10 ms·
The link between language and cognition is a red herring
- toolslive 10y agofinally somebody dares to say it: Chomsky's wrong. (It's also quite obvious that a linguist would say that "language" is of the utmost importance).
- eli_gottlieb 10y agoLots of people dare to say it. Then Chomsky comes to their research talks and heckles them.
- corecoder 10y agoWhat is he wrong about, exactly? (by the way, thousands of people have been saying that Chomsky's wrong for some fifty-something years, now).
- tim333 10y agoI'm not sure he is wrong. Here's a quote with his position. Seems fairly reasonable: QUESTION: It might help if you could define how you use the term “cognition” as opposed to the term “language.” CHOMSKY: Well, I wouldn’t use the term “cognition” as opposed to the term “language.” Rather, cognition is an overall term that includes every system of belief, knowledge, understanding, interpretation, perception, and so on. Language is just one of many systems that interact to form our whole complex of cognitive structures. (https://chomsky.info/1983____/ https://chomsky.info/1983____/)
- toolslive 10y agoI'm referring to the idea that reasoning requires language.
- Synaesthesia 10y agoI think there's it can't be denied that there is a strong link between cognition and language, since from introspection I feel that my thoughts are in language, and language certainly permits tremendous richness of expression of thought. Chomsky discusses these views here - I don't think this article repudiates them. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rH8SicnqSC4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rH8SicnqSC4 I will agree with the author that, despite being not possessing language, animals are more intelligent and sensitive than frequently given credit.
- leephillips 10y ago"from introspection I feel that my thoughts are in language" Have you ever had the experience of having to stop in mid-sentence, stuck, because a word was "on the tip of your tongue"?
- toolslive 10y agoSome people think visually, and then suffer from the problem that the solution of the problem that they "see" is difficult to explain in words.
- tokenadult 10y agoYou mean the strong version of the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis is wrong. Which people like me (originally trained as a linguist) have been saying for years.
- bitL 10y agoMaybe that hypothesis is wrong when your brain is young and as it starts losing its elasticity, it becomes valid?
- WorldMaker 10y agoThe Strong Sapir-Whorf hypothesis seems obviously deficient because you can certainly think about things your language has no words (concepts and feelings, etc). It's the Weak Sapir-Whorf hypothesis that is much more interesting and still at debate. Certainly things that are easier to describe in a language would seem easier to reason with. Our brains leverage language as a tool to map concepts and the concepts we can name are easier to grasp and utilize than the ones we cannot. The Weak hypothesis does seem like it would be affected by brain elasticity. Keeping concepts close to hand in your language would presumably keep them easier to conceptualize as your brain plasticizes.
- corecoder 10y agoWho does defend the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis? I've never seen anybody defending it, while I've seen lots of people arguing against it; the first name that comes to mind is Steven Pinker.
- micimize 10y agoChomsky believes the human capacity for language to be one of many "mental organs" specialized to different tasks. This article is pretty confused, and Chomsky would probably say the root cause of the author's confusion is the ill defined terms "language" and "thought".
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tim333 10y agoIt's interesting that we may get more insight into this stuff through building neural networks with similar functionality.
- Normal_gaussian 10y ago> But who says that what people say about themselves reveals actual emotions and motivations? > This might be true for simple attitudes free from moralisations (‘What is your favourite music?’) My answer to that question changes depending on who asks me, where, and when. As for a link between language and cognition, it completely depends on the definition. Like the arguments of religion they are both pointless and masturbatory unless the participants are willing to agree on concrete definitions beforehand. Cognition is murky because it involves understanding, and understanding is a most variable and undefined term.
