9 ms·
Pilot test of storing carbon dioxide in rocks
- SquirrelOnFire 10y agoNeat! Storing carbon stably is huge. We have much easier ways to get to 10,000 year storage (turning fast-growing biomass like miscanthus or other giant grasses into charcoal and throwing it in an old mine), but i haven't heard of other super-long-term storage options.
- aeorgnoieang 10y agoLink(s)? And why is 10,000 year storage not good enough for us to already be doing it?
- hugh4 10y agoIndeed. Either the people 10,000 years from now will be smart enough to figure out something better, or they'll be hunter-gatherers who won't be too deterred by a little sea level rise on the very edge of their territory.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- SquirrelOnFire 10y agoApparently I mentally added an order of magnitude - best link I could find says 1,000 year storage http://www.carbolea.ul.ie/files/Biochar%20Swift%20Hayes%20Chemrawn.pdf http://www.carbolea.ul.ie/files/Biochar%20Swift%20Hayes%20Ch... and biochar.org
- aeorgnoieang 10y agoThanks for the link!
- aeorgnoieang 10y agoBut even 1,000 years is a long time. I'm really curious what economists, or business-people, think about biochar. Not only is it apparently inexpensive but it also improves plant yields! That seems too suspiciously like a $100 bill lying on the sidewalk. Why has no one picked it up yet? The following paper doesn't explicitly state that this is the case, but it certainly seems like biochar is not as relatively effective a fertilizer, or fuel source, as alternatives and that therefore it's relative advantage when compared to its alternatives or substitutes lies in its ability to sequester carbon: - http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40095-014-0106-4 http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40095-014-0106-4 So I guess it's really a $0 bill until the price of carbon rises (for whatever reason).
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- semi-extrinsic 10y agoThe flipside of this is that mineral precipitation (though not necessarily carbonate) is also a problem for CO2 injection into aquifers, which are more readily available and for which we have better understanding, better technology and better infrastructure. (No disrespect for the CarbFix people implied, they do great work.)
- moftz 10y agoHumans put out 40 billion tons of CO2 every year. Offsetting all of this would require 1 trillion gallons of water which sounds like a lot but is only 1 cubic mile of water. It doesn't say how fresh the water needs to be but if salt water is possible to use, then these injection systems could be setup all over the world in places where access to ocean water and basalt bedrock is plentiful. That energy company says they plan to setup facilities to inject 10000 tons of CO2 every year. It would still take 4 million more of these facilities to offset all carbon emissions.
- semi-extrinsic 10y agoAt this point, the CCS tech is all there; cost is the main problem. Currently we're at or above $100/tonne of CO2 captured, transported and stored, with capture being the main cost driver. To make this economically feasible, it requires a carbon tax equivalent to a price increase on gasoline of around $1/gallon (IIRC). Which would be unpopular, to say the least.
- schoen 10y agoGas prices vary a lot more than that between countries today (largely due to differences in existing taxes). http://www.globalpetrolprices.com/gasoline_prices/Europe/ http://www.globalpetrolprices.com/gasoline_prices/Europe/ That's stated in dollars per liter (an unusual unit). In dollars per gallon, Germany would be $5.79/gallon today and the U.K. would be $6.13/gallon.
- lucaspiller 10y agoHere in Italy it varies a lot even within the country. Yesterday I drove ~600km from the south to Rome and prices varied between €1.45 and €1.75 per litre.
- fpoling 10y agoIn Norway prices can vary by 10-15% on the same gas station withing hours. In many places the cheapest gasoline is on Sunday evening with significantly higher price coming on Monday.
- bpodgursky 10y agoI know geo-engineering schemes are well-intentioned, but I'm worried that once productionized, country-specific motivations are going to move from "status quo" to "arms race" Yeah we all know global warming will cause chaos etc, but some countries will be net winners, and some net losers. Canada and Russia have a lot to gain from global warming, with sea routes and more farmland. African nations, Bangladesh, India have huge amounts to lose. Once we have sequestration technology working, would anyone put it past the Indian / Egyptian / etc governments to set a goal CO2 PPM below the "historic" status quo to lower temperatures for the benefit of their people? Would anyone put it past Russia to be upset about this and intentionally release methane to counteract the cooling effect? I think it would be very hard to prevent weaponization of this tech; "keep everything how it is" is easy to say but I don't think will actually happen.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoOne would hope that the MAD doctrine would kick in and curtail at least more blatant attempts at offensive geoengineering. On the other hand, at this point we can't really afford not to do anything. So it might be worth the risk to actually try and implement such a scheme.
- graeme 10y ago>Canada and Russia have a lot to gain from global warming, with sea routes and more farmland. Is this really true? I'm Canadian. I think we have less to lose, but I'm not sure we'll gain. Currently we have a boreal forest wildfire larger than Delaware that's still burning out of control and already destroyed much of Fort McMurray. From what I've read, the Boreal forest is at risk of fire and ecosystem death, and not much is suited to replace it in the near term due to soil quality. We'll also lose cities due to sea level rise.
- hughes 10y ago"More farmland" to me reads "highly sensitive to drought". Warmer does not mean better if it brings with it less rain.
- ck2 10y agoIt's hilarious how certain people keep talking about "clean coal" like it's plausible and scientists don't even have this basic requirement worked out yet.
