17 ms·
Why Aging Isn’t Inevitable
- reasonattlm 11y agoI'll note that the authors here favor programmed aging, a vocal minority in the research community at the moment. This has a number of varieties, but essentially boils down to the root cause of aging is considered to be epigenetic changes. So epigenetic changes -> damage. The majority view in the research community is vice versa, that damage -> epigenetic changes. Aging is an accumulation of cell and tissue damage, something that spirals down ever faster as the damage starts to cause damage repair systems to fail. The forms of fundamental damage that cause aging are actually well agreed upon, but there is a lot of argumentation over which are more important and how exactly they cause specific age-related conditions. How can a field sustain two such diametrically opposed sets of theory? Because while we know the differences between old and young tissue, we still don't have a full accounting of cellular metabolism, and certainly don't have a full map of how a->b->c for all molecular biology at any given time, let alone over the entire course of aging sufficent to explain from start to finish any specific age-related condition. This is why SENS ("repair the damage, don't try to understand why it causes age-related disease, just fix it and things will become clear one way or another") is so important. We can repair the damage. That is much, much easier and cheaper than trying to understand the full chain of cause and effect. The next five to ten years should see one or other side proven conclusively wrong. The challenge is that addressing secondary effects in aging can still produce benefits. The water is muddy. On the damage viewpoint, we have things like senescent cell clearance now under development in companies like Oisin Biotechnologies and UNITY Biotechnology. Clearance extends life in mice. Senescent cells are known to contribute to many age-related diseases. On the epigenetic alteration side we have things like restoration of youthful GDF11 levels, which improves health in mice by signaling stem cells to go back to work. From the damage viewpoint, those stem cells are in decline as a reaction to damage, and the signaling therapy is an override. From the programmed aging point of view the signaling change is the primary cause. I think that the most compelling argument against programmed aging and for damage is that some forms of damage cannot be repaired by our biochemistry. Specifically persistent glucosepane cross-links in the extracellular matrix, for example, causing loss of structural properties such as elasticity. Also some of the constituents of liposfusin that builds up in long-lived cells and causes their lysosomes to malfunction. It doesn't matter how youthful your epigenetic patters are, you cannot break them down.
- agumonkey 11y agoYou work in one of those fields ?
- fasteo 11y agoHe is the mastermind behind https://www.fightaging.org/ https://www.fightaging.org/ and Longecity guardian[2] [2] http://www.longecity.org/forum/user/137-reason/ http://www.longecity.org/forum/user/137-reason/
- agumonkey 11y agoTo be honest, fightaging theme isn't the most 'serious' looking one. First page content seem technical enough to compensate though.
- findthewords 11y agoAny possible news on how to isolate glucosepane so we could even get started? Last time I checked, there were no solution that wouldn't also dissolve the surrounding cells.
- reasonattlm 11y agoNothing more recent than this summary post from January - but read the comments, since a researcher with an alternate approach participated. https://www.fightaging.org/archives/2016/01/the-present-state-of-progress-towards-clearing-glucosepane-cross-links-a-contributing-cause-of-degenerative-aging/ https://www.fightaging.org/archives/2016/01/the-present-stat... Essentially the few people working on this are still looking for drug candidates, largely based on mining the bacterial world for suitable enzymes to use as a basis. They have bacteria that consume glucosepane, so that's a starting point.
- majewsky 11y ago> The way this graph [of surviving population size over age] has been constructed, a straight line going diagonally downward is neutral, or no aging at all. Um, no. They introduced age as probability of dying within that context. Therefore a constant age would produce a population size that shrinks exponentially, but never reaches the zero line, just like with radioactive isotopes' constant decay rate.
- bsmith89 11y ago> The way this graph has been constructed... It's a log y-axis. A diagonal line downwards is exponential relaxation to 0.
- majewsky 11y agoIf it is, then the text does not mention it. And I'd doubt it, given that various lines flat out at the same height which therefore looks like zero.
- nograpes 11y agoThe article does not mention it, but the cited journal article says that: "Survivorship (on a log scale) is depicted by the shaded areas." Notably, the journal article shades the area underneath the line that is labeled 'survival' in the linked article.
- amelius 11y agoOne inevitable problem with aging is still that your memory will, at a certain point, become full.
- manmal 11y agoMemories are heavily compressed the older they get, and there always is forgetting :)
- agumonkey 11y agoIt's even a mandatory need, people without 'normal' memory loss describe themselves as suffering.
- krisroadruck 11y agoI'm not so sure this is how brains work. I get the impression both from what I've read and uh... personal operation.. that the resolution of memories fades with time/disuse which likely makes "space" for new information. Brains have a very high plasticity. You might say well if you forget what you once knew are you still you. I'd argue you go through this several times already in our relatively short current lifespan. Are you the same guy at 35 as you were in your early 20s? I'm sure not.
