15 ms·
Save Firefox
- usernamebias 11y agoCan someone explain why we're stoking the fire this late in the game, not that it shouldn't be? Firefox implemented this since May 12, 2015 -- https://blog.mozilla.org/blog/2015/05/12/update-on-digital-rights-management-and-firefox/ https://blog.mozilla.org/blog/2015/05/12/update-on-digital-r... Chrome's had it since v 42 https://www.chromestatus.com/feature/6578378068983808 https://www.chromestatus.com/feature/6578378068983808
- Endy 11y agoBecause, with the recent decisions re Thunderbird & Firefox, the only browsers that were designed with the intelligent and free user in mind aren't getting better - they're actually getting worse. Also, EFF has been running articles about DRM lately. It's not that we're only stoking the fire now... It's that they are writing about it again.
- Aloha 11y agobackground?
- twblalock 11y ago> Thunderbird & Firefox, the only browsers that were designed with the intelligent and free user in mind That's not remotely close to being true.
- HalcyonicStorm 11y agosome examples, por favor?
- BoysenberryPi 11y agoVivaldi?
- scholia 11y agoVivaldi is (a) new; (b) based on Chromium; and (c) not actually open source. (I use both Vivaldi and Firefox, but not Chrome.) Historically, Firefox has been the main user-entered browser, but not the only one. Especially if you include forks.
- Endy 11y agoVivaldi also shares a design lineage with Opera 12 and previous, in terms of who the designers are/were. When we lost Opera, I think we lost the open web in a lot of ways. As much as Opera was a closed-source proprietary engine etc. browser, it stood out against the background of the larger Web giants. When they folded and gave in to Google, I was horrified. Still, the loss of a Community Firefox is a bad thing.
- JetSpiegel 11y agoelinks?
- blacksmith_tb 11y agoAs a long-time FF user I should be flattered, but it seems like a tough claim to back up. I don't see any design emphasis in Firefox on 'intelligent' users; 'free' is a little easier to believe, in the sense that the other major browsers are very tightly bound to certain OSes and/or their creators (IE/Edge on Win, Safari on OSX, Chrome on, well, lots of things). Chrome seems just as likely to appeal to the intelligent user (if their smarts run toward fast browsing), though given all its telemetry (e100.net etc.) it isn't perhaps the most free...
- nwah1 11y agoMozilla fought harder against EME than any other browser vendor by far. As a user concerned about the open web, using Mozilla products is a way to bolster it.
- throwaway2048 11y agoYou make it sound like other browser vendors fought it at all, the EME spec was written by Google, and supported by microsoft and apple. This is not a case of the w3c "forcing standards" upon innocent browsers. The people writing w3c standards work for these companies.
- bzbarsky 11y agoTo be fair, there were specific people at Google who _did_ fight the EME spec, including in the W3C discussion; the spec was written by the "youtube" part of Google, and the people who were more in the "open web" part of Google didn't necessarily agree with it. But yes, Google as a whole sure didn't object and didn't exactly delay implementing in Chrome...
- neurobuddha 11y agoDoesn't Mozilla have a lucrative deal with Yahoo? I mean Yahoo!
- RubyPinch 11y agoyeah but so? from my read-through, its not literally "save the one and only firefox", its "we need an environment that allows for other browsers to enter the field" which DRM prevents
- adrusi 11y agoDoes EME prevent new browsers from implementing it freely. I admit I haven't read the spec but from what I've read second-hand, it seems like it enables the vendor to ship the DRM code as a binary blob that runs natively in a sandbox. As I understand, EME doesn't lockout new browsers, it locks out new architectures and kernels. But any new architecture that comes along that anyone would want to use to view DRM-encumbered media would be mainstream enough that content providors would support it, and people running an experimental OS kernel already have to use a more traditional system for a lot of things, and probably aren't a demographic too keen on DRM in the first place.
- bzbarsky 11y agoEME doesn't prevent browsers from implementing EME. But since EME doesn't describe how the browser should talk to the CDM (just how scripts on a page talk to the browser), implementing EME is not useful in terms of working with actual CDMs that exist in the real world...
