19 ms·
Why I won’t give talks about being a woman in tech
- pselbert 10y agoSandy Metz, of "Practical Object Oriented Design in Ruby" [1] fame made a comment about this on The Bikeshed[2] recently. She stated that she refuses to make reference to gender when she is giving her talks, though her gender is ultimately what got her the opportunity to write a book and talk in the first place. Ultimately she is regarded as an amazing teacher and a dynamic speaker, not because she is a woman in tech. [1] http://www.poodr.com/ http://www.poodr.com/ [2] http://bikeshed.fm/70 http://bikeshed.fm/70
- jesterman81 10y ago100%. I value her work because its well done. Not because she is a women.
- gluelogic 10y agoI just happened to have listened to that bikeshed episode last night. It's damn good and Sandy Metz is a captivating speaker. Check it out!
- sp332 10y agoA better title would be "I won't give talks about being a woman in tech". She's not against talking about it in general.
- programminggeek 10y agoAnd yet, she made the title the way she did for a reason and not by accident.
- sp332 10y agoI thought about it, but I couldn't figure it out. What's the advantage to the current title?
- trustfundbaby 10y agoI think the (and neither should you) kinda negates that last part of your point though.
- sp332 10y agoHer last paragraph makes it clear that she does talk about it, she just wishes she didn't have to.
- dang 10y agoThe first sentence makes it clear that that's what it means, so let's just evade this bikeshed by disambiguating the title above.
- mc32 10y ago"It not only is very insulting and distracting, but also pigeonholes you into “talking about being a woman in tech”, instead of “woman who knows her tech”. It feels like, once again, we’re delegating on women and other vulnerable collectives the “caring for others” matters, in addition to their normal job. That is not OK." Sometimes, identity, gets in the way of things. Do what you feel comfortable with. Do it for yourself. Don't do it for or because of others. Feel that you want to do it for your sake and for its own sake. Doing something because of agendas, can be good for the group, but, it's less clear it's always good for the individual. In a nice world, you'd be valued for many things, not just your economic productivity and contribution. And our identifiers would be afterthoughts. But for friends and foes alike, some at least, it's clear identifiers are important and some would want to find leverage and make use of the opportunity. Yet, it's not owed, and it's up to you if you feel comfortable with lending yourself for a cause, as it were. That said, just do what you like to do, don't explain it as a result of principles, etc. What I mean, our decisions don't have to be internally politically explained, or consistent. Just like liking or not liking broccoli does not have to be internally politicized to like it or not like it (or bacon).
- pg_is_a_butt 10y agouh.... you just did. you're an ignorant hypocrite.
- grb423 10y agoThis is very refreshing. Diversity is a key to strength but seeing a woman present tech stuff is my preference at a tech conference. I was at a conference recently and I heard a neckbeard, seeing a woman warming up for the presentation we just sat down for, say something dismissive about another diversity talk. He actually left without sitting down. His loss. The talk was pure tech gold. As the OP says, the diversity presentations should be left to the diversity professionals.
- searine 10y ago>I heard a neckbeard, seeing a woman warming up for the presentation we just sat down for, say something dismissive about another diversity talk It's really hard to take your criticism of a sexist dismissal seriously when you preface it with a sexist dismissal.
- shanemhansen 10y agoReminds me of a response once given by Richard Feynman (I can't find the source so I apologize if I misremember it). Essentially he was to be included in a book of successful Jewish people. He declined because he considered his ethnoreligious background to be irrelevant to his accomplishments as a physicist. To stave off the inevitable response that the experience of a white american man is irrelevant, let me leave this quote from the head of the princeton physics department: "Is Feynman Jewish? We have no definite rule against Jews but like to keep their proportion in our department reasonably small". So even in the face of systematic discrimination Feynman wanted to be known not as a Jewish scientist, but as a scientist.
- return0 10y agoSomething similar happens in science too. Anecdotally i watched it happen with my supervisor, as the latest "women in science" wave started about a decade ago. She got a number of administrative positions, which I increasingly felt she got "because she was a woman". That led to her being visibly left behind in her scientific field. It's funny, because she s far from what you would describe as feminist.
