3 ms·
United States of Paranoia: A growing tribe of troubled minds
- bananasabk 10y agoIts a real phenomena; I'm a programmer and run r/gangstalkingmkultra. Humans did not evolve defenses against biohacking, We did not evolve: scales, snake eyes, ear drums seperate-enough from the skull. We consider these features ugly, not necessary... The animal mind is a sensor [of light, color, heat, sound, vibration, emf], and is extremely sensitive to these. There are 90+ patents for mind control, everything from Radio, EMF, Infrared, Pulse positioned sine waves, and ultrasound. Science wont talk about most of this stuff, for example a scientist told me radio could not affect the humans nervous system since we are 96% water; they now claim we are 60% water, but forgot they said radio was not the cause. Scientists are purposely discrediting these people, and are wrong about/lying about/not studying so many topics i have compiled a partial list [ reddit.com/r/gangstalkingmkultra/comments/4fb98a/science_lies_relevant_to_mind_control/ ] Its rather bad because psychiatry was a complete fraud. The "treatments" for one mental illness were [ reddit.com/r/gangstalkingmkultra/comments/4a4y1d/psychiatry_is_a_medical_fraud/ ] hand crank drill to the skull and drain blood dr freemans icepick lobotomy dr freemans shock until KO more bizzaro surgeries straight jackets 24/7 tying the person to a bed 20 hours a day drugging them and locking them up lithium a toxin so poisonous its used for chemotherapy to kill unkillable mutant cancer cells sterilization and eugenics and current treatments are worth 10,000,000,000 a month, but I dont think they cured anyone [their previous treatments were stopped because they did not work and were barbaric]. Anyways its a real phenomena, web and youtube have videos and articles, ex-CIA, ex-FBI, ex-Army, ex-NSA, have testified that a global mind control system exists. google agency name + DEW, mk ultra, or mind control. Theres something like 30-40+ serial killers/spree shooters that said mind control exists before they went on their spree.
- hugeflyingsquid 10y agoThis is a serious question. what differentiates these people from those who say they were born with the wrong genitalia? In both cases there is evidence to the contrary of the person's claims (no one is watching the paranoid person, a person's genitals exist as they exist). Why do we accept a transgendered person as being reasonable but a paranoid person as not?
- CydeWeys 10y agoThere are several reasons this comparison breaks down, but here's one: Transitioning as a solution to gender dysphoria works. It drastically increases the quality of life of those who suffer from it. Sure, in an ideal world where we had full knowledge of human biology and an ability to edit the brain, we'd treat gender dysphoria simply by making people believe they were the "correct" gender. But lacking that ability, we do the next best thing possible that we can do. On the other hand, you can't cure paranoid schizophrenics in any sort of similar way.
- Programmatic 10y agoAt the risk of derailing this conversation, do you have resources to show that transitioning works? The debate on both sides has muddied the water for me and I'd love to see evidence for this. Thanks in advance.
- rosalinekarr 10y agoI know this is largely anecdotal and not very scientific, but just listen to [what trans people have to say about it][]. There are some people who do regret transitioning, but usually the reason they give is the discrimination they experience because of transitioning, not any genuine dissatisfaction with themselves. There is [a small propaganda war being waged by transphobic conservatives][] to create the illusion of a large percentage of trans people that regret their transition, but just look at their references. You'll find every link is either to the Daily Mail or some other hate group referencing even more hate groups in a big web of circular reasoning. Generally, there's not a lot of hard data to work with on issues relating to the trans community right now, which is a little frustrating, but hopefully there will be more soon as the scientific community is finally starting to recognize the LGBT community and conduct real science on this stuff. [1]: https://www.reddit.com/r/asktransgender/search?q=regret&restrict_sr=on&sort=relevance&t=all https://www.reddit.com/r/asktransgender/search?q=regret&rest... [2]: http://www.sexchangeregret.com/ http://www.sexchangeregret.com/
- 10y ago
- bpchaps 10y agoI do "government watchdog" work, have bipolar and have dealt with paranoia on a relatively unhealthy level before and to some extent, now. It's not fun. It's very hard to determine what's "real", who's telling the truth and who's trying to "get me". I've spoken to my psychiatrist about this multiple times, but every time I bring it up, he says that it's a perfectly rational feeling to have considering what kind of work I'm doing and that thinking through it is all I can do. To make matters worse, I met up with a journalist the other day to discuss a couple large projects I'm working on. Later in the night, I was mugged. My phone, license and credit cards were stolen. My bag with my laptop, etc wasn't stolen, though. It's very hard to express the sorts of paranoia it caused. The lack of empathy, lack of cops in a usually cop-laden area and a genuine lack of interest in checking city camera footage didn't help. What's worse is that talking about it makes others consider you a paranoid crazy person. There's very little area for discussion, because the default discussion is, "stop acting crazy", rather than "Let's discuss why you feel this way."