- RubyPinch 11y agoit locks out new browsers because acquiring CDMs can be a pain if you want to roll-your-own https://hacks.mozilla.org/2014/05/reconciling-mozillas-mission-and-w3c-eme/ https://hacks.mozilla.org/2014/05/reconciling-mozillas-missi... ctrl+f for "What does this mean for downstream users of the Firefox code base?" tl;dr you either need to run a mozilla-built sandbox with no modifications, or literally call up adobe and ask about being given a CDM for your own browser, which they might just scoff at
- azakai 11y ago> [The W3C] needs to hear from you now. Please share this post, and spread the word. Help the W3C be the organization it is meant to be. This isn't about the W3C. This is about EME, and about the companies that created it and promoted it: Google, Microsoft and Netflix (as you can see on the spec, for example https://www.w3.org/TR/encrypted-media/ https://www.w3.org/TR/encrypted-media/ ). Telling the W3C not to do DRM is not going to be effective. The only thing that can work is to put direct pressure on the parties behind EME, and their products: Google and Chrome, Microsoft and IE/Edge, and Netflix. Not only is it not effective to focus on the W3C, it's counterproductive - it shifts the blame away from the real culprits just mentioned. If you lobby the W3C against EME but still use products from the companies that created EME, you're sending mixed messages at best. Furthermore, even if somehow we got the W3C to not do EME, it wouldn't matter. Google, Microsoft and Netflix would still be implementing it. They would just find another standards body.
- shmerl 11y agoThat goes without saying. I don't think EFF encourages anyone to use DRMed services, quite the opposite.
- mark_l_watson 11y agoI didn't know that. I think that Netflix, Google Play Movies, etc. are the only valid use for DRM: high value content that is rented. Types of DRM that are bad magazines this is just my opinion, are eBooks, music, etc. that are purchased. I donate a few times a year to EFF and FSF. I think there are occasions when DRM is OK, and even though I almost exclusively use Linux laptops (just converted my last Mac to Linux this week) other people using proprietary software does not much bother me.
- shmerl 11y agoThere is no valid use of DRM. It's always invalid. It's based on its unethical nature (overreaching preemptive policing).
- Karunamon 11y agoLet's get something straight here. This EME debacle was never a choice between DRM and no DRM, it was a choice between DRM in a consistent standard vs DRM with a thousand ad-hoc plugins. The browser without EME will be pilloried by its users for not supporting the content they want to access. Users use a browser to access content, not to support philosophical positions on what software should and shouldn't do. The lesser of two evils was chosen. You don't have to like it, but that's the reality of this situation. It is not realistic to suggest that the largest browser vendors not support user demanded content. Speaking of philosophical positions, most DRMed content accessed by a user in a browser is going to be of the streaming variety, i.e. something that DRM isn't preventing you from doing something you're otherwise not supposed to be doing anyways.
- jessriedel 11y agoI mostly agree, but isn't it plausible that a centralized standard allows DRM to become more prevalent? Right now lots of copyright-able content is begrudgingly released freely to attract eyeballs, but that could decrease if DRM becomes more seamless.
- Karunamon 11y agoThe DRM makers still have to write, ship, and get people to install the decryption piece - EME just gives it hooks into the browser (and allows said plugin to be appropriately sandboxed, restricted, and treated like the hostile black box piece of crap that it is). So in other words, probably not any more than the current system.
- jessriedel 11y agoGood answer, thank you.
- slrz 11y agoJust that now, the CDM piece ships by default in Chrome, Safari, IE/Edge and is automatically downloaded on demand on Firefox. They're probably fine with ignoring the existence of any other browser. See about:plugins on Chrome to see for yourself.
- binaryanomaly 11y agoAs much I would love to... Just recently switched from FF to Chrome since the latter just works technically a lot better :-( Hope the new servo engine can make FF shine again otherwise I fear the worst.
- Eupolemos 11y agoYou really should have read the article before posting.