- LeifCarrotson 11y agoMine seems to do a halfway-decent job of emptying obsolete data automatically. It's much more adaptable than a PC that goes into a kernel panic when the hard drive fills and it can't swap anymore. However, right now my brain can't remember where I left my wallet, and it's stuck on a loop remembering some stupid kids song, so you may have a point. In any case, the remembered parts of a millennium may not be complete, but that would be better than a still-incomplete memory of a century.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- crispyambulance 11y agoComputer analogies aside, I think that the longevity community (perhaps justifiably) is ignoring some really critical aspects of aging and dying. In the same way as relatively new diseases such as cancer and heart disease have confounded the progress of medicine upon finally mastering the treatment/prevention of infectious disease, what new maladies await us when we "defeat" those and start living well past 100? What does the psychological health of a 100++ year old even look like? Will we _really_ want to live that long, and if so, who dies to make room for the living?
- huuu 11y agoA lot of cultures are telling stories of people over 200 years old. It's remarkable that those stories have some things in common. For example live span decreases after a 'big flood' or another big event. So some people think that climate also might account for how long we live. And even today some people claim to be very old: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Longevity_claims https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Longevity_claims
- user_0001 11y agoI would content a lot of cultures are not very good at recording age
- Retric 11y agoI think the much more reasonable explanation is people always tell tall tales. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Bunyan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Bunyan PS: Consider, if people are having kids at 12-15, then at 100 someone might be your great, great, great, great, great, grandparent. Why they must be 200 ;0
- sickbeard 11y agoHalf way through the article the author starts to confuse 'aging' and 'dying'. I would argue both are inevitable, we all age and we all die but not at a constant rate. Isn't that what inevitable means?
- nograpes 11y agoThe author defined aging in terms of the probability of death. I found this definition helpful rather than confusing. You noted that we age and die at a constant rate; how would you define aging if not in terms of the probability of death? There are some problems with the definition. Humans have very high relative probability of death during their first five years, but this quickly declines and then starts to rise again. This means that humans "age" backwards for the first part of their life, which is not particularly intuitive or helpful. However, the definition is helpful in the context of understanding how our aging compares to aging in other animals.
- germinalphrase 11y agoI would imagine that the folk definition of aging is more closely align to your body improving itself vs declining/plateauing. For the first 1/3 - 1/2 of our lives our bodies are building themselves up through growth, but then you hit middle age-ish, hang up the football cleats, and start caring more about your health because "you're not a teenager anymore". The premise that aging is defined as the probability of death feels artificial, or at least out of line with typical understandings of the word.
- lqdc13 11y agoThe author is somewhat confusing aging and dying. Aging is a mechanism. It is there for (probably) many reasons. One of them is to protect against cancer, and therefore from dying. You either age or you get cancer.
- astazangasta 11y agoThis sort of adaptivism has got to go. First of all, nothing is there for any reason; it just is. Evolution is an ad hoc process where things happen because they need to, and they happen based on expediency. There are many facets of life that escape adaptive constraint - selection has a limited reach. This comment supposes that aging protects cells against cancer; I think this presumption is based on the antitumor properties of telomeres, which impose the 'Hayflick limit' on cellular division. It is presumed by humans that this mechanism may have some adaptive role in tumor suppression. However: this is not why it appeared (all eukaryotes have telomeres, even unicellular ones), so any antitumor properties are an ancillary benefit. It is incorrect to assume it impute reason to evolution. It seems highly likely that aging rests close to the border of selective influence, and it is highly presumptive to imagine it is governed by consequence.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- lqdc13 11y agoThis is not a presumption I made. This is believed by many scientists. Telomeres are just part of the story. There are many other reasons[1,2,3]. The third link is not a paper so very readable. The cell has many ways to combat oncogenesis and when these protections fail, it tries to go into senescence (SIGTERM) or die(SIGKILL). Nanobots that would replace damaged cells with new non-cancerous ones are not yet here. [1] http://www.impactaging.com/papers/v2/n7/full/100178.html http://www.impactaging.com/papers/v2/n7/full/100178.html [2] http://www.nature.com/nrc/journal/v3/n1/full/nrc984.html http://www.nature.com/nrc/journal/v3/n1/full/nrc984.html [3] http://newscenter.lbl.gov/2008/12/02/cellular-senescence/ http://newscenter.lbl.gov/2008/12/02/cellular-senescence/
- nxzero 11y agoPeople that try to live forever normally don't live at all.
- nathan_f77 11y agoWould you care to expand on this? I don't understand.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- emodendroket 11y agoI feel like this is based more on wishful thinking than a sober examination of the facts.
- ak39 11y agoPic of dead mayflies doesn't look right. They look more like African flying termites.
- js8 11y agoA more interesting question would be why software programs, or databases, age and die. At some point, their own size and complexity will make them hard to change, and they will be left to slowly die. When I was younger, I wanted to live forever. But now I came to believe that dying is actually good, for a similar reasons. As we age and learn, we become experts at many things, but at the cost of flexibility and speed of learning (this is actually expressed in myelin coating of synapses). So we need to have next generation of people starting from scratch, questioning everything, otherwise we would be stuck with the old ways of doing things. So perhaps aging and death is an evolutionary adaptation, to changing conditions in our environment.
