8 ms·
China Tops U.S. in Supercomputers
- narrator 10y agoWhat's worse is that the U.S prevented China from buying Intel chips to build their supercomputer with[1]. It was a huge order and probably had something to do with the recent layoffs. [1] http://nextbigfuture.com/2016/05/us-supercomputer-chip-ban-delayed.html?m=1 http://nextbigfuture.com/2016/05/us-supercomputer-chip-ban-d...
- bhouston 10y agoThe worst is yet to come. China's home grown chips may now spread out from China to undercut Intel at the end high cloud market if Linux-based software is easy to port to it. Intel's CPUs are way over priced and ripe for disruption if someone can get the required massive upfront investment to create a real competitor, and it looks like China is doing this. Repeatedly topping the supercomputer list is perfect marketing for introducing a new high performance CPU to the world.
- lallysingh 10y agoAFAIK, Chinese CPUs are MIPS and Alpha based. Both run Linux well.
- ams6110 10y agoThis post has a little more detail about the processors: http://www.nextplatform.com/2016/06/20/look-inside-chinas-chart-topping-new-supercomputer/ http://www.nextplatform.com/2016/06/20/look-inside-chinas-ch... Summary, it's a RISC architecture that resembles an Alpha but it's not a straight-up copy.
- Brybry 10y agoI wonder what the process node size of SW26010 is and if the chips were actually manufactured in China or if they were manufactured by TSMC/Taiwan. I wasn't aware that China had competitive fabrication plants for processors. If they don't and they built these at say 40 or 45nm then wouldn't this design performance be even more impressive?
- melling 10y agoSounds like a big win for consumers. AMD has not been very competitive. Intel needs to remember that "only the paranoid survive."
- Retric 10y agoCPU performance is not that important when building a supercomputer it's more budget * performance per node / price per node. Performance per node is useful as most workloads only scale so far.
- bhouston 10y agoYes, but that is exactly what people are generally looking for in cloud machines. But I guess we need a benchmark that is oriented to web application development such as serving N nginx/go/nodejs requests per second, or running a MySQL/Postgres/MondoDB server at a certain load.
- mtgx 10y agoA former NSA and CIA chief, wrote a post about stuff like this, before the US banned US chip makers from selling to China: > By the time I became NSA director in the late 1990s, however, the calculation was no longer that simple. We still wanted an MTOPS advantage, of course, but we were fast realizing that our preferred limits were undermining the global competitiveness of the U.S. computer industry — the very industry on which we relied for our success. It was becoming clear that the overall health of that industry was more important than any MTOPS advantage against a specific target country. We still insisted on limits with regard to places such as Cuba and North Korea, but we became far more forgiving elsewhere. This, of course, had a powerful, positive commercial impact, but the NSA didn’t flip its position for commercial reasons. We did it for security reasons. On balance, this change made us stronger, not weaker, over the long haul, since retarding exports would inevitably retard the technological progress that was both our economic and our security lifeblood. That early lesson has caused me to continue to challenge arguments that technological protectionism furthers national security. It might, but then again, it could have the opposite effect if it freezes development, alienates allies, feeds distrust or invites the creation of similar barriers abroad. I would recommend these broader considerations to those in the U.S. security enterprise with responsibility for evaluating these trade-offs today. https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/dont-let-america-be-boxed-in-by-its-own-computers/2015/04/02/30742192-cc04-11e4-8a46-b1dc9be5a8ff_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/dont-let-america-be-... The whole post is worth reading. The same logic could be applied to US trying to put backdoors in its products for a specific national security goal, which will ultimately end up undermining US technological supremacy and national security as well. And yet the current CIA director just implied that US would be fine with backdoored products, because "where are people going to get their encryption from? The foreigners? Ha!" This sort of arrogance, which is the same type of arrogance that ended up banning chip sales to China last year, is what will make the US lose out in the long term. https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20160618/08022234741/cia-director-john-brennan-says-non-us-encryption-is-theoretical.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20160618/08022234741/cia-d...
