15 ms·
Genetic evidence for natural selection in humans in the contemporary USA
- sp332 10y agoI don't understand. Why has educational attainment gone up and age at menarche gone down if there is selection pressure in the other direction?
- danieltillett 10y agoBecause these have non-genetic factors working in the opposite direction.
- relyks 10y agoHow is educational attainment a genetic trait? Intelligence is partially hereditary, but isn't educational attainment a behavior?
- aab0 10y agoIntelligence is as much a behavior as education is. You observe it by what people do and how they perform. There is no physical or neurological correlate of intelligence like height or brain size or white matter integrity which measures intelligence as well as observing performance does. As for how education can be genetically mediated, there's many ways. Through intelligence (high genetic correlation/overlap), but also through personality traits, ADHD-proneness, and other mental and physical characteristics which are undoubtedly under genetic control.
- cSoze 10y agoStill doesn't make much sense to use a secondary trait like educational attainment (58% heritability at highest) over a primary one like IQ (>80% heritability). Most of these phenotypes strike me as pretty questionable. Maybe I missed something, but how well does BMI measured at age 45-50 correlate with BMI at reproductive age? Wouldn't a far simpler approach be to measure allelic frequency at regions near GWAS QTLs in multiple generations?
- aab0 10y ago> Still doesn't make much sense to use a secondary trait like educational attainment (58% heritability at highest) over a primary one like IQ (>80% heritability). Educational attainment is phenotyped much more often than is IQ, so it's both available in this dataset and available in the much larger datasets of the GWAS in question. Aside from being a phenotype of interest in its own right and a case of looking under the lamppost, EA also proxies for intelligence on both the genetic and phenotype level. (In some cohorts, like the UK Biobank, the cognitive performance test used has such low test-retest reliability that anyone who is looking for intelligence variants is going to want to use the education variable anyway!) > Maybe I missed something, but how well does BMI measured at age 45-50 correlate with BMI at reproductive age? I'm sure the correlation is <1. But as long as it's not an inverse correlation, it's fine. That is just measurement error which will bias down to 0 the estimate and lead to underestimate of selection. > Wouldn't a far simpler approach be to measure allelic frequency at regions near GWAS QTLs in multiple generations? How do you aggregate those QTLs? You can't examine them individually, that would be horrifically underpowered. If you wind up summing them, don't you get a polygenic score back and do what OP did?
- cSoze 10y agoConsidering that natural selection is generally considered to not operate on post-reproductive phenotype (prime case is antagonistic pleiotropy literature) I consider any conclusion based on these measures pretty suspect. Worse, specific heritability for these traits in this cohort, as far as I can tell, wasn't even estimated. Given that the supplemental says the mean in the literature is 40%, it could very well be sub 20%. I suspect that selecting only known high effect QTLs would actually not impact your power all that much as it limits the number of tests performed. If you can't see selection at high effect alleles I'm not sure you'll be able to detect them in aggregate either, especially with very noisy phenotype data. At the end of the day natural selection is a change in allele frequency driven by differences in phenotype. Sure, this maybe was an easy analysis to do given that the data was available, but I don't really see the value.
- aab0 10y ago
- pessimizer 10y agoPeople who are highly educated like to feel like they are members of a higher species.
- ggggtez 10y agoI'd argue that it's just as likely that our ability and desire to make teaching and learning more interesting (wider availability of college courses even without enrolling in a 4 year degree) could have had just as much impact on increasing the average EA.
- mirimir 10y agoThe author looks at the relationship between fitness, educational attainment, and age at menarche. He measures fitness by number of grandchildren. So what he reports is that people with higher educational attainment, and women with later menarche, had more grandchildren on average. That makes sense to me. It's pretty well established that educated people have fewer children. And early menarche might arguably be associated with long-term health problems.
