11 ms·
Friends are as genetically similar as fourth cousins
- douche 10y agoWhere I grew up, it's a pretty good chance all my friends were fourth or fifth cousins. Small population + limited outbreeding = family hedges, instead of family trees. There were kids in my grade who couldn't date in town because all the girls were their first or second cousins...
- mnbcvx 10y ago> second cousins Didn't stop my great grandparents :) My mom's side is Mennonite, which is also a very tight knit community. When my grandma sends random pictures from in and around Goshen, Indiana, my wife has commented multiple times "whoa that guy in the background really looks like you!"
- runholm 10y agoReally not an issue with second cousins. Second cousins are genetically different enough that issues with the children are just barely more common in non-related couples.
- mnbcvx 10y agoYep. That's the kind of thing you look up at a young age when you discover you're the recent product of second cousins. Some interesting quotes from the "Cousin Marriage" Wikipedia article: "According to Professor Robin Fox of Rutgers University, it is likely that 80% of all marriages in history may have been between second cousins or closer." "Worldwide, more than 10% of marriages is between first and second cousins." "In some countries it is seen as incestuous and is legally prohibited: it is banned in China and Taiwan, the majority of U.S. states, North Korea and South Korea." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cousin_marriage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cousin_marriage
- hellofunk 10y agoEinsten, Darwin, and Giuliani all married their first cousins, from what I understand.
- pliny 10y agoThat is less interesting, in the context of inbreeding, than any of them being products of first cousin marriage.
- eru 10y agoI think Roentgen, discoverer of x-rays, was the product of first cousins. (I bet Wikipedia has a list of famous persons being children of first cousins.)
- tempestn 10y agoMaybe they were trying to breed super-geniuses.
- Jedd 10y agoDarwin's family history is fascinating -- the intertwining with the Wedgewoods (as you note, Charles and Emma were first cousins), but doubtless exacerbated by the frequent first-cousin marriages in Emma Wedgewood's recent ancestry. Darwin was aware of the risks of inbreeding, and this marriage in particular, expressing those concerns in various writings. They had 9 or 10 children, IIRC, with 3 or 4 of them dying in childhood, and only a couple going on to produce a further generation. (Not so uncommon these days, but at the time I believe this was quite noteworthy.)
- jacobolus 10y agoFrom a genetic perspective, even occasional first-cousin marriage is not really a problem. The problems start when you have several generations of cousin and sibling marriages, allowing homozygous recessive alleles to concentrate.
- thaumasiotes 10y agoWhat jacobolus said. First cousins are also genetically different enough that issues with the children are just barely more common than in unrelated couples. (The relative risk adjustment is quite high, but the absolute risk is still low.) If marrying your first cousin is a culturally accepted practice, it happens all the time and people get much more inbred than you might expect from looking at, or calculating from, a stylized 8-person cousin marriage family tree. And that goes for second-cousin marriages too, to a lesser degree.
- jhbadger 10y agoBut first-cousin marriages generation after generation are not a great idea, as happened in various royal houses of Europe in order to make sure both parents were of noble blood. In fact, it has been estimated that the last Hapsburg ruler of Spain, Charles II, ended up with more homozygous alleles than someone who was the offspring of siblings would. And he had numerous physical and mental problems that were probably the result of it.
- hx87 10y agoIt wasn't first-cousin marriages that screwed up the mainline Habsburgs; it was generation after generation of uncle-niece marriages that did it in. The current branch of the family (Habsburg-Lorraine/Hohenberg) was fortunate enough to avoid that.
- thaumasiotes 10y agoYour reply starts with "but", but I don't see the contrast with anything I said? My comment specifically notes that cousin marriage as a recurring practice causes much bigger problems than a single case of cousin marriage in isolation. That note is more than half of the entire comment. Fun fact: people like to present Charles II as the inevitable result of ongoing inbreeding, but he was noticeably less inbred than more competent historical rulers. Amenhotep I and his great wife had, between them, two parents, two grandparents, and two great-grandparents. Unsurprisingly, he and his great wife turned out not to produce any viable children. Unsurprisingly, that line also experienced early death outside of combat. But surprisingly, they don't seem to have been plagued by mental difficulties at all; as best we can tell from the record, they were very strong kings.