- oh_sigh 10y agoWhy do you think you're interesting enough to be gang stalked?
- bpchaps 10y agoBecause I'm very, very aggressively seeking Chicago mayor's phone's records through FOIA. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1hgG79eIr8MbkjYrCvcTRN8n876KL8aXYYu5it8Lg0g8 https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1hgG79eIr8MbkjYrCvcTR...
- studentrob 10y agoWhy not tell your pyschiatrist that you'd like to discuss the details of why you feel that way? I gather you are looking for someone who will believe you, and without evidence, nobody is likely to believe you, leading you on a deeper and deeper quest for something that passes as real evidence. That sounds super tough. Take care, good luck
- kordless 10y agoFirst, I want to say that I believe people when they say they are seeing things. Most humans appear to have a mechanism by which they can visualize objects as if they are real. This phenomenon of visualization has been largely unexplored. It would appear people visualize in widely different ways. These people are apparently tormented by bad visualization system security. I've hypothesized about visualization systems going bad before when I looked at working at Magic Leap. If we all end up wearing AR headsets, how is it that I can guarantee what I'm seeing is an accurate representation of what I want to see? Don't let anyone tell you we a solution for trusted security for this stuff! We fucking don't. Yet. How is it that human's visual systems are secured against penetration? How is it that some appear to be vulnerable, while others, such as myself, appear to be completely "locked down" in their visualization systems? I'm beginning to suspect that this so called affliction "Aphantasia" is actually a strong feature that is related to insanity. I'm thankful to the fact I don't have the ability to visualize. I also may be crazy and don't realize it.
- tn13 10y agoWhy not make sleeping meds and other meds that treat mental illeness over the counter drugs ? There is simply too much friction to get proper medicines in USA. A walk into drug store lowers human dignity as one is treated like a criminal by default.
- mercer 10y agoThe problem is that medication isn't a cure-all, and can actually significantly worsen a situation. It would be like selling 'radiation devices' people can use to treat their own cancer. Of course, if we have medication that has been proven to work without side-effects, I'd be all in favor.
- tn13 10y agoI know people who had psychological issues. The doctor gave them a simple prescription for "Restyl"[1]. The person has then simply buys the medicines by walking into a drug store with the same old prescription for the rest of his life. One doctor's visit that is all. In USA the guys will have to make several doctors visit, renew the prescription every month. Not to mention the insane amount of friction to get that doctor's appointment. I do get the point you guys are making but letting the drug companies actively advertise their medicines will help in informing customers what drugs they may buy. [1] Restyl, also known by the brand names of Niravam, Xanor, and Xanax, is a benzodiazepine-class, short-acting medication used to manage moderate to severe panic attacks and anxiety disorders. It is also used as an auxiliary treatment for anxiety caused by moderate depression. It's available in both generic form and extended release form (Xanax XR). In America, this medication is a schedule IV controlled substance under the Controlled Substances Act.
- DanBC 10y agoSleeping meds - the Z drugs (like Zopiclone) - have some potential for addiction. (One of the top ten drugs obtained using stolen prescription pads in France; increased numbers of people attending drug rehab services in Ireland). And for most people they need to be doing other stuff before using the meds. Working through sleep hygiene first. The anti-psychotic meds are pretty harsh. They have harsh side effects. And it's hard to work out the correct dose. And, again, they're part of a package of care. A bunch of other stuff should be happening for people who need to take mental health meds (and for the people who care[1] for them). [1] "Carer" in UK is someone who provides care but who is not paid to do so. Normally a relative or spouse.
- beshrkayali 10y ago"United States of Amnesia" - Gore Vidal
- ilaksh 10y agoImmediately the article associates 9/11 truthers with mental illness. That is the main point of the article -- to remind everyone that if you believe your government did something truly heinous, you must be crazy. There is a long history of governments using accusations of mental illness when they get caught. Maybe you are all just living in a false reality created by constant propaganda on television and a type of collective denial. 9/11 was a false flag attack. Now people will tell me to 'get help'.
- Programmatic 10y agoRegardless of your opinion with regard to the responsibility for the 9/11 attacks and the methods by which they were carried out, society itself was already transforming at that point to be more internet -connected and -dependent, as well as having heightened security and nationwide paranoia about further terrorist attacks and nebulous threats. This would seem to be relevant. The article also did not mention the nature of their attribution for the attacks as a binding factor of the paranoid.