- vinceguidry 10y agoWe don't think in terms of language. Language is simply a translation layer for the underlying neurological phenomenon. It feels like we think in language because we tend to understand concepts after they've been turned into words. I can turn this off and just compare the word referents to each other. In fact, I have to in order to get any serious thinking done. Translating to and from words just introduces friction. The tradeoff to doing this is that the end product insight is not at all relatable to other humans, it's some deep deep link into my subconscious that's extremely abstract. Sometimes I'll conjure up, in my head, an imaginary conversation partner, and converse with them. Then I will use words, because the point is to use the other person as a clarifying foil. I'll hew to the rules of human logic, and make points that they can follow. In my own head, I don't have to use the same logic everyone else does. To me, human logic presents as a strict subset of rules of my logic, but still "logic-complete" in that I can represent most of my findings in semantic form given enough time to find the right 'compilation'. I believe that language is in the process of deeply integrating into the brain and still isn't really done yet. People have tricks that they use in order to increase the compression rate of words. Narrative for instance. But we still have trouble reaching for words when we need them. I think the language part moves in parallel to the rest of the brain, silently translating thoughts and presenting them to the executive function. (what you think of as you) Thoughts are multi-dimensional, whereas words have many fewer. In the future, we'll become more strongly aware of the limitations semantics places on articulation. People tend to get too hung up on what words mean, and discussions will often digress to the moors of semantic posturing.
- ffwd 10y ago>I believe that language is in the process of deeply integrating into the brain and still isn't really done yet. People have tricks that they use in order to increase the compression rate of words. Narrative for instance. But we still have trouble reaching for words when we need them. I think the language part moves in parallel to the rest of the brain, silently translating thoughts and presenting them to the executive function. (what you think of as you) Thoughts are multi-dimensional, whereas words have many fewer. Yeah I don't know about all this though. Maybe the brain is very messy and we can't really understand something consciously until we can write/speak it in words, and that words connect disparate thoughts into something meaningful. Maybe this is what you were getting at with 'multi dimensional', but I would think language creates structure, not reduce structure. For things directly related to the body and rote repetition, the brain might do things we can't consciously express while still being good at it, but that's not really knowledge, that's more automatic neural response. To have knowledge you should have to encode it into some language I think. On a more broad level, I wonder what symbols like the alphabet and words really 'are', I would tend to think they have no more priority than other stimuli from the environment, but that rather in themselves as an environment for the brain, they have a lot of innate capability for representation and that the brain has learned to manipulate that environment with great skill, but that as far as internal thought goes it's just another environment like navigating a forest or sleeping in a hidden place under the trees to hide from predators. "it's all aesthetic as stimuli" so to speak
- fennecfoxen 10y ago> I am not sure that I think in words, and I never seem to hear any inner voices. This caused a bit of an embarrassment once at a meeting about the evolution of conscience, when fellow scholars kept referring to an inner voice that tells us what is right and wrong. I am sorry, I said, but I never hear such voices. Speaking overbroadly, with way too many generalizations, simplifications, and the like... You stand a stronger chance of hearing such voices if you actively seek out and speak to those voices. The directive given to young children to actively seek out and talk to their conscience (a la Pinnochio) is a cultural one which, over time, can shape a portion of your mind to give you this sort of feedback. Further training of this portion of your mind might be provided through a channel such as certain traditions of prayer or meditation found in western Christianity, seeking to program this part of the brain to guide you to be as ethical as possible; some Protestant denominations in particular focus extensively on building a "personal relationship with God" through conversational prayer. Specifics may vary widely within individual cultures, and even over an individual's lifetime, but America in general has seen a strong influence from Protestantism over the years, and it may be affecting the way people in America organize their thoughts with inner dialogue. I wonder if those working in the science of conscience are subject to some sort of cognitive self-selection bias...
- mitchty 10y agoHe just might be one of the roughly 1 in 70 people that lack inner monologue. I remember reading about another person a month back that had a hard time reading books because we use visual metaphors in books and can do thing like imagine a beach in our minds eye. But not everyone can apparently. Can't find the link will keep digging through my history.
- corecoder 10y agoThat's interesting, can you point me to a source about the 1 to 70 ratio? I once had a weird conversation with a friend about thinking in a foreign language: he said he didn't understand what that would mean, as he didn't usually think in our own language anyway.