- binaryanomaly 11y agoTrue ;)
- hsod 11y ago> This system, "Encrypted Media Extensions" (EME) uses standards-defined code to funnel video into a proprietary container called a "Content Decryption Module." For a new browser to support this new video streaming standard -- which major studios and cable operators are pushing for -- it would have to convince those entertainment companies or one of their partners to let them have a CDM, or this part of the "open" Web would not display in their new browser. Isn't this just a standardization of the status quo, with Flash/Silverlight? Why is it that I always feel like I'm being sold a bill of goods when I read EFF pieces?
- wmf 11y agoIn theory a new browser could load the existing Flash NPAPI plugin without help from Adobe, but it's much more work for new browsers to support EME. And plugins (read: Flash) are being phased out, so if EME could be killed then DRM would also be phased out from the Web.
- gshulegaard 11y agoI am a little confused by this comment. What status quo? Silverlight is deprecated. Flash is (at least seems to me) taking its final breaths. HTML5 pushed many web native standards for open media: https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/Guide/HTML/Using_HTML5_audio_and_video https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/Guide/HTML/Usin.... In fact, the HTML5 video/audio was so open that YouTube had to kill a Chrome extension that allowed users to use YouTube as a music source without advertisements or video: http://thenextweb.com/insider/2015/07/21/how-youtube-killed-an-extension-with-300000-users/#gref http://thenextweb.com/insider/2015/07/21/how-youtube-killed-.... (Side note: the history of what went on with Streamus is woefully simplified in this article...but let's just say the Streamus dev was open from Day 1 with Google but only after his extensions started getting traction they shut it down.) Anyway, moral of the story is this would be a standardization that steps _back_ (in many ways) to the days of Flash/Silverlight dominance...not standardization of the status quo (at least IMO).
- dtech 11y agoProblem is that Netflix & co are stuck with Flash or similar because content owners will not allow it to be streamed/provided without DRM. So currently it's Flash with no alternative. EME is not the ideal situation from the consumer's PoV, but it's on par with flash (maybe a bit better) and preferable to nothing* . It would be a net loss if previously unencrypted content would now become encrypted, but I don't think that's likely as a host like say Youtube already had access to DRM/encryption in their Flash player even before HTML5 video was a thing but never used it. I thus expect it to be mostly a net gain/neutral. * If you personally think nothing is preferable over watching content with EME: great, don't use it. But forcing that choice upon others is not better.
- jflatow 11y ago> This system, "Encrypted Media Extensions" (EME) uses standards-defined code to funnel video into a proprietary container called a "Content Decryption Module." For a new browser to support this new video streaming standard -- which major studios and cable operators are pushing for -- it would have to convince those entertainment companies or one of their partners to let them have a CDM, or this part of the "open" Web would not display in their new browser. This is the crux of the issue. The W3C is creating a standard which gives control to the publishers over which browsers can display their content. Whether that's "right" or "wrong" is worth debating, but sometimes the real issue at stake gets obscured in these discussions.
- gshulegaard 11y agoYou hit the nail on the head. Thank you.
- mynameislegion 11y agoI've read many articles critical of EME and this is the first time I've heard this information. If true, as you said, it is THE issue. It was always my assumption that EME represented a standard way for CDM's to interact with the browser. EME is to CDMs as NPAPI is to plugins. That is to say, a CDM can theoretically work in any browser implementing the EME standard. Is this assumption completely false?
- bzbarsky 11y agoSadly, the assumption is false. The EME standard is a standard for a way for scripts on a page to ask the browser to talk to the CDM. The actual interaction between the browser and the CDM is completely unspecified; it just needs to enable the browser to implement the EME APIs. I think a more apt comparison is that EME is to CDMs more like the 2D canvas API is to graphics libraries. At least in a world in which graphics libraries had very restrictive licenses and you could require, via the canvas API, a particular graphics library to be used for rendering your canvas.
- mynameislegion 11y ago
- 0x0 11y agoIf firefox really cared about its users maybe it should stop force-feeding "value-adds" like Hello and Pocket down everyone's throat by default.
- zeveb 11y agoIf Firefox really cared about its users maybe it shouldn't have broken the security of Firefox Accounts and Sync. It used to be secure; it no longer is.
