14 ms·
NVIDIA Announces the GeForce GTX 1000 Series
- MichaelBurge 11y agoHow good does it look for a hobbyist manipulating large matrices for use in machine-learning?
- slashcom 11y agoPretty good; 8gb memory and impressive transfer speeds. The 980 Ti is pretty common in the Deep Learning community. Only the Titan X is more popular, and that thing is far outside any average person's budget. I'm definitely looking to pick up one of these soon.
- aab0 11y agoTitan budgets are definitely a problem, which is why you see so many acknowledgements of Nvidia in deep learning, thanking them for giving a Titan.
- jkldotio 11y agoIsn't the Titan X also about RAM? It has 12GB to the GTX 1080's 8GB. At the low end you could just buy more than one GTX 1080, so it looks like a good deal there, but at the top end you are running out of slots for cards.
- vessenes 11y agoLarger learning sets, essentially. I'm a neural net novice, but I think the general perspective seems to be that 8 vs 12 is not a big deal; either you are training something that's going to have to get split up into multiple GPUs anyway, or there's probably a fair amount of efficiency you can get in your internal representations shrinking RAM usage. One thing not mentioned in this gaming-oriented press release is that the Pascal GPUs have additional support for really fast 32 bit (and do I recall 16 bit?) processing; this is almost certainly more appealing for machine learning folks. On the VR side, the 1080 won't be a minimum required target for some time is my guess; the enthusiast market is still quite small. That said, it can't come too quickly; better rendering combined with butter-smooth rates has a visceral impact in VR which is not like on-screen improvements.
- fscherer 11y ago8 vs 12 is a really big difference - especially with state of the art deep learning architectures. The problem isn't the size of the dataset but of the model. Large Convolutional Neural Networks often need the whole 12 GB VRAM of a Titan card for themselves and distributing over multiple cards/machines adds a lot of complexity.
- paperwork 11y agoCan someone provide a quick overview of the current GPU landscape? There seems to be Nvidia's pascal, gtx, titan, etc. Something called geforce. And I believe these are just from Nvidia. If I'm interested in building out a desktop with a gpu for: 1. Learning computation on GPU (matrix math such as speeing up linear regression, deep learning, cuda) using c++11 2. Trying out oculus rift Is this the right card? Note that I'm not building production models. I'm learning to use gpus. I'm also not a gamer, but am intrigued by oculus. Which GPU should I look at?
- rpedela 11y agoI would get a NVIDIA card that Oculus recommends. Any card that can support Oculus Rift will have more than enough power for learning GPU computation.
- gavanwoolery 11y agoBuy a GTX 1070 if you are on a "budget" (around $350ish, comes out June 10th) or a GTX 1080 if not ($600ish, comes out may 27th). Do not buy a Titan model unless you feel you really need to work with 64 bit numbers on the GPU (32 bit floats should cover most of your cases).
- paulmd 11y agoDo you need FP64? If so, right now the OG GTX Titan is the default choice - it offers full double-precision performance with 6 GB of VRAM. There's nothing better south of $3000. If not, the 980 Ti or Titan X offer excellent deep learning performance, albeit only at FP32. And their scheduling/preemption is not entirely there, they may not be as capable of Dynamic Parallelism as Kepler was. The 780 Ti is actually a more capable card in some respects. The new consumer Pascal cards will almost certainly not support FP64, NVIDIA has considered that a Quadro/Tesla feature since the OG Titan. If DP performance is a critical feature for you and you need more performance than an OG Titan will deliver, you want the new Tesla P100 compute cards, and you'll have to convince NVIDIA you're worthwhile and pay a 10x premium for it if you want it within the next 6 months. But they probably will support compute better, although you should wait for confirmation before spending a bunch of money... For VR stuff or deep learning, the consumer Pascal cards sound ideal. Get a 1070 or 1080, definitely. The (purportedly) improved preemption performance alone justifies the premium over Maxwell, and the FP16 capability will significantly accelerate deep learning (FP16 vs FP32 is not a significant difference in overall net output in deep learning).