- coldtea 10y ago>Oddly enough, this particular desire must have passed me by, because I have never felt it. I am not waiting to hear what my animals have to say about themselves Confirmation bias? >This might be true for simple attitudes free from moralisations (‘What is your favourite music?’), but it seems almost pointless to ask people about their love life, eating habits, or treatment of others (‘Are you pleasant to work with?’). It is far too easy to invent post-hoc reasons for one’s behaviour, to be silent about one’s sexual habits, to downplay excessive eating or drinking, or to present oneself as more admirable than one really is. No one is going to admit to murderous thoughts, stinginess or being a jerk. I'm not sure where this person lives, but they don't seem to have much social experience. People lie yes. But they also tell the truth all the bloody time too, even for what would seemingly be their most private thoughts. Heck, sometimes you need to really try hard to stop them from endlessly filling you in into what they believe is the truth -- including about their flaws. >In one study, female college students reported more sex partners when they were hooked up to a fake lie-detector machine, demonstrating that they had been lying when interviewed without the lie-detector. Well, duh. An interview situation, and with a lie-detector attached to your hand to boot, where you're being asked to reveal private data to a random stranger/official, is nothing like confiding to another human being. >There is a notable irony here. In an earlier age, the absence of language was used as an argument against the existence of thought in other species. Today I find myself upholding the position that the manifest reality of thinking by nonlinguistic creatures argues against the importance of language. The real irony is not seeing that the "hand gestures" and other signals the author seems to appreciate, also constitute a language (as they have all the essential attributes of one -- actual verbalizations in sound or writing are secondary expressions of having a language).
- morsch 10y agoHe mostly rejects that we literally think in words: ‘The obvious (and I should have thought sufficient) refutation of the claim that natural languages are the medium of thought is that there are non-verbal organisms that think.’ (This is him quoting Jerry Fodor.) I don't think this is particularly controversial among contemporary linguists. It's important to him because if we did think in natural languages, and if further we were the only linguistic animal (which he first posits and than backtracks), then it would follow that animals do not think, which, given only such a binary option, seems absurd. There is a rich field of linguistics that studies the relationship between language and cognition: Language can shape the way we think in obvious and non-obvious ways even if it does not determine the limits of our cognition. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linguistic_relativity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linguistic_relativity One field I found very rewarding (and approachable) is conceptual metaphors, involving parallels in cognition and language. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conceptual_metaphor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conceptual_metaphor So I think the title of the article is sort of a red herring itself.
- theptip 10y agoYes, exactly this. It does feel like something of a straw man argument that the author is disproving (though perhaps it's one that he encounters often). I think the obvious and un-controversial position is slightly more complicated; language is not required for thought, but like most (every?) other activity in the brain, it affects thought.
- panglott 10y agoThe metaphor I like is that "language is a tool for thought". It's a technology that dramatically expands human cognitive potential, to the extent that they could be confused. There's a great Radiolab episode about the experiences of some Deaf adults who acquired (sign) language as adults (the 1st story) and an adult who temporarily lost language ability as an adult due to brain trauma (the 2nd): http://www.radiolab.org/story/91725-words/ http://www.radiolab.org/story/91725-words/
- PepeGomez 10y agoHow does language expand human cognitive potential?
- koonsolo 10y agoSee http://www.slate.com/blogs/lexicon_valley/2013/10/16/piraha_cognitive_anumeracy_in_a_language_without_numbers.html http://www.slate.com/blogs/lexicon_valley/2013/10/16/piraha_... 'Among Pirahã's many peculiarities is an almost complete lack of numeracy, an extremely rare linguistic trait of which there are only a few documented cases. The language contains no words at all for discrete numbers and only three that approximate some notion of quantity—hói, a "small size or amount," hoí, a "somewhat larger size or amount," and baágiso, which can mean either to "cause to come together" or "a bunch."' ... 'We can only count so fast, after all, but the Pirahã appear not to be counting at all—because, well, how could they? Instead, they're employing what Everett calls an "analog estimation strategy," which works well for a few items but breaks down beyond that.'
- PepeGomez 10y agoBut are they unable to count, because their language has no words for numbers, or does their language lack words for numbers because they don't count?