- 0x0 11y agoSource?
- samuellb 11y ago[I edited my answer, because now I read that new system is claimed to be end-to-end secure as well] https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/sync-your-firefox-bookmarks-history-passwords-and- https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/sync-your-firefox-bookm... In the old system your data was encrypted with a key that was only stored on your devices. Adding a new device meant that you had to do a kind of key exchange process (which was perceived as complicated[1]). When Mozilla introduced the new system there was very little information on how the data was encrypted. I think the documentation only said that they used TLS (or something like that). But when reading their current documentation I see that it's not the case; they are apparently encrypting your data with a key derived from your password. So if you use a (cryptographically) strong password it should be secure[2]. Assuming that it works as documented of course. [1] http://www.cnet.com/news/mozilla-adopts-plain-vanilla-password-sign-in-for-firefox-sync/ http://www.cnet.com/news/mozilla-adopts-plain-vanilla-passwo... [2] https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/firefox-sync-upgrade-frequently-asked-questions https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/firefox-sync-upgrade-fr...
- zeveb 11y agoThe new system encrypts one's secrets with a function of one's Firefox account password and stores it on Mozilla's servers. That has two effects: one, an insecure Firefox account password (i.e., a password it is possible to remember) can compromise one's entire synced data; two, anywhere one enters one's Firefox account password is a potential danger. As it turns out, Mozilla serves JavaScript files which are used to handle Firefox account passwords. Any government Mozilla is beholden to could compel them to serve malicious versions of those files and steal one's Firefox account password (and then decrypt all of one's synced data, including passwords). Likewise, a malicious Mozilla employee could do the same. As a result Mozilla Sync may no longer be used by anyone who cares about the privacy of his browsing history and/or passwords.
- Ileca 11y agoYou can test your convictions by disabling DRM content in Firefox. Uncheck "Play DRM content". Unfortunately, convictions won't have consequences on future decisions because the standard is here and the more you wait the more it becomes embedded. W3C allowed it to come to light when various plugins wouldn't make DRM viable or at least more difficult to implement and reach general agreement. Now, even if you can opt out with Firefox, Netflix really don't care about that because you decided to disable it so you are a bad client anyway. I understand why the article is talking about pop-ups because the moment Firefox decided to implement it, we lost the fight. I use Firefox but lately, I am saddened by their lack of strong convictions and how they tend to follow google a little too much. (At least, FF sandboxed the CDM, while not perfect, the other browsers didn't do it, isn't it?)
- yborg 11y ago>Uncheck "Play DRM content". You need to turn this on <_< about:config browser.eme.ui.enabled true to allow the checkbox to be displayed. FF 46.0.1 OS X.
- Ileca 11y agoI didn't have to turn this on. It's in Content section by default... https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/enable-drm https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/enable-drm media.eme.enabled to false to disable EME if you want to tweak the config.
- _nato_ 11y agoCan someone clarify what is meant by `publisher' in this piece?
- jflatow 11y agoThe parties which provide the content, often the one's who create it but not always. As opposed to the browser vendor, or the consumer (browser user).
- k-mcgrady 11y agoHonestly, I'm not against online/streaming content being protected with DRM. I don't think it's very effective but it doesn't effect me as I don't own the content so I don't really care. This seems to be a step to far though. The browser should be a standards based 'viewer' that anyone with the will and the time can create. Let's say Netflix implements this DRM. They account for more than a third of internet traffic. If your browser can't support Netflix it's dead in the water. This is open to so much abuse. The gatekeepers (it seems to be the entertainment companies in this case) get to choose which browsers live and die. As we've seen over the last 20 years competition in the browser space is very important - without Mozilla stepping up and competing with IE I can't imagine the sorry state the internet would be in today. Edit: Once again, the DMCA rears it's ugly head. Time and again it seems to be the thing that is abused to screw over consumers. Maybe that's what we should actually be fighting against.
