4 ms·
Children shoudnt be a risk. Everyone should be encouraged to have at least two and getting help from the government to raise them.
by k__ 10y ago
Children shoudnt be a risk. Everyone should be encouraged to have at least two and getting help from the government to raise them.
- aminok 10y agoHelp from the government means forcing people, through threatening them with time in the dungeon, to help. It's collectivist ideology turned into dogmatic religion.
- marchenko 10y agoThat ship sailed a long time ago with the disappearance of the frontier and homesteading opportunities. Now that it's virtually impossible to completely opt-out of society, some safety net is a necessary correlate of removing that liberty.
- brbsix 10y agoBecause it's considered to be requisite to interact with society, it's necessary to initiate force to collect funds for a safety net? I don't really follow.
- marchenko 10y agoit's now impossible to use foraging or subsistence farming as a last-ditch survival strategy because all land is claimed by public or private actors (not to mention regulatory and land use obstacles). With the disappearance of that formerly natural right, we are obligated to provide at least minimal support to persons we've locked into the modern system. While there might be other mire common justifications, the loss of the choice to opt out is the ultimate grounding behind the social safety net, in my view.
- aminok 10y agoWe have no natural right to forage any given plot of land.
- NickNameNick 10y agoYou did before the plots existed. albeit on the level that a wild bird has a right to forage for wild berries.
- aminok 10y agoI had the means, not the right. As soon as someone homesteaded it, I lost the means. By definition, you cannot have a right to unclaimed property. Having a right to it is synonymous to having a claim on it.
- kaitai 10y agoThere are actually a number of national legal frameworks that would disagree with you. See "everyman's right" in Finland, Iceland, Scotland, Norway, which has law backing it up. Just because in England such a right wasn't recognized doesn't mean that everyone agrees on this. (In Finland, by definition of "everyman's right", everyone has a right to hike and to respectfully pick berries and mushrooms on claimed and unclaimed property -- in essence, all of society has limited rights on your land.)
- aminok 10y agoThose are explicit national legal rights, limited to the citizens of a particular nation, granting them rights to land under the legal jurisdiction of the national government. It's not the same as a general implicit right possessed by any given person to forage any given plot of land. In this comment I further explain why I don't believe these national legal rights, and their subsequent abolishment, in any way justify a tax on private income: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11797024 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11797024
- 10y ago
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- x0x0 10y agoAt least two? We've exceeded the carrying capacity of Earth already. Governments encouraging further population growth is a looming disaster.
- tptacek 10y agoA. No we have not. B. That's what the Malthusians said. C. Google: [demographic crisis europe].
- markbnj 10y agoThank you.
- stesch 10y agoThe so called "demographic crisis" ignored current technological development. We don't need more people without jobs.
- danbruc 10y agoA. There is obviously nothing like THE carrying capacity of earth¹, it heavily depends on the consumption per capita and the technology available. I never did the math but I always wondered what would happen if we upgraded every human in existence to the first world. I think seven billion people with first world living standard are possible but I am not sure it would end well today, resource consumption would increase by a factor of maybe two. So I can imagine that we are not in big trouble with seven billion people and current technology and consumption only because we still have a lot of relatively poor people. C. We improved living standards and decreased mortality in early years, so a pyramid shaped population structure is a thing of the past. And countering this with continued population growth is not an option because it is not sustainable. Some countries could nonetheless use a few more babies to get back to 2.1 children and avoid an inverted pyramid due to a shrinking population. ¹ There is certainly some theoretical upper limit but that is also certainly not relevant here.
- nkurz 10y agoresource consumption would increase by a factor of maybe two That's significantly lower than most estimates I've seen. Jared Diamond for example says that the first world versus developing world resource consumption ratio is 32, with the majority of the world's population being much closer to the developing world: The estimated one billion people who live in developed countries have a relative per capita consumption rate of 32. Most of the world’s other 5.5 billion people constitute the developing world, with relative per capita consumption rates below 32, mostly down toward 1. He goes on to say that if China was to increase to match US consumption levels --- with no change in population or change in consumption elsewhere --- that alone would double the worlds consumption: Per capita consumption rates in China are still about 11 times below ours, but let’s suppose they rise to our level. Let’s also make things easy by imagining that nothing else happens to increase world consumption — that is, no other country increases its consumption, all national populations (including China’s) remain unchanged and immigration ceases. China’s catching up alone would roughly double world consumption rates. Oil consumption would increase by 106 percent, for instance, and world metal consumption by 94 percent. http://www.nytimes.com/2008/01/02/opinion/02diamond.html http://www.nytimes.com/2008/01/02/opinion/02diamond.html
- wolfgke 10y ago> Everyone should be encouraged to have at least two Why?
- m4x 10y agoOfficially supporting families who have more children than their income allows encourages bad parents to have (and neglect) more children so that they can claim additional benefits from the government. We would be better served by loss-of-income insurance, where people who made reasonable choices based on their income and then lost it would be able to continue supporting their families.