- roninb 10y agoIn case you were also wondering what a "fourth cousin" was, someone who shares a pair of great-great-great grandparents[0]. Wikipedia has a great set of diagrams[1] in case you're also confused about first, second, or third cousins. I figure through induction you can presume any nth and nth removed from that page (I foolishly thought 3rd was where people arbitrarily stopped keeping count....) [0] https://www.reference.com/family/fourth-cousin-7b40e096c6d654b7 https://www.reference.com/family/fourth-cousin-7b40e096c6d65... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cousin#First_cousins https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cousin#First_cousins
- skylan_q 10y agoWhere our family is from the priests wouldn't allow marriage between 6th cousins. My grandfather was 6th cousins three times removed from my grandmother. (so she was 9 generations away from common ancestors with him) They had to get written permission from the bishop to get married.
- milesskorpen 10y agoSounds like they basically penalized record keeping ...
- civilian 10y agoAh, it was probably the Church who was keeping the records in the first place.
- usrusr 10y agoThe beauty of selective enforcement. Dig deep enough into your ecclesiastical data-monopoly and you can veto just about any marriage at will. It never was the same again once laymen started to read and write.
- skylan_q 10y agoYes, it was the Franciscans who were a huge influence and kept record of these things. Most people would remember relations as far as great-grandparents and relations to families/family friends that they knew. Literacy was pretty high in the region early on as well, but people continued to rely on the church for recordkeeping.
- ilaksh 10y agoCould it just be more common for people who are in the same social group to be in the same ethnic group, and maybe that explains most of the genetic similarity they saw, rather than necessarily proving some kind of fitness advantage or something? Probably because often your friends are from the same neighborhood.
- aab0 10y agoThe genetic similarity here is estimated within the cohort; the Framingham cohort is by design ethnically homongeous to try to eliminate that sort of population structure confound. This way, the homophily is not picking up on the obvious stuff like ethnic groups. If they studied people from multiple ethnic groups, the results would be trivial and uninteresting. (This is why astazangasta's criticism in another comment is so amusing - this is meaningful because the sample is so 'biased'. This also holds for all the other studies done on Framingham.) But because only one highly homogeneous sample is studied, the chance genetic similarities of friends aren't due to just similar ethnic backgrounds, but are being caused by the genetic influence on things like SES and personality and intelligence and religiosity and hobbies and things like that. These similarities would probably also hold when considering a more unusual and cosmopolitan group, but it would be difficult to spot the increased similarity on a genome-wide basis because of all the racial differences in genomes (most of which would be nonfunctional and irrelevant to anything).
- a_bonobo 10y agoThey only apply population stratification from Figure 2 including onwards: >The results so far do not control for population stratification because we wanted to characterize overall similarity. However, it is important to remember that some of the similarity in genotypes can be explained by simple assortment into relationships with people who have the same ancestral background. The Framingham Heart Study is composed of mostly whites (e.g., of Italian descent), so it is possible that a simple preference for ethnically similar others could explain the results in Fig. 1. However, in the following results, we applied strict controls for population stratification to ensure that any correlation we observed was not due to such a process. I don't understand why they did not do this for Figure 1 (or why they do not show that figure) - I assume that the difference disappeared, but who knows. I just realized that this paper is from 2014, first published on arxiv in 2013. I can't find any study replicating it in the 34 citations since so I would be careful (but this type of dataset for replication is hard to come by) https://scholar.google.com.au/scholar?cites=7301900347564089851&as_sdt=2005&sciodt=0,5&hl=en https://scholar.google.com.au/scholar?cites=7301900347564089...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- microcolonel 10y agoI live in Toronto, and frankly I doubt my Panjabi, Sri Lankan, Chinese, and Korean friends are as genetically similar as my fourth cousins.