- burfog 10y agoThe result of selection (lower education, etc.) will necessarily lag behind the selection pressure. Only the most extreme selection (immediate 100% death for non-selected variant) will show up immediately. Milder selection takes time. You can tell that it is happening if you look at millions of people, but it won't be easy to notice without some number crunching. Suppose the difference is that one group averages 1.7 kids per woman, with typical generation-to-generation time of 35 years, while the other group has 2.1 kids per woman, with typical generation-to-generation time of 20 years. You probably can't notice, especially if those averages are blurred by lots of random variation. It will take many generations to severely reduce the genetic predisposition toward learning. As it happens, it will be difficult to recognize. People learn less, but why? Many alternate explanations will be offered. There may in fact be multiple factors that each partially explain the result. Some of these factors may be taboo. We might explain away the situation by saying that the economy just doesn't support education, or that the culture has changed.
- haddr 10y agoSide comment: the author is using first person in his paper, which is slightly odd. I know he is the only author, but would it be more suitable to use some other form?
- KZeillmann 10y agoI often find it more distracting when people avoid the first person than when they use it. If it makes sense, why not use it?
- ethan_g 10y agoTo be clear, "we" is first person, plural. I take it your comment and gp to mean "I" by "first person" and not "we". Anyway, it's standard in scientific writing to use "we" instead of "I". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/We#The_author.27s_.22we.22 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/We#The_author.27s_.22we.22
- fragsworth 10y agoIt is also a very subtle way to make it sound more credible, because it gives the reader a sense that multiple people did the work.
- jkot 10y agoOr it was written by king :-) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Royal_we https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Royal_we
- grondilu 10y agoOn the other hand it can also some kind of proof of honesty and transparency. "Hey, I did that work alone, which is slightly odd, but hey at least I'm not hiding this fact." I agree with haddr above. People should not be ashamed of using "I" instead of "we" when it's relevant.
- dekhn 10y agoFor single author papers, I see many papers that switch from "we" to "I". We are probably observing a trend in the process.
- meeper16 10y agoThese days I see a lot of non-genetic evidence as well.
- stephengillie 10y agoEspecially in how rich people use their wealth and social influence to increase their wealth and social influence. And they give greater assistance to their offspring than their less-affluent cohorts are able to. One example of this is the $1 million gift Bill Gates received on his 0th birthday.
- eggy 10y agoAgreed to an extent. I think Bill Gates deserves some credit for his success. Just look to the number of failures in Silicon Valley with huge startup money and well-educated youth; it doesn't guarantee success. I remember seeing an article in a NYC newspaper in the late 70s or early 80s that followed up on the first winners of Lotto in the State. The majority of them spent it on cars, fur coats, hookers, booze, drugs and other things, went into debt and didn't escape their former poverty. Some wound up in jail. I grew up in poverty, and my father upon reading it remarked, 'Money is worthless to somebody who doesn't understand the value of a buck.' Very true in my experience, as I have aged and observed. I couldn't find the original article from I believe the Daily News or Post, but here's one from the The Atlantic along the same lines: http://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2012/03/terribly-sad-true-stories-lotto-winners/329903/ http://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2012/03/terribly...
- TheOtherHobbes 10y agoThat's because when you grow up with money you either have so much that you can do all the usual things and you won't run out, or you already have an investment machine in place for you. Lottery winners certainly don't have the latter, and often don't have the former either. They may think $1 million makes them rich, but it really doesn't. Money is as much about training and education as anything else. It's a lot easier to handle if you get that training and education than if you don't.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- rdtsc 10y agoAnother anecedotal (and probably wrong) idea related to this is the explanation of prevalence of ADHD in US relative to EU, for example. The genetic selection idea goes something like this -- individuals who ended up migrating here, self selected for being bolder, ready to take on more risk, being less content staying in one place. On one side that is a postive trait, but on the other side manifests as ADHD. There is a study from 2003 showing that it is not true and that it is due to how diagnosis is handled: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1525089/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1525089/ Other places claim a strong genetic factor is there: "ADHD often runs in families. Researchers have found that much of the risk of having ADHD has to do with genes" http://www.nimh.nih.gov/health/publications/attention-deficit-hyperactivity-disorder-easy-to-read/index.shtml http://www.nimh.nih.gov/health/publications/attention-defici...