- oh_sigh 10y agoOr - is it possible that they weren't talking generally (that is - if you believe a government can do anything wrong, you're crazy), and they were talking specifically(if you think the US government did 9/11 - you're crazy)? Just because governments can do bad things isn't proof that a particular bad thing happened from the government.
- funthree 10y agoMy account was ruined because I posted some things about politics that were right of center. I am a totally normal and good person. If you are a mod please take the time to restore my account, thanks.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- hetfeld 10y agoI have a paranoia clicking a link to nytimes because of tons of ads in the first place.
- stephengillie 10y agoI just want to point out the lack of paywall on this article. Either it's not a big money-maker, or they're going to make up for the paywall profits with the volume of other ads they're showing today.
- joncp 10y agoOh, the pranking opportunities....
- jhall1468 10y agoI'm pretty sure using someones mental illness to play psychological "tricks" on them isn't a prank. I'd call it abusive.
- oolongCat 10y agoAnd some people don't just care. Look at some of the "pranks"(aka "social experiments") on youtube these days. Makes you wonder what type of things are going through the minds of these so called pranksters.
- tluyben2 10y agoI was going to say that here. That could be reason for jailtime as far as i'm concerned; I have two friends with serious mental illnesses (developed around 18 using recreational drugs); if you would 'prank' them you would endanger them and people around them. It's a nasty thing.
- wpietri 10y agoDefinitely. My family is big on jokes and and pranks. But the right spirit is "let's have fun together". Without that, I think it is just abuse.
- tomjen3 10y agoMaybe, but is that going to stop fourchan?
- Kristine1975 10y agoI would say that depends. 4chan's technology board /g/ for example seems to respect Terry A. Davis, who has schizophrenia, for his TempleOS. On the other hand, transgendered people are often considered to be mentally ill by the politics board /pol/ and bashed mercilessly. P.S: Terry also has an account here on HN.
- wyldfire 10y ago> The similarities of the cases spoke to a wide-ranging campaign, he said. “If the psychiatrists want to say that this is schizophrenia or delusional disorder, that’s fine,” he said. “But every one of these victims have the same story.” Just because there's thousands of folks suffering identical symptoms doesn't mean it's not psychosis. But it would be interesting if somehow there were an environmental component to the problem. Likely not a pernicious, perpetrated-by-ne'er do wells one, but it could be that something most people interact with daily and thought to be harmless has a harmful effect in some small number of people.
- danmaz74 10y agoIn fact, there is an "environmental component" to the problem, mentioned right there in the article: the self-organized groups on the internet which amplify and reinforce the persecutory delusions these people are experiencing.
- Decade 10y agoPeople have been developing schizo persecution complexes for as long as I remember. Just the contents of the delusions differ depending on the victim’s experiences. I wonder if modern society exacerbates or amplifies it, though by “modern” I mean post-Agricultural Revolution. We humans tend to think that we can handle any problem that we create for ourselves, but I think there is some strain, and everybody has a breaking point. We don’t all break the same way. See also: Education practices. It certainly doesn’t help that the government really is trying to spy on you, the government really is pushing people to do crazy things ([0] and others), and the people in government offices really are lying to you ([1], [2], for why the President is wrong about Snowden having official channels). The article mentions MKUltra[3], which obsesses one of the relatively harmless schizos whom I know. Some things are clearly false, or false but difficult to falsify (mind control satellites, anyone?), but I feel that this nuance is usually lacking in persecution complexes. [0]http://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/do-f-b-i-stings-help-the-fight-against-isis http://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/do-f-b-i-stings-help... [1]https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20130809/12594124128/obamas-simply-wrong-whistleblower-protections-would-not-have-applied-to-snowden.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20130809/12594124128/obama... [2]http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/may/22/how-pentagon-punished-nsa-whistleblowers http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2016/may/22/how-pentagon-... [3]http://gizmodo.com/project-mkultra-one-of-the-most-shocking-cia-programs-1370236359 http://gizmodo.com/project-mkultra-one-of-the-most-shocking-...
- bdavisx 10y agoAnyone from Hollywood on here, I can think of a couple of movie opportunities from this story right here: * people who are actually being targeted because they have some kind of "hidden" genetic "power" or something like that (eg x-men mutants) * ordinary people who are actually being targeted by some tla organization testing out "mind weapons" Of course, making a movie like either one of these isn't going to do much good for the poor people from the story...
