7 ms·
Literature in Castro’s Cuba
- rayrod2030 10y agoThe amount of BS that Castro spouts during this interview is laughable. His ideology and theories have ruined a nation and imprisoned the minds of millions of it's citizens. The funniest part of all is that almost 60 years later Cuba is in shambles and the government still speaks in this way.
- elsurudo 10y agoA lot of that is due to their circumstances and the US embargo. I don't quite see what you are saying here – we may disagree with his policies and ideology, but he seems very candid and truthful here, admitting many faults of his country's system. This is something a "Western" politician would rarely – if ever – do these days. You also need to be mindful of the situation in Cuba before the revolution, where the people felt that their country was becoming a satellite of the US, and losing control over its own destiny.
- rayrod2030 10y agoI was born in Cuba and just returned from the island 3 days ago. I'm pretty mindful of the situation there. There is no one to blame for the dire situation in Cuba other than the regime and it's leaders.
- tw04 10y agoSo... in your opinion the US embargo had absolutely no effect on the situation? Or you're suggesting that any nation that doesn't act as a puppet of the US should be forced into severe economic sanctions as punishment? In other words, the US should be the only sovereign nation in the world?
- tptacek 10y agoIt's possible to disagree with the parent commenter without egregiously stuffing words into their mouth. Please read comments charitably.
- tw04 10y agoI didn't stuff any words into his mouth - that's what the question marks were for. His first comment made his stance pretty clear so I gave him room for clarification. But thank you for doing what you just accused me of - I'm surprised your head didn't explode from the irony.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoWell, at a minimum you're asking him, in quite an accusing way, to defend against a bunch of things he didn't say. That's pretty close to "putting words in his mouth, but with question marks after them". It's not a fair form of debate, and it's not welcome here.
- tw04 10y agoHe actually literally said that when someone mentioned the embargo being a huge reason that Cuba was in the situation they're in (which is true). If asking people to explain inflammatory statements like there's NOBODY to blame but the leaders in a situation like Cuba's is unwelcome, I'm not sure why this place exits. >There is no one to blame for the dire situation in Cuba other than the regime and it's leaders. I've not heard a single credible expert on the subject throw out an idea as laughable as the US embargo not having any effect on the Cuban economy. If you're going to support him I suggest you also provide some facts to backup such a ludicrous statement. Or, you know, just down vote me for calling him out.
- AnimalMuppet 10y ago
- peterwwillis 10y agoThe US has increased the regime's oppressive effects, though. The embargo has created a dearth of medical supplies & knowledge, has negatively impacted nutrition, lack of resources, lack of tourism dollars, and provides a bogeyman for the regime to blame for all its ails. It has helped repress and impoverish the people more than anything else. The United Nations General Assembly has passed a resolution every year since 1992 opposing it. It's possible that, like China, the oppressive effects of Communism could have been lessened (even if just a little) under the benefits of trade with a Capitalist democracy. Medical crises would have been dealt with quicker, and they would have had more cash on hand from tourism to invest in agriculture (or at the very least, import more food). And you may feel differently about this, but I think the ban on travel really sucked ass for Cuban families who couldn't visit their relatives, and the bans on transfer of money to family members in Cuba. But that's not really a regime thing, that was just the US being dicks.
- bmmayer1 10y ago> like China, the oppressive effects of Communism could have been lessened (even if just a little) under the benefits of trade with a Capitalist democracy The oppressive effects of communism were lessened because China lessened communism by introducing free market reforms. It wasn't just trade with capitalist nations that improved the welfare of China and its people, it was becoming more capitalist a nation itself.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- peterwwillis 10y agoRight... and it was becoming a more capitalist nation (technically a socialist market economy, otherwise known as state capitalism) due to influences by its Capitalist trade partners. In a single year (1978-1979) new party leader Deng Xiaoping led economic reforms to the PRC, signed an accord with Jimmy Carter for the US to officially recognize the PRC, and attracted new business from Boeing and Coca-Cola. More reforms followed soon after. But it is absolutely clear that they thought the Capitalist model was what worked and they wanted a form of it, and used trade with the US as its beginning. I make this distinction about the US influencing them because without the successful model (and attractive potential partner) of the US, the push for a market economy may not have worked. Cuba could have done the same, except we were still giving them the finger.
