anywhere at all.
- mrep 10y agoI think you just discovered the first actual use case for ethereum. Albeit, the architecture would have to be a little different and there's a lot of complications in that. It wouldn't surprise me one bit if ethereum came to be a way to host illegal websites considering bitcoins main market is for illegal transactions.
- thatcat 10y agobitcoins main market is speculative investment, its a good hedge against inflation
- dsacco 10y agoYou just described what.cd. What.cd open sourced Gazelle, the source code for the website and tracker. The core development team accepts pull requests, but they are themselves insulated from the owner and operator of what.cd. Since opening Gazelle, many other private trackers have adopted it.
- Aelinsaar 10y agoThis is the major hurdle in all criminal endeavor.
- josho 10y agoI'm interested in the problem of how you would solve a distributed system that is moderated yet guards against bad actors. To answer your question I think these are one man shops because they get shut down before reaching the size that you could have a larger team involved. Maybe if someone without a profit motive started something up they'd build a system that solved the problem above and could therefore last longer than a lone individual's contribution.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- DSMan195276 10y ago> This seems like a bus-factor problem. Why does it keep happening? Why aren't these sites being run by multi-national teams that can survive a loss like this? I mean, I would assume it's because it's shady business. Even if you made it multi-national, there are probably only a few places where you could reasonably keep the server hidden for an extended period of time (Keep in mind, these aren't Tor services or anything, they're pretty out in the open as far as I can tell) - and you're making money off of ads, so actually getting paid is another complicated issue. And really, if you only need one person, why bring in the risks of a second one? I don't think you'd be very concerned about "keeping the scene alive" if you're going to jail. Wikipedia is easy in comparison because most countries don't throw you in jail for running a Wikipedia server.
- airza 10y agoBecause realistically speaking nobody cares. Having people trust wikipedia to stay open or be at least backed up and not controlled makes them more likely to contribute to the upkeep of the site. If i'm downloading software for free from a list of public trackers, it is more or less completely interchangeable to me and everyone else involved in the process.
- johnmarius 10y agoIt would be a bus-factor problem if any one person ran all these things. But they're all run by different people, none is essential.
- ekianjo 10y ago> Meanwhile, there's no single country that could shut down e.g. Wikipedia. You don't have to shut it down, you can simply prevent access to it, like in China. Problem solved, if that's something you considered a problem in the first place.
- thatcat 10y agoWikipedia is designed to be easily downloaded and distributed in other ways
- ekianjo 10y agoEasily, only when you have fast connections. The smallest archives are in the 20 GB kind of range for the English language, and that's without pictures. And good luck finding updated mirrors for the content, or even recent dumps.
- spdustin 10y agoI can ship a BluRay disc or three pretty quickly...
- samuellb 10y agoI've used a re-compressed version in the past, with reduced xml markup, and with the most rarely visited articles removed. It was around 1GB when I downloaded it, and it used the proprietary MDX/MDict format. You can find downloads here (from 2010): http://sh0dan.blogspot.com/ http://sh0dan.blogspot.com/ Or you could just download the Wikipedia CD. It contains 5500 articles from 2007: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Wikipedia_CD_Selection https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Wikipedia_CD_Selecti... Neither of those two are very up to date of course, but it shows that it can be done.
- chx 10y agoBecause these sites do not matter? Torrent sites are pretty much bottom feeders but public torrent sites doubly so? The important sites are scene FTP sites, especially topsites where releases actually happen.
- zouhair 10y agoPopcornTime is alive and kicking. Actually 2 of them popped up after the demise of the first one.
- pbhjpbhj 10y agoCopyright infringement isn't a tort in San Marino, nor Ethiopia AFAIK, setting up there would seemingly put you beyond legal obstructions. USA government always have a way though, there's no way either place would stand up for their own citizens once the USA start threatening sanctions.