- HannibalLecter 10y agoI was going to go with time travel. Let's say in the future some team of people figures out how to travel back in time. They do so and immediately seek to do something about the people who are in power at the time. So they figure out ways to sabotage these people. Think of it like a person doesn't just go back in time and shoot Hitler -- he goes back in time and abuses him. Hitler's confidence was his ultimate power. Without it, what would Germany have looked like? So maybe these people who are targeted would have invented something or started some company. tl;dr: anti-competitive time travel
- koalaman 10y agoI think it's called 'conspiracy theory'
- thatcat 10y agosounds like sense8 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sense8 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sense8
- rotskoff 10y agoThis article touches on a host issues very similar to those associated with "The Truman Show delusion." There's a good New Yorker article (http://bit.ly/1ULiZr6 http://bit.ly/1ULiZr6) from 2013 about these delusions and their relation to media and social media.
- tunap 10y ago“They end up in a closed ideology echo chamber,” I cannot deny I often find myself pigeon-holed into this category, the derision poured upon me to "fix" something has been consistent & unwavering. Problem is, I was always more interested in books/work over socializing before the netz, I don't hear voices in my head besides my inner-monologue(hopefully=not-schizo) and my 'echo chamber' is anything but... I am drawn to alien, re-framed & unique perspectives of the world I live in. My solitude is a result of not being current on the TV shows, my choice to avoid Web2.0 style social(sic) media and a very low consumption fueled lifestyle... all these are past-times for the mass majority. Good for them, if that is what people choose. Good for me for not choosing to do the same. My outlier mentality has subsequently been reinforced by the writings/works of some very smart people. A few examples: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Dragons_of_Eden https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Dragons_of_Eden https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Demon-Haunted_World https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Demon-Haunted_World https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manufacturing_Consent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manufacturing_Consent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Black_Swan_%28Taleb_book%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Black_Swan_%28Taleb_book%2... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adam_Curtis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adam_Curtis edit:added conclusion, 3rd and 2nd to last sentences.
- coldtea 10y ago>My solitude is a result of not being current on the TV shows, my choice to avoid Web2.0 style social(sic) media and a very low consumption fueled lifestyle... Which might make you an obsolete example of a sane social citizen unable to function in a changed bizarro anti-social society.
- rboyd 10y agosee also Terrence McKenna "Culture Is Not Your Friend" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4-tY6hmKcms https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4-tY6hmKcms Still, there's seeing a culture for what it is and then there's running from invisible monsters. I think we can agree that most of the folks from the article need some healing.
- tremon 10y ago
- SonicSoul 10y agothis is incredibly sad. could loneliness be a contributing factor? This reminds of This American Life episode about a man who got off his medication and felt like there were trained assassins after him. He ended up causing a lot of damage, attacking cops, and being shot in the process (not deadly). Luckily we do have medication that can help with such conditions. http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/579/my-damn-mind http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/579/m...
- unimpressive 10y ago>being shot in the process (not deadly) Being shot is always deadly, I think you meant to say he was not fatally shot. EDIT: This is not a point of idle pedanticism, it's a very common misconception that there are 'safe' places to shoot a human body such as the shoulder. There are no safe places to shoot somebody, all shots taken by police are shots to kill. https://www.pfoa.co.uk/110/shooting-to-wound https://www.pfoa.co.uk/110/shooting-to-wound
- SonicSoul 10y agoAlways appreciate feedback considering English is not my first language, but considering the past tense wouldn't it be ok to say the shot was not deadly? That is not to say the intent wasn't
- cromulent 10y agoPerhaps "not fatally" would be a better way of indicating that the outcome was not death, regardless of the intent :)
- Decade 10y agoAh, the old practice of using a word that comes from French to give some nuance when a Germanic word once worked. The Miriam-Webster dictionary says SonicSoul’s usage was correct, meaning “in a manner to cause death,” but now is archaic.
- 10y ago
- orf 10y agoI really like the play on words in the title. These communities seem natural given the nature of the internet. The barrier to publishing or forming a community is pretty much non-existent, and because the internet transcends most borders the critical mass of people required to form communities with non-mainstream ideals is incredibly low. And so you get groups of holocaust deniers, flat earthers and apparently (+ unfortunately) paranoid schizophrenics. It seems like the internet might almost reinforce the echo chamber by amplifying the feeling that everyone else is a 'sheep', because you see the big communities of people (news organizations, social media etc) dismissing your communities ideas and so people turn more inward and focus more on others who hold the same views.
- vasaulys 10y agoThe internet also forms a sort of release valve. People being bigots with words over the internet is better than lynching or public beatings imo.
- n72 10y agoIs there evidence for this?
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoProbably. Is the evidence in an easy-to-consume form? Probably not.
- dave2000 10y agoPlease try and find anyone who'd rather be lynched or beaten than have their racial group spoken of negatively.