- vixen99 10y ago'its leaders'.
- matwood 10y agoSo are you blaming all the human rights issues on the US embargo? One of my Spanish teachers grew up in Cuba. He was extremely vocal about how bad it was there, and he was well off because his parents were part of the government. He ended up getting snuck out on a sailboat with his grandparents and never saw his parents again. Perhaps his stories were unique and his visible anger misplaced, but I don't think so.
- turar 10y agoWhat particular stories of human rights issues, as distinctly separate from embargo-induced economic hardships, did he talk about?
- andrenth 10y agoLack of freedom of speech comes to mind. As in being killed for voicing dissent.
- matwood 10y agoIt was ~20 years ago, so I don't remember all of the details. The main things centered around what we have all read and heard about. Lack of freedom and political dissidence landing people in prison or worse.
- caente 10y agoI'm sorry but no. They destroyed the lives of my parents. They convinced a generation that the future was at hand, that you only need to sacrifice a little more, and everything would be great. They convinced a generation that any other alternative was a treason against Cuba and humanity. There is no justification for what they did.
- terio 10y agoThe Castros are the main responsible for the dire economic situation of Cuba. Regardless of all the international relationship mistakes he made, Fidel Castro stands as one of the most economic incompetent of all communist dictators, with the notable exception of the ones in North Korea. Despite the embargo which affects mainly the commerce with the US, Cuba has always had commercial relations with many countries that were largely unaffected by the embargo. He basically had the whole country under his control. Think about a CEO of a very diversified industrial and agricultural conglomerate. He managed to screw it all and there was no other reason than his incompetence.
- pavlov 10y agoI confess to some degree of admiration towards young Castro. He led possibly the most successful guerrilla war in history. In about two years, he went from having an army of exactly two people stranded in a tobacco field to defeating a dictator supported by the world's strongest army. (In a way he is the ultimate "startup hero" -- from zero to world-class disruptor!) That said, his government has clearly failed all the ideals he touts in this '60s interview. For example, he speaks in favour of freedom of expression -- if only the means were there for everybody to get published: "The day will come when all the resources will be available, that is, when such a book would not be published to the detriment of a textbook or of a book having universal value in world literature. Then there will be resources to publish books on the basis of a broader criterion, and one will be able to argue whatever one wishes about any theme. I, especially, am a partisan of the widest possible discussion in the intellectual realm. Why? Because I believe in the free man, I believe in the well-educated man, I believe in the man able to think, in the man who acts always out of conviction, without fear of any kind. And I believe that ideas must be able to defend themselves. I am opposed to the blacklists of books, prohibited films, and all such things." Well, the Internet became just that medium, but Castro never deemed fit to give access to the citizens of his country. He and his comrades are just too old to get it. They should have made room for new generations long ago instead of clinging to power and the illusion of their own indispensability. Their extended single-party reign has crippled the Cuban economy more than any sanctions could.
- marcoperaza 10y agoThere's nothing to admire. The brutal repression started very shortly after Castro marched into Havana. The romantacization of his regime by elements of Western political groups is reminiscent of their praises for Stalin in an earlier time, or their enthusiastic support of Hugo Chavez more recently. It requires a willful ignorance of the facts, or a deeply troubling view of the world that accepts execution of dissidents as acceptable when used to achieve one's political goals. Beyond the political executions and purges, one of the first orders of business for Castro was the establishment of Committees for the Defense of the Revolution in every neighborhood. Their task? To monitor the population for disloyalty and errant political thoughts. My family escaped this horror and had to rebuild their lives from scratch well into adulthood and with children in a new land, so it really bothers me to see people praise anything about this monster. Would you post a comment saying that you admire Hitler for his takeover of a massive industrial power? So why would you for Castro?