- nickpsecurity 10y agoThanks for that article by Hayden. Wow. It echoed much of what Schneier et al kept saying to him. Shows that they're more honest, receptive, or both when they finally leave the job that forces them to BS for SIGINT gains. ;)
- KKKKkkkk1 10y agoWhy is it bad if China wants to subsidize hardware for others?
- bhouston 10y agoWell it is good for consumers, but it is clearly bad for Intel.
- peter303 10y agoI've hearing this for over three decades: "Country X is on the brinking of beating US general computing lead." I must have shuddered in over 60 pairs of boots since then.
- mrb 10y agoExcept it happened and you didn't even notice. Much computer electronics is designed and made in China. And today this: "China Tops U.S. in Supercomputers". What more evidence do you want?
- winter_blue 10y agoWhy was China banned from buying Intel chips?
- detaro 10y ago> In a notice published online the US Department of Commerce said it refused Intel's application to export the chips for Tianhe-2 and three other Chinese supercomputers because the machines were being used for "nuclear explosive activities". http://nextbigfuture.com/2015/04/us-will-make-180-petaflop-supercomputer.html http://nextbigfuture.com/2015/04/us-will-make-180-petaflop-s...
- mtgx 10y agoOh no, they're using their supercomputers to do nuclear research? That's horrible. Who would do such a thing? The given reason is all bullshit, and they must think we're all morons if they expect us to buy it. If anything it's retaliation for some IP theft or some silent trade war going on between China and the US. It's certainly not because the US gov is "shocked" that China uses its supercomputers to do nuclear research.
- zhte415 10y agoIf you want to sell technology products in the China market, you need to transfer technology to China, such as setting up a R&D centre. Everyone answers to sales. Then comes Machiavellian management strategies that demonstrate large companies are not idiots, and withdrawal of such scheme 2-5 years later, while still holding sales lines in China. Source: Have worked on both sides of the technology transfer equation.
- ams6110 10y agoWho said anybody was shocked?
- schoen 10y agoSimulating nuclear explosions in software has been a major response to treaties that forbid nuclear tests. As I think you were ironically pointing out, it's common now. It might be hard for the U.S. government to effectively prevent the Chinese government from doing these simulations, but it's plausible to me that the U.S. government would still want to see the Chinese government hindered in nuclear weapons simulations.
- mrb 10y agoSo let me get this straight: 1. Intel loses this business. 2. US employees lose their job. 3. China acquires skills designing the system themselves. 4. And they get to have their supercomputer after all. How can anyone not see how stupid these export restrictions are?
- angry_octet 10y agoMore like: 1. China creates much slower CPU which they will be able to sell to absolutely no-one. 2. Augments slow CPU with impossible to programming Xeon Phi. 3. Spends significant effort achieving heroic linpack benchmark. 4. Researchers are unable to obtain real world fast compute. 5. Chinese programs for stealth, submarines, nuclear are significantly delayed. Expertise diverted into useless PR project. 6. PR backlash as US goaded to reinvest in next generation supercomputing, GPUs, etc. Mission accomplished.
- DominikR 10y agoThey already did in 2013 with Tianhe-2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tianhe-2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tianhe-2 What is interesting about this new supercomputer is that it is apparently built with CPUs that were developed and produced by the Chinese themselves. New Supercomputer: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sunway_TaihuLight https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sunway_TaihuLight CPU architecture: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ShenWei https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ShenWei
- supergirl 10y agoclickbait title. previous top supercomputer, now number 2, was also chinese. should link this article instead of the paged, clickbait one: http://www.top500.org/news/china-tops-supercomputer-rankings-with-new-93-petaflop-machine/ http://www.top500.org/news/china-tops-supercomputer-rankings...
- qd6pwu4 10y agoHappy to see the US government ban intel chips from China, we are forced to make something by ourselves, good start.
- iofj 10y agoI have a question. 125.4 Pflop/s ... that would be about 23k nvidia GPUs (granted, 1080s). They claim they'll be able to do that with 10k by the end of the year, beginning of next year with server-class GPUs. So that Chinese number seems awfully low to me. I would expect that the number Amazon has to be higher, for instance. Same for Microsoft and Google. Therefore I'd be amazed if the DoD, NSA and even the DoE wouldn't have more capacity available.