- BuckRogers 11y agoI watched the livestream, looked good and love the performance/watt. 180watt card. Way more GPU power than I need professionally or for fun though. I'm actually all-in on the new Intel gaming NUCs. Skull Canyon looks fantastic and has enough GPU performance for the gaming I do anymore. Mostly older games, some CS:Go (my friends and I play at 1280x1024 anyway since it's competitive gaming) and League of Legends. It's also nice to have an all Intel machine for Linux. I'd use a lowend NV Pascal to breathe new life into an older desktop machine since NV seems to always have a bit better general desktop acceleration that really helps out old CPUs. If building a high end gaming rig I'd probably wait for AMD's next chip. I've liked them more on the high end for a few generations now. Async compute and fine-grained preemption, generally better hardware for Vulkan/DX12. AMD is also worth keeping an eye on for their newfound console dominance, subsequent impact if they push dual 'Crossfire' GPUs into XboxOne v2, the PS4K and Nintendo NX. That would be a master stroke to get games programmed at a low-level for their specific dual GPUs by default. Also, the removal of driver middleware mess with the return of low-level APIs to replace OGL/DX11 will remove the software monkey off AMD's back. That always plagued them and the former ATI a bit. I'll probably buy the KabyLake 'Skull Canyon' NUC revision next year and if I end up missing the GPU power, hook up the highest end AMD Polaris over Thunderbolt. Combining the 256MB L4 cache that Kabylake-H will have with Polaris will truly be next-level. Kaby also has Intel Optane support in the SODIMM slots, it's possible we'll finally see the merge of RAM+SSDs into a single chip. But more than anything, I want Kabylake because it's Intel's last 14nm product so here's to hoping they finally sort out their electromigration problems. Best to take a wait and see on these 16nm GPUs for the same reason. I'm moving to a 'last revision' purchase policy on these <=16nm processes.
- rjbwork 11y ago>my friends and I play at 1280x1024 anyway since it's competitive gaming Can you elaborate on this? Never heard of this.
- lewisl9029 11y agoI'd assume it's because higher resolutions would offer an advantage due to simply having more pixels to aim at, and possibly higher FOV if you're using a widescreen resolution.
- gavanwoolery 11y agoWorth noting - IIRC the stream mentioned that it could do up to 16 simultaneous projections at little additional performance cost. This is important for VR...a big part of the cost, when you are dumping many vertices to the GPU, is performing a transform on each vertex (a four component vector multiplied by a 4x4 matrix) +. Even bigger cost comes from filling the resulting polygons, which if done in two passes (as is fairly common) results in something that violates cache across the tiles that get filled. So, in other words, its expensive to render something twice, as is needed for each eye in VR - from what they have shown, their new architecture largely reduces this problem. + This is a "small" part of the cost, but doing 5m polygons at 60 fps can result in about 30 GFLOPS of compute for that single matrix operation (in reality, there are many vertex operations and often many more fragment operations).
- paulmd 11y agoI was thinking about this earlier - the transition from a warp of 32 to a warp of 64 that Pascal supposedly made sounds exactly like how you would accelerate multiple projections (by at least a factor of 4). edit: apparently Pascal still has a warp-size of 32.
- pandaman 11y agoI am not sure I follow, how does processing 64 vertices instead of 32 at once accelerates anything, provided the total number of ALUs is the same?
- paulmd 11y agoA major concept in GPGPU programming is "warp coalescing". Threads are executed an entire warp at a time (32 or 64 threads). All threads execute all paths though the code block - eg if ANY thread executes an if-statement, ALL threads execute an if-statement. The threads where the if-statement is false will execute NOP instructions until the combined control flow resumes. This formula is followed recursively if applicable (this is why "warp divergence/branch divergence" absolutely murders performance on GPUs). When threads execute a memory load/store, they do so as a bank. The warp controller is designed to combine these requests if at all possible. If 32 threads all issue a request for 32 sequential blocks, it will combine them into 1 request for 32 blocks. However, it cannot do anything if the request isn't either contiguous (a sequential block of the warp-size) or strided (a block where thread N wants index X+0, N+1 wants thread X+0, X+2N, etc). In other words - it doesn't have to be contiguous, but it does have to be uniform. The resulting memory access will be broadcast to all units within the warp, and this is a huge factor in accelerating compute loads. Having a warp-size of 64 hugely accelerates certain patterns of math, particularly wide linear algebra. edit: apparently Pascal still has a warp-size of 32.