- thaumasiotes 10y agoJust to point out, there is no conflict between the claims (1) "ADHD is diagnosed more often in the US than in the EU because the US has looser diagnostic standards"; and (2) "ADHD is genetically determined".
- PhasmaFelis 10y agoAnecdotally, I have heard French people say that it is practically impossible to get a adult psychiatric diagnosis of ADD in France, regardless of how clear and debilitating your symptoms are. It may be that the apparent low rates in the EU are actually systemic diagnostic failures. (Similarly, I have read that in [I think] Japan, it is actually illegal to begin a course of ADD medication after 18--if you were diagnosed as a child, you're fine, but if your parents never took you to a psych, you're screwed forever. Even in the US I've had a general-practice doctor tell me that they thought ADD just went away after a certain age. There's a lot of denial about adult ADD.)
- rdtsc 10y agoInteresting. Wonder if it is cultural, and if there is any element of antagonism against US practices -- i.e. "we know US is pretty liberal with this diagnosis, we think it is rather wrong, so we'll just go the other way and deliberately shy away from diagnosing it as much as possible".
- chrismealy 10y agoEconomists dabbling in other fields have a uniformly appalling track record, but who knows, maybe this one is the exception.
- Amygaz 10y agoNo this isn't. He should have spent 1.5 more months thinking about his experimental design. He doesn't even try to make the distinction between causality and coincidence. We could achieve the same conclusions by talking about socio-economic changes rather than genotype-to-phenotype. For a guy who was has is name in the big GWAS published in Science, he obviously didn't understand what his co-authors did or wrote. Sorry for the rant, I can't stand people who are getting a free-ride on a paper, and he just proved that is one of them.
- sugarfactory 10y agoIt's just funny that it is still called "natural selection" even when the environment that selects individuals is created by nothing but ourselves. I think it'd be much more accurate to call it "social selection" because for humans the environment is not nature, but society. With that in your mind, those of you who are clever might wonder: what is the fundamental difference between "social selection" and eugenics, which many consider morally wrong? My answer is: they are essentially the same thing. It's because if we define eugenics as society deciding who to reproduce and who not to, that's exactly what is happening now.
- Asooka 10y agoThat's a philosophical question I haven't seen posed before - is our own selection natural or not? There is practically no outside force killing individuals before they reach reproductive age, so our selection is entirely due to social dynamics. On the other hand, we are part of the natural world and so is our behaviour... Eugenics is a small group with power deciding that people they don't like cannot have children even if they are consenting partners in marriage. In the abstract both have people behind the selection process, but in practical terms eugenics is the antithesis to social selection, because social selection is entirely predicated on individual choice, while eugenics is one choice being forced on all individuals from people in power.
- eggy 10y agoI will not argue the common usage meanings that have come about for 'natural' and 'artificial' for things like plastic flowers or street lamps, but I look at 'ourselves', or humankind as part of nature, and not supernatural, or apart from it. I am not sure when this distinction or usage arose, but 'artificial' or using 'societal' here seems self-hating, and I don't think the term 'natural selection' is archaic or exclusive in this sense. The same reason I find cell towers made to look like trees an eyesore, and I much prefer the 'natural' shape a truss tower takes with its wide supportive base, diagonals and ever-decreasing thickness to the spire. I personally find these more aesthetically appealing. Light from 'artificial' light bulbs is made of photos regardless of color temperature and the time of day it is turned on. I don't like plastic flowers, although plastic is also found in nature, but just not as structured, homogenized, or in the quantities we produce it. I agree with you on the 'social selection' and eugenics bit. My Mom had bought me a hardcover 'Eugenics' textbook from an old bookshop originally published in England in the 20s. Scary content given what occurred 20 years later, but it was humorous to me when reading it in 1976, especially the chapter on 'The Honeymoon' and how to have the proper one with attendant drawings! I was twelve at the time.
