8 ms·
“I'm a public defender. Clients prefer jail to registering as sex offenders”
- swiley 10y agoAt least with jail you have garnanteed food and shelter. Being a sex offender means you're probably never going to be participating in society in any meaningful way anyway and at least prison sentences tend to have an end.
- FussyZeus 10y agoYou can assign the death penalty to every offense above stealing and it won't make a difference, the vast majority of actual criminals don't know or don't care and the vast majority of defendants (in the US anyway) don't know or didn't even think they committed a crime.
- joefkelley 10y agoDo you happen to have a source for those stats? Not that I'm doubting you - I often make similar claims - but it would be nice to be able to back it up.
- thescriptkiddie 10y agoYou're probably going to get a lot of flack for making a claim that (in America at least) goes against common opinion without backing it up with any sources. Here are a few. http://nij.gov/five-things/pages/deterrence.aspx http://nij.gov/five-things/pages/deterrence.aspx http://www.nytimes.com/roomfordebate/2012/06/05/when-to-punish-a-young-offender-and-when-to-rehabilitate/prison-is-a-poor-deterrent-and-a-dangerous-punishment http://www.nytimes.com/roomfordebate/2012/06/05/when-to-puni... http://www.slate.com/articles/business/the_dismal_science/2007/01/the_irrational_18yearold_criminal.html http://www.slate.com/articles/business/the_dismal_science/20... http://www.businessinsider.com/report-says-long-sentences-dont-deter-crime-2014-5 http://www.businessinsider.com/report-says-long-sentences-do...
- tonyarkles 10y agoThis is a pretty dark thought, but... While that may not have much of an effect on first-time crimes, it'll definitely have an effect on recidivism rates :)
- spraak 10y agoThis is sad to read. :/ Can people convicted of this be around their own children?
- mgkimsal 10y agoi would think it would depend on the state, and the feeling of the other parent/family. Had a friend who was convicted of possession of child porn. I've no idea what the specific content was, but it was a mandatory 5 years in prison, and his ex-wife petitioned for sole custody of their child, and I think she'd tried to get all parental rights removed 100%. not sure if that succeeded. he had another teenage daughter at the time who just... didn't get to see him when he was in prison (michigan, but he was in prison in mass most of the time). She's... mid 20s now? They have an OK relationship now, from what I can tell.
- nostrebored 10y agoSomeone who engages in the exploitation of children probably shouldn't be around teenagers. Painting him as a sympathetic character is just wrong. The things that he watched, and as a consumer encouraged to be produced have harmed children in irreversible ways.
- Oletros 10y agoIf you're a 16 old girl with a picture of your boyfriend naked you can be guilty of child pornography. How is she engaging in the exploitation of children? This is the problem, that a percentage of sex offenders are people like this hypothetic girl (or boy). When a 18 years person can be guilty of sex offending by having ex with his/her 17 old partner we have a problem
- nostrebored 10y agoYour comment is orthogonal to the situation posed by the GP. And I would say that if you're an 18yo who's looking at child pornography you should not be around children, especially those to whom you have unfettered access to as a parent/guardian. >When a 18 years person can be guilty of sex offending by having ex with his/her 17 old partner we have a problem I'm not arguing that Romeo and Juliet laws are a bad thing (even though I think that some state's implementations are too generous -- Georgia's laws effectively mean you can be a college freshman sleeping with high school freshmen). But when you're in the position that you're an 18yo with nude pictures of a minor, you do effectively have child porn. You should know well enough by that point to delete it. You are an adult. A non trivial number of these pictures do end up on the internet. Do you think that you should be a sex offender if as an 18yo you disseminate a picture of your 16yo partner? Do you think we should have a separate tier of images that are by definition child porn, but because of who possesses them they are not considered to be child porn? This will assuredly help actual offenders avoid the consequences of their actions.