- Etheryte 10y agoThis isn't about total computing power, but about computing power per one system.
- jobigoud 10y agoBut if you have an application that can be distributed transparently to thousands of GPUs, the difference between one and several systems is not very relevant.
- zhte415 10y agoIt is, because some problems can be distributed to 1000s of GPUs and done in parallel, and some can't, because the answer to one calculation depends on the answer to another calculation. You could combine the computing power of Azure, AWS and Google, and be pretty disappointed because of all the waiting time due to latency from one data center to another That's when the system's architecture - software and hardware - becomes important.
- dekhn 10y agoMany problems are very latency tolerant. Unless you have an algorithm which is truly latency intolerant, I argue you are best served not investing in low-latency interconnect because it costs so much. When I ran Exacycle, we distributed protein folding, protein design, drug discovery, telescope design, and other problems globally. We never had an issue with latency, because these problems all partition really well. People who claim supercomputers are "necessary" for these problems typically construct problems that are well-matched to supercomputers (for example, running molecular dynamics on huge proteins) but they tend not to have very high scientific value. In my experience, partitioning to minimize communication has always increased my total scientific throughput, while programming to supercomputers has always reduced it.
- sanxiyn 10y agoFor technical information, read the paper: http://www.netlib.org/utk/people/JackDongarra/PAPERS/sunway-report-2016.pdf http://www.netlib.org/utk/people/JackDongarra/PAPERS/sunway-... Compared to Tianhe-2, the previous top system, 2.7x more flops, and 3.2x more flops per watt.
- bjd2385 10y agoPlease excuse my ignorance in this area, I was just wondering - why does it matter so much who has the biggest and baddest supercomputer? Shouldn't that which we process on them matter more? A while back I recall reading rumors that China didn't even know what to process on their Tianhe-2. That kind of makes a supercomputer look like a pile of hardware, no matter how well it's organized or engraved.
- dibanez 10y agoIts essentially a matter of realistic benchmark acceptance. Right now machines are compared by how well they run this benchmark called LINPACK, which has been criticized for being non-representative of real science codes. As mentioned here [1], China's new system only achieved 0.3% of its peak flops on a slightly more realistic benchmark, HPCG. [1] http://www.hpcwire.com/2016/06/19/china-125-petaflops-sunway/ http://www.hpcwire.com/2016/06/19/china-125-petaflops-sunway...
- sanxiyn 10y agoWhile Sunway TaihuLight has weak HPCG performance, 0.3% number should be understood in context. Tianhe-2 (#2 system) scores 1.1%, and Titan (#3, US #1 system) scores 1.2% for HPCG. So Sunway TaihuLight is 3~4x worse for HPCG compared to other top systems. Note that K computer (#5 system, Japan) scores 4.9% for HPCG. So Tianhe-2 and Titan are again 4x worse for HPCG compared to systems which score best for HPCG.
- bhouston 10y agoWhy does the Sunway TaihuLight have bad HPCG performance? I suspect it has to do with memory bandwidth needed to serve 260C on the same chip?
- sanxiyn 10y agoYes, it's memory and interconnect. I don't think it's as simple as LINPACK bad, HPCG good. LINPACK is representative for some workloads, when compute dominates. HPCG aims to balance compute and memory. There is Graph500, if memory dominates for your workload. By the way, K computer is #1 in Graph500.
- bhouston 10y agoSo what is the cost of these CPUs? Could then be used in desktops or more importantly various cloud services (AWS, Google, Microsoft)? What OS do these run? Is there plans to commercialize these chips? We need accessible low cost ultra-high core count chips widely available. I feel that Intel and AMD have been under performing in this area (growing core count) for the last decade. And Intel has kept the price of CPUs exceptionally high for the last decade as well. If low cost ultra-high performance chips from China under cut Intel's excessively priced Xeons (+$3K per CPU), it really could change things. If these start to spread, I wouldn't be surprised if Intel tried to prevent the spread of these CPUs outside of China via trade barriers.
- imtringued 10y agoUltra-high performance and low cost don't belong in the same sentence. Even with intel if you want bang for buck you're better off buying 12 core CPUs than the 18 core ones.