- sakaloda 10y agoDiversity in tech will never work. You are going against reality if you think everyone has the same aptitude to be good at math/engineering. Look at the data below. SAT Math by race [1] : - Asian/Pacific Islander = 598 - White = 534 - Mexican American = 461 - Black = 429 SAT Math by gender [2] : - Men = 537 - Women = 503 [1] https://nces.ed.gov/fastfacts/display.asp?id=171 https://nces.ed.gov/fastfacts/display.asp?id=171 [2] http://www.fairtest.org/sat-race-gender-gaps-increase http://www.fairtest.org/sat-race-gender-gaps-increase
- Tcepsa 10y agoGoing by your extremely tenuous suggestion that genetics is an accurate predictor of math/engineering aptitude because of how people of certain ethnicities or sex perform on the SAT, we should have a distribution in tech that looks like this: - Asian/Pacific Islander = 29.6% - White = 26.4% - Mexican American = 22.8% - Black = 22.1% - Men = 51.6% - Women = 48.4% In other words, roughly equal numbers of all of the demographics (specifically _not_ an overwhelming majority of White Men). So even if your argument were valid it seriously undermines your point.
- buckbova 10y agoAnd I bet this would be true, if women didn't gravitate moreso to the natural sciences.
- drdeca 10y agoNot that it likely impacts your point much, but does this adjust for population sizes?
- Tcepsa 10y agoI totally misinterpreted the data; for some reason I assumed it was the number of students from each group that scored above some threshold, rather than the average score of that group. My calculations are completely garbage, and I would withdraw the comment but it looks like I can't at this point.
- 10y ago
- someone7x 10y agoI went to ngconf this year and two of the talks that stood out to me were given by women. One was the angular materials talk / demo and it was amazing. The presenter was exuding tech prowess, I was blown away by how easy she made it look to make a dog adoption website. One of the best talks. The other was by the CEO of girl scouts giving a patronizing 5 minute talk about how we need all help women in tech succeed and change ourselves so the world can change for the better. One of the worst talks. I had those in mind when I read the article and for that reason I think I can see where she's coming from. When a woman just gives a tech talk, it's just a tech talk incidentally given by a woman. Isn't that the goal? More talks like the first one I described?
- jonnybgood 10y agoWell, I don't think it's the goal of a CEO of a social organization to give a talk on tech issues. Their focus is on social issues, so I don't see this as a good example.
- andkon 10y agoTo say nothing of the fact that it doesn't seem coherent to distinguish between "tech issues" and "social issues," this literally only makes sense if you think that the lack of diverse folks in tech isn't a social issue. That's deeply, deeply wrong. Of course it is a social issue.
- jonnybgood 10y agoI didn't say anything contrary to that.
- drcoopster 10y agoPerhaps then she shouldn't have been giving a talk at a tech conference.
- jonnybgood 10y agoThat falls under the purview of the organizers.
- jordigh 10y agoThis is called the Unicorn Law: http://geekfeminism.wikia.com/wiki/Unicorn_Law http://geekfeminism.wikia.com/wiki/Unicorn_Law
- jordigh 10y ago> No! The answer to an all male line-up is not a talk on women on tech by a women. The answer is diverse people in the line-up, talking about tech. At the last US Pycon, where 40% of the speakers were female, there were a broad range of topics. Several female speakers did speak about "soft" issues like being a woman in tech, but many others also spoke about "hard" purely tech issues. There were also males on both sides of the soft/hard line. You can see the topics here: https://us.pycon.org/2016/schedule/talks/ https://us.pycon.org/2016/schedule/talks/ I don't think it's a problem to give soft talks, and I think Pycon is doing a great job of increasing diversity. It's not perfect and there's work to be done, but I really don't see soft talks by women as an evil to be avoided. If people want to give soft talks, let them do it.
- btilly 10y agoI personally know several successful professional women who have a policy of refusing to belong to any women-only groups. Their reason is that in their experience such groups are populated by people seeking reassurance. The result is that they offer the "support" of lowered expectations. Which won't help you succeed. One also pointed out to me that if a group of men were to form a men's only business club, that would be seen as sexist. It is no less sexist to form a women's only club, but nobody sees fit to criticize it. This is not a bias against women in general. They just refuse to deal with people whose identify first as women, and only secondarily as professionals.
