4 ms·
From the Github issue [0]: > Further hostility against the company or our users will > not be tolerated in this forum, and will be met with > bans.
by OJFord 11y ago
From the Github issue [0]:
> Further hostility against the company or our users will
> not be tolerated in this forum, and will be met with
> bans.
Odd reaction. Especially when they've _changed_ from open to closed source, and what benefit is there, really, to a closed-source 'OpenPGP' implementation?
They're looking for a profit, sure, but they're blessed to be a hardware company. It's not like I can just clone they're repo and not need to buy their product.
[0] - https://github.com/Yubico/ykneo-openpgp/issues/2#issuecomment-219021710 https://github.com/Yubico/ykneo-openpgp/issues/2#issuecommen...
- slavik81 11y agoI don't think that's an odd reaction at all given what they were responding to: > Everyone that does not have shit for brains knows that security through obscurity doesn't work .... it should not take to long for someone to exploit the dumb asses that buy and use their allegedly "secure" closed source product.
- OJFord 11y agoAh, I didn't see that comment. What I thought was "odd" was reacting to community feedback that OS involvement was so prized by closing the issue (and therefore discussion) without explaining why this decision was made. Perhaps more seriously concerning is that it took people rooting through the code and issues to discover that this was the case. Many would say that security companies have something of a duty to be open-source; I think they at least ought to announce that they've deprecated the open-source versions of their code!
- MBCook 11y agoWhat's so terrible about asking for civility? You don't have to be happy about the change, you can register your displeasure and that you will no longer do business with them civically and in a forceful tone. Why is 'it's on the internet and they did something I do like so I can be an add' so accepted no matter what the circumstances are? Seems like a very reasonable and measured reaction. It's not like they're banning all discussion of the topic, just trying to keep civility.
- Dylan16807 11y agoIt depends on how 'hostility' is defined. It could mean 'non-civility', it could mean 'criticism'. Explicitly insisting on civility would have been better.
- Tomte 11y agoRead the last comment before the thread was locked and tell me if that was constructive criticism or outright insults.
- teraflop 11y ago"In this forum" being the key operative words. A bug tracker is supposed to be a tool to help software developers to get stuff done, first and foremost. Even at the best of times, it's not ideal to use it for end-user support, and it's especially bad for contentious discussions about product direction or organizational policy. Just look at bug trackers for large projects like Chrome. Any time there's a bug report or feature request that attracts lots of attention, without heavy moderation, the technical content is quickly drowned out by me-too-ing and angry rants.
- zobzu 11y agoThey also do not own github issues. The tone and content of all the replies is pretty bad, and, like, yeah, I'm no longer supporting Yubico either as a result.