- alanwatts 10y ago>We walked down the path to the well-house, attracted by the fragrance of the honeysuckle with which it was covered. Some one was drawing water and my teacher placed my hand under the spout. As the cool stream gushed over one hand she spelled into the other the word water, first slowly, then rapidly. I stood still, my whole attention fixed upon the motions of her fingers. Suddenly I felt a misty consciousness as of something forgotten — a thrill of returning thought; and somehow the mystery of language was revealed to me. I knew then that "w-a-t-e-r" meant the wonderful cool something that was flowing over my hand. That living word awakened my soul, gave it light, hope, joy, set it free! There were barriers still, it is true, but barriers that could in time be swept away. >I left the well-house eager to learn. Everything had a name, and each name gave birth to a new thought. As we returned to the house every object which I touched seemed to quiver with life. That was because I saw everything with the strange, new sight that had come to me. -Helen Keller, The Story of My Life
- gerbilly 10y agoCognition doesn't require language, but it can use language. The brain is a parallel processing engine, and can recruit several modules at once for cognition, spatial modules, visual ones etc...[1] It's a good thing we don't think in words, because as good as they are for transmitting information to others, and for recording it, it is a serial format, and the part of our brain that processes it has a limited capacity.[2] If you've ever had the solution to a problem come to you before you can express it in words, you know that words aren't required for cognition, even awareness isn't.[3] [1] http://psychologydictionary.org/working-memory/ http://psychologydictionary.org/working-memory/ [2] http://psychologydictionary.org/phonological-loop/ http://psychologydictionary.org/phonological-loop/ [3] Cognition can go on subconsciously and then present us with the solution to a problem ready made. They typical Eureka experience.
- ComodoHacker 10y agoNo reference to research, just a plug for a newly published book. Skipped. P.S. The book itself might be interesting and have references, I don't know.
- hzhou321 10y ago(I again find myself on the other side of most comments) I think it is obvious that we think in a language, or more specifically the vocabulary. Try to imagine thinking without language (yes, you can do it), e.g. think about an apple. When I tried it, I was picturing the apple and imagined the smell and taste. That was a lot of details. On the other hand, when I think about with the word "apple", the shape and color, smell and taste does not come on so strongly yet I still have the feel that I got the (idea of) apple. So in my opinion, language vocabulary is an abstraction over a collection of ideas that allows us to focus our thought without recollecting (flood our limited short term memory slots) all the details. There is this saying that our short term memory only have 7 plus or minus 2 slots and this short term memory is like our ram that enables our thinking. Vocabulary allows us to abstract complex ideas to fit into a single memory slot, thus it is essential for us to be able to have complex (when we have multiple components of ideas interweaving) thoughts. Now, I do not distinguish one language from another. Different languages may accidentally possess different power of abstraction in particular area due to the culture behind the language, but in general, I believe the abstraction power is similar -- if not, we can always invent new vocabulary and we do. So whether you are thinking in English or Spanish or jumping back and forth or mixing in between, but the abstracting aspect remain the same. For those bi-linguists try think "apple" in one language and "eat" in another language and try think anything that involves eating apple. For me at least, I do not have trouble use either language for either apple or eat, but once I start my thought, I do not swap it -- that is, if I started thinking apple in English, I remains thinking apple in English. It is the function of words as abstracting that is key to our thought (not language as typically a language teacher would define). Then there is grammar in addition to vocabulary. I don't think grammar is part of our thought. They are more like cues. We don't think about grammar, but grammar automatically comes as we use the vocabulary. The grammar do not really occupy any memory slots (except when you are learning the language). It is not that we have to think in a language -- we can think in pictures and imagine playing a movie, but thinking via a language allows us to think in a more abstract way and I believe it is essential for us to develop and grab complex thoughts.
- corecoder 10y agoI think that we have to give up the idea that we can understand anything about thought and more generally cognitive processes by looking at how it "feels" thinking (or doing math, vision, etc). The more we observe how we work, the more we learn that we really have no idea how we work. The ancient idea that we can understand reason by reasoning have to be abandoned: it is, after all, an idealistic belief; if we accept that our cognitive processes are physical phenomena, we also have to accept that reasoning without observation is powerless.