- kaeluka 10y ago> would be seen as sexist. "would be seen" talks about everyone, and I obviously can't speak for everyone. I'll try to anyway: A men-only club would be judged differently since men are perceived to be the privileged class -- a concern would be that in this club, unfairly obtained advantages are carried on. A women-only club is much less of an issue, because women are perceived to be disadvantaged as-is. Having them organise in a secret circle won't cause any damage. Beware: I'm not commenting on how sound this reasoning is, or defending or denying anyone's right to meet non-publicly.
- btilly 10y agoYou have indeed captured the standard reasoning. But when a group of people forms an exclusive club, the result is inevitably politics. And politics of a kind that is bad for everyone. It is bad when people in power do it. But it is also bad when people who are disenfranchised do it. The specific comment in question came about as follows. It was triggered by her recommending a book club to me, then having the organizer ask me not to come "because it would change the dynamic too much to have a man there." This lead to the woman who recommended it to me dropping out of said club because it became something which she did not wish to be associated with.
- undersuit 10y ago>Having them organise in a secret circle won't cause any damage. Are you stating a fact or is this part of the thoughts of society in general?
- 6stringmerc 10y agoVery nicely worded sentiments and I think it's a good counter-point, a rational and thought out one, to the knee-jerk habit of having a trend-chasing, "WE CARE!" framing around certain issues. This piece is strong in pointing out that "ISSUE X IN TECH" is not particularly a "tech talk" - it's more in the sociology/humanity side of discussion, right? I like how this tries to make that distinction. On a personal note, I think I appreciate the article a bit more because I could substitute "handicapped person with condition X" for the same kind of framing that she's discussing. I don't want to be known as X, I want to focus on the subject matter. If I happen to be an inspiration for others in the X group, super, great, blaze a trail and thank me later if you really feel compelled, but that's not the purpose of me pursuing success. It's not "in spite of X" it's just that X is another inconvenience in the way of goals, much like having to pay taxes or empty my cat's litter box, scope and effort aside.
- Frondo 10y agoPersonal story time...I was at a recent conference, listening to men, women given talks. One of the women, in her talk, uses an interaction with her daughter as the framing narrative for the talk (imagine Socrates and Glaucon, only this woman and her daughter). Almost immediately, three guys to my right start making fun of the speaker, sotto voce, making all manner of little jokes to themselves, that are becoming increasingly gender-specific. When one of them says loudly enough for me and others to hear, "Your daughter sounds like a real bitch! hur hur", I turned to them and said, "You guys need to knock this off now." Embarrassed silence. And it stayed that way. Of course, I'm a tall well-built, well-dressed white guy, i.e. all the things that automatically command respect. The thing is, I don't think those guys were bad people, I don't think they sat there in their minds thinking, "let's tear the woman down". I really don't think they thought about it at all. I also don't think they'd have sat there, chattering away, if a man had used the same framing story (father and son, father and daughter). I think there's a lot of unconscious, unconsidered, unthoughtful bias that they (and we) all carry around by default, that makes it easy to pick on weaker people if you're going to pick on anyone. And there are a lot fewer women around these tech conferences, and they're used to placating aggressive people, putting up with shit, etc. I guess, I wish women didn't have to talk about being a woman in tech. I hope they keep doing it, though, until people start thinking about this kind of asinine behavior.
- JoeAltmaier 10y agoWow I don't have anywhere near the empathy for those yokels mouthing off, that others seem to have. Real dipshits. No way they are innocently unthoughtful or unconsidered. They seem to have issues.
- Frondo 10y agoI don't blame them for personally considering, reflecting on it, and adopting a view of women that permits sexism. I think the culture is still deeply sexist. I think that's the default position. I think they were just aping the world around them, unthinkingly. I do blame them for not paying attention to all the women in the world saying "look guys there is a problem that we are experiencing," but you know what? That's part of the sexist worldview again! Dismiss the woman, she's just a hysterical baby, whatever, do anything but listen because you might be made temporarily uncomfortable as you realize you've been part of the problem, and need to change your thinking and behaviors if you want to make the world more just. I fault them for being shallow, unthinking people, but that's a big part of the human condition. :/
- cheez0r 10y agoThat sure sounds like what the tech industry always seems to prefer: walk the walk, not talk the talk; software, not slideware; etc. Be a strong tech woman and you don't have to advocate for them; your actions speak louder than words. Just ask Dr. Neil DeGrasse Tyson.
- not_anit_woman 10y agoI think you may be missing the point of affirmative action to encourage more women/minorities in tech... Just ask Dr. Neil DeGrasse Tyson.
