10 ms·
Silicon Valley's housing crisis, in one sentence
- bllguo 10y agoSo how does the process of adding housing units work? If there's space as the article claims, and plenty of demand, whats holding things up? Bureaucracy? I'd like to see reasonable prices sometime in my life !
- kqr2 10y agoThis is a complex question, but here are some resources to get started: http://www.lao.ca.gov/reports/2015/finance/housing-costs/housing-costs.aspx http://www.lao.ca.gov/reports/2015/finance/housing-costs/hou... http://techcrunch.com/2014/04/14/sf-housing/ http://techcrunch.com/2014/04/14/sf-housing/
- pjlegato 10y agoMainly: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Proposition_13_(1978) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Proposition_13_(197...
- xienze 10y agoWell that valley has pretty much every bit of flat land developed, so where are you going to put these high density developments without knocking down existing houses?
- TulliusCicero 10y agoI also wanted to note that not all of the new housing is coming on top of houses. Close to where I live, there's a strip mall with an enormous parking lot that just got knocked down and is being converted to mixed-use development, including lots of apartments[1]. A bit further away next to Lawrence Caltrain station, and old suburban-style office park was torn down and again, has a big mixed-use development being built there[2]. 1 - http://www.bizjournals.com/sanjose/news/2015/10/13/santa-clara-kohls-to-close-after-holidays-as-essex.html http://www.bizjournals.com/sanjose/news/2015/10/13/santa-cla... 2 - http://blogs.mercurynews.com/internal-affairs/2014/05/19/santa-claras-big-new-project-and-its-back-story/ http://blogs.mercurynews.com/internal-affairs/2014/05/19/san...
- hx87 10y agoAllow residents of those existing houses to add additional floors, convert garages, add a granny flat, et cetera. Large parts of Boston consist of nothing but 3-story, 3-unit apartments, often with a live-in landlord, and it's quite dense.
- xienze 10y agoI don't think there's enough people in the valley with the money and the desire to convert and rent out part of their house to do much of anything about the demand.
- hx87 10y agoYou might have a point about desire, but with the levels of land value inflation there, almost any owner can take out enough of a home equity loan to finance the construction or conversion of additional units.
- kqr2 10y agoWe should let the market decide. The same argument was used against airbnb : who wants to rent out part of their house to strangers?
- TulliusCicero 10y agoI disagree, but either way, looser zoning would allow it to happen, not force it to happen. If people don't want to sell, well, nobody would make them.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- TulliusCicero 10y agoWhat's wrong with knocking down existing houses? If the homeowners want to sell to developers that will build higher-density housing on their land, what exactly is the problem? I mean, probably every dense neighborhood in the world was at one time lower-density, and had its old buildings knocked down and replaced. This isn't anything new.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> If the homeowners want to sell to developers that will build higher-density housing on their land, what's wrong with that? Generally, not all of them do, which is why redevelopment usually involves use of eminent domain.
- TulliusCicero 10y agoSource on that? AFAIK eminent domain for private development is rare, the vast, vast majority of the time developers just offer enough money to convince people to sell.
- pyre 10y agoNot so rare that it doesn't have a Supreme Court case[1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kelo_v._City_of_New_London https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kelo_v._City_of_New_London
- TulliusCicero 10y agoIt's my understanding that the Supreme Court case is so notable precisely because eminent domain for private development is so rare.
- xienze 10y agoI didn't say there's anything wrong with that but it's certainly a hurdle to clear (what if one person refuses to sell?).
- skewart 10y agoThe same places that you put urban developments in most cities - you repurpose existing underused buildings and spaces in existing urban neighborhoods. There are lots and lots of parking lots, underutilized commercial buildings, and low density apartment complexes that can be redeveloped at a relatively higher density.
- raldi 10y agoPlaces like this: http://missionlocal.org/2016/01/community-meeting-on-new-sf-mission-housing-turns-ugly/ http://missionlocal.org/2016/01/community-meeting-on-new-sf-...