- MereInterest 10y agoIt sounds like the Catharsis Hypothesis, which states that the release of aggression in small ways prevents large expressions of aggression. This has been rather thoroughly discredited. Small displays of aggression (e.g. ranting online) train an individual that aggression is an appropriate response, and leads to larger displays of aggression (e.g. physical attacks). Source: http://www-personal.umich.edu/~bbushman/PSPB02.pdf http://www-personal.umich.edu/~bbushman/PSPB02.pdf http://blog.uwgb.edu/alltherage/four-questions-on-the-catharsis-myth-with-dr-brad-bushman/ http://blog.uwgb.edu/alltherage/four-questions-on-the-cathar...
- nxzero 10y agoHaving run into people like this and the fact there really are people that are the subjects of targeted psychology operations, it's a very troubling and complex topic. Guess I'd be curious if there's a way to prove to someone they're not being targeted.
- alkonaut 10y agoNo doubt targeted operations exist, but unless you have good reason to believe you should be targeted (such as you having left the church of Scientology or a similar organization) then you aren't targeted. Believing that you were randomly selected for a form of psychological terror that would take enormous resources from the attacker is a pretty clear sign you are delusional. This is a group of people with mental health issues that unfortunately also self sustain by suggesting relatives are "in on it" and that seeking help is bad.
- lettergram 10y agoTo be fair, some people (to a lesser extent) were targeted at random when Facebook was showing some people more negative posts on their newsfeeds as an experiment.
- nxzero 10y agoFact that it's random means it's not the same; explicitly talking about targeted efforts. Also, online efforts are not as resource intensive as in the real world. Only way this might be similar is if for training or testing reasons that someone randomly became the subject of some effort. Given the resources this would take, such efforts would be short in duration and likely near known R&D or training spots for entities that would engage in things like that.
- alkonaut 10y agoThat is both something that has a reason (they want to test something, in order to change/improve their product) and it doesn't require massive resources since it's automated. Believing this isn't necessarily crazy.
- phren0logy 10y agoI'm a psychiatrist. When I went to med school I thought I would go the radiology route, because that's where all the cool tech is, but one of the things that drew me in was the unexpected consistency in the themes of severe mental illness. Paranoia is, on an academic level, a fascinating phenomenon. It also causes a lot of suffering. Please remember that these kinds of communities have sprung up in the context of the ongoing stigma of mental illness, and the limitations of present medications for psychosis (most have unpleasant side-effects). Other contributors are a mistrust of authority, and the always-complicated balance between individual liberties and involuntary treatment. Finally, a plea for some compassion. Many of these people live a deeply tormented life, and feel like they can't trust anyone. It's a hard existence for both them and their families. It might seem like a humorous phenomenon, but there's a lot of suffering here.
- kordless 10y agoHave you listened to any lectures by Gregory Bateson? He goes into some relationships around schizophrenia, computation and suffering.
- gist 10y ago> I thought I would go the radiology route, because that's where all the cool tech is Also where the money is as well (vs. Psychiatry).
- jonknee 10y agoThought much less likely to be taken over by computers. Radiologists have way too good of a gig going to last.
- gist 10y agoThere are many areas of radiology interventional for example which is aided by but not likely to be taken over by computers. There are threats to any profession but if you look at the earnings from psych vs. radiology it would take a great deal to drive down earning in rad to the level of psych in the near term.
- caseysoftware 10y ago> Mental health professionals say the narrative has taken hold among a group of people experiencing psychotic symptoms that have troubled the human mind since time immemorial. Except now victims are connecting on the internet, organizing and defying medical explanations for what’s happening to them. I think that paragraph has implications far beyond just the paranoia described...
- studentrob 10y agoMaybe if they see themselves in a mirror some will be able to identify the illusion.. Group therapy works for other stuff (I'm joking and not an MD, please don't take this seriously)
- mercer 10y agoHa, that reminds me of this here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Three_Christs_of_Ypsilanti https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Three_Christs_of_Ypsilanti
- studentrob 10y ago> Rokeach added a comment in the final revision of the book that, while the experiment did not cure any of the three Christs, "It did cure me of my godlike delusion that I could manipulate them out of their beliefs." LOL alright, well, it seems the people in the article/video are asking for help. They similarly would be unreasonable to demand that someone give them help in a specific way. Beggers can't be choosers.
- arca_vorago 10y agoIt's not paranoia if they're really after you! Kidding aside, while I know the article is talking about gang-stalking and paranoia of things that aren't there as variations of psychosis, there is a deeper conversation to be had about the role of real government and private business in actions and methods that actually encourage them, along with the fact that sometimes people aren't just crazy and things really are happening to them. So as not to get to distracted from the original topic, I won't expound too much, but in an era of mk ultra, emf weaponry, massive surveillance societies, silencing of dissidents, including assassination, and various other trust breaking experiments or operations against our own citizens, perhaps they arent all crazy.
