15 ms·
Michael Dell Bought His Company Too Cheaply
- grok2 10y agoMore financial writing should be like this. The various points of view are clearly presented and explained in proper layman terms and it made for very nice reading.
- harryh 10y agoMatt Levine is the best. All of his writing is basically like this. Highly recommended!
- mathattack 10y agoHe also writes the best footnotes I've ever seen. :-)
- zymhan 10y agoYeah holy crap I'm still reading the footnotes and they may be even more interesting than the article
- hkmurakami 10y agoHe is known for his footnotes and acknowledges that he is known for his at times excessive (much to our joy) footnotes. :)
- harryh 10y agoIndeed! https://twitter.com/harryh/status/707018942469021696 https://twitter.com/harryh/status/707018942469021696
- tacostakohashi 10y agoI disagree, and find myself increasingly annoyed with his popularity. I liked his earlier journalism, 1-2 years ago, but as he's become increasingly popular he's become like a John Oliver or Michael Moore of finance. The formula is the same - take a complex issue, simplify it beyond recognition, and then act outraged that the rest of the world, when considering the entire complexity of the issue, had a range of reactions different from your five-year-old view of things. It's great entertainment for the masses, but it's a different genre from informative journalism.
- harryh 10y agoReally? I don't generally find that he over simplifies things. Can you cite an example?
- scotty79 10y agoHe totally failed to mention that all people who owned Dell stock were forced to sell for that price whether they wanted it or not. That made me think that all of the process of deciding the price outside of the market is insane while it's exactly opposite.
- sosuke 10y agoThis logic is terrible. The share holders would have never gotten $17.62 so why are they being awarded $3.87 per share with interest?! Reminds me of the land taxes on the value of the property. The value of the area goes up, the house is taxed into a higher bracket because it is worth such and such. But no one will buy it for that appraisal so how can it have that value?! Or collecting comics or coins. My comic book is valued at $1000! Great, but no one will buy it for that much. I only get $500 offers for it. Things are only worth what they are actually exchanged for.
- gxs 10y agoAgreed. I am sitting here baffled hoping someone with a finance background comments and explains why this makes sense. Wouldn't this ruling mean that going forward private equity companies will pay even less for companies, building into the price that somewhere along the way they will get sued and have to pony up some more?
- brians 10y agoThe argument is that some people were compelled to sell at this low price, and a fair price (the nearly-$18 number) is about what would have persuaded them to sell. All the high-sounding ideas about making arguments by offering to buy ignores the fact that this wasn't a market deal: small shareholders were compelled to sell whether they wanted to or not, and the board had a fiduciary interest to them.
- gxs 10y agoAh - that does make sense. They were looking out for shareholders who didn't have a choice who would have been happy to wait for years to realize their gains.
- ScottBurson 10y agoI think your second point above is right, though. If this reasoning applies to pretty much any LBO, it has to be factored into the price of future LBO offers.
- Shivetya 10y agoThat is just bizarre. So if you buy out a company where no other group even tries to outbid you investors can later come back and claim you did pay a fair market value? Has this happened with other buyouts or mergers? I thought the point of the share price was to show what investors were willing to pay. To assume every buyout is purposefully under cutting the price by 25% will just depress future offers
- pliny 10y agoIANAL but you can search through the Delaware court system website[1] with the text "appraisal" and find plenty of examples of this sort of lawsuit, which I understand is very common (perhaps to the degree that every buyout gets challenged by shareholders who voted against the buyout). [1]http://courts.delaware.gov/opinions/ http://courts.delaware.gov/opinions/
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoThe given example - $10 v. $20 so you pay $12 - is an example of the principle of consumer surplus. Not the EMH. "The efficient markets hypothesis" is not precisely the same as "consumer surplus". The EMH is dependent on consumer surplus, but the EMH could be wrong and consumer surplus would still not be. Consumer surplus is a microeconomics concept; the EMH is macro. This error isn't critical to the rest of the article, but it's jarring to see something like that in the first few paragraphs.
- ccostes 10y agoHe does say in the footnote that he was kidding and that this is simply called "economics", if that makes you feel better.
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoIt does not. :)
- SilasX 10y agoTrue, but the concept of consumer surplus fundamentally changes in financial markets, in which both parties want the same thing -- more money. In most markets, people want different things, so it's understandable for both parties to be better off, since each value's the other's stuff more. Nothing funny about Alice valuing Bob's widget more than her wadget, and vice versa. But when both parties want "the thing that throws off the most money", it's a lot harder to come up with a scenario in which (reflectively consistent) preference sets allow for a range of possible sale/purchase values. IOW, it's fine for a worker to be (hypothetically) willing to take a lower-than-market value for their labor ... but if a financial seller is, then there's (probably) a misvaluation somewhere, and thus an EMH violation.