- eggie 10y agoIt could be that you share certain alleles at a much higher rate than expected by chance. That said, if the study is working off the Framingham data, I do wonder how general a conclusion it is...
- rogerthis 10y agoHaven't read the text yet, but the title remembered me of the Hungarian psychiatrist Leopold Szondi.
- astazangasta 10y agoThis is a dataset designed to study genetics in a cohort of mostly white people from Framingham, MA. How can anyone claim to be able to draw conclusions about the genetics of friendship from this cohort? This is such a biased dataset I can't believe this got published. For the record, I am Indian, my best friend growing up was Italian, my current best friends are a Russian Jew, a Scotch Irish mix from Woburn, and a Canadian of some uncertain European temperament. I have never had a best friend even close to being my fourth cousin.
- Manishearth 10y agoThey explicitly call this out and apply population stratification later in the paper.
- astazangasta 10y agoYeah, which means the extensibility of these claims is exactly as good as those corrections, which can't possibly hope to model the missing information (the actual genetic distribution of friends).
- Manishearth 10y agoGiven that the US is a lot more racially heterogenous than the majority of the world (where the average person would have friends of a closer genetic makeup), I would bet that if anything these results are skewed the other way.
- chaostheory 10y agoExactly. These results would make sense in almost every part of the world, except the US.
- Noseshine 10y ago> Given that the US is a lot more racially heterogenous The US? Sure, but this isn't about the US. The population chosen (or available) for the study does not reflect that diversity. https://www.framinghamheartstudy.org/participants/index.php https://www.framinghamheartstudy.org/participants/index.php > The Original Cohort of the Framingham Heart Study consisted of 5,209 respondents > of a random sample of 2/3 of the adult population of Framingham, Massachusetts So I don't understand why you point to diversity in some wider but not included group to reason about results based on the much more limited one. Stratification doesn't help much - it doesn't generate missing data, it still is based on that limited population. The study isn't "wrong" of course, it clearly states what data it is based on and what methods they employed. If there's anything wrong it's the interpretation by others. This is merely a hint "maybe worth having a closer look at this", it isn't meant to be used to draw any final conclusions from. Papers like this are for "internal use", for other researchers in the field, it should never go to the wider media. It's like a programmer showing their very first lines of code for a new idea, and then trying to draw conclusions about the quality of the final software to be released five years later, written by different people in a different programming language. Bad example, because here at least you already know what it will be about while in the study this remains open, so I reframed it to be about "(software) quality".
- kbd 10y agoPretty sure my Thai best friend is more dissimilar to me than a fourth cousin.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- sndean 10y agoThere's a pretty good CGP Grey video that explains family trees and what fourth cousins are: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PM79Epw_cp8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PM79Epw_cp8
- LoSboccacc 10y ago* fourth cousins genetically as diverse as random strangers would be a better wording the current title has implications not yet rigorously tested and people is already looking into selection bias to explain correlation where probably there's none.
- tomtomtom777 10y ago> fourth cousins genetically as diverse as random strangers would be a better wording That is not the same at all. From the abstract: > More than any other species, humans form social ties to individuals who are neither kin nor mates, and these ties tend to be with similar people. They specifically tested friends to include the general preference of friends to be similar.
- compactmani 10y agoThe main finding from my perspective is that we can score and rank friendship likeliness and see signal in a hold out dataset. I can almost hear Facebook clamoring to offer free genotyping.
- Snoooze 10y agoThe dating world is already experimenting. (e.g. http://www.genepartner.com/ http://www.genepartner.com/)
- cafard 10y agoHow many Americans know any fourth cousins? In the village from which two great grandparents emigrated, I have met some third cousins, some at least twice removed, and here in the US I have met second cousins once removed. For what it's worth, it would take a very sharp eye, and maybe an unduly imaginative one, to spot family resemblances between the third cousins and me.
- tomrod 10y agoI know plenty, due to both an active family reunion group and due to genealogical research. It can be pretty fun learning about your ancestors.
- avodonosov 10y agoCan it be interpreted that friends are as similar as random people?