- iamdave 10y agoAre you using 'affirmative action' prescriptively here, because that term has a very specific and understood definition?
- not_anit_woman 10y agoI am not sure what you mean, I was just commenting on the ease at which a women/minority will be chosen for a job over a "WM" every time, all else being equal, or even close to equal.
- iamdave 10y agoIn the absence of codified policies, rules or regulations, I'm hesitant to associate "the [mere] ease" of hiring a woman over a man with de facto `affirmative action'. Though I (think) I understand your point.
- dang 10y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12129860 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12129860 and marked it off-topic.
- pc86 10y ago
- cloudjacker 10y agoI agree Now for the counterpoint, there are a lot of people in the marginalized group that actually do look up to people that advertise their marginalization. Everyone that doesn't advertise that they are a "woman in tech" or a "black executive" flies completely under the radar. There are literally groups I've been invited to where people make lists of these inspirational characters, because they want to support their businesses more than others. And the people that never said "I'm a black female software engineer that got VC funding" never show up. People assume they don't exist, when the reality is that isn't what they wanted to be known for! Any compromises?
- 1_2__3 10y agoWe're not here to make people feel better about themselves, we're here to get things done. Someone who obsesses over marginalized groups so much that they can only respect people who play the victim are exactly the sort of people I don't want to work with.
- cloudjacker 10y agook, except there are other perspectives you have dismissed such as all of the competent people on the periphery of the industry that really are inspired by the women's list in forbes, or the immigrant that hasn't been exposed to the opportunities available for people like them yes, a lot of us are annoyed by it. we are annoyed by the pitiful "lead generation rates" these kind of talks have in changing any demographic in tech. but there are people that actually are inspired by them and don't have another adequate way to filter people. People see Elizabeth Holmes and think that "the man won't let them be successful" reinforced by a history of disenfranchisement, when there are plenty less dramatic examples of success that run counter to that theory. But when those examples don't write articles about it on Linkedin and Medium, people assume they don't really exist.
- cocktailpeanuts 10y agoI don't think the founder of Zipcar or VMWare got to their success by going to conferences and talking about "women in tech". They built stuff that people want. Period.
- not_anit_woman 10y agoThen why are we not allowed to have Tall well-built white men clubs?
- dont_spout_lies 10y agoYou are.
- dang 10y agoIf you abuse HN like this again we will ban not only the throwaway account but your primary account as well.
- not_anit_woman 10y agoban away...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dang 10y agoWe've banned this account for trolling. We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12130026 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12130026 and marked it off-topic.
- not_anit_woman 10y agoYour right, women get hired more easily and get paid more, so it is very much not symmetrical.
- xenophonf 10y agoAt least in the U.S., women get paid less: http://www.aauw.org/research/the-simple-truth-about-the-gender-pay-gap/ http://www.aauw.org/research/the-simple-truth-about-the-gend... I couldn't quickly locate a study comparing employment rates. Perhaps you have data backing up your claims?
- btilly 10y agoThe claim was pretty clearly meant as sarcasm.
- jacalata 10y agoIt's not clear to me, I would not be at all surprised to see someone make that claim here.
- clifanatic 10y agoI don't think he was being sarcastic at all. I'm sure it's true of younger women.
- xenophonf 10y agoSadly, that is not the case. From the aforementioned link: http://www.aauw.org/files/2016/02/Fig-5_spring-2016.jpg http://www.aauw.org/files/2016/02/Fig-5_spring-2016.jpg The median salary of younger women, ages 16-34, is 90-92% that of their male peers, a smaller but still significant gap compared to the median salary of older women, ages 35 and up, which is between 76% and 81% that of their male peers.
- dang 10y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12130029 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12130029 and marked it off-topic.
- jondubois 10y agoI don't think women have it particularly hard in tech. Some aspects are harder but other aspects are easier.
- smt88 10y agoSome of the "harder" aspects are being sexually harassed and intimidated in ways that aren't possible to do to men. I have a friend who was raped by her boss, and then he raped another coworker. They were afraid of getting fired, so they didn't tell anyone. Finally her friend spoke up and was fired. (This was at a VC-backed, Silicon Valley firm, by the way.)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jondubois 10y agoThat sounds terrible, but these things are quite rare. They should have gone straight to the police and pressed criminal charges. As a woman in the office, your main issue is that some male bosses won't take you seriously. On the other hand, if you're a woman, many bosses (female bosses and also some sympathetic male bosses) might give you extra help/special treatment (which is fair enough).