- kevincox 11y agoI don't have any problems with the concept of DRM (controlling how a movie is used) but I have major issues with what is required to implement it. Essentially by definition you need to run some code that the user doesn't control on their computer. How Firefox does it isn't that bad because it is fairly well sandboxed but over time the urge will be to push it further up the stack so that gaining access to the content becomes more and more difficult. I suspect give enough time they will push until they close the Analog Loophole.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- astrobe_ 11y agoIt seems to me that the implementation issue is just a symptom of a deeper problem: copyright and DRM by definition grants a monopoly. This monopoly can be abused. For instance, if you want to watch movie X and it is distributed in such a way that you have to give private data, your options are not to watch it or get a "non official" version. Could the copyright law be extend in order to prevent its abuse and protect the consumers, for instance by using the concept of "abusive clause" [0]? [0] http://en.wikimediation.org/index.php?title=Abusive_clause http://en.wikimediation.org/index.php?title=Abusive_clause
- jakobdabo 11y agoIsn't it trivial to reverse engineer the DRM module to create its clean room open source implementation thus effectively deprecating it?
- wmf 11y agoAnd then it's trivial for the DRM creator to sue you under the DMCA. I also suspect that CDMs can update (this is called "renewability" in DRM newspeak).
- besselheim 11y agoIf the reversing and reimplementation happens outside of the US you can avoid the DMCA issue entirely. Or take steps to publish anonymously.
- slrz 11y agoYou probably should also give up on going to any conferences on US soil in the future.
- besselheim 11y agoThat's true, they treated Sklyarov most unfairly, given that it was entirely legal in his home country.
- majewsky 11y agoThat's the large problem here. If you wanted to get the content out, it would be more effective to obtain a HDCP master key, since that one is embedded in a lot of deployed physical devices and thus cannot be easily changed (AFAIK). A CDM in a webbrowser can be updated today and content distributors could stop using the old key tomorrow already.
- yAnonymous 11y agoDRM in games has gotten to the point where reverse engineering is almost impossible. Obfuscation works.
- maker1138 11y agoThe biggest problem is intellectual property. Copyright lasts life + 70 years and patents last 20 years. That's a long time to have a legal monopoly on something, and is partly why companies are so big and can behave so badly. Innovation comes through competition, not monopoly. Ideally, we'd eliminate patents and copyrights altogether, but as a compromise, I think having terms of 3 years, with no renewals, is fair. That way a business can capitalize on what it creates and get a 3 year head start on competition, but you still get competition fairly soon which benefits consumers.
- Santosh83 11y agoI agree although three years seems a bit too short. I would say copyright for 10 years and no software patents altogether. Also copyrighting APIs seems like it warrants a close re-look as well. Then again, none of the "leaders" of any of the nations are listening are they? They are almost unanimously aligning behind big-business interests.
- hyperdunc 11y agoI doubt reducing the monopoly period would stop companies from pushing DRM, but the length of IP protection is ridiculous and has to change. 3 years will never happen, though. 10-15 years for copyright and 5 years for patents is more reasonable.
- majewsky 11y agoI saw a study some years ago that compared the interests of copyright holders of that of consumers, and concluded that 14 years after initial publication (non-renewable of course) is the optimal duration for copyright.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- xvilka 11y agoThere is a way to protect the content by adding per-user (subscriber) watermarks in the video/audio streams. Thus, no one will need these shady CDMs and Co. Of course, you say, you can try to find those watermarks/etc. But in the same way you can try to circumvent CDM code as well. Still, it will allow to eliminate proprietary extensions from the web standards.
- xori 11y agoI'm interested to see how effective the EME is to prevent illicit copying of media. YouTube and Netflix both use DRM now but it doesn't stop youtube-dl or pirate WEB-DL rips from netflix from existing.
- wahsd 11y agoI just found out that Firefox removed the 3D Inspector with v.47. It's a shame because that was an excellent tool for auditing and inspecting. If you haven't had the chance, give it a whirl.
- epmatsw 11y agoIt was a neat tool for sure, but apparently did not work in multi-process Firefox. Guess it wasn't used enough to merit a rewrite.