- valine 11y agoI'm hopeful this will provide a significant speed up for my 3D modeling / rendering. The number of cuda cores is only slightly higher than the 780. I'll definitely wait for more benchmarks.
- drewg123 11y agoDoes anybody know what kind of performance a modern Nvidia card like this can provide for offloading SSL ciphers (aes gcm 128 or aes gcm 256)?
- robert_foss 11y agoThere are data-dependencies in most AES modes (except ecb) which prevent parallelization. If you however run 2k separate AES encryption streams you could expect a nice performance increase. But for a single stream there is little performance to be had.
- drewg123 11y agoWe run tens of thousands of streams in parallel.. So that's not a problem. :) I'm just realizing that GPUs could be a viable alternative to specialized (eg, expensive) encryption offload engines or very high end (eg, expensive) v4 Xeons with many, many cores. However, it is rather hard to find data on the bandwidth at which GPUs can process a given cipher. I'm just now starting to look into this, so I could very well be mis-understanding something,
- paulmd 11y agoThroughput 100% depends on how hard they need to hit memory. GPUs love stuff that they can do entirely within registers. Having to hit (the limited quantity of) shared memory slows things down much more. Inefficient/non-coaslesced use of shared memory or global memory too often can trash performance. Hitting host/CPU memory in any non-trivial amount usually dooms a program. With each step you not just cut down your bandwidth but also you increase your latency and that has a huge impact.
- serialx 11y agoGuys have a look at SSLShader[1] [1]: http://shader.kaist.edu/sslshader/ http://shader.kaist.edu/sslshader/
- mioelnir 11y agoTowards the end of the article in the table overview, they list a `NVIDIA GP100` model with a memory bus width of 4096 bit. It is still shared memory, but considering bcrypt only requires a 4k memory working set, that now fits into 8 cycles instead of the 128 of 256 bit bus architectures... Am I wrong to think this card could really shake bcrypt GPU cracking up?
- ChuckMcM 11y agoThis has a similar leap to the one I felt when the 3Dfx Voodoo 2 SLI came out. The possibilities seem pretty amazing. I'm interested to know how quickly I can plug in a machine learning toolkit, it was bit finicky to get up and running on a box with a couple of 580GTs in it but that might just be because it was an older board.
- agumonkey 11y agoNot long ago I found this 2009 project https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fastra_II https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fastra_II built to give a 'desktop' cluster class performance based on GPUs. I wonder how it would fare against a 1080.
- Sanddancer 11y agoOn paper, the Fastra II would still be a fair bit faster, and would have more RAM. However. in a standoff, I'd put my money on the 1080 simply because of the overhead of wrangling all those GPUs to work together.
- cheapsteak 11y agoCould someone clarify if they meant that one 1080 is faster than two 980s in SLI? Or did they mean two 1080s were faster than two 980s?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- gnoway 11y agoHe meant one 1080 is faster than two 980s in SLI, but that seems pretty hard to believe; we're going to need to wait for some 3rd party reviews.
- mkhalil 11y agoI might believe 980s but not 980tis. That would be a feat
- abtinf 11y agoFrom the article: > The performance of NVIDIA’s GeForce GTX 1080 is just off the charts. NVIDIA’s CEO, Jen-Hsun, mentioned at the announcement that the GeForce GTX 1080 is not only faster than one GeForce GTX 980 but it crushes two 980s in SLI setup.
- kayoone 11y ago1080 should be a bit faster than a single 980Ti or as fast as an overclocked 980Ti which would put it pretty much at 980 SLI performance.
- egeozcan 11y ago> a bit faster than a single 980Ti From the article, I got the impression that the difference was like night and day. I wonder when we will be getting some early real-world benchmarks.
- tjohns 11y agoAll the benchmarks I can find are comparing this against the GTX 980. I'm curious how it compares to a 980 Ti.