- philip142au 10y agoHere's an idea about natural selection, we had two world wars, during the wars the fit and healthy brave people went, the cowards hid and stayed at home. The cowards survived to live another day, so cowardice and unfit individuals are selected for breeding, giving us the people of today.
- oofabz 10y agoWhy start with WW1? Wouldn't this effect work with earlier, smaller-scale wars as well? And since we've had wars for all of history, and have even observed wars in other primates, surely bravery has been selected against for millions of years.
- olalonde 10y agoBy definition the people who survived are fit, not unfit.
- mamon 10y agoThey are "fit" as in "best adjusted to their environment" but not "fit" as in "good at sports", which I think is what parent comment meant :)
- jarek-foksa 10y agoA brave person that always choses to confront an enemy, no matter how powerful he is, has lower chances for survival, just like a coward who always choses to run away, leaving his resources to the enemy and risking being killed by his own people for treason. That's why most people of today are neither brave nor cowards, they are somewhere in-between.
- VLM 10y agoIn the pre civil engineer era, civilian death rates averaged around 80%, typical woman has 12 kids, 10 die before they reproduce, etc. Against those odds, world war level losses are a rounding error. Its telling that the influenza epidemic after WWI killed more people than WWI.
- whyenot 10y ago
- ascotan 10y agoI'm sorry was this an April Fool joke? By definition a 'phenotype' is the expressed traits of a genotype. As far as I know there is no known gene or set of genes which express the 'phenotype' of 'Educational Attainment'. I looked at the paper and the author provides no methods to replicate his study. For example, there is no discussion as to the SNP markers he was tracking to associate the 'phenotype' of EA. What the author is implying here is that there is a gene for 'educational attainment' that is becoming more common in the population in general due to selection pressure. I'm sorry but this is total hogwash. Anyone that correlates educational attainment to genetics is following a 'chopstick' gene. Imagine that you correlate the ability to use chopsticks to genetic markers. What you'll find is that people with black hair and brown eyes have a much greater ability to use chopsticks then people with blond hair and blue eyes. You could even produce some pretty convincing graphs about this. However, as we all know the usage of chopsticks is cultural not genetic. There is nothing to prevent blond haired, blue eye people from using chopsticks genetically. In fact you can correlate any two things that have no relationship to each other and find a correlation. For instance, the sun coming up in the morning and traffic congestion. They correlate, but have no causal relationship. i.e the sun does not cause traffic.
- sdiepend 10y agoWhen the sun goes up, it's easier to do your work or job. So people get to work and cause traffic jams.
- timeu 10y agoCorrect me if I am wrong, but I though the chopstick gene example has more to do with population structure confounding than with the heritability of the trait? For example one could make a similar example with malaria resistance and skin color.
- nabla9 10y ago>My results imply that natural selection has been slowly favoring lower EA in both females and males lower educational attainment, not higher see: GWAS of 126,559 Individuals Identifies Genetic Variants Associated with Educational Attainment (one of the authors is Beauchamp) http://science.sciencemag.org/content/340/6139/1467 http://science.sciencemag.org/content/340/6139/1467 >Three independent single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) are genome-wide significant (rs9320913, rs11584700, rs4851266), and all three replicate. Estimated effects sizes are small (coefficient of determination R2 ≈ 0.02%), approximately 1 month of schooling per allele. A linear polygenic score from all measured SNPs accounts for ≈2% of the variance in both educational attainment and cognitive function
- grondilu 10y agoIsn't it fairly known that less educated people have more children?
- mirimir 10y agoYes. Education and economic prosperity have reduced population growth rates in many places. Too much, perhaps, in some places.
- caseymarquis 10y agoI'll take another look when we have a few hundred samples of this size over the course of a thousand years or so.