- shams93 11y agoServo might save it the c++ codebase for firefox is a nightmare but servo could wind up taking back the crown from chrome.
- fpgaminer 11y agoMedia DRM is not and never was primarily designed to prevent piracy. Rather, DRM is used by content producers (Fox, Disney, Warner, etc) to assert control over the rest of vertical market. This article is a prime example of this. Thanks to DRM the movie studios force browser vendors to sign agreements to get access to the CDM, and from that agreement they can assert control. They can subtly suggest, for example, "Hey, Mozilla, could you revamp your plugin API to make blocking ads harder? It's fine if you don't, but, oh, by the way, your CDM agreement expires next month. Looking forward to seeing you at the re-negotiation meeting." The same thing goes for encryption on Blu-ray discs, which forces Blu-ray player manufacturers to sign agreements with them. HDCP on HDMI and DisplayPort asserts control over TV manufacturers and infests video cards. This is the same industry that pushed the DMCA on us, extends copyright in perpetuity, sues families because their kid downloaded an MP3, would like nothing more than SOPA to pass, etc, etc. I know that the comments here like to demonize Google, Microsoft, Netflix, etc. Honestly, I don't believe it's their fault; Netflix in particular. Netflix is in no position to fight this. If they say no, the media empire will pull all their licenses and the company will collapse. And Netflix is already fighting for its life against these same companies for net neutrality (the major ISPs are owned by the media empire...). Google is leashed by its need for advertising revenue. Microsoft is beholden to its customers, who want access to DRM'd content. In other words, we shouldn't be taking our fight to the W3C, Google, Microsoft, Netflix, etc. The media empire is the real enemy here. And there's hope. The rise of cheap, digital cameras and distribution platforms like YouTube and Twitch have enabled a wide array of independent artists to create AAA content mostly unbeholden to the incumbent media giants. Some of the best and most entertaining content I've watched has come from Patreon funded YouTubers. If that was the only content that the world watched, the media empire would starve and whither away, and DRM along with them.
- rtpg 11y agoIs there real evidence for this? Does Paramount care about ad blocking? I feel like the simple explanation (DRM is about piracy + a certain worldview about effectiveness about DRM) is a bit easier to believe than a conspiracy. DRM is being used as a red herring so that movie studios can control web browsers? What?
- pmoriarty 11y agoBetter solution: repeal the DMCA.
- 746F7475 11y agoI thought from the title that this was a plea for Mozilla to rewrite Firefox from scratch since it such a bloated mess
- majewsky 11y agoActually they're rewriting the better part, see Servo.
- baby 11y agoI'm actually more concerned by the "save itunes" ( https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11670232 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11670232 )
- dredmorbius 11y agoThe problem here is capture. W3C has been captured by the digital restrictions management cabal. Mozilla, Google, Apple, and Amazon are playing along. In three cases, they are the cabal.
- reacweb 11y agoCurrently, watching a DRM protected video requires flash and gives an inferior experience than watching a non DRM protected video. Most of the non protected video can be easily downloaded using youtube-dl. Recently, I wanted to watch a movie on M6 live (french TV). Firefox (on wine to have the latest upgrade of flash) crashed twice. As a result, I downloaded it from a torrent and removed it after watching it. I think the current situation gives a lot of motivation to avoid DRM. If EME becomes a standard, we would lose much.
- reacweb 11y agoTo make my opinion clear: current situation is a mess, a future with EME would be a hell.
- SmellyGeekBoy 11y ago> Literally none of the dominant browsers from a decade ago are in widespread use today. Sorry to nitpick and detract from the real point here, but unless my memory deceives me IE was the dominant browser in 2006 and by a lot of measures still is. What a bizarre statement to make.
- Freak_NL 11y agoChrome, for better or for worse, has the largest market share, by a fair margin. IE11+/Edge, Safari, and Firefox each have a good share, but none are dominant. IE10 and lower are down to 1-2% (!).¹ [1]: http://caniuse.com http://caniuse.com
- jbmorgado 11y agoWhat Firefox needs to be saved from, it's from Mozilla.