- jon_richards 11y agoI've always been amazed by this chart http://www.videocardbenchmark.net/high_end_gpus.html http://www.videocardbenchmark.net/high_end_gpus.html I'm sure some of those expensive cards have extra features, but the pricing differences are still crazy.
- TylerE 11y agoA big part of what you're paying for with the workstation-grade cards (EG Quadro/FirePro) is certification. If you're using many "serious" applications like 3D CAD, you must be using a certified (e.g. not consumer grade) card to be fully supported. They run fine on the consumer cards - but don't expect support.
- hengheng 11y agoAnd as it happens, the companies that specialize in cad support will use every opportunity to shove these overpriced cards down your throat. As far as I've understood their business model, they earn almost nothing from selling licenses, so they live on their maintenance contracts and selling Quadro/Fire cards. Meanwhile we have no problems with an office running on 950Ms and 780/980 GTXes, except for some weird driver bugs that only occur on the single Quadro machine that we keep for reference.
- yohui 11y agoNo artificial benchmark is perfect, but if I had to pick one I'd prefer 3DMark from Futuremark: https://www.futuremark.com/hardware/gpu https://www.futuremark.com/hardware/gpu AFAICT, PassMark's GPU benchmarks are most often used simply because it's usually the first Google result for "video card benchmark".
- 11y ago
- voltagex_ 11y agoI wonder what the idle power usage of one of these would be? I wish my motherboard allowed me to turn off the dedicated card and fall back to the Intel chipset when I didn't need the performance.
- tjohns 11y agoFrom the slides in Nvidia's presentation, it looks like the max power consumption is about 180 W. That puts it squarely between the GTX 980 (165 W) and the GTX 980 Ti (250 W). Idle power consumption is an order of magnitude less. For the 980 Ti, you're looking at about 10 W of power consumption while running outside of a gaming application. Maybe 40 W if you're doing something intensive. [1] [1]: http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/nvidia-geforce-gtx-980-ti,4164-7.html http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/nvidia-geforce-gtx-980-t...
- tgb 11y agoMy laptop does that, but it's frequently a pain. Pull up a demo of OpenGL ES stuff on Chrome and it won't switch to to the dedicated card, even if I ask it to since Chrome 'isn't a graphics application'. Plus Linux drivers for it are hit-or-miss (it's improved since launch). Still a good idea though and it keeps the fan from running much of the time.
- kayoone 11y agoI am just curious (and a total machine learning novice). If you were to experiment with ML, what are the benefits to getting a fast consumer card like this or use something like AWS GPU instances (or some other cloud provider) ? Or phrased differently: When does it make sense to move from a local GPU to the Cloud and vice versa ?
- marmaduke 11y agoAWS would make sense if you don't yet know if your ML algo scales well on a GPU: you can try the hardware without losing much money. Consumer cards are a good deal if you know your algo works well on GPUs in single (32-bit) floating point and you don't mind dicking around with hardware configurations to save money.
- nightski 11y agoI'm a relative novice also, but we have run an EC2 8 way GPU instance. Basically the GPUs are a bit slower and they only have 4 GB of ram. Also getting everything set up and uploading a data set is tedious. Costs weren't too bad. I could see AWS being used for training smaller problems and learning. If you have a serious project it probably won't fit the bill.
- frozenport 11y agoImage analysis is cumbersome on the cloud, copying data back and forth gets tedious really quick. I would use the cloud only when I was confident as what I was doing.
- mtw 11y agoThe AWS Linux GPU instances only have 4GB of memory which means processing can be slow (memory swaps) if your datasets is large. Generally, it makes sense to have a local GPU to try out models, and move to the cloud for large scale computing, once you have a better idea of the model.
- verbify 11y agoIt's about how much machine learning you're currently doing and how much you expect to spend. E.g. if you play around for a little bit, you could end up spending $50 on the cloud. By contrast, a card will set you back $350+. If you're doing lots of machine learning, the cloud will quickly rack up. There's other factors. E.g. the cloud's performance can vary depending on the time of day (and whose using the application). Don't buy a graphics card unless you're certain you're going to do lots of ML. Or buy one if you think that'll motivate you to do justify the purchase by doing lots of ML.
