6 ms·
Fish Have Feelings Too
- anusburger 10y agoKurt is a goddamn liar.
- nefitty 10y agoIt gets harder everyday for me to justify consuming any type of animal product. I wish there wasn't so much distance between vegetarianism/veganism and mainstream morality. I understand that hard line ethical stances are off-putting, especially when it comes to ingrained cultural behaviors like eating. I'm glad these types of articles and research are getting attention, though. Society benefits the more conscientious people become about their everyday choices.
- greglindahl 10y agoThe way to not be off-putting is to not proselytize.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- rosser 10y agoIt's perfectly possible to be strictly veg*an and not be a dick. I just really wish I could convince some of my acquaintances of that. I'm currently eating meat on the instruction of multiple of my healthcare practitioners, but I was a strict vegetarian, and part-time vegan for years before that, and I never pissed anyone off by getting in their faces about their dietary choices. I would happily have a conversation with anyone who wanted about my choices and why I'd made them (primarily ecological, secondarily ethical), but I would always explain things as being a matter of me choosing how I wanted to live my life. My choices were never offered as normative, and although I don't think I changed any minds, I also never lost any friends.
- tw04 10y agoA lion wouldn't struggle with eating you if given the option, why would you waste time returning the favor? I get making a concerted effort to make sure animals don't suffer in the process of becoming food as much as humanly possible, but refusing to eat other animals when you're an apex predator is... silly. For starters, you may quickly find yourself no longer apex. Do you enjoy spending time outdoors without fearing for your life?
- rosser 10y agoLions don't have prefrontal cortices. Humans aren't obligate carnivores. Yes, we're omnivores, but we have a choice to engage more ethically with the animals we choose to put on our plates. To point to animals that have to kill other animals or they will die as normative for our behavior is fatuously specious.
- greglindahl 10y agoA good example of how to be off-putting.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- vacri 10y agoHumans generally don't eat apex predators. Herbivores and omnivores are our preferred dietary targets. And given how much we've made our stamp on the world, the idea that we'd lose 'apex predator' status is nonsensical.
- Udik 10y agoThe essence of modern ethics is not to do to others what they'd do to you - it's not doing to others what you wouldn't want to be done to you. Unfortunately, I see this kind of reasoning applied often also to relations among peoples: "in their country they wouldn't allow you to, so ..." and even "if it were for them, they'd kill us, so...". This is wrong.
- pygy_ 10y agoNext up we'll find that in their own way we can't relate to, plants and even single cells are conscious too. Nihilarianism is the only choice we can justify ethically. Alternatively, what Raed667 said (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11943656 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11943656)...
- douche 10y agoIs anybody surprised that fish are kind of sentient? Nevertheless, they are still really tasty...
- wyager 10y agoI am almost certain that 100 years from now, almost everyone will look back on the farming of sentient animals in the same way we look back on human slavery. Meat farming is more or less essential to our standard of living and it's completely socially normalized, and yet there are obvious and compelling moral arguments against it. The same was true of slavery 250 years ago. As with slavery and the industrial revolution, I suspect improved technology (i.e. tank-grown meat) will eliminate our dependence on meat farming, and its social acceptability will soon follow. I say this as someone who eats meat from sentient animals, but recognizes that vegans have a uniquely coherent, self-consistent, and compelling set of arguments against the practice.
- chucksmash 10y agoI think a comparison to slavery might be a little ambitious here. There are plenty of other things we presently do to human beings which our ancestors can be cross with us for that are probably higher on the badness scale than eating meat.
- rosser 10y ago> ...probably higher on the badness scale than eating meat. You're kinda making 'wyager's point for him. http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Not_as_bad_as http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Not_as_bad_as
- chucksmash 10y agoThat's a bit tangential. My point (which I stand by) is that eating meat is almost certainly not the epoch-defining evil in the world today the way slavery was for America in the 19th century. I've made no comment on whether we should or should not worry about it because there are umpteen worse things - just that the early 2000s aren't likely to be looked back on as the decades of the eaters of the flesh. Maybe I'm wrong...
