8 ms·
He Was a Hacker for the NSA and He Was Willing to Talk. I Was Willing to Listen
- alexandercrohde 10y agoNot too much new in this piece. I wonder why the interviewee is so confident that the world will always be a place of conflict. I can think of no rational, or no necessary, reason why multiple conflicting powers should exist based on the lines on a map. Perhaps it's for the same reason he is religious (i.e. he's just wrong sometimes, like every human).
- whatshisface 10y agoA conflict between two people only needs one of them to start it. The FBI does not consent to the existence of crime, nor did the Crown consent to the existence of the US. A crushingly-powerful global omni-state could only win battles, not end the game. If you tried to prevent conflict by making people afraid to start it, then you would really just end up holding yourself in perpetual conflict with everyone.
- voxic11 10y agoMaybe he knows the CIA plans to keep it that way.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- gnaritas 10y ago> I wonder why the interviewee is so confident that the world will always be a place of conflict. It always has been. > I can think of no rational, or no necessary, reason why multiple conflicting powers should exist based on the lines on a map. You mean other than the fact that it's always been that way? These are just tribes on a larger scale, humans are tribal, we fight, it's in our nature.
- woodman 10y ago> ...we fight, it's in our nature. Do we perform any action that is not "in our nature"? Do you feel the same way about slavery which, until relatively recently, was the natural order of things?
- gnaritas 10y agoSlavery is still very much alive, it's just no longer publicly supported. Saying something is in our nature doesn't justify it, it's merely an explanation why something still is. As long as resources are scarce, man will fight, that is the way of things.
- woodman 10y ago> Slavery is still very much alive, it's just no longer publicly supported. That misses the point, but I can pin the example down if that helps: ... publicly supporting slavery, until relatively recently, was the natural order of things. The point is that saying "something is in our nature" doesn't justify it or explain it - because everything everybody has ever done or will do is something in our nature. > As long as resources are scarce, man will fight... This is better than the nature angle, but not by much - as pretty much anything (including adherents to a religion) can be called "resources". We just need to crack the whole post-scarcity thing... kind of a silver lining.
- gnaritas 10y ago> saying "something is in our nature" doesn't justify it or explain it It doesn't justify it, never claimed it did, but it most certainly does explain it.
- woodman 10y agoI understand your position, but I guess I've failed to communicate mine effectively - because you don't seem to understand me when I've said in two different ways that your nature argument is tautological.
- RockyMcNuts 10y agoAll great apes have hierarchical, territorial, aggressive societies. Most don't have maps though. Humans primarily distinguish themselves by their creative abstractions and rationalizations to justify fighting/killing other tribes...also imaginary friends in the sky who demand it, nonexistent differences in DNA, etc., etc. Territorial disputes are the least imaginary of the lot. (Desmond Morris's 'The Naked Ape' is an interesting look at how human behavior relates to apes - spoiler alert, a lot of similarities https://www.amazon.com/Naked-Ape-Zoologists-Study-Animal/dp/0385334303 https://www.amazon.com/Naked-Ape-Zoologists-Study-Animal/dp/... ... I've heard good things about 'Sapiens' as well https://www.amazon.com/Sapiens-Humankind-Yuval-Noah-Harari/dp/0062316095 https://www.amazon.com/Sapiens-Humankind-Yuval-Noah-Harari/d... )
- venomsnake 10y agoLets start with the absolutely obvious - there are not enough resources for everyone. Oil, gas, water and food supply are national security interests of the highest order with zero or very small elasticity and long market response delays. A crunch in any of those leads to internal or external instability. Free market in supply crunch is great for the people that have the money or the supply. The ones that only have demand can either go to war or get destroyed as a nation. The arab spring was not caused by the sudden love for democracy. It was caused because of the massive spike in commodities and staples' prices across north of Africa and parts of the middle east.
- Spooky23 10y agoApparently the author wasn't willing to write about what he heard. Pretty low content ratio here.
- systematical 10y agoNot much substance in this article...
- robocat 10y agoThis article smells like the journalist has been tricked.
- drawnwren 10y agoI agree. The interviewee sounds more like a script kiddie with a very powerful script than anyone of note at the NSA.
- anf 10y agoWhat qualifies someone to be "of note"?
