8 ms·
Scientists Find Form of Crispr Gene Editing with New Capabilities
- amelius 10y agoThis gene editing technology sounds powerful, but also dangerous. Should we be worried?
- toomuchtodo 10y agoYes, but the technology is so simple, there isn't any way to stop someone nefarious. Hope for the best.
- therein 10y agoYeah, CRISPR is a quite straight-forward process, so much so that pretty much any intelligent pre-med student can learn the process by reading papers. Given they have the tools, execution is no problem.
- amelius 10y agoHow difficult would it be to use this technology to selectively apply gene editing to specific humans based on DNA, or to humans of a specific race? Could this technology spread through food or water supplies? Could it be distributed with a delayed effect? How dangerous is this technology?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dghughes 10y agoTechnically there is only homo sapiens sapiens the only "race" of human.
- roywiggins 10y agoCorrect, there is no way to reliably determine race via genes or any other physical method, and biologically speaking race doesn't exist. But you can find genes that determine phenotypes that people think are racially relevant (skin color, hair texture, eye shape, etc) and you could imagine a gene drive that could do bad things to people with those genes. Whether those people are always (or even primarily) identified as or identify with a particular race could only be awfully approximate, but the effects could still be really bad.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- patall 10y agoWell, in priniciple variant specific application has nothing to do with CRISPR, any genome alternation could be coupled to certain mechanisms that rely on reading out the specific traits of the targeted humans. Of course, the current developments enhance these possebilities with gene drives etc. But on the other hand it also allows the development of defense mechanisms, no technology is the ultimate game changer (though CRISPR is thought to get pretty close). Spread through food or water supplies is probably possible, given that CRISPR is currently mostly administered via virusses like AAV or lentivirus. But that nothing new, those virus cassets existed before, and can also be used with other methods like zink-finger nucleases or TALENs. Delayed? I don't know, probably. It really depends on what you want to do. Keep in mind that most current applications affect around 0.5 percent of all hit cells. The effectivness of the process heavily depends on the construct and probably decreases with complexity. But sure, delayed promotors and other regulatory circuits should be possible, though unlikely for now. The whole technology is dangerous, so dangerous that we probably cannot stop it now and have to form and regulate it. But it also has enourmous benefits associated, and again, can probably defend against itself. You cannot win evolution, only participate.
- gallonofmilk 10y agoeli5: what can we potentially do in the near and long term with this technology? play god?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- patall 10y agoThat question can be seen equivalent to asking "How many computers will we need in the future?" in the 1950s. Could be 5 could be the current 5 billion or how many we have to day. Maybe someone more involved can say more about it. In theory possebilities are enourmous like currently healing HIV, personal cancer therapeutics, creating of custom crops (that currently do not necessarily count as GMO, mind you), enhanced model organisms. More down the road are deextinction of species, extinction of invasive species (rodents, zika, mosquitos, tilapia, humans ;). Targeted editing of embryos with herited disease. It has been said that if only 10% of what has been proposed will be feasible, we have a huge game changer. Whether this is playing god I do not dare to say (Last member of my family was babtised 80 years ago). When people invented the airplane people said that the sky is god place and they should not go there. Craig Venter was dubbed God 2.0 many years ago. Still, its just another new technology. In the 1940/50s antibiotics were a huge improvement, today its just what we are used to. I think I will get along with it, what you think depends on you.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- 88e282102ae2e5b 10y agoNo. You could eat a jar of it and nothing in your genome would change - you'd just digest it like any other protein. You could sit in a bath of it, again, no problem. In fact, the downside of crispr is that making changes in mammals is still difficult. Progress is being made on delivery mechanisms, but it fundamentally can't go into a runaway process. You'll always need an injection of some sort, or some deliberate action the part of a doctor.
- TruthAndDare 10y ago> No. You could eat a jar of it and nothing in your genome would change Um, I don't think that is what anyone is worried about, rather what can be done intentionally with it and to what extent we are still humans after a few generations of heavy use on ourselves.
- 88e282102ae2e5b 10y agoOP below asks about contaminating water supplies.
- pizza 10y agoWhat are the control mechanisms that prevent (which?) runaway process?
- 88e282102ae2e5b 10y agoIt's just a protein. It evolved in bacteria and archaea to operate in those cells. There's no mechanism for it to exit the cell, or replicate, or evolve, or anything you'd need to get it to from one organism to another on its own. I am glossing over the concept of gene drives, which is potentially worrisome, but as far as accidents go the risk is literally zero.
- Obi_Juan_Kenobi 10y ago> but it fundamentally can't go into a runaway process. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gene_drive https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gene_drive The basic summary is that you can make a CRISPR construct that will copy itself into the homologous chromosome in a zygote/embryo. Thus, any progeny resulting from mating with an individual with the construct will be homozygous for said construct, a runaway process. This is being considered as a way to eliminate deadly pathogens, and obviously could be used to wreak immeasurable ecological harm. I still wouldn't worry about it for humans, though, as simple genetic testing and further editing could counteract it.
- jdimov10 10y ago... asked everyone who ever heard of a new technology.
- return0 10y agoWe should be excited first.
- pella 10y ago> Should we be worried? "Top U.S. Intelligence Official Calls Gene Editing a WMD Threat ( WMD = weapon of mass destruction) Easy to use. Hard to control. The intelligence community now sees CRISPR as a threat to national safety. ... The CRISPR technique’s low cost and relative ease of use—the basic ingredients can be bought online for $60—seems to have spooked intelligence agencies. " https://www.technologyreview.com/s/600774/top-us-intelligence-official-calls-gene-editing-a-wmd-threat/ https://www.technologyreview.com/s/600774/top-us-intelligenc...
- bunkydoo 10y agoPeople who think strong AI will cause a violent apocalypse are gravely mistaken. CRISPR gene editing is the eminent domain of conscious AI, and a conscious machine would seek to create designer organisms to inhabit other worlds as well as potentially birth humans superior to what we know today to become leaders of our sociological hierarchies. It would take just a few generations to rid our race of things like depression, anxiety and mental illness with this kind of intervention. While providing the opportunity to increase diversity to a level where no two humans would be alike physically.
- redditmigrant 10y agoIf you are interested in learning more about CRISPR checkout this article - http://gizmodo.com/everything-you-need-to-know-about-crispr-the-new-tool-1702114381 http://gizmodo.com/everything-you-need-to-know-about-crispr-... . This podcast by Radiolab also breaks down the idea really well - http://www.radiolab.org/story/antibodies-part-1-crispr/ http://www.radiolab.org/story/antibodies-part-1-crispr/ . I am currently reading this book - The Gene http://www.amazon.com/Gene-Intimate-History-Siddhartha-Mukherjee/dp/1476733503/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1465093665&sr=8-1&keywords=The+gene http://www.amazon.com/Gene-Intimate-History-Siddhartha-Mukhe... to gain a better understanding of what genes are and I have found it to be really well written even for someone who last studied biology over 15 years ago.