- ArkyBeagle 10y agoShhhh! The Commies might be listening! :) The only reason I ... tolerate markets ( and I tolerate them quite well ) is that they act as a price discovery mechanism, a way of constructing decision trees using dynamic information. I have enough bandwidth to understand that basic trade - someone selling vegetables on the side of the road - is a win-win. Beyond that? I dunno. Hypothetically, Bob and Alice are specialized to each widget, which makes them more efficient. If we cannot come up with a preference-relation in which a range of possible sale/purchase values is allowed, then we can't really even hoist consumer surplus into use to support the EMH, can we? Isn't it at its core now a phony, game-playing exercise? There's no there there; it's curve-fitting nonsense on stilts at best. Self-referential systems are known to be deep pools of unmanageable complexity. And M&A seems to be a widely ignored disaster. I suspect - but really lack the chops to prove - that Adam Smith had it right all along, but that humans will always revert to isolated pools of mercantilist rent-seeking. That "markets" require beings who do not exist, or who have managed to get just enough ethical boilerplate to avoid the rent seeking. Just as Progressivism requires philosopher kings, so do ( apparently ) markets. So we're down to "well, it keeps the people who might otherwise be violent busy." When asked about American democracy, Ghandi said "I think it would be a good idea." I think capitalism would be just such a good idea. ObDisclosure: I have an old Usenet contact who is quite wealthy from a hedge fund. This guy's a PhD in applied math. He reports "I refute the EMH thusly" by kicking the logo of his firm.
- SilasX 10y agoCan someone give the devil's advocate view? As others are saying, the judge's ruling is ridiculous. I can understand if there were material misrepresentations that affected the offer price, but to rule that you should offer more than the market was valuing it? Even though no one was actually willing to pay that price? And on the grounds that "investors are too stupid to correctly value it"? Isn't the whole point of a buyout that you think other investor's are incorrectly valuing a venture based on the available information? If any buyout is going to be subject to this later, with-more-hindsight review that forces buyers to "top up" to the "correct" value, what's the point? Sometimes I wonder how business manages to work at all in the presence of this "jackpot justice".
- jacquesm 10y agoIt depends on whether or not it was a 'drag along'. That can make a big difference in how the price is interpreted after the fact. It means you don't exactly get a say in the price at which you sell. Of course it also matters if you were on the record as disagreeing with selling your shares at that price.
- pilom 10y agoThe issue is that some shareholders were forced to sell at $13/share even if they didn't want to. There were a minority of shareholders who were holding onto the shares on the assumption that the new long term vision would work out great and expecting their shares to be worth something >$13/share. Those people were forced to sell at $13 because the majority of shareholders agreed to take $13/share and let the company go private. Maybe someone bought at $14 a share years ago and simply was a buy and hold investor living off the dividends and convinced that it was under priced but totally ok with that because they expected to own the company forever. That person would be pissed at the $13/share offer.
- alistairSH 10y agoPissed? Sure. But, anger isn't generally grounds for a successful lawsuit.
- pliny 10y agoVice Chancellor Lester quotes in an opinion from 2014[1]: [S]elf-interest concentrates the mind, and people who must back their beliefs with their purses are more likely to assess the value of the judgment accurately than are people who simply seek to make an argument. Astute investors survive in competition; those who do not understand the value of assets are pushed aside. There is no similar process of natural selection among expert witnesses and [] judges And ―The benefit of the active market for UFG as an entity that the sales process generated is that several buyers with a profit motive were able to assess these factors for themselves and to use those assessments to make bids with actual money behind them. For me (as a law-trained judge) to second-guess the price that resulted from that process involves an exercise in hubris and, at best, reasoned guess-work. [1] http://courts.delaware.gov/Opinions/Download.aspx?id=215980 http://courts.delaware.gov/Opinions/Download.aspx?id=215980
- thegranderson 10y agoApparently this Laster guy has been an tough judge for cases like this over the past few years, and has spoken out against this before: From the article (in reference to shutting down a suit against Aruba for selling too cheaply to Hewlett Packard) "It wasn’t a first for Mr. Laster, long the court’s firebrand. In his six years on the bench, he has made weeding out weak cases something of a pet issue. But “this time feels different,” said Ed Micheletti of Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP, in part because Mr. Laster’s colleagues are joining him." http://www.wsj.com/articles/the-judge-who-shoots-down-merger-lawsuits-1452076201 http://www.wsj.com/articles/the-judge-who-shoots-down-merger... It seems that in this case he felt that the price discovery mechanism of the process and go-shop wasn't sufficient to reach the theoretically "correct" price, which makes sense. The reason any market approaches efficiency is because investors can easily buy and sell undervalued or overvalued securities. In massive transactions of this sort, there are only a handful of buyers who can participate, and it would be unreasonable for such a situation to be as efficient in price discovery as a liquid, publicly traded market. My sense is that the issue is more with the law, and ability to challenge this sort of thing (which is mostly capitalized on by specialized hedge funds who buy shares and sue) holds a transaction to a different standard than when it actually occurred. Specifically - the board, representing the fiduciary interests of shareholders, should be expected to make a reasonable effort to get the best price. If markets are not efficient and no one has the capital to step up and make a purchase, how would they know that? You can never prove the counterfactual in that type of situation, and it seems dangerous to attempt to do so via ex-ante analytical modeling.[1] 1. I get that this concept is widespread in settlements of all sorts (loss of use, damages, etc.), but in this case, no one was defrauded or coerced. Shareholder agreements were obeyed, and that should be that.