- james-watson 10y agoPrecisely. I am completely flabbergasted by the parent comment. How can someone allow a rapist to walk free? What job is worth keeping that interferes with justice being done? Which VC can survive a lawsuit resulting from firing an employee who was raped by her direct supervisor???? These questions must be answered if the parent's story is to be believed. If the story is true, it would be international headline news for weeks.
- smt88 10y agoPeople did not believe her. That's why she was fired. It was a he-said, she-said situation. Plenty of people didn't even believe Cosby's accusers until it was revealed that he himself had admitted to drugging and raping women. Even if people do believe you, you're heaped with shame. Who wants to make an "international headline" out of something so painful and personal?
- clifanatic 10y ago> They need to do their homework, instead of reaching out to the first “tech woman speaker” they can think of ... unless that homework points to a man being the most appropriate speaker?
- StavrosK 10y agoSoledad came to my city (Thessaloniki) for a conference a few months ago, and gave a very interesting talk on the new audio/graphics APIs in browsers. It was a great talk, and, I agree with her, much more interesting than "I'm a woman, here's my experience". I also dislike the mentality this mindset implies that I, as a man, should be surprised that a woman can code, and should therefore ask her about how she managed that feat, as if it's not pretty much exactly the same as how I started.
- lalos 10y agoEnjoyed 'but also pigeonholes you into “talking about being a woman in tech”, instead of “woman who knows her tech”.' Subtle difference, I believe that's the purpose of this up and coming podcast show that I've been following [1]. Women having a space to talk about tech instead of talking about how's it like to be a women in tech. [1] https://thewomenintechshow.com https://thewomenintechshow.com
- colmvp 10y agoI think it depends on the state of knowledge. The tech industry is well aware of the gender/ethnicity distribution. And quite frankly, at least companies, community groups, and profound leaders have progressively been doing something about it for the last number of years. It just takes time to make progress. Look at other industries which have poor representation of men or ethnicities and see how many inroads they've made in say, the last five years compared to tech.
- ktRolster 10y agoBecause I am fine writing, but feel completely awkward displaying myself in public! (I'm speaking for myself here).
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mhurron 10y ago> I don't think those guys were bad people, I don't think they sat there in their minds thinking, "let's tear the woman down". I really don't think they thought about it at all Yes, they are bad people, and the fact that they didn't have to think about going out of there way to tear someone down is part of why they are bad people. They didn't have to think about "let's tear the woman down" because they were already at the position 'she didn't belong there.' And yes, there would most likely be something similar with a man and his daughter, it just would simply be along the lines 'she's never going to get married if you teach her to act like a boy.' > I think there's a lot of unconscious, unconsidered, unthoughtful bias that they (and we) all carry around by default, Yes there is, and it makes you a bad person. You should be derided for it every time it shows itself.
- dang 10y agoPlease don't pour internet vitriol on HN. Rushing to denounce others as "bad people" is not compatible with the civil, substantive discourse we're hoping for. We detached this comment from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12129958 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12129958 and marked it off-topic.
- rfrey 10y agoShaming people - even dipshits - and fanning the politics of polarization has not historically been an effective way to change attitudes. I totally understand the feelings of righteous rage and desire for justice. I've often imagined scenarios where the target of my wrath is so shocked by somebody's contempt for them that they re-examine their attitudes and positions. But that's a fantasy. In reality, shaming obese people leads to more obese (but now psychologically damaged) people; shaming racists leads to people resurrecting the confederate flag and "all lives matter" movements; and shaming misogynists leads to idiocies like mens' rights groups. Do you want to feel good, or do you want to change things?
- eropple 10y ago> Yes there is, and it makes you a bad person You're reaching here, and it damages the rest of your post. No one person is responsible for the weight of the societal programming that we all share. (Mind, some of the strongest defenders of patriarchy are women.) Recognizing our unconscious biases and working to counteract them is part of the job of being good, but for many people, especially those whose circles don't bring them in contact with people working in social activism, there really is a "too big to see" aspect to it. Derision doesn't work (though sometimes it's more fun than it should be), and I've tried to swear off the tactic.