- AnimalMuppet 10y ago"Clean coal" doesn't usually mean "no CO2". It means "no mercury" or "no particulates".
- smt88 10y agoThat is absolutely not the implication of clean-coal marketing in the US.
- _red 10y ago98% of a trees mass comes from "carbon capture".
- simplemath 10y agoCarboniferous period, pt. II I look forward to our descendants' giant cockroach overlords
- SquirrelOnFire 10y agoTrue! But it also returns to the atmosphere when it burns or decays. Turn it into charcoal [1] and you have about 1,000 years of stability. Turn it into a mineral and you have indefinite stability. [1] http://www.carbolea.ul.ie/files/Biochar%20Swift%20Hayes%20Chemrawn.pdf http://www.carbolea.ul.ie/files/Biochar%20Swift%20Hayes%20Ch...
- masklinn 10y ago> it also returns to the atmosphere when it burns Don't burn it? > or decays In a healthy forest, a decaying tree is replaced by new growth, and part of the carbon is captured into soils (including high-carbon peaty soils, which is what's under the forests currently being burned for palm in south-east asia), so a growing forest is a large carbon sink and a stable grown forest is at best carbon-neutral, possibly a small sink depending on its composition. > Turn it into a mineral and you have indefinite stability. The lithospheric carbon cycle is still a cycle[0]. Lithospheric carbon gets released by volcanoes and by acidified oceanic water. [0] http://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/Features/CarbonCycle/page2.php http://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/Features/CarbonCycle/page2....
- Fej 10y agoCan we start panicking now? We need to get to 350 ppm of CO2 in the atmosphere and we're above 400, with no easy solutions on the horizon.
- xigency 10y agoThere's certainly something good that there isn't an "easy" solution. If it were trivial to reduce CO2 from 400 ppm to 350 ppm, it would be easy to get to 0 parts per million, which would extinguish all plant life on the planet and also kill us.
- Fiahil 10y agoI would really like if americans could stop using deprecated units like gallons and miles. Especially when starting a paragraph using regular tons. It would really make the whole thing more meaningful.
- linkregister 10y agoAgreed, but since this is an American website your complaint is unlikely to change any minds. When I lived in other countries, I adapted to metric and learned enough of the native languages to get by. Maybe it's not too much to ask that we let Americans use their own units on their own websites. I don't whine about people speaking French on Skyrock.
- spiderfarmer 10y agoOh I'm so sorry, I feel like I'm intruding. How did I end up here? They should have used an IP blocker..
- hueving 10y agoNobody cares if you participate. It's just pointless to complain that US styles are used in a US article posted on a US website.
- serge2k 10y agoIt really is at this point. All but what, 3 countries? America deserves to take a bit of a beating for their embarrassing inability to learn the metric system.
- randyrand 10y agoWhat if we just planted more trees?
- erikpukinskis 10y agoMore expensive than not cutting down existing trees.
- randyrand 10y agoWhat about genetically engineered trees that reproduce and spread for free? Ones designed for removing CO2
- mark_edward 10y agoDoesn't this describe almost every tree?
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoYes, except for the "genetically engineered" and "designed for removing CO2" parts. (Presumably "designed for removing CO2" means "designed for removing more CO2"...)
- trentmb 10y agoInadvertently create a species of flora that out competes others, leading to their extinction?
- deciplex 10y agoCould be, but more likely the opposite: the species will be at a disadvantage compared to its competitors in the wild (which are, naturally, optimized for survival and not correcting humanity's mistakes). It will not thrive on its own and will need help from humans to do its work i.e. probably not scalable.
- lordnacho 10y ago
- co2isgood 10y agoGreat! Now all that needs to be done is establish that anthropogenic CO2 is a significant risk. The jury's still very much out on that one.
- deciplex 10y agoIf by "out" you mean they're out having a post-trial lunch because they already turned in their verdict decades ago then... yes.
- co2isgood 10y agoNot even decades ago, it was realized that lots of money could be diverted from good use by making alarming claims about the possible negative effects of anthropogenic CO2. Nor is this realization lost on those touting CO2 sequestration. Back in the old days, the same types made money selling snake oil.
- deciplex 10y agoAh yes, Big Eco. They will surely crush us underfoot along with the struggling Big Oil, which merely lacks the vast resources which would certainly be required to refute this obviously bogus science.
- co2isgood 10y agoNo, my friend, the people who are crushed when the rent-seekers come out to play are the poor. That's why it's a bad idea to divert scarce resources in pursuit of worthless (indeed, probably harmful) pursuits like CO2 sequestration.
- nikdaheratik 10y agoWell, I'm not your "friend", pal! But seriously, did you even read the article (or any other ones covering this)? The Iceland corp. also used the technique to remove H2S and other noxious gases released when harvesting the geothermal heat. They decided to study what happened to the CO2 as well and it turned out they came up with something new and interesting. TL;DR: the only people who see this as a "worthless pursuit" are those too blinded by their own political nonsense to even bother looking at the science.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoThis seems like a great result, and its pretty easy to parallelize if you have a lot of basalt available. It will be interesting to see if we succeed at encasing CO2 before we get another "oxygenization event".
- co2isfine 10y agoGreat! Now all that needs to be done is establish that anthropogenic CO2 represents a significant risk. That has not been proven.
- moe_ronald 10y agoI'm going to have to flag this comment and have it deleted, because I disagree with it. Or something.