- giardini 10y agoDon't know why the downvote for OP. A variant on the same joke: I had a friend who used to occasionally say "Just because you're paranoid doesn't mean they're not out to get you!" which always made me laugh. I laugh still but less, because our surveillance society has now reduced the vague "they" to government/police agencies who seem relentlessy devoted to shredding any concept of privacy that ever existed in Western thought. And the OP is right: the revelation of so much previously-unrevealed surveillance by government and law-enforcement can only, to someone who is from suspicious to paranoid, increase their suspicions or in some cases _prove_ (to them) their fears. When I was a child I feared because my parents told me that "God is watching you!"; today I fear because God knows who's watching me! At least, in the case of "God", I understood his intentions.
- hashkb 10y agoReminds me of https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Morgellons https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Morgellons
- stevens32 10y agoThese are actually mentioned in the article, the first person introduced says he suffers from this.
- hashkb 10y agoYep. Posted before finishing the article. Makes sense that there'd be overlap between the two online communities. Wonder how many other online delusion reinforcement communities there are... I'm definitely not commenting on one now.
- krapp 10y ago>I'm definitely not commenting on one now. Certainly not. I have to go rant about Google being a front for the NSA now.
- stevens32 10y agoGood instincts. The word 'Morgellon' in turn reminds me of Scientology. I hate to betray a bias here, but I wonder what percentage of that group are or were fairly religious? I know someone like this, and they were heavily involved with their church (Christian).
- mercer 10y agoThere could be an overlap. While I don't know if this has been researched, my experience in Evangelic and Pentecostal churches is that it has a really high number of people who have mental disorders. That's not a cheeky militant atheist comment, by the way. I'm not counting the average church member who believes things that to most (or at least many) of us is crazy. Honestly, it was really nice to see. Many of these people suffered greatly outside of and before their church life, but as part of a community that itself was considered 'acceptably crazy' by much of society, and a community that strongly emphasizes care for each other, they often thrived and, interestingly, their symptoms often decreased. For example, prophecy was a relatively common element of church life. There were special services where there was 'more room for the holy spirit', and people could share what I would call 'intuitions', which could range from a premonitory dream they had to a full-blown vision. This was catnip for people with 'known' mental issues, but the mere fact that their visions were given room and a measure of respect seemed to actually help them 'get better'. What was fascinating about all this to me was that there was, in fact, a huge difference between the average church goer and the 'mentally ill' person sharing a prophecy, even if on a rational level I consider both prophecies to be fundamentally delusional (and I don't mean that in a derogatory way). I've long been meaning to dive into this again, or look into research on the matter, because it's just so incredibly weird to experience a bunch of people acting, by some measures, insane and yet noticing a marked difference between those who are 'otherwise normal' and those who are not, even as a nonbeliever.
- paradite 10y agoI will probably not be convinced to believe these group of people, but I am troubled by the fact that the author has written this article with the pre-assumption that these people are absolutely, without any doubt, sick and being paranoid. When you are covering a story where there are conflicting views, it is not nice to pick one side and see the opposing view as an illness that needs to be treated. It is just not right, no matter how absurd the opposing view sounds to you.
- danmaz74 10y agoThe author isn't saying that "these people are absolutely, without any doubt, sick and being paranoid". What he actually said is: "A large number appear to have delusional disorder or schizophrenia, psychiatrists say."
- paradite 10y agoAt a glance, yes, the author did cover both sides of the story. But if you do read carefully, you would notice the wording and tone clearly suggest the author's opinion and pre-assumption. The whole article resembles an interview of a group of patients and their doctors. Some quotes that reveals the author's view: "For the few specialists who have looked closely, these individuals represent an alarming development in the history of mental illness: thousands of sick people, banded together and demanding recognition on the basis of shared paranoias." "The vast majority of people with psychosis never resort to violence. Still, studies suggest that a small number of those experiencing psychotic episodes — especially paranoid thoughts, accompanied by voices making commands — are more likely to act on hostile urges than people without a mental illness." "The big hope is that society will wake up to what’s happening and put a stop to it, those who feel targeted say. In some cases, they do seek psychiatric help. In others, the delusions subside. For the rest, the prognosis isn’t good, psychiatrists say. Many contemplate suicide." "One thing he is certain of though, he says: He’s not crazy."
- Retric 10y agoAlways trying to present a 'balanced' view is an extreme form of bias. 10 million well informed people on one side 10 fools on the other. Let's give them equal air time. Someone is always going to disagree and trying to accommodate extreme fringe beliefs basically prevents you from communicating accurately. Worse it adds a fake air of legitimacy to every wack-job out there.
