10 ms·
In other countries it's common to live with your parents until you're married, or even a little bit past that. In America it's looked down upon. Nothing wrong w
by bluedino 10y ago
In other countries it's common to live with your parents until you're married, or even a little bit past that. In America it's looked down upon. Nothing wrong with staying home, saving money (even if you pay rent to your parents, it's cheaper than living on your own). You can save money, pay for school, or not be forced to work a job by staying at home longer.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- shams93 10y agoThat's true, in Italy this is definitely the norm, but this kind of screwed up economy that only functions for the oligarchy has also been the norm in Italy for hundreds of years so there would seem to be a correlation between not having families and people being stuck under systems of oligarchy.
- sotojuan 10y agoLiving at home while working at even a decent paying tech job is a great way to save tons of money or pay loans. Definitely something I've considered doing. Also works great with remote jobs.
- joe_the_user 10y agoSure but of course most people who live with their parent do so because they can't afford to do otherwise regardless of the clever few who aim to save even more money.
- branchless 10y agoThis is true, but now you are saving for a meager deposit so you can take on a mountain of debt so that the rentiers can keep all your labour. This is not a good development, even if they used to do it in England in the 18th century.
- morgante 10y agoTo be clear, that's always been the case. Looking historically, the brief period in which the working class enjoyed a modicum of wealth in the 20th century is an aberration, not a historical precedent.
- branchless 10y agoSame for voting. What's your point?
- marf 10y agoAlways doesn't mean that it is a good thing.
- guard-of-terra 10y agoHumans always starved, always died of infections, always were mass-murdered. Why is that even an acceptable reason? All the XX century was about changing things that were considered constant. Have we given up? History should lead us somewhere. Is this already lost on us?
- morgante 10y agoI never said it was a good thing and I agree we should take steps to oppose rentiers. I'm just pointing out that the norm of easy homeownership is actually quite recent and unusual.
- guard-of-terra 10y agoThe norm of easy ownership of anything is quite recent. Any wealth was scarce. But now there's no reason why everybody won't have some place to live for them.
- carsongross 10y agoYes, but if the current young generation of americans is poorer than the preceding generations (a conclusion I think is inescapable at this point), then it is worthwhile considering why. The world is certainly richer than it was in the 80s. We are vastly more efficient at producing all sorts of goods. So, then, why is the current generation of Americans unable to afford what was available to the middle class previously? I believe that the answers to this crucial question are obscure and are unlikely to be found in conventional economic and political analysis.
- taurath 10y agoThe wealth is somewhere. I know quite a few millennial friends who will be rich when their parents die, and quite a few who will have nothing.
- ljf 10y agoThink they will be rich... Wait until the health care and other end of life costs start to add up. Even here in the UK they can be high, if you end up spending time in a 'home' that can quickly eat through savings. So unless there are amazing full life health care and other insurance policies covering these guys then there is ever chance that all that money could go.
- taurath 10y agoThen the health care business owners will be rich, and then the health care business owners children!
- branchless 10y agoThis. The entire point of the establishment convincing people to hand over large chunks of their labour for fiat currency is because they are giving you peanuts. You can't cash it in! All these houses "worth" $1MM - who is going to buy them? Demographics are shifting as the boomers die off.
- branchless 10y ago
- guard-of-terra 10y agoIf everyone is saving money prices will climb up and most of them will end up with nothing. What should be done is that market should be encouraged to provide enough housing that young people can afford when they need it. Same way Ford did with cars.
- xhrpost 10y agoI thought living with your parents in other countries was more of an aspect of a collectivist culture, versus a hyper-individualistic culture here in the US. I'm not arguing for or against either, my point being that it is simply countercultural and is probably not due to a culture shift but rather other external factors. Any culture experts care to comment?
- triztian 10y agoIn Mexico it's more the case of not being able to afford living alone if you're not a college educated professional; also roommates are not a common thing in Mx as there is always a general lack of trust towards strangers
- lrem 10y agoIn France the idea of a young adult living with parents was so alien that it was enough to make a movie about it in the 90s. Now it's the reality for half the population.
- userulluipeste 10y agoIn Romania, especially in its rural parts, it's customary to keep one of the offspring if not with the parents then at least somewhere close to parental home. Families encourage their kids to grow and develop themselves, and support them in doing so up to a certain point in time. Afterwards, they go in the other direction and "encourage" through all their available leverages retention inside the family, and this goes in various forms, from mild pleas for payback care up to heavy psychological pressure with nasty tricks and everything, that stops only when a decision was made by one of their children. The "lucky" one becomes their heir and caretaker and the others are released off the hook. If you're better with or off your parents depends on the times you're living in (be it Romania or other place), but clearly that's not something as simple as a cultural trait.
- slantyyz 10y ago>> In America it's looked down upon. Is there an ethnic variation to this, or does this apply to all groups?
- Shivetya 10y agothere are ethic variations if not some that developed regionally. however a lot also deals with perceptions built up over time. Farm communities tend to see this for farms passing to the next generation. The college industry is big money and they are incessant in their message that if you spend tens of thousands you will be a success. This implies that those who don't are not trying or worse.
- refurb 10y agoDefinitely ethnic variations. I've known plenty of people who are relatively new to the US and still hold a lot of their previous customs about the living arrangements of children and young adults. My impression is that most Americans look at it and say "that's different", but don't look down on it.
- dikdik 10y agoYour argument is just people making excuses. If our food quality went down or the quality of our air went down due to pollution, would you still be quoting "oh well it used to be so much worse in the 40's so don't complain" ??? This is a BAD sign. It is indicative of an economy that is not working for most Americans. Making excuses and disregarding these proxies for American quality of life does no one favors except for the 1%.
- dominotw 10y ago>In other countries it's common to live with your parents until you're married, or even a little bit past that. You are also not allowed have sex in these countries. Sexual repression sucks ass. I would take poverty over sexual repression. As someone who has experienced this; it has had major psychological impact on my life that I feel the effect to this day. And I am not alone, millions of youth in my country experience this. Imagine what kind of society that breeds, imagine living in a sex segregated society.
- Kurtz79 10y agoI have been living in countries where it's perfectly normal to live with your parents until you are married, which are no different in terms of sexual freedom (of freedom in general) or quality of life than the US. It sucks if it not the case with your country, but do not make it a general case.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> In other countries it's common to live with your parents until you're married, or even a little bit past that. In America it's looked down upon. Its quite common in America, too.
- megablast 10y agoYou think there isn't, I think there is. And not just the US, western countries. You will notice the important of the individual in these countries, getting out on your own, supporting yourself. being your own person, not what your parents want to be. This is a good thing.