- nosegoes 10y ago>We must avoid "one-size-fits-all" labels for those convicted of a broad range of offenses. I don't know what the author is going on about. At least in my state (WA), sex offenders are registered on a spectrum from I to III (most violent). >Mario was a sex registrant because, as a teenager, he inappropriately touched a fully dressed boy on two occasions. Uh... so her sympathetic example is a serial child molester? Note she does not say how old a "boy" or how old a "teenager" he was -- you can bet that the "boy" was probably under 7 and Mario was a 19-year-old, otherwise she would have given more details to make him seem more sympathetic (like she did with "fully clothed"). I am more concerned about the victims of our laws regarding petty drug offenses (i.e. small amounts of marijuana) -- those people are true victims.
- mgkimsal 10y ago> At least in my state (WA), sex offenders are registered on a spectrum from I to III I think your state may be unique, or at least in a minority. > Uh... so her sympathetic example is a serial child molester? There are much more sympathetic examples - teen boy having sex with someone who lied about her age: http://www.cbsnews.com/news/indiana-teen-zach-anderson-labeled-sex-offender-after-sex-girl-lied-about-age/ http://www.cbsnews.com/news/indiana-teen-zach-anderson-label...
- fucking_tragedy 10y ago> 25 percent of people on the sex offender registry are under the age of 18. This is the money quote. These people's lives are ruined forever and they haven't even begun.
- nostrebored 10y agoThere lives have certainly begun enough to become a sex offender. Holding people accountable for the crimes that they commit means that we have hard and fast boundaries. Especially in the case of sex-crimes which are pervasive throughout our society. When you keep in mind that a large number of those people have likely sexually assaulted someone their age, do you feel differently? You can talk to me about "not-fully-developed brains". all you like, but as a 16yo you certainly have the capability to make the decision to not rape/assault/etc.
- TempleOS 10y agoGod is perfectly just. If you suffer, that's how you earn a reward. In the Bible a woman lied and a guy went to prison for seven years. Then he became ruler of the country. If you want to lock me up. I don't care. Yer a retard nigger. God is perfectly just. That's how you earn blessing. God says... vector's tragedian effulgent abrasive bolt rapport intake's glisten's redistributing reprint horizon's beeper's breasting passivity's Lombard sophistry's trainee Solis upstage gainsaying tear weak tiebreaker's braggart's shows pupil Netherlanders drab devalues sobers tawdry tsar It makes a big difference when God talks to you and there is absolutely no uncertainty in God being just.
- fucking_tragedy 10y agoThe problem with Godwin's law is if you cast something minuscule as being on par with what occurred in Nazi Germany, you're undermining the actual horrors committed by humanity during that time. If you consider everyone that's taken a piss outside of a bathroom or the 17 year old who Snapchat's her boyfriend of the same age as sex offenders, you put them in the same camp as someone who has committed real horrific crimes with actual victims. Hope to hell and back that you or someone you care about never find themselves cast as a witch in this witch hunt.
- unclenoriega 10y agoI think there is a risk on the other side as well. If this sort of equivalency becomes common, it becomes easy to dismiss all sex offences as minor.
- delish 10y agoThis is from a linked memo from the California Sex Offender Management Board: > One recent large study found a recidivism rate of 5.3%. The re-offense rate is the lowest of any crime category (except murder) and research shows that the rate and the risk continue to decrease every month and year that the offender remains offense-free in the community. [0] This memo didn't name other crimes and rates. So I checked Wikipedia. Wikipedia cites some study by the US's Department of Justice: > Released prisoners with the highest re-arrest rates were robbers (70.2%), burglars (74.0%), larcenists (74.6%), motor vehicle thieves (78.8%), those in prison for possessing or selling stolen property (77.4%) and those in prison for possessing, using or selling illegal weapons (70.2%). Within 3 years, 2.5% of released rapists were arrested for another rape, and 1.2% of those who had served time for homicide were arrested for homicide. These are the lowest rates of re-arrest for the same category of crime. [1] As mentioned in the vox article, this is evidence against, "once a criminal, always a criminal," with respect to sex offenders. [0] http://www.casomb.org/docs/Challenge_of_Locating_Programs_3-17-16.pdf http://www.casomb.org/docs/Challenge_of_Locating_Programs_3-... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recidivism#Recidivism_rates https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recidivism#Recidivism_rates
- nosegoes 10y agoData is tainted by the fact that robbery is nearly always reported, whereas sex crimes (especially against children) often never are. EDIT for source: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/06/29/us/rate-of-child-sexual-abuse-on-the-decline.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2012/06/29/us/rate-of-child-sexual-ab... And CSA has fallen dramatically since the 90s, when the registry laws were passed.