- johan_larson 10y agoZoning laws. And existing owners who staunchly oppose increasing density by building larger buildings. A lot of people who bought their single-family homes years or decades ago now live in appealing low-density neighborhoods with home values that are sky-rocketing. They don't want their neighborhoods to change into concrete canyons, and the ever-rising values of their homes fund their retirements very nicely. They therefore fight any attempt to increase density by loosening zoning laws. This behavior is exacerbated by how California handles its property taxes. Essentially, the property taxes on a home are fixed at the value of the home when you bought it, meaning people living in homes that have increased in value are paying disproportionately low property taxes. This tends to discourage people from moving, thereby reducing the liquidity of the home market.
- jandrese 10y agoIt is also one of the big reasons California can have such an enormous theoretical tax base, but still manage to run a massive deficit. You can bet there would be more pushback on those skyrocketing home values if people had to pay the taxes on them. Its too late for a lot of people in the valley, they couldn't afford to pay anything close to what their homes current access at. It is the epitome of Got Mine, Fuck You.
- TelAviv_1 10y agoWhy do you think I should pay crazy property tax values on the Sunnyvale house I paid $250,000 for in 1988 just because some nut paid $2,000,000 for the identical house next door to mine last year? Why do you want to see my pushed out of my home with a $45,000/year property tax bill? You are pure evil, plain and simple.
- ojbyrne 10y agoWhile the point is somewhat valid, California hasn't had a budget deficit (let alone a "massive" one) since 2012.
- codemac 10y agoThe people who bought their houses 30+ years ago I really feel for. The change the area is experiencing is brutal, and imagine if everyone just kept asking you why you don't sell and move away from the very place you built? It's futile for them to fight things, and honestly it ruins a lot of people's lives that they do. However I completely understand why they would push back on density, most people don't have to deal with growth at these types of numbers over their lifetime.
- Animats 10y agoThat's been called the "jobs-housing imbalance" since the 1980s.
- HarryHirsch 10y agoIt is was only housing! But it's infrastructure, too. You need to put in extra sewage, electric, roads, schools &c to accommodate the rise in population, and that is going to be painful. With Proposition 13, how does a municipality raise funds for new schools or a sewage plant expansion?
- gozur88 10y agoTypically through Mello-Roos districts. It's pretty common for residents of newer developments to have an additional line item on their property tax bills. This is to service bonds that were taken out for things like new roads, schools, water, and sewage. Mello-Roos districts are pretty popular with existing residents, since they don't have to pay for new infrastructure to accommodate new residents. From the wiki page: >Many communities requiring new schools or other public infrastructure such as public parks and roads impose Mello-Roos taxes as an alternative to (or in addition to) impact fees paid directly by real estate developers. While real property taxes are generally levied as a percentage of the assessed value of the parcel, a Mello-Roos tax is levied independent of assessed property value (a parcel tax), and is not subject to Proposition 13 property tax rate limitations.
- shostack 10y agoI think Mello-Roos is awful in some ways. New owners in the area shouldn't have massively disproportionate tax burdens because they moved there a few years later (in some cases that is a very large difference). Especially when you consider things like the fact that people are still using the resources just as equally. Areas change, and increasing taxes on all residents (even if it forces some out) is unfortunately part of the downward pressure of house prices that our market is missing. Elsewhere in the country in saner real estate markets, if taxes increase too much and you need to move as a result, that's what happens. It absolutely sucks, but it helps balance the inventory.
- beachstartup 10y agoi went to school with a lot of wealthy kids from the bay area. they and their families simply do not want to develop the area any further, in order to keep housing as high as possible and the area exclusive as possible. in private conversation they talk about it openly. personally i don't think it's much more complicated than that.
- hx87 10y agoLike many other problems in California, this one can be largely traced back to a single source: Proposition 13
- xienze 10y agoWhich was created to combat the problem of grandma kicked out of her house because she can't afford her property taxes. How do you get around that?
- johan_larson 10y agoYou don't. Grandma should move to someplace cheaper. The cures are worse than the disease, and if property taxes really have increased that much, she's in for a nice windfall when she sells and buys something cheaper elsewhere.
- mosdave 10y ago> Grandma should move to someplace cheaper. ..and somehow NIMBYs are painted as the heartless ones?