- thonos 10y agoI went to a recent tech conference and a few things came back when I read this article. In particular that the conf had a lot more female talkers than male ones (It was curated and invitation based). Most talks were good but a handful were nuggets where clearly the deciding factor why that person got the talk was because she was a woman and not her expertise in the area. Your typical dose of women who code talks were im there too but one that stood our from the rest was a woman who thought she kept having to tell people things like "use your slackbot to tell people to stop using 'guys' and 'team' instead." or "women need remote work so they can cry silently when their male colleagues steal their ideas". I am not denying that there are gender issues in tech (though in my career path I have yet to encounter them), but I paid good money out of my own pocket for that conference. I am not going there to see you speak. I am going there to learn and get value for my money.
- wccrawford 10y agoMy wife gave a tech talk locally earlier this year and I didn't even think anything about her gender in regards to the conference until just now. Thinking back, there were very few women giving talks that day, and none of them were about 'women in tech'. My wife does talk about being a woman in tech, but not in conferences. And in general she says, "Whatever, use the term 'guys' if you want. It doesn't matter." She's more worried about people treating her differently (changing their speech patterns when she's around!) than anything else, I think. The idea that women should work remotely so they can cry if they get upset is... Horrifying. For many reasons. First, that women should cry if unfair things happen. And that guys shouldn't, or that they don't have a reaction at all. (Hint: They do.) Would some prefer it? Sure, but so would some guys, for the same reason. And other reasons. Anyhow, good on Soledad for insisting on talking about the things that she wants to, instead of being pigeon-holed. In the end, I suspect her talks about actual tech are a lot more effective at raising awareness of the women-in-tech issues than talks on the subject itself would be.
- kafkaesq 10y agoMost talks were good but a handful were nuggets where clearly the deciding factor why that person got the talk was because she was a woman and not her expertise in the area. And how did you come to "know" this, exactly? As opposed to merely speculating that that's what the deciding factor was? Really, now -- please do tell.
- renegadesensei 10y agoI feel similarly about being a black guy in the tech industry. It is always the deliberate efforts to "reach out" to minorities that make me feel the most uncomfortable and unwelcome. I have given talks on AWS, Cassandra, Python, and other subjects. You could never get me to talk about "being a minority in tech." Similarly I live in Tokyo and have no interest writing or talking about "being black in Japan." Thoughts from my blog: https://righteousruminations.blogspot.com/2014/11/another-side-of-diversity.html https://righteousruminations.blogspot.com/2014/11/another-si... Recent thoughts on tokenism: https://righteousruminations.blogspot.com/2016/07/on-changing-characters-race-and-gender.html https://righteousruminations.blogspot.com/2016/07/on-changin...
- onetwotree 10y agoIt's really bullshit to ask people from disadvantaged groups to take on additional responsibilities and "educate" their less disadvantaged peers. To give an example that is, in my opinion, much more disturbing, but qualitatively similar, my friend, who's a trans guy, was living in a sober house a while back. The manager demanded that he reveal his gender identity (he passes like a pro, beard and everything) to his conservative, homophobic roommates. The manager seemed to be well intentioned and wanted to "teach the roommates a less about diversity", but hey guess what, that's not my friend's fucking job. His "job" in sober living, simply put, is to stay sober. He did so with flying colors, but someone with a more tenuous recovery could easily have been pushed over the edge by this bs. Similarly, it's not the job of women in tech to represent other women and try to force cultural changes. It's their job to be good at tech.
- droopybuns 10y agoI respect this person's rationale. I'm thankful to hear her perspective. I know lots of incredible women in tech doing great things. I assume they and everyone else wakes up each day and has to figure out what challenges they'll be overcoming, and how they will end up spending their one life on this earth. So this public rejection of gender-specific talks nourishes me, because I am dropping all packets when someone starts to talk about gender or privilege issues. I feel that enthusiasm for these topics is a tell that the speaker is a narcissist who believes other people exist to either validate their own opinions or serve as an adversary. It is uncompassionate. I suspect a group of academics organically instrumented a taxonomy that directly mirrors established trolling tactics. They have spent the last 10 years providing gender studies philosophies that are being implemented by graduates- who will now get to discover firsthand whether these ideas are constructive. Kids now think that disagreement is evidence of cultural misogyny and racism. Well, I disagree, but I'm not going to bother trying to engage with this type of person. Where is your diversity now? How is your behavior going to cultivate the outcome you desire? It's left me feeling exhausted and repulsed by the topic. I'm wary of some women in tech now because of their enthusiasm for these ideas. It is very frustrating. I'd like to support them, but I also want to lead a happy life. I want positive, encouraging people around me. The privilege crowd just doesn't seem healthy. This person seems pretty thoughtful. She has nothing to gain from posting something like this. I feel a little less cynical after reading her post.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- socalnate1 10y agoI can't wait to hear what a bunch of white men think about this article!