- pmarreck 10y agoSo, http://time.com/4327424/idiocracy/ http://time.com/4327424/idiocracy/, basically. I know who _I'm_ voting for: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CV0dnFtWEAAwj_k.jpg https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CV0dnFtWEAAwj_k.jpg
- seventytwo 10y agoCTRL-F "Idiocracy" But seriously, can it really be said that this is related to natural selection rather than some other pressure? I guess it kind of depends on the definition, as one could argue that any result within a given environment is causal to that given environment. However, while I do anecdotally see that more highly educated people have less children (and also the opposite, which the author writes of), I still think that people generally try to select for the smartest and most capable people within their social sphere. In other words, I think people are still selecti mates which are smarter, but due to socioeconomic factors unrelated to breeding, the less educated end up having more children.
- gwern 10y agoFurther reading: - "Assortative mating and differential fertility by phenotype and genotype across the 20th century" http://www.pnas.org/content/early/2016/05/25/1523592113.full http://www.pnas.org/content/early/2016/05/25/1523592113.full , Conley et al 2016 (education/intelligence polygenic score is dropping 0.0029 SDs per year: http://www.pnas.org/content/suppl/2016/05/25/1523592113.DCSupplemental/pnas.1523592113.sapp.pdf http://www.pnas.org/content/suppl/2016/05/25/1523592113.DCSu... ) - "Constructing genomic maps of positive selection in humans: Where do we go from here?", Akey 2009 http://genome.cshlp.org/content/19/5/711.long http://genome.cshlp.org/content/19/5/711.long - "Measuring selection in contemporary human populations", Stearns et al 2010 https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Douglas_Ewbank/publication/45462159_Measuring_selection_in_contemporary_human_populations/links/0c960516c1c8b5ef7d000000.pdf https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Douglas_Ewbank/publicat... - "Exceptional Evolutionary Divergence of Human Muscle and Brain Metabolomes Parallels Human Cognitive and Physical Uniqueness", Bozek et al 2014 http://journals.plos.org/plosbiology/article?id=10.1371/journal.pbio.1001871 http://journals.plos.org/plosbiology/article?id=10.1371/jour... - "The phenotypic legacy of admixture between modern humans and Neandertals" http://www.gwern.net/docs/genetics/2016-simonti.pdf http://www.gwern.net/docs/genetics/2016-simonti.pdf, Simonti et al 2016 - "The Genetic Cost of Neanderthal Introgression" http://www.genetics.org/content/203/2/881 http://www.genetics.org/content/203/2/881 Harris & Nielsen 2016 - "Genome-wide patterns of selection in 230 ancient Eurasians" http://www.gwern.net/docs/genetics/2015-mathieson.pdf http://www.gwern.net/docs/genetics/2015-mathieson.pdf, Mathieson et al 2015 - "Eight thousand years of human] natural selection in Europe" http://biorxiv.org/content/early/2015/03/13/016477.full.pdf http://biorxiv.org/content/early/2015/03/13/016477.full.pdf, Mathieson et al 2015 (Khan http://www.unz.com/gnxp/selection-in-europeans-but-it-still-sweeps/ http://www.unz.com/gnxp/selection-in-europeans-but-it-still-... ; see also EDAR https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ectodysplasin_A_receptor#Derived_EDAR_allele https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ectodysplasin_A_receptor#Deriv... - "Detection of human adaptation during the past 2,000 years" http://biorxiv.org/content/early/2016/05/07/052084.full.pdf http://biorxiv.org/content/early/2016/05/07/052084.full.pdf, Field et al 2016 (commentary https://plus.google.com/103530621949492999968/posts/3DmLLdDfR61 https://plus.google.com/103530621949492999968/posts/3DmLLdDf... - "Population structure of UK Biobank and ancient Eurasians reveals adaptation at genes influencing blood pressure" http://biorxiv.org/content/early/2016/05/27/055855 http://biorxiv.org/content/early/2016/05/27/055855, Galinsky