- shostack 10y agoPeople don't like to hear this because it is just a very non-PC narrative, but it is the truth. In other real estate markets, this is a huge downward pressure on housing prices by the fact that if taxes get too high, it increases the inventory by the amount of people forced out. The Bay Area is almost entirely lacking in that pressure, which combined with other Prop 13-related issues and the area's popularity makes a perfect storm for this current fiasco. Nobody wants ol' granny, or that single mom who has lived there forever, etc. to have to uproot their life and leave, but there simply is no way to have a happy outcome for everyone. And, to your point, if property taxes have increased that much, the increased home value should take some of the sting out of it when they go to sell. There are very real emotional downsides to all of this, but ultimately I'm of the opinion that people being forced out of areas as they gentrify due to property taxes are a necessary part of a healthy real estate ecosystem. Really curious to see what happens in the long game as the families who inherit homes that were locked into old tax levels are forced to sell as they can't pass them on to a second generation without the tax rate resetting. Anyone have an estimate on when that may be? Perhaps we'll see a major correction in Bay Area house prices at that point as the inventory increases from that.
- baron816 10y agoWhy are people so adamantly opposed to density? Well, I know the reason is to prop up the value of their homes, but if you think about places like New York, London, and Paris, that argument doesn't exactly hold. Those cities are incredibly dense and expensive, but people love living there enough to pay the high prices. People who can live anywhere choose to live there. I'm willing to bet that SV could triple its population, and property values would hold or increase. Supply will create it's own demand.
- adrianratnapala 10y agoThey pay high prices, but then they also vote for anti-building laws in those places too. (At least in NY and London, I don't know about about Paris). In all cases, the restrictions are good for the people who are already there.
- epa 10y agoAs a home owner in this area, the majority likely already have double or triple unrealized gains on their home value. The potential to lift that to 'quadruple', for the cost of increased noise, traffic, people, etc is probably not worth the the incremental gain (in theory).
- hkmurakami 10y agoIn the previously underdeveloped and less desirable neighborhoods of Santa Clara, Sunnyvale, and even Mountain View, home prices have more than quintupled since the early 90's. In the first two, prices have roughly doubled since 2010.
- Johnny555 10y agoI think it's because they are so attached to their cars, and more density brings more traffic. Especially when starting with a low-density neighborhood that's poorly served by transit and everyone that lives there is tied to their car. Places like NYC, London, and Paris have great public transit systems, it's easy to live there without a car, but much harder to do that in spread out Silicon Valley, even if you live next to a VTA light rail station, be prepared for a very long trip if you want to go across town. I live in mid-density housing in a mostly low density area, and many of my neighbors fought hard against a new high density apartment building being built nearby -- 2 of the most common concerns raised were traffic and street parking (oh, and crime was also raised -- apparently they thought that criminals were going to move in to those $3000 apartments). It's been nearly 2 years, and those concerns are mostly unfounded -- I haven't seen any significant increase in commute time car traffic (though I bike to work, so maybe I just don't see it), there's usually still street parking available in the neighborhood, and afaik, there's been no uptick in burglary.
- adrianratnapala 10y ago> The really strange thing is that the city's officials aren't being irrational. As Yglesias is well aware, the city officials are only being rational in a very narrow sense. A building project can only create as many jobs as it can pay for -- and the workers must be payed enough to buy or rent places to live. What lies behind the claim that it will "create too many jobs" is that the construction workers will compete in the housing market against people that the officials want to protect. And even that "protection" is only coherent within a mindset where it is somehow evil to build new things, or else the stock of accomodation could be increased.
- pjlegato 10y agoConstruction workers already cannot remotely afford to compete in the Santa Clara / SV housing market, and they haven't been able to for a very long time. Construction work is also short-term and temporary in character. That is not the issue. Not everything that happens is a hidden plot against the long-suffering proletariat by the evil, scheming bourgeois. The issue is what happened in Mountain View with Google, and in Cupertino with Apple -- a company builds a huge new campus that creates 60,000 or 100,000 new permanent, high-paying jobs, but zero new housing gets created, making the cost of living insanely high for everyone (not just for construction workers.) This is because the cities won't allow any zoning changes to their low-density 1960s suburban setup. Their goal is to preserve the physical infrastructure in that low-density shape, not to keep out lowly poor people as such.