- kavok 10y agoHasn't all crime gone down since the 90s? Edit: https://www2.fbi.gov/ucr/cius2009/data/table_01.html https://www2.fbi.gov/ucr/cius2009/data/table_01.html So the answer is yes, crime has been declining since the 90s.
- nostrebored 10y ago
- jessriedel 10y agoI don't get how something like this gets published: > The myth that those who commit sex crimes are more likely to reoffend is pure fiction; numerous studies, including those cited the California Sex Offender Management Board's recent report, noted that sex offender re-offense rate is actually lower than any crime other than murder. Indeed, research shows that only about 5 percent of new sex offenses were committed by previous sex offenders. It's obviously true that "those who commit sex crimes are more likely to reoffend" than the average citizen. The author tries to support his false debunking with two completely distinct statistics that do not speak one way or the other to the issue. Why doesn't Vox's fact checker flag this?
- nosegoes 10y agoNot to mention the fact that child molestation, for example, is almost never reported at the time by the child, or is hushed up by the family, etc. It is impossible to know the true re-offense rate for sex crimes because reporting is so low.
- zzalpha 10y agoIt is impossible to know the true re-offense rate for sex crimes because reporting is so low. By that logic, it's equally impossible to know how frequently it goes unreported in the first place. So your statement in unsupportable based on your own reasoning. In short: Either we can rely on sexual offense reporting rates in order to make legal policy decisions, or we can't. You don't get to have it both ways and only rely on the data when it suits your agenda.
- conflagrate 10y agoIt's not impossible to know because people report they were molested long after the fact. There are a lot of estimates to the number of people molested as children (some say 1in 5), and the NYT article linked in another thread suggests that these numbers are falling and that currently about 50% of sex crimes against children are reported. Statute of limitations etc. It's not very black and white, you know.
- bargl 10y agoI want to focus on one thing in here, because I disagree with a ton of the article. Some people on the list shouldn't be on there. In digging around to answer nosegoes question to find one instance of someone getting on the registry for peeing in public I found this site. It's interesting to see a compilation of bullshit ways your life can get ruined. http://www.solresearch.org/report/Look_Whos_on_Registry_Now http://www.solresearch.org/report/Look_Whos_on_Registry_Now This is an example of a broken system in the USA. The rules to get on the registry are broken, but the idea of a registry in and of itself is, in my opinion, good. As a parent I want people to be on there who abuse kids, but also as a parent, I expect judges and police to know the difference between child porn and a family member capturing memories.
- zzalpha 10y agobut the idea of a registry in and of itself is, in my opinion, good. Based on what, exactly? Your gut? Before you consign folks to a lifetime of punishment, I'd suggest you actually analyze the data and determine if the concept actually yields a benefit, given the objective costs in both dollars spent and lives ruined. The criminal justice system should be designed to protect the public, and to rehabilitate criminals. It doesn't exist to give you warm fuzzies through the implementation of otherwise ineffective laws that achieve neither of those goals.
- conflagrate 10y agoThe sex crime rate has been dropping faster than the general crime rate since the 1990s when the registry was implemented.
- zzalpha 10y agoDo I really need to break out the old correlation/causation saw, or is that at least self-evident with this crowd?
- DrScump 10y agoThe very premise of the title is faulty. It's not an either-or; such crimes generally mandate sex-offender registry even after parole or release.