7 ms·
Can a 700 M.P.H. Train in a Tube Be for Real?
- benlower 11y agoSounds like a bit of a "pipe" dream
- mike_hock 11y agoI see what you did there.
- mozumder 11y agoI can't believe how many adults actually fall for this garbage. There's too much that's just broken about it, from fundamental design to implementation. Some people LOVE bad ideas.
- trhway 11y ago>Some people LOVE bad ideas. That immediately reminded - state owned Russian Railways Corp has just recently publicly expressed huge interest in it :)
- ItsDeathball 11y agoRussia may be one place this technology makes sense. They have to rebuild the Trans-Siberian Railway anyway to get it up to modern standards, so why not skip ahead to something faster than a subsonic flight to Vladivostok? Additionally, an elevated tube might be able to take a more direct route, as the pylons could better deal with permafrost than a continuous roadbed. Paying for it is left as an exercise to the voter.
- maxerickson 11y agoIs it not used for freight?
- dang 11y agoPlease don't post unsubstantive dismissals to HN. Claiming grandly that an idea is broken (and putting other people down) adds no information. On HN, the idea is to post civilly and substantively, or not at all. For example, neutrally explaining how an idea is broken would be substantive.
- mozumder 11y agoThat's nice and all but the article itself lists all of those, and this would be a reaction to the article itself, instead of repeating it. (I'm assuming everyone read the article?)
- peterwwillis 11y agoI'm reminded of when those tubes that drive-through bank tellers send get stuck and go out-of-order. And i'm reminded of earthquakes. Burying the tubes? Maybe not such a great idea.
- elf_m_sternberg 11y agoIt's sorta clever how Elon Musk convinced Ayn Rand-besotted train-crazy tech bros to invest in his testbed for a Clarke Mass Driver.
- tjalex 11y agoService between LA, SF, and the Moon by 2020!
- dang 11y agoPlease don't call names in arguments on HN. This is in the site guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html. Especially please don't post comments that do nothing but call names.
- knieveltech 11y agoThere was a time, not terribly long ago, where the HN hivemind could tolerate a bit of sarcasm. Now it goes full on "mommy and daddy are fighting again" at the faintest whiff of real controversy. I leave it to the reader to decide if this shift represents an improvement.
- jasonkolb 11y agoThe shit talking about this is disappointing to me. Isn't this the route of crazy idea that moves us into the future? It's not supposed to be easy. You think people would put their livelihood and reputation on the line for something that they think is a sham? Seriously, if this mentality were pervasive we would not be having this conversation on the internet or driving cars to knowledge work jobs, we would be riding horses to the field. I love the nerve and ambition it takes to try something that seems impossible, these are the people moving the world forward. Edit: words
- Reedx 11y ago"No wireless. Less space than a Nomad. Lame."
- noobermin 11y agoHalf an hour in a tube is better than 4 hours of flying with wifi (including the security and delays in an airport)...not to mention the cost.
- mozumder 11y agoIt's not an impossible idea. It's just a really bad idea. There are far more efficient ways of transporting people at high speeds and lower costs than this. What are the advantages here? It's more expensive than high-speed rail, for example.
- fla 11y agoWe've been there already in the 90s, and it was too expensive [1]. Has the technology changed that much ? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swissmetro https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swissmetro
- jcranmer 11y agoHyperloop feels a lot like supersonic, vactrain, maglev PRT--which is to say, 4 technologies that have all ended up miserably failing. It's worth noting that the skepticism involved is not in any way displaced by the recent test. The major problems with Hyperloop boil down to: 1. High-speed switching, necessary to expand more than single-city pairs 2. Ability of the loop to maintain tolerances and structural integrity after weather and seismic considerations (particularly CA!) take their toll 3. Right-of-way feasibility, both in terms of cost-effective land acquisition and in terms of curve radii tolerances (note that even 300 km/h HSR systems in practice often have effective speed limits lower than that on much of the track) 4. The ability to get safety certifications--and the implications that would have on headways and consequently passenger throughput 5. Ability to maintain the necessary pressurization of such a long pneumatic tube 6. The cost/benefit of hyperloop relative to other technologies (like conventional HSR, maglev, even highways and airports). The way that the company seems to be shrugging off all of these questions is not a good sign.
- vermontdevil 11y agoNot to mention it might be economically cheaper to pursue automated automobiles since we already have the roads built.
- MBCook 11y agoCertainly in the short term, perhaps in the long term, but even automated cars come with externalities we might want to reduce such as costs/inputs of manufacturing, pollution, addition time compares to a fast point-to-point link, etc. For some popular long distance routes, I could see the Hyperloop being useful. Between all reasonably large cities? Probably not.
- vertex-four 11y agoYou're comparing capex vs opex, once you get past a certain period of time. It's possibly cheaper to build automated cars - we have the infrastructure to do so already, and we're close to having the software - but is it actually cheaper to run them, after all externalities are considered?
- cyann 11y agoWe had a project[1] like that for Switzerland, but it was canned in 2009 (underground: too expensive). Above ground tube is probably going to make it for flatter countries. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swissmetro https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swissmetro
- pbreit 11y agoHow does one get a name like "Brogan BamBrogan"?
- calebsurfs 11y agoBest part of the article: "Mr. BamBrogan’s real first name is Kevin. This is just one of many aspects to this undertaking that makes me feel that it will all be revealed as a breathtaking piece of performance art." Is entrepreneurship sometimes completely, or partially, performance art?
- maxerickson 11y agoEverything is performance art from some perspective.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]