- Meegul 10y agoBecause people's opinions should totally be discounted based on the color of their skin! Privileged or not, I will never support those who try to fight that privilege with discrimination and censorship.
- socalnate1 10y agoNot discounting, but we really must at acknowledge the irony that this discussion on women/diversity in tech is largely being undertaken by white men.
- dang 10y agoAcknowledging irony is fine, but posting uncivil, unsubstantive comments like https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12130815 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12130815 is not fine; please don't do so here.
- 415Kathleem 10y agoWhile I can certainly understand where the woman who wrote this article is coming from, I really enjoy hearing and seeing women in tech. I work in tech, albeit peripherally (EA/Admin role at the moment, just getting in the door), and 99% of the time I feel like I've wandered into a men's club. I am treated really well by my male colleagues (I'm lucky enough to work with a group of kind, talented people, though), and generally am treated well by the men I meet at meetups and the SF tech scene, but they don't see me as a threat. I'm not on GitHub responding to code reviews and changing things they've worked on. I'm not competing for their jobs. I have a feeling that the second that happened, a large percentage of the men who are now cordial to me would be less than that. I guess my point is that though I see why nobody wants to be a token female on a panel, and nobody should be coerced into giving talks they're uncomfortable or unqualified for, as a woman just stepping into the scene, it would be really great to see more women speaking out visibly in the field.
- forgottenpass 10y agoI have a feeling that the second that happened, a large percentage of the men who are now cordial to me would be less than that. If you expect it, then that's how you'll perceive it. Even if they're just worried about the project quality. They might even be treating you with kid gloves compared to their male colleagues. But if you expect to find it, you'll find it.
- pritianka 10y agoI 100% agree with this article. Whenever I am invited to talk, I always speak about my work and expertise, as opposed to women in tech stuff, because being there and being good at what I do, is much more effective than statements about diversity (IMHO). The only time I've done women in tech type conversations, it's been in small, intimate settings for an all-female audience. In that scenario, it makes sense to discuss the challenges and learn from each other.
- skylan_q 10y agoIf there is no gender parity, there is a problem. No, there isn't. We don't have a "gender parity problem" in nursing, pre-k education, garbage collection, nor boilermaking. Just because it isn't 50/50 doesn't mean it's a problem.
- busterarm 10y agoWhere's my Barbie Sanitation Shift Supervisor and matching Ken Stay-At-Home Parent/Blogger dolls?
- logfromblammo 10y agoThey're in your fabric and sewing machine, waiting for you to let them out.
- busterarm 10y agoI'm a man and I own a sewing machine! And I use it!
- zer00eyz 10y agoHave an up vote! As a guy who does this, and is out and proud about it to his other male friends I have to say the reaction I get has been only positive. Then again I'm also the one you call to help move or fix something with a soldering iron or a power tool. A sewing machine is a dangerous power tool and not to be approached in a casual way. Sewing is a lot more forgiving than wood assuming your working with fabric. It is a lot less forgiving if your working with plastics or leather (holes are forever).
- mpweiher 10y agoThey'll be there if and when customers demand them.
- busterarm 10y ago
- ivanhoe 10y agoHuge respect for this lady, both for the attitude and for all the interesting tech stuff that she does...
- qwertyuiop924 10y agoYes. I agree. So much. These are my metrics for a good tech talk: 1) It is informative 2) It is entertaining 3) It is actually about tech Well IAWAT (I Am A Woman In Tech) talks can be 1 and 2, they cannot be 3. That would be okay, if they were informative or entertaining, but they so often aren't. Many just quote the same statistics we've heard before, and call for change. There is a reason that I will watch Piotr Szotkowski's "Standard Library, Uncommon Uses," Or Linus Torvalds' talk on Git, or Hilary Mason's opening talk at FutureStack, or absolutely every talk Bryan Cantrill does (even if it IS just to play Bryan Cantrill Bingo), or countless other talks whose names I forget. Because they are informative, they are entertaining, and they are about tech. And male or female, if you give a good talk, I'll listen. If you just want to get on the stage and talk about your gender, then I will be out of your talk faster than an ICMP packet travelling down an empty fiber cable.