- protomyth 10y agoCan this ruling be appealed?
- nfriedly 10y agoJust to put this into perspective, only a relatively small number of people are eligible to receive the higher price: they must have voted against the buyout and jumped through some other hoops that indicate they were against the lower price. (They were forced to sell and presumably wouldn't have otherwise sold without a higher price.)
- henrikschroder 10y agoDoesn't this create some sort of prisoner's dilemma situation, in which it's in the best interest of each individual shareholder to vote no to a buyout, hoping that a majority votes yes, but if a majority votes no, noone gets anything above market price.
- nfriedly 10y agoYep. And personally, I disagree with the ruling.. but I'm not in charge.
- domdip 10y agoIf you look at this as a one-shot game, sure, but it's not. If everyone votes no the buyout would be rejected and the prospective buyers would have to offer a higher price to get it approved. The tricky thing is that shareholder voters exhibit very weird and irrational behavior (due to proxies, lobbying, the T Rowe Price craziness, etc.), so I'm not sure game theory is terribly useful to begin with here.
- mikeash 10y agoOnly if you think the company is actually worth more. If you think it's worth less and the buyers are suckers, then you'd want to vote yes so you can get extra money before reality sets in. Which is to say, your incentives for voting line up with whether you think the buyout is a good deal.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- 10y ago
- richardw 10y agoIt seems much easier to convince a court of a high stock price than it does an entire market. Therefore, sell at the price offered and spend your time on convincing the court, later.
- TheCoelacanth 10y agoYou aren't allowed to get the court to second guess the selling price if you consented to the sale, only if you were forced to sell.
- SilasX 10y agoBtw HN editors: The title is misleading. What it's actually saying is "Court shouldn't have ruled that Dell buyout paid too little".
- usefulcat 10y agoThat wasn't my takeaway. The implication of the title, in the context of the article, is that the suit would have had less merit if the sale price had been higher.
- whack 10y agoWell said. It reminds me of all the bluster I hear from people about how they are "100% sure" that "FB is definitely overvalued at $80B" or "AMD is certainly undervalued at $5B" and yet, they never seem to back up their certainty with the actual act of buying or shorting the stock in question. When it comes to financial markets, anyone who doesn't put their money where their mouth is, should be completely and utterly ignored.
- forgetsusername 10y ago>yet, they never seem to back up their certainty with the actual act of buying or shorting the stock in question Most of the vehemence is in regards to privately held companies which can't directly be shorted. In fact, that may actually contribute to the odds of the company being overvalued.
- bigmanwalter 10y ago"Markets can remain irrational longer than you can remain solvent." - John Maynard Keynes
- tynpeddler 10y agoBut nobody was insolvent. That quote sounds like it's more suited to catastrophes than to run of the mill equities acquisitions.
- cortesoft 10y agoNot having access to capital does not mean that you can't be right about a company's valuation.
- whack 10y agoMost of the people I've met who talk about how "FB is definitely overvalued" do have some amount of capital. They could safely short FB with X% of their portfolio if they are really so sure, and yet, they never do so.
- cturner 10y ago
- B1FF_PSUVM 10y ago> Again, this is super oversimplified; please don't use this description to prepare for your investment banking interviews. Disregard that note, and sue Bloomberg and the writer anyway. Seems to work, according to the text.
- whitecat 10y agoWhat this article does not explain is who is entitled to the money. It just says those who have jumped through hoops. I owned dell stock and it was sold without my consent, am I also entitled to the increased amount?
- spectrum1234 10y agoOne of the best finance articles I've read in a long time.
- superbatfish 10y agoThis whole article is a little misleading. It makes it sound as if anyone who happened to own Dell stock at the time of the buyout could have sued to get some extra cash. But only in the footnotes does it mention this: >To be eligible for the court-ordered price bump, investors must have voted against the transaction. Clearly, everyone who owned Dell stock at the time thought it was worth more than $9.35. That's why they held the stock in the first place! Those who thought the company was worth much more (say, $18 per share), presumably voted against the transaction. They were understandably pissed when the transaction succeeded anyway, so they sued. But those who voted in favor of the transaction didn't get an extra penny -- they agreed on a price, and that's what they got. On a related note, here's an interesting game theory tangent: If you think the buyout offer is a great deal, should you vote for it? After all, if you're confident the deal is going to succeed even without your votes, maybe you should vote against it -- to preserve your option to sue for even more money. But if everyone thinks like that, then the deal won't go through at all...
- facepalm 10y agoYeah, as your last paragraph explains, that rule makes the whole thing even more crazy.
- dnautics 10y agoAt first I thought this was silly, but when you're negotiating a complete buyout, it can be tricky: What if you really really didn't want to sell the stock at the price, maybe you had just yourself identified it as a value deal (hard to prove), and felt coerced into the buyout for a value that didn't, say, recouperate the expected gain. What if you had an outstanding sell order at $20 (unlikely, but easy to prove). In theory, what one should be doing is to drill down the ask chain until all of the outstanding asks are fulfilled. But that's not really possible either. Of course, having a judge decide is silly, too.