- BurningFrog 11y agoI'd prefer to find a way to clean off myelin coating over embracing death.
- ewzimm 11y agoOr better yet engineer a more efficient replacement for the central nervous system. 100 years in the future at increasing rates of technological development, it seems very likely that we could engineer a substance that could interface with the brain to augment it and eventually replace it seemlessly with no jarring loss of consciousness.
- civilian 11y agoOne of Heinlein's books plays with this concept. There's a Martian race that are essentially immortal, at least from natural causes. Every 40-50 years they go through a change and become childlike for 5 years. Lack of awareness, playfulness, no interest in sex, and an emotional state that changes quickly. It's explained that it's how they are able to rejuvenate themselves.
- mrfusion 11y agoUnless there's also a way to reset your brain to a younger state.
- 11y ago
- jsnathan 11y agoGoing to try to summarize a bit. The article explains that different organisms exhibit different patterns of aging, when we consider aging as either defined by increases in the probability of death, or decreases in the probability of reproduction. Taken together with the evolution of species, this implies a plasticity in both the mechanisms and utility of aging - something which is otherwise considered to be a rather solid constant of life. The takeaway then is that we must 1) widen our definition of aging to accommodate the variety of natural phenomena, and 2) reconsider the intuition that a specific pattern of aging, such as the one found in humans, is necessary for the survival of the organism and/or the species.
- dahart 11y agoI'm a little troubled by the argument that an increase in the probability of death signifies or is equivalent to an increase in the rate of aging. I feel like that conclusion doesn't follow and is misleading, but I'm not sure. Am I off base? If we suppose humans live to around 85 years on average, and rarely if ever die before 65, then there's a big bell curve normal distribution on 85, and what looks like a non-linear exponentially increasing probability of death up to about 80. But that doesn't mean everyone started aging faster at 65, it just means people started dying around 65. Imagine that you go bowling and throw 20 mph balls on average. The distribution would look similar. Bell curve on a pin dropping at around (say) 5 seconds, but the curve starts at around 4 seconds and ends at 6ish. Does this mean the ball suddenly accelerated at the end? No, in fact the opposite happened, it was slowing down. But the rate of probability that a pin goes down is exponentially increasing from 0-5 seconds. Not a perfect analogy to aging by any stretch, but am I right that an increase in the probability of death is unrelated to aging - the speed at which we approach death?
- Jtsummers 11y agoI don't think this is a reasonable conclusion: If we suppose humans live to around 85 years on average, and rarely if ever die before 65, then there's a big bell curve normal distribution on 85, and what looks like a non-linear exponentially increasing probability of death up to about 80. You're suggesting that the probability of dying after 85 decreases. That's not the case, it continues to rise. If it decreased that would suggest an improvement in health (un-aging) at 85, which doesn't occur. Having an average at some point doesn't mean there's a bell curve around it. The average of a uniform distribution [0-100] may be 50, but there's no bell curve around 50. It's just a uniform distribution all the way through.
- dahart 11y agoYou misunderstood me and confused the probability of dying by 85 with the probability of dying at 85. You're talking about the cumulative distribution and I was talking about the probability distribution. The chance of death at a given age is a bell curve. The chance that I'll die at 150 years old is zero, it is less than the chance that I'll die at age 70. The chance that I'll die by the time I'm 150 is 100%.
- kaonashi 11y agoDeath is…
- ratsimihah 11y agoLet us die young or let us live forever!
- dmh2000 11y agonice contrast to this article at the same site. http://nautil.us/issue/36/aging/physics-makes-aging-inevitable-not-biology http://nautil.us/issue/36/aging/physics-makes-aging-inevitab... I'll go with physics in this case
- messel 11y agoFantastic read, very curious about post fertility life and population stabilization.
- Stasis5001 11y ago>"From the perspective of natural selection, once you’re no longer able to reproduce, you might as well be dead." Both today's article and yesterdays said something to this effect, which is blatantly wrong. A now-infertile parent affects the survivability of their offspring, possibly positively or negatively. Since their offspring share their genetics, the parent thus is still involved in the natural selection process.
- Pica_soO 11y agoIf life is a dice, even the biological immortal throw it every time they climb into a car. In the long run, every methusalem is bed ridden, when statistics catch up to him/her.
- ilaksh 11y agoI prefer the SENS approach where the assumption is that different types of damage accumulate, but that there are ways to improve the cells machinery to repair or improve the problems.
- tim333 11y agoIt kind of fits with Kurzweil's guess that in 15 years or so we'll be extending life expectancy faster than we age. Though he's big into the nanobots idea which I'm skeptical of. But with advances in AI and DNA sequencing I can see people figuring out which bits of DNA do what and being able to modify the aging process.
- make3 11y agoeven in the most optimistic of views, we're all dying some time before the heat death, that's for sure, unless we alter the laws of physics or move to an other universe