- amelius 10y ago> An internet search for “gang-stalking,” however, turns up page after page of results that regard it as fact. “What’s scary for me is that there are no counter sites that try and convince targeted individuals that they are delusional,” Dr. Sheridan said. “They end up in a closed ideology echo chamber,” she said. Could Google help here?
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoWhat could reinforce this viewpoint any more than one of the most powerful entities on the planet modifying their results to convince them it's all in their heads?
- joesmo 10y agoWhen it's just tens or hundreds of thousands of people that believe in something ridiculous, we call it delusions but when that number gets into the millions we call it truth. Popularity is indeed the harbinger of truth. In other words, how is this different than the idiots who are convinced terrorists are after them? Just because we haven't yet identified the mental sickness in the latter group doesn't mean their conspiracy theories are true rather than delusions, but we are fine with even going to war to protect them. I see no difference between delusional psychotic patients, in other words, and many run of the mill idiots.
- themartorana 10y agoIf they only knew the real, actual surveillance they're under every second of their lives - every call, every packet online, every entrance into public space, every single move from one location to another... It's scary that we call these people are "paranoid" for thinking people are watching them - mentally ill, even - when the reality may be (edit: is) far scarier than the fantasy.
- salgernon 10y agoThe difference is that while the cost of performing electronic surveillance approximates zero for each individual in a society as a whole, these people believe that the government will pay X agents $N salary to spend time to target them specifically. Individual surveillance of course happens - but it probably isn't happening to most of these people. It isn't reasonable.
- Programmatic 10y agoAnd regardless the yardstick by which we measure the paranoia of people, and especially paranoid schizophrenics, is whether they are prompted to perform harmful actions. "Sometimes they bumped into him and whispered nonsense into his ear, he said." is a different ball park than believing that the government is watching everything you say.
- eggy 10y agoI think it is just being reported more, organizing with support groups forming due to the internet and other new technologies. I can't help but recall the opening to the 1997 movie 'Conspiracy Theory' with Mel Gibson. This is pre-9/11, so there must have been enough whiff of the zeitgeist to make it then into a mainstream movie. That sort of lends evidence to my position that this is common to heavily populated urban areas where the disenfranchised can go unnoticed, and it is not a new phenomenon or necessarily growing more; it's just more visible. I worked in the B. Dalton bookstore on 8th Street in the Village in NYC back in the 80s. One of the clerks was really into conspiracy theories and other fringe occult and alternate lifestyle stuff. He would throw me a book either self-published, or from an obscure publisher about many things like the U.S. government using Orgone energy guns to control the public and weather [1]. These texts were always similar to real academic publications - footnotes, bibliographies, photos, graphs - they were very fun to read! He also turned me on to the book 'The Holy Blood And The Holy Grail' published 21 years before Dan Brown's 'The Da Vinci Code', and before learning of the plagiarism lawsuit, it seemed like a fictionalized account of the book. Of course Dan Brown created a story outside of just the conspiracy theory premise [2]. Another was 'Spear of Destiny' published 1973 about the history and occult powers of the storied spear used to pierce Jesus Christ's side [3] I also used to go with my bookstore buddy to visit some squatters living in the East Village. I'd listen to all of the theories about mind control, tainted water, secret cable TV brainwashing messages, and on and on. Great fun, really, but there were some truly neurotic people in the bunch. But then again, also some real rational people just living an alternate lifestyle. I can relate to being the participant-observer in my life's adventures. I guess its part of ethnography formally. But then again, this was the time of the conspiracy-driven, weird film 'Videodrome' by David Cronenberg. I really need to get hold of a copy, and still see how it compares to how much I enjoyed it back then [4]. Just to see the video cassette inserted into James Woods' stomach! 'Call me, call me any, anytime' - Blondie [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orgone https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orgone [2] https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2007/mar/28/danbrown.books https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2007/mar/28/danbrown.books [3] https://openlibrary.org/books/OL8111347M/Spear_of_Destiny https://openlibrary.org/books/OL8111347M/Spear_of_Destiny [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Videodrome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Videodrome
- rl3 10y ago
- andy 10y agoIt's not paranoia if they're really after you. Read my blog at http://surroundedbyspies1.tumblr.com http://surroundedbyspies1.tumblr.com. I have written about 1) Cops trying to get me to talk about Muslims in a bar, after posting a lot of anti Muslim stuff online about ground zero mosque. 2) Finding a user avatar of Osama Bin Laden on the profile of a contractor I paid, reporting it to the FBI, and being involuntarily committed few weeks later for 20 days. 3) Being recruited by the UN and then finding proof via Rapportive gmail tool that they were spying on me via someone I fell in love with on Twitter. I wrote Rapportive asking about the proof and Rapportive stopped using Rapleaf, their data provider, that day. The service Rapportive is named for. We are not all delusional.