- gbrown_ 10y agoWhilst touched on in the linked article but not mentioned is that the codes for the Gordon Bell runs are in the 30-40 petaflop range of sustained application performance. That's not too shabby. According to TOP500 author Jack Dongarra, three scientific simulation codes run on TaihuLight have been chosen as Gordon Bell Prize finalists, two of which have managed to reach a sustained performance of 30 to 40 petaflops. The award is bestowed each year on the most noteworthy HPC application, based on “peak performance or special achievements in scalability and time-to-solution on important science and engineering problems.” Source: http://www.top500.org/news/china-tops-supercomputer-rankings-with-new-93-petaflop-machine/ http://www.top500.org/news/china-tops-supercomputer-rankings...
- grkvlt 10y agoHere's something that's always bothered me. In the HPC and scientific computing world, it seems that the word 'program' is never used to refer to what is being run on the computers, rather it is always 'codes' (note plural) that are executed. Does anyone know when or why this split of terminology occurred?
- dkural 10y agoThe truth is, US Super-Computer spending is hard to justify and most of the owners of these in various national institutes are shopping for customers to justify their funding, although their set-up is not a good fit for many types of computing. Every dollar spent on building these computers is a dollar NOT spent in the budget of a research-driven grant. Give these dollars to physicists, mathematicians, genomics scientists, chemists, climate people etc. This way the demand in computing will dictate the type of systems built. p.s. I've attended the event in person that's listed in the article hosted by the OSTP, which is a part of the White House (National Strategic Computing Initiative). My conclusion was most of these computers aren't needed and a misdirection of funds to the tune of billions of dollars that computing / scientific computing could really benefit from in other ways.
- batbomb 10y agoYep. I'm part of a significant project which is being shoehorned into a Cray because the government has already spent the money for it. If it's not an MPI job, it's going to be painful.
- gbrown_ 10y ago> If it's not an MPI job, it's going to be painful. What are you using for communication between nodes? To make the tone clear I'm genuinely interested as I'm not sure what running on a Cray prevents you from doing?
- batbomb 10y agoThat's the problem: We don't need to communicate between the nodes; We don't need MPI. We need distributed databases and we might need Spark. We need machine learning. We need servers. We would like availability and reliability. We get full batch nodes that are relatively anemic in memory for our workload (4GB/core) for a maximum of 24 hours at a time.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- partiallypro 10y agoForgive my ignorance, but what's the point of a "super computer" in a world where we can have an application access thousands of machines around the world at once with a button click to compute something? I could see maybe cost savings, but considering how much it costs to build the machine and that I doubt it's used to 100% capacity at all times. Is it a security thing, or just a pride thing? What's the advantage over just farming it out to a cluster in the cloud?
- aab0 10y agoTraditionally, supercomputers and mainframes have way higher inter-node IO performance like bandwidth than anything you can spin up on EC2. IO is extremely important because it's very rare to have a true shared-nothing algorithm, which means that Amdahl's Law will bite you and make the little bit of IO and coordination a dominant factor. For example, in deep learning, an awful lot of the work is simply moving around and updating data, which has been a bottleneck for attempts to train NNs on multiple GPUs.
- filereaper 10y agoChina Tops for now Sierra and Summit are coming out soon, which are POWER based. https://www.olcf.ornl.gov/summit/ https://www.olcf.ornl.gov/summit/ http://www.cnet.com/news/ibm-nvidia-land-325-million-supercomputer-deal/ http://www.cnet.com/news/ibm-nvidia-land-325-million-superco...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- fspeech 10y agoDesigners of the supercomputer published their paper here: http://engine.scichina.com/publisher/scp/journal/SCIS/59/7/10.1007/s11432-016-5588-7?slug=abstract http://engine.scichina.com/publisher/scp/journal/SCIS/59/7/1...
- ArtDev 10y agoThe Chinese government has been committing industrial theft on a large scale for years. This is well-documented but somehow China has gotten away with it.
- jonbaer 10y agohttp://www.netlib.org/utk/people/JackDongarra/PAPERS/sunway-report-2016.pdf http://www.netlib.org/utk/people/JackDongarra/PAPERS/sunway-...