et al 2016 - "Greenlandic Inuit show genetic signatures of diet and climate adaptation", Fumagalli et al 2015 http://www.gwern.net/docs/genetics/2015-fumagalli.pdf http://www.gwern.net/docs/genetics/2015-fumagalli.pdf - "Genetic Adaptation to Levels of Dietary Selenium in Recent Human History", White et al 2015 http://mbe.oxfordjournals.org/content/32/6/1507.full http://mbe.oxfordjournals.org/content/32/6/1507.full ; see also "Human Adaptation to Arsenic-Rich Environments" http://mbe.oxfordjournals.org/content/32/6/1544.full http://mbe.oxfordjournals.org/content/32/6/1544.full Schlebusch et al 2015 - "Evidence for evolution in response to natural selection in a contemporary human population", Milot et al 2011 http://www.pnas.org/content/108/41/17040.long http://www.pnas.org/content/108/41/17040.long - "Quantitative Genetics in the Postmodern Family of the Donor Sibling Registry" https://www.donorsiblingregistry.com/sites/default/files/files/dissertation%281%29.pdf https://www.donorsiblingregistry.com/sites/default/files/fil..., Lee 2013 - "What women want in their sperm donor: a study of more than 1000 women's sperm donor selections", Whyte et al 2016 http://www.gwern.net/docs/genetics/2016-whyte.pdf http://www.gwern.net/docs/genetics/2016-whyte.pdf - "Why Are Some People So Smart? The Answer Could Spawn a Generation of Superbabies" http://www.wired.com/2013/07/genetics-of-iq/ http://www.wired.com/2013/07/genetics-of-iq/ - "The Rhythm of the Tide: When I heard data from an island had proven humans are still evolving, I had to visit" http://nautil.us/issue/29/scaling/the-rhythm-of-the-tide-rp http://nautil.us/issue/29/scaling/the-rhythm-of-the-tide-rp - "The Indicted and the Wealthy: Surnames, Reproductive Success, Genetic Selection and Social Class in Pre-Industrial England", Clark 2009 http://www.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/gclark/Farewell%20to%20Alms/Clark%20-Surnames.pdf http://www.econ.ucdavis.edu/faculty/gclark/Farewell%20to%20A... - "Older fathers' children have lower evolutionary fitness across four centuries and in four populations" http://biorxiv.org/content/early/2016/03/08/042788 http://biorxiv.org/content/early/2016/03/08/042788, Arslan et al 2016 (from "The cost of inbreeding in terms of health" http://www.unz.com/gnxp/the-cost-of-inbreeding-in-terms-of-health/ http://www.unz.com/gnxp/the-cost-of-inbreeding-in-terms-of-h... ) - "Childhood Autism and Assortative Mating" http://economics.uchicago.edu/workshops/Golden%20Hays%20Childhood%20Autism.pdf http://economics.uchicago.edu/workshops/Golden%20Hays%20Chil..., Golden 2012 - "Heritability, Autism, & Fear of Breeding" http://www.unz.com/gnxp/heritability-autism-fear-of-breeding/ http://www.unz.com/gnxp/heritability-autism-fear-of-breeding... - "Estimating the Inbreeding Depression on Cognitive Behavior: A Population Based Study of Child Cohort" http://www.plosone.org/article/info:doi/10.1371/journal.pone.0109585 http://www.plosone.org/article/info:doi/10.1371/journal.pone... ; see also http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/gnxp/2013/07/genetic-diversity-and-intellectual-disability/ http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/gnxp/2013/07/genetic-diver... - "Mutation and Human Exceptionalism: Our Future Genetic Load" http://www.genetics.org/content/202/3/869 http://www.genetics.org/content/202/3/869, Lynch 2016 - "The Biodemography of Fertility: A Review and Future Research Frontiers" Mills & Tropf 2015 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4577548/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4577548/ - Fertility and intelligence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fertility_and_intelligence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fertility_and_intelligence - "Assortative Mating, Class, and Caste", Harpending & Cochran 2015 http://www.gwern.net/docs/genetics/2015-harpending.pdf http://www.gwern.net/docs/genetics/2015-harpending.pdf