- mlvljr 10y agoA nice spice-up for my X-files watching routine, thanks.
- salgernon 10y agoA few months ago, I was in hospital for a major surgery. It went OK, I saw family but was going to be in for a few days to deal with recovery. Heavy painkillers. After a few days, I woke up just after sunrise and discovered an eerie silence. I realized that I had been kidnapped and put on a train to some foreign country - they had been coming in every few hours to interrogate me and check my papers as we passed through different territories - but now the train had stopped and I was completely alone. There was a strange city outside the window and I knew that it was my job to escape - I am a security operative and I'd been taken against my will. They were putting drugs in me to keep me sedated - I ripped the IV out of my arm and made my way to a closet area where I ripped through supplies until I found street clothes (I realized that there was another sedated agent in the train car as well - he stirred, but I managed not to wake him.) I snuck out of the train and into the landing tube, which was empty except for some thugs at the far end; I snuck the other way and had made it to the elevators before I was caught. And gently led back to my hospital room, had the blood cleaned from my arm, and put back into my hospital bed. Where I woke up a few hours later, with memories of this strange dream. But it wasn't a dream - I did rip out my IV and try to escape from a hospital. There was a strange city outside my window - I had to travel for surgery. And I was conscious when I made my escape and completely and utterly convinced that what I thought was reasonable and real. Of course I was such a valuable individual that they would kidnap me - and that there was an external "they" (or to put it another way "the other") that was doing something to me. I believed this completely - it was as true to me as my cat (or what I like to think of as my cat, if you prefer) throwing up on the carpet in front of me right now. But now I know that my cat is not doing this on purpose, nor was he poisoned by the NSA. Andy, I'm very sorry that you're going through what you're going through, and my experience informs me that what you feel is absolutely real is what is real to you - but there are objective and subjective realities and if you can externalize yourself from the situation you find yourself in, you may discover that coincidences are coincidences and you don't need to find a hypothesis to fit a random pattern. I think that pareidolia can be applied to situations and feelings as well as visual artifacts. Humans pattern match compulsively.
- malz 10y agoThese people found an ally in California's anti-mind control candidate for U.S. Senate: "... the freedom to think one's own thoughts free from interferance such as that from Voice to Skull (V2K) mind control technology ... legislation to ban non-consensual human experimentation and mind control slavery by means of satellite weapons systems and and GWEN Tower platforms ..." http://www.massiemunroe4ussenator.com http://www.massiemunroe4ussenator.com
- studentrob 10y agoVoice to skull is much too obvious.. It'd be something innocuous-sounding like the fluffy unicorn program, FUP
- tremon 10y ago"Smart media -- for smart people"
- studentrob 10y agoHaha, what does that imply, all tech is unnecessary?
- tremon 10y agoNo, it was just my lame attempt at coming up with a marketing phrase for the OP's "Voice to Skull (V2K) mind control technology".
- studentrob 10y agooh, haha. Since smart media already exists and is a real thing, I thought you were making fun of people who use SmartMedia.
- matt_wulfeck 10y agoThe saddest part about this is probably how alienating it must feel. Any of your friends that try and convince you that you have a problem are simply part of the problem working against you. I bet that at least plays a small role in the documented unwillingness to seek out professional help.
- dsabanin 10y agoThe article goes right into lumping up all the people who doubted official story on 9/11 with paranoids. Nice. Reminds me of the way psychiatry was used in Soviet Union to put people who objected the official party line into mandatory detention in the hospital.[1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_abuse_of_psychiatry_in_the_Soviet_Union https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_abuse_of_psychiatry_...
- narrator 10y agoThe problem with these articles is they mix delusional paranoia, which is a real thing, with investigation into government corruption, which is also a real thing. The article muddies the waters between the two in a politicized way and thus helps to legitimize ad hominem attacks.
- lovemenot 10y agoThere is one sense in which they are almost certainly correct in their claims of being victimised by a group: Trolling. The article says that Targeted Individuals support each other online. I cannot imagine trolls do not represent a good number of such a support community.
- hackaflocka 10y agoLook up "ratting computers" on Google. It's when someone takes remote control of your computer and then uses it to harass you (among other things)... e.g. by suddenly opening your DVD tray, etc. I wonder if some of them are victims of "ratting."
- cLeEOGPw 10y agoThis looks like a preparation for society to dismiss anyone who will be actually targeted as insane. Technique widely used during Soviet regime times. Asylums were for nonconforming opinions. This looks ripe for abuse for just that.