- Snoooze 10y agoNo. The article mentions a number of reasons why friends can be (and are) genetically closer than random people.
- jlebrech 10y agoso what would be the best way to increase genetic diversity?
- thesz 10y agoRelated: https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2008/02/080207140855.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2008/02/080207140855.h... Third cousins are most fertile. So, marrying friend is a good idea from fertility point of view.
- amelius 10y ago"Fertility" does not necessarily mean "fit offspring", but your point stands.
- thesz 10y agoDefine "fit offspring". I consider "offspring that has many offsprings" as one that fits definition "fit offspring". If you read the article you would know that third cousins' couples have more grandsons. Thus, third cousins direct offsprings are... more fit than others!
- hockeybias 10y agoI find this interesting as it relates to all of the race-related issues in the U.S. today.
- TheLarch 10y agoThe lead author, Nicholas Christakis, is the man who was reviled by some students at Yale during the Halloween costume debacle: http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2015/11/the-new-intolerance-of-student-activism-at-yale/414810/ http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2015/11/the-new-....
- sliverstorm 10y agoI hope you're not suggesting that has any bearing on the quality of the paper?
- eric_h 10y agoI don't think there's any implication of that. It's just a nice piece of trivia.
- bmelton 10y agoFrom my reading, the article in question gives me a complimentary view of the author, and a less complimentary view of those who reviled him.
- TheLarch 10y agoNot sure if you are speculating that I am a supporter or detractor of his. My only impression of the man up until now was that I thought he and his wife conducted themselves with grace and forebearance during the Halloween fiasco. I find this research fascinating.
- eric_h 10y agoThanks for reposting that article. I swear I'm starting to feel like an old man "back in my day, vigorous intellectual disagreement and debate was the point of living on campus during college"
- kafkaesq 10y agoBack in my day, vigorous intellectual disagreement and debate was the point of living on campus during college Well they've sure fixed that, haven't they.
- peter303 10y agoMost people with European ancestry are 10th or 11th cousins to each other based upon how every US president is related to every other. This includes the current President who is half Eoropean.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Retric 10y ago2 ^ 11 = 2048 great ... grandparents. However, the top row only counts as one set. Thus, at most 1,024 couples. 10 generations down with 3 kids a generation is 59,049. Assuming zero deaths and zero intermingling that's 60,466,176. So, your going to need very large family sizes for that to work out once you account for deaths without children or intermingling. France averaged 4.5 kids a couple in 1800 so I don't think this math works.
- peter303 10y agoIts not math, but exhaustive geneologies by experts who've tracked every US President as far back as Saxon England. These emperical results constrain theoretical calculations.
- Retric 10y agoYour assuming US Presidents are a representative sample. That seems highly dubious. I mean one is the child of another. More importantly 11th century is much more than 11 generations back. Go to 20 generations and include people at different generations then sure.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Most people with European ancestry are 10th or 11th cousins to each other based upon how every US president is related to every other. "The people who have been elected President of the United States" are not a representative sample of "people currently alive with European ancestry" (or even a nonrepresentative subset of that set) such that generalizations about relations between members of the latter class could be drawn from the relations between members of the former class. And even if they were, strong conclusions can't really be drawn from an N=44 sample.
- aj7 10y agoVery weak correlations. Spun as a hypothesis-positive result.
- peter303 10y agoAssuming you have 44,000 genes (a copy from each parent) and random recombination each generation, then some of your ancestors will have stoped contributing genes by 16 generations (400 years). These assumptions arent perfect, but givebyou a sense of what happens. (People have far fewer than 2^N ancestors due to distant cousin inbreeding) (Genetic recombination is not random, but chunky.)
- Retric 10y agoThis is not necessarily accurate as a fair amount of what we think of as Junk DNA is actually used. And a large chunk of DNA is devoted to basic cellular function which fails if it's modified.
- bencollier49 10y agoDoesn't 23andme "identify" fourth cousins?
- awl130 10y agoin other words, we pick friends from the same ethnic group