- johan_larson 10y agoYou'd think at some point salaries would climb high enough -- driven by housing costs -- that it stopped making sense to hire people in SV. But that hasn't happened yet, at least not for programmers.
- pjlegato 10y agoThey believe (rightly or wrongly) that the added costs are worth the benefits from the network effect of being in the region, around lots of other tech people. Many of them are starting to build satellite offices in other places.
- disposeofnick9 10y agoI live in a VW somewhere in Silicon Valley. Ask me anything (respectful, non-troll) EDIT: I don't usually bite, but when I do, I won't eat much.
- johan_larson 10y agoYou mean one of those mini-buses? http://www.truckchamp.com/images/articles/vw-minibus---abbey-street-infomatique40-l.jpg http://www.truckchamp.com/images/articles/vw-minibus---abbey...
- disposeofnick9 10y agoNot quite as old and cool as an aircooled 22 window DIY EV like the electric samba, just a digijet Vanagon Westy water-boxer plankton-burner. If/when I had 12 grand, I'm ripping the gas motor out and going EV because there's so many free/cheap charging places available now. Plus, climate change and jihaadis. PS: CA, NJ and others plz vote today. I did yesterday. If you want change, you gotta be counted.
- joss82 10y agoDo you mean a RV? First serious question: how do you manage your social life?
- hx87 10y agoI don't live in an RV, but ~0% of my social life takes place at home. I just sleep there.
- disposeofnick9 10y agoThanks bro, I got this. :) Although I do have an LED spinning light ball, an old tape-player radio and the world's smallest dance floor.
- sokoloff 10y agoSuppose you want to bring a date home and have sex. What's been the typical reaction to the "van down by the river"?
- slantaclaus 10y agoResidential building height, per acre unit density and minimum off-street parking space per unit restrictions.
- Pica_soO 10y agoCould you pack people into shared flat- without them noticing? As in - selfre-arranging Walls and Furniture, and Set-Furniture (Kitchen/Bathroom) that quietly pops up even before the user arrives?
- hkmurakami 10y agoSimilar forces in effect for school districts. I remember Cupertino being against additional medium density development because of concern over overcrowding of schools. Given that background I'm modestly surprised that the new Vallco redevelopment got approved.
- shostack 10y agoSunnyvale is likewise overcrowded and parents are PISSED [1]. Can't say I blame them--if you drop a massive amount of money to get into a neighborhood with the school being a large driver of that, only to be told "sorry, we're overcrowded and you're kid is going to go to this school that is known to be significantly worse" I know I'd be livid and consider whatever means necessary to fix it. While SF's random lottery system certainly has its issues, it does actually solve for some of these problems. [1] http://www.mercurynews.com/sunnyvale/ci_26825651/sunnyvale-school-district-considers-redistricting-hundreds-parents-not http://www.mercurynews.com/sunnyvale/ci_26825651/sunnyvale-s...