- ap0 10y agoShowing that women have great technical aptitude by giving a legitimately interesting tech talk is much better for the cause of promoting diversity than just talking about being a woman or minority in tech, IMO. I worked at a large online retailer that catered primarily to women, and internally there was a large push to hire more women. We hired two women on my team. One was fantastic, one was horrible. The fantastic one passed the interview loop without reservation, and would have been hired regardless of her gender. The other did not do as well and multiple people had reservations, but she was hired anyway. She was an immediate burden and terminated after three months. The first one didn't need any sort of handicap for being a woman -- she was qualified and competent. The other one just didn't belong in this role. But management aimed for diversity over competence, and ended up hurting morale. Treating people like equals is the best way to achieve equality. Don't insult them, and don't let those who legitimately don't have the skills necessary through because of their identity. Seems pretty common sense to me.
- cocktailpeanuts 10y agoI'm glad there actually is a competent woman who can say this out loud. Nowadays it's impossible to say anything against "We need more women in tech" without being called a sexist. I do realize it is harder for women but the world is not a fair place. Poor people who were born to poor parents are born into an unfair world. A white guy or asian guy who really wants to play basketball in NBA finds himself in an unfair situation. But that's what powers these people. A lot of successful people came from bad background because they grew up being sick of this unfairness and they tried hard to get there. To use the NBA example, you never see Jeremy Lin or Yaoming giving talks about how "We need more asian basketball players in NBA". They are well aware of how that's how it is, but still managed to succeed by pushing themselves hard. Again, I do realize it's unfair, but if I were someone in an unfair situation I would spend 100% of my time working hard to overcome it, instead of using my precious time thinking and talking about how my group needs to be more well represented.
- triplesec 10y agoThe article makes a great point that just being a woman doesn't make you a good speaker about [the sociological problems] of women in tech. Rather than have her out of her skillset, hire her to talk about databases, or other parts of her expertise, and hire academics, HR and others (of both genders, according to skill relevance) qualified to talk about social-tech challenges.
- digitalpacman 10y agoI agree with this. I am male though so my opinion might not count.
- spoiler 10y agoI agree 100% with the author. Another thing that I feel this "let's talk about women in tech" attitude is causing is causing a negative effect, rather than a good one. An example of this is my (female) friend who rolls her eyes at any mention of "women in tech" and makes jokes about all these online "troll" feminists[1]. We should as a community—like the author herself said—focus more on inspiring women to join the industry; not talk them into it. I think the author's suggestion to have confident women talk about their awesome tech is a great start! [1]: I am not trying to discredit feminism. We can't deny there are some people who take it too far when they have online discussions; this happens regardless of the topic being discussed.
- throwaway991823 10y agoHad to use throwaway here, sorry. I attend and organise various conferences and its simple. You got to get Women. 10% minimum, more is better. One of our own engineer (who is very mediocre but a women) got accepted to a major conference. She was told her talk is not so good, but they still want her and she should think of something. End result? When I see a woman talking in a conference I assume she is there because of her gender, not skills. Lose lose to all
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- onetwotree 10y agoThanks, I've fixed it.
- dang 10y agoGreat! I've deleted my parent comment and marked the subthread off-topic, so it won't distract from what you posted. Btw we're probably going to build moderation tools so users can give each other feedback about the guidelines like this without it having to take the main discussion off topic.
- kkelleey 10y agoDoes anyone know if there is data somewhere that shows the male/female speaker proportion across different conferences? Would be interesting to see how it compares across the different industries. I didn't see anything after some basic googling.
- Mz 10y agoIf someone approaches me to talk somewhere just because I’m a woman, they haven’t done their job of finding what my expertise is. Therefore, I am going to insta-decline. This is a really good policy. She's 100% right.
- tomc1985 10y agoThe secret to diversity is not giving a shit about stupid criteria like race or gender, and shutting the hell up about it. Quiet acceptance of anyone who fits and does good work. People talk about diversity like it's some magical talisman. It isn't. Diversity is: not being turned off by someone who doesn't possess whatever stupid criteria you think make for a good human being. That's all.