- codezero 10y agoI've been very cynical that this would be true. I really hope it is, and until now, I wasn't sure other people felt the same way I did about it. Thanks for posting this. I'd love to buy you a beer.
- Raed667 10y agoI honestly can't seem to care whether the things I'm eating have feelings or not. But I'm considering cutting down on meat (especially bovine) because of its carbon footprint.
- kranner 10y agoUnfortunately none of the examples provided in the article (I haven't read the book) prove sentience or suffering as a result of pain. They demonstrate pain, but it can be argued that the pain that fish feel is nonconscious/nonsentient. I'm only complaining that the proof here isn't watertight btw. As a former-meateater-turned-vegetarian (because of 'sentience' guilt) my intuition is that the pain they feel must be similar to the pain we feel.
- rosser 10y agoEpistemic asymmetry. You can't even prove that the pain-behavior you observe me demonstrating reflects an internal experience that's anything like your experience of pain, so asking for "proof" that a fish's pain is actually painful isn't even an objectively meaningful question.
- kranner 10y agoRed herring :) I know I can't know what it's like to be a bat, but maybe suffering in fish can be demonstrated via FMRI. Perhaps it has been but this article doesn't mention it. Just because something shows avoidance behaviour against a chemical gradient doesn't follow that it suffers.
- rosser 10y agoSuffering is experiential and subjective. Pain is measurable, in terms of neurotransmitters and electrical activity. Different people can tolerate pain wildly differently. The same person can tolerate pain wildly differently, depending upon circumstances. One can't even meaningfully draw a straight-line relationship from pain to suffering between individuals of the same species, let alone across as wide a gulf as fish to humans.
- kranner 10y agoI understood your point the first time. I'm talking about the leap made between the article's contents and the headline. Edit: we might mean somewhat different things by 'suffering'. I'm talking about an experience usually (but not always) concomitant with pain that can be measured objectively. Is there such a thing? Can it be measured? I don't know for sure. I feel that it must be there in fish too, but the shallow conflation in this article of suffering and seeming-to-act-under-suffering is a problem for me.
- codezero 10y agoI stopped eating meat after stories last summer highlighted people eating dog at a festival in China. I was very upset, and mad, but then I asked myself, why was eating dog so upsetting? The dogs eaten in China were much less abused than any animal eaten in the US. We have industrialized the slaughter of animals. Either I am OK with dogs being eaten, or I am not OK with the industrialized slaughter of every other animal. I still love the smell of meat. I remember the things I loved to eat, and it's a struggle, but we (many of us at least) live in a world where we don't need to imprison and eat animals to sustain our lives. With all that said, I don't expect anyone else to feel the same way. We're slaughtering animals constantly, and I don't have any expectation that anyone stop eating animals.
- asciimo 10y agoIt's heartening to hear your story. It's hard to come to terms with cognitive dissonance and change your behavior.
- codezero 10y agoIt's very very hard. I am lucky to have a wife who has been vegan for many many years to help support me.
- wahern 10y agoI resolved the cognitive dissonance by actually eating dog on a trip to South Korea. Choosing not to eat meat doesn't really resolve all the problems. Not that eating dog does. But, for example, on a recent walk through Golden Gate Park I noticed signs that referred to "dog guardians" rather than "dog owners". I found that interesting. I neither agree nor disagree with that terminology, but it just goes to show that the issue isn't a binary matter of choosing to eat or not eat animals. I've been eating much less meat lately, for various reasons. But I tend to think that by choosing to be vegan some people are taking the easy way out--in the present sociocultural environment being vegan is our "get out of jail free card" in terms of dealing with the issue of humane treatment of animals. But without a more sophisticated and nuanced line drawing, it's a facile choice. Eating animals is only one dimension among many in regards to their humane treatment. And in some respects it's the least interesting and even the least harmful.
- pvaldes 10y agoZebra fish feel pain, as everybody knew before, because... they have pain receptors. This is extrapolated somehow to: The 31.000 species of fish extant "have feelings too", that is a big jump in my opinion. Last hour news: Corals and slugs also can feel pain. Ehhhmmm... Was this experiment really neccessary to the improvement of the human knowledge? Where is my big surprise?