- xenadu02 10y agoVery few people bother to vote in non-presidential elections. I keep hammering this point to anyone I meet in the startup scene here in SF. If just 1% of you reading this right now (who live in SF) bothered to vote on a pro-housing basis, we'd immediately turn into a huge voting bloc that could not be ignored. You should shame your coworkers and remind people in slack channels too. A few thousand NIMBYs currently control SF housing policy. Filling out an online form is all it takes to change that. It's also really easy: register online and they mail the ballot to you. It's called "Permanent vote by mail". It takes almost no effort whatsoever. http://www.sos.ca.gov/elections/voter-registration/vote-mail/ http://www.sos.ca.gov/elections/voter-registration/vote-mail... You don't need a California drivers license. You don't need to have lived here for a year. You just have to have the intention to make California your current home (eg not a tourist). For the lazy, SF Yes In My Backyard puts out voting slates of pro-housing politicians and propositions. Just reference that, draw the lines on the ballot, and drop it in the mail. You don't even have to buy a stamp. http://www.sfyimby.org http://www.sfyimby.org
- djcapelis 10y agoI support the goals of increased density and more housing. I can't possibly vote the YIMBY slate though, and have advised friends not to as well. The YIMBY slate supports candidates who are the opposite of folks I'd like to see in government. The YIMBY slate endorses people who have voted to restrict people's ability to sit and lie in public places, voted against police reform and voted to make it illegal to be naked in the Castro. I'm sorry, but those issues are important and for me, many of the people the YIMBY slate endorses are on the wrong side of it. We don't have to sell out our values to be pro housing. Down with height limits, down with protracted approval processes for construction, down with many of the things that hold back progress in the city. Let SF reach toward the sky. But also, down with the YIMBY slate. It's just a set of candidates who aren't what I want to see in the city. If the YIMBY slate wants to back actual tangible propositions or policy suggestions, I'm all ears. When they ask me to vote for people they selected because they think they might be "pro-housing" (as if anyone in SF is really anti-housing?) then I'm going to tell them the people I select to represent me are my business. I'm happy to advocate for pro-housing policies. But I sure didn't and won't vote that YIMBY slate, and for the sake of the city I live in, I hope it's soundly defeated.
- nolepointer 10y agoI can't really blame residents for wanting to keep the status quo. Living in a neighborhood of single-family homes has always been the image of the American dream. Why would they want to relinquish that?
- taurath 10y agoThey link to missing middle housing... http://missingmiddlehousing.com/ http://missingmiddlehousing.com/ as if thats the solution. Having lived in the bay for a long time - there are many "middle" housing places. Just none of them are new. Duplexes, and multiplexes are almost always in the worst areas, because they're not big enough to allow for walking or being close by a lot of services, but are dense enough to be VERY easily annoyed at neighbors. The only thing they're good at is being cheap to build. Townhomes are popping up frequently and offer a slightly nicer version, but I don't honestly see much difference between a townhome without a yard and a more dense mid-rise other than available floorplans. I'm all for more density, but what frequently happens is that they build in moderately dense housing but all the plots are walled off from each other, there's nowhere to walk and so you just have more and more cars and traffic on the road. Full density or bust, I say.
- pessimizer 10y agoWhy in the world would an area with 100% employment want to add jobs?
- AceJohnny2 10y agoRemember when you played SimCity, and you had those demand bars for Industry, Commercial, and Residential Zoning? ... Of course in the real world, you can't arbitrarily bulldoze existing zones to replace them with high density residential :|
- TheCoelacanth 10y agoOf course, but you can at least rezone and allow people to bulldoze their own buildings and replace them with high density residential if they choose to. If housing prices are high enough, many of them will choose to do that.
- DrScump 10y agoPerhaps the subtlety of the sentence is being missed. It says: San Jose has taken the rare step of publicly opposing the project, saying it would add far too many jobs, exacerbating the region’s housing shortage. In my opinion, the motivation is that the San Jose City Council is assuming that most of the workers would live in San Jose, exacerbating their housing price pressure while denying them any of the developer-fee benefits or tax base improvement. And that's true. This has been the pattern throughout the history of the valley: San Jose's traditional business-unfriendliness has resulted in the major Silicon Valley names locating their businesses in Santa Clara, Sunnyvale, Cupertino (Apple!), and Mountain View (Google!) over the decades. San Jose's emphasis was always on grabbing all the land they could (incorporating county lands) without creating a business-friendly environment there. (Look at San Jose city boundaries in, say, 1950 versus now.) It's another side-effect of one-party rule (for all but one mayoral dynasty) during this period. Another demonstration of this nimby-ism is that San Jose and surrounding cities tend to dump problematic development on each other's borders. For example, Santana Row and Valley Fair straddle the San Jose - Santa Clara border. Neither felt any incentive to consider traffic effects of dumping all of this retail in less than a square mile. Result: gridlock so bad that it actually backs up onto the neighboring freeways (280 and 880/17) during November and December, at least. Yay.
- DrScump 10y agoPerhaps coincidentally, this from today's Wall St. Journal: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11854989 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11854989