- LoSboccacc 11y agofirefox invested more time in the omnibar nobody wanted than in fixing compatibility issues. we are actively discouraging people using firefox because whenever we try to use anything modern, firefox will fail it. the wonky outline implementation has been borked for more than a luster, has multiple bug opened and ignored etc. https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=687311 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=687311 and I found people complaining as early as this http://www.webdesignerdepot.com/2010/03/css-bugs-and-inconsistencies-in-firefox-3-x/ http://www.webdesignerdepot.com/2010/03/css-bugs-and-inconsi... and now I wonder how many of those are still there. firefox cornered itself out of relevance, and this "We need more Firefoxes. We need more browsers that treat their users, rather than publishers, as their customers." doesn't match with firefox priorities as observed so far at all. firefox needs to save firefox.
- developer2 11y agoAre clickbait titles permitted on HN? The link has absolutely nothing to do with Firefox, let alone "saving it". It's an opinion piece / call to action regarding the W3C and the state of Encrypted Media Extensions. "Firefox" does not belong in the title, as it's irrelevant to the topic. Luring us with the name of a popular open source application, to then present a piece with a barely-related agenda behind it should not be acceptable. As a side note, I'm sad to see that the EFF has adopted a PETA-like strategy to the way they tackle issues.
- phn 11y agoWell, the issue is that popups were a nuisance, while being able to watch all those publishers content is not. I totally understand the concerns, but making users choose something out of ideology is much harder than simply providing a better experience.
- majewsky 11y agoHonest question: How relevant is DRM in preventing piracy in non-interactive media? Consider a theoretical world in which DRM would reliably prevent unauthorized copying or decryption of DRM-secured content 100% of the time. The obvious attack vector for pirates would be to play the video and audio and just capture it with a camera directly in front of the monitor, and a microphone attached to every speaker. Are pirates doing this today, or is it just not worth it because DRM schemes are easily circumvented? I'm quite confident that copying of the physical signals should produce good results. There are consumer cameras capturing 4K video, and a video that's distorted by a non-orthogonal view on the screen can trivially be fixed in software. (It loses some fidelity, but you should still be able to get near-full-HD output out.)
- AtticusRex 11y agoQuestion: He says EME will allow publishers to dictate which browsers can implement CDMs that can interoperate with their content, and therefore control the browser market, and that this will quell innovation. I have questions about this, however. In the old but waning status quo, Adobe and Microsoft got to decide which browsers would work with Silverlight and Flash (right?) so it still wasn't possible for a developer to make a new browser that could play DRMed video without getting their permission. What is the meaningful difference from the new status quo? Is the difference that now, publishers control content and compatibility, whereas before publishers controlled content and DRM companies controlled compatibility? Is that actually a meaningful change for users or for browser developers? It doesn't seem like it is. Am I missing something?
- makomk 11y ago> In the old but waning status quo, Adobe and Microsoft got to decide which browsers would work with Silverlight and Flash (right?) Nope. The status quo was that any browser which implemented NPAPI (officially the Mozilla plugin API, but historically used by everyone but IE) could use Silverlight and Flash. That's how Google Chrome got Flash support initially and the reason why obscure browsers that neither Adobe and Microsoft cared about could still support both.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- brianpgordon 11y ago> users want to sit in the driver's seat. > We need more Firefoxes. > We need more browsers that treat their users, rather than publishers, as their customers. Until they started talking about DRM I was hoping that we were "saving Firefox" from mandatory extension signing. As of Firefox 47, you will not be able to install any extension which hasn't been digitally signed by Mozilla. There will be no about:config setting to override this. They claim that this will prevent adware from disabling the digital signature requirement. But it's also taking power out of the hands of users, with the justification that supposedly Mozilla knows better than their users do what code they want to run. This is the death-knell of Firefox for me. I'll be switching to an unbranded fork and hoping that the security updates keep coming. https://wiki.mozilla.org/Add-ons/Extension_Signing https://wiki.mozilla.org/Add-ons/Extension_Signing
- literallynone 11y agoJust don't pay for DRM'd content. Use torrents, libgen, etc.