- drawnwren 10y agoIn the context of my comment, I meant someone deeply involved in the technical implementation of collection techniques or strategy. The interviewee comes across as someone who is skilled at a small process but doesn't seem to be the person who discovered the exploit or did a significant part of the creative thinking involved in the exploit.
- anf 10y agoFor the purposes of an article like this, I don't think technical prowess would be very useful. He's providing an opinion informed by speaking with a variety of people with clearance speaking freely about their work. That's pretty rare in its own right.
- drawnwren 10y agoWhile you are correct, my intent was to serve as a counterpoint to statements like this in the article, "He identified himself and his highly trained colleagues at the NSA as a breed apart — a superior breed, much in the way that soldiers look down on weekend paintballers. Perhaps this shouldn’t be altogether surprising, because arrogance is one of the unfortunate hallmarks of the male-dominated hacker culture."
- ryanmarsh 10y agoThere's enough personally identifying information given for the lamb that, assuming it's not a smoke screen, he'd be easy to dox. My instincts tell me this was a PR/recruitment piece (or a hoax) and the journalist fell right into it.
- ryanlol 10y ago> assuming it's not a smoke screen, he'd be easy to dox. So what? Just because he doesn't want his name in the article doesn't mean he's scared to death about his name coming out.
- batbomb 10y agoThis is garbage. There is easily enough information to uniquely identify him (lamb of god, religious convictions, recently left the NSA, social media), which calls into question the entire premise of the article.
- anf 10y agoHow so? I'm sure he revealed exactly as much as he intended to by his surroundings. He's not exactly leaking classified info, just contributing a personal opinion.
- mmaunder 10y agoThanks. It started feeling like Wired after a few paragraphs so I bailed. Filler piece I guess.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- drawnwren 10y agoAre the leaks redacted originally? If not, all someone would have to do would be cross reference the linked slides with the originals.
- AdeptusAquinas 10y agoThose details seemed to be highlighted almost, which means Id assume the journalist made them up to anonymise the hacker.
- efes 10y agoMaybe he didn't want it comming up when HR departments do background checks.. But another possibility is that the real person that corresponds to the leaked messages isnt such a perfect shill, but he can't complain as this PR imposter never claimed to be him.
- harry8 10y agoThe NSA can ID him. It's not just the NSA he'd want to be anonymous from. "Famous" NSA Hacker guy - target for every wannabe braggart script-kiddie etc. He might be comfortable with the NSA knowing who he is and that he's talking the intercept but not comfortable with his local shopkeeper, his kid's grade-school teacher, priest knowing the same.
- simbalion 10y agoNo matter what he might think he feels, he is not amongst his 'brethren' at def con. I thought the reference to the film 'good will hunting' was appropriate, because the subject of the article is a sell-out.
- ganoushoreilly 10y agoI would bet even within the agency (assuming he's real) this guy is an exception. most of the feds i've met at "FedCon" are actually pretty normal people and seem genuine in the interests and motivations (even if people disagree with their roles). The whole article comes off a bit braggadocios for this insider and more of a fluff piece by the Intercept to push more viewers.
- spacecowboy_lon 10y agoThat's a big ask and very subjective POV
- simbalion 10y agoSubjective? I disagree. From everything I know of the hacker scene, working for the NSA to invade people's privacy for Uncle Sam is not good karma.
- sverige 10y agoThe problem with spies of any stripe is that you can never know if they're lying. Le Carre's books do the best job of communicating this depressing fact, I think. So if you can't know whether they're lying, any information they provide is just noise ultimately, because you'll very rarely (like never) beat them at their game; and if you do, they'll change the game.
- spacecowboy_lon 10y agoDo you mean Spies or Officers?
- vonnik 10y agoI didn't find this piece particularly illuminating, frankly.
- fluxy 10y agoThe title was the only thing interesting from the article. Everything else is most probably made up.
- shrugger2 10y agoHello, I am a hacker that works for the NSA and you can believe me because I am telling the truth, obviously. I can confirm that the NSA hates all Americans, and are actually controlled by aliens from outer space, billions of light years away, and they've come to Earth because of our carbon-based lifeforms. Here is some personally identifying information so that the organization I belong to can kick my apartment open and waterboard me for weeks on end until I decide to bash my head against the wall on my own and end it, since I divulged their secrets and 'endangered' other Americans. * I am a male * my social security is 123 45 6789 * I live at 123 Obvious Bait Lane, Journalism, USA