- bobthechef 10y agoHonestly, define language first because the word it thrown around and used sloppily with no one taking the time to reflect on it. (I shouldn't be surprised, of course, by the willingness of HN posters to pontificate on subjects they have not studied or comprehended in any meaningful way. The Emory professor is just embarrassing to read.) This topic has been studied for a very long time and a rudimentary understanding of concept, signifier, denotation, etc, would cut the bullshit drastically. Donald Davidson, Karl Buehler and Karl Popper are contemporary contributors to the subject. Frege. Aristotle. Tarski. I can keep going.
- panglott 10y agoNo wonder people may assume the philosophy of language is outdated, if Aristotle is a contemporary contributor ;)
- joe_the_user 10y agoThe article is something of a Rorschach blot - mention language and consciousness and a hundred ill-defined pet theories are going to come of peoples mouth, or out of their fingertips onto the comment section. Not that these pet theories are necessarily bad. Usually they're variations on existing frameworks but with lots of things left uninvestigated because each theory is developed just enough to satisfy the individual.
- hyperion2010 10y agoI tend to think that we think in actions and consequences. It just so happens that speech is an action which has a very tight loop for direct consequences which other parts of the brain can make use of (sound waves). When you're angry you imagine punching someone, or if you're happy you imagine jumping around ecstatically, etc. The tight coupling between sound an movement means that the agent in the brain for most people just uses the auditory representation since it is more salient (grabs the attention better) than the motor movements of the mouth/tongue/vocal cords. When learning a new language and trying to figure out how to produce a new phoneme if all you think about is the sound that comes out rather than what you are actually doing with your speech motor system you will have a much harder time learning. Consider a deaf person whispering or a 'truly' deaf person (who can't hear low frequencies via bone conduction) speaking. They can do it, but they must be thinking in terms of the movement of their mouth and vocal cords, not in terms of the 'sound' they make.
- Animats 10y agoFrom an AI standpoint, that's probably right. This was an unpopular position in AI a few decades ago. As progress continues on vision, robotics, automatic driving, and dealing with the real world without language, it's become more of a mainstream position. All the mammals have relatively similar DNA, and the DNA differences between humans and the great apes are minor. This suggests that getting to chimpanzee-level AI is 90-95% of the way to human-level AI. Yet that doesn't require language.
- bitcuration 10y agoAs everyone's ability to express self is different, there is certainly a difference how linguistical one's forming thought in own head. My theory is, more you engaged in inter-person communication, from moment to habit, more you may have thought in the form of language, and more the thoughts are limited by the nature language. Deep thoughts especially those sparked creativity are certainly much beyond language, and difficult to express. Complex concept takes time to communicate is a proof of this.
- westoncb 10y agoThe mathematician Jacques Hadamard carried out an interesting study on this subject and presented his findings in a small book called, "The Psychology of Invention in the Mathematical Field". Here are a couple of excerpts from it that I found compelling (he's talking about a sort of 'schematic' thinking with something like relationship diagrams, and much of his motivation is the contention that thinking is only done linguistically): "Indeed, every mathematical research compels me to build such a schema, which is always and must be of a vague character, so as not to be deceptive. I shall give a less elementary example from my first researches (my thesis). I had to consider a sum of an infinite number of terms, intending to valuate its order of magnitude. In that case, there is a group of terms which chances to be predominant, all others having a negligible influence. Now, when I think of that question, I see not the formula itself, but the place it would take if written: a kind of ribbon, which is thicker or darker at the place corresponding to the possibly important terms; or (at other moments), I see something like a formula, but by no means a legible one, as I should see it (being strongly long-sighted) if I had no eye-glasses on, which letters seeming rather more apparent (though still not legible) at the place which is supposed to be the important one." "About the mathematicians born or resident in America, whom I asked, phenomena are mostly analogous to those which I have noticed in my own case. Practically all of them -- contrary to what occasional inquiries had suggested to Galton as to the man on the street -- avoid not only the use of mental words, but also, just as I do, the mental use of algebraic or any other precise signs; also as in my case, they use vague images." My experience with thinking in abstract domains matches this perfectly—and I bet it can be trained/taught. I've written more on the subject here, btw: http://westoncb.blogspot.com/2013/01/an-architecture-for-deliberate-thought.html http://westoncb.blogspot.com/2013/01/an-architecture-for-del...
- fao_ 10y ago> My experience with thinking in abstract domains matches this perfectly—and I bet it can be trained/taught. Well, when I first started reading mathematics books I found them extremely difficult to read, and had to labour over each statement that was made to try and get the structure of the thing they were defining -- nowadays a lot of the trouble has subsided, because I'm more able to visualise it. An example of this are the set-theoretic ideas of sets, union, intersection, etc. Nowadays something a bit like a Venn diagram appears in my head, that I can manipulate at will. One thing to note is that I used to put a lot of focus on the names of variables, whereas now I think more about what it represents in general. I would add that something similar happened with programming.
- DamagedProperty 10y agoI prescribe to the idea that all thought and language is metaphorical. Language and thought do exist separately but also combine in useful ways for all of us. This is why you can think of something but not find the word for it. But just look at the metaphorical structure of language. Concepts are nothing but our ability to map our modalities in a way that become useful for our biological goals. George Lakoff has some great books on metaphors. Metaphors we live by is a great book.
- AnthonBerg 10y agoIt being a red herring is another red herring.
- mwfunk 10y agoSpeaking just for myself, language is thought and thought is language. I've talked to other people about their inner monologues (or lack of one) and everyone has different experiences (or different perceptions of similar experiences, a la the blind men and the elephant). Unless I have articulated a thought in my head in terms of language, I don't feel like I have thought of anything at all. My nonverbal "thoughts" are just a mishmash of emotions, memories, images, sensory input, reflexive reactions to things, and pseudorandom associations that pop up occasionally. If other people can think in depth about abstract concepts through some means other than imagining words to describe those concepts, I'm either very very jealous, or they don't mean the same thing I do by words like "thought" and "thinking". In the same way that we use language to serialize ideas from one person to another, my own mind uses language to communicate with my own lower-level cognitive processes. Those low-level processes are the real sources of thought, but without language to interpret what bubbles up from that level, and without language to steer thinking at that level, I would lose the ability to debug my own brain (root out biases, play devil's advocate against myself, examine my own mental state, make good life choices, understand other people's points of view, etc.). I don't know if this applies to anyone but me, but without using language as a tool for reasoning, I feel like I would 100% be a product of my environment, and not someone who is capable of imagining different paths that my life could take and then going down one of the non-default paths (which is good, because otherwise I'm pretty sure I would've been dead or in jail by age 30 :).
- ktRolster 10y agoSpeaking just for myself, language is thought and thought is language. I used to be like that, but then I learned a second language, and learned to think in the second language. Soon, I realized their was a place in my mind where thoughts were formed, before being verbalized (although the verbalization happened so fast and automatically before that I didn't notice it). Then I learned to trust that non-verbalized part of my brain, and I could think faster by not using words. Another way to see the same effect while not going to the effort is while playing a game like chess; you can think "she moves here, then I move there, the she moves there...." going with words through all the variations. But if you just look at the variations without putting them into words, you can go faster.
- mwfunk 10y agoI'm not a fan of Ayn Rand, but I have read some insightful statements from her over the years. The one that has stuck with me the most is the idea that if you don't have a conscious, clearly defined philosophy, then your actions are still dictated by SOME philosophy. You just don't know what it is because you've never articulated it or thought critically about it. It is almost certainly a mishmash of biases and contradictions. By articulating your own philosophy (i.e., just putting it into words), you gain the ability to critically reason about it, better understand your own feelings and actions, and hopefully fix the ways in which that unarticulated philosophy was broken. I'm sure there are lots of other people who are a lot smarter than I am and don't need to articulate things in order to reason about them, but I am not one of those people.
- wodenokoto 10y agoI'm not really sure what claim it is he is trying to refute.