- marmaduke 11y agoThe lower TDP is just as significant as speed. I've got a pair of GTX 480 that I can use to heat my office with a light workload. How many 1080s could run in a single workstation?
- chx 11y agoHaswell-E chips have 40 PCIe Lanes. If you give 8 to each then 4 is a go although cooling that will be fun. Now that already exceeds the ATX 7 slots but many cases (especially those that offer SSI EEB compatibility) offers 8 slots. Four such GPUs, a Haswell-E, the motherboard -- it'd be challenging to assemble this below $3K but I think $4k is a reasonable target. Going beyond that is not impossible but requires server grade hardware. For example, the Dell R920/R930 has 10 PCIe slots so does the Supermicro SuperServer 5086B. The barebone for the latter is above $8K. You need to buy Xeon E7 chips for these and those will cost you more than a pretty penny. I do not think $20K is unreasonable to target. Not enough? A single SGI UV 300 chassis (5U) provides 4 Xeon E7 processors, up to 96 DIMMs, and 12 PCIe slots. You can stuff 8 Xeon E7 CPUs into the new HP Integrity MC990 X and have 20 (!) PCIe slots. How much these cost? An arm and two legs. I can't possibly imagine how such a single workstation would be worth it instead of a multitude of cheaper workstations with with just 4 GPUs (you'd likely end up with a magnitude more GPUs in this case -- E7 CPUs and their base systems are hideously expensive) but to each their own.
- marmaduke 11y agoWow thanks for the detailed response on hardware. I was aware of the Supermicro beast. Setting aside this 1080, just on per CUDA core prices, cheaper workstations with pairs of 970s are much better deals, because everything gets cheaper, not just the GPUs.
- chx 11y agoI left out something: the Supermicro 6037R-TXRF Server is dual socket and has ten slots and since it's an older dual socket even with CPUs and RAM it can be had for <$3K so together with five GPUs you can have it for less than $6K. It's a whole another question whether almost double the price worths adding another GPU (no).
- mrb 11y agoNote that in terms of pure compute performance the new 16nm Nvidia GTX 1080 (2560 shaders at up to 1733 MHz = 8873 SP GFLOPS) barely equals the performance of the previous-generation 28nm AMD Fury X (4096 shaders at up to 1050 MHz = 8602 SP GFLOPS). Of course the 16nm chip does so at a significantly lower TDP (180 Watt) than the 28nm chip (275 Watt), so it will be interesting to see what Nvidia can achieve at a higher thermal/power envelope with a more high-end card... I am waiting impatiently to see how AMD's upcoming 14nm/16nm Polaris chips will fare, but from the looks of it it seems like Polaris will beat Nvidia in terms of GFLOPS per Watt.
- redtuesday 11y agoYeah, it will be interesting to see how good AMD's Polaris chips will be, especially when it comes to energy efficiency. Fury was a step in the right direction (I'm wondering how much of this can be attributed to HBM's lower voltage etc.). But I'm even more interested in AMD Vega - the high end competitor to Nvidias GP 100 that is equipped with HBM2. Especially if AMD has an advantage over Nvidia when it comes to implementing HBM, since they developed it together with SK Hynx and have previous experience with Fury, or if this doesn't make a difference. Vega is also exiting because it should be released when AMD's Zen CPU's will be released, and there were rumors about a HPC Zen APU with Vega and HBM.
- yohui 11y agoBoth Vega and Zen are supposed to be due sometime next year, correct?
- redtuesday 11y agoYes, Zen for the desktop (Summit Ridge) is even listed for end of 2016 [1], followed by first Zen APU's (Raven Ridge) sometime 2017 and Vega early 2017. [2] [1] http://imgur.com/rRjKZDk http://imgur.com/rRjKZDk [2] http://i.imgur.com/lkjgayO.jpg?1 http://i.imgur.com/lkjgayO.jpg?1
- mtgx 11y agoIf we're discussing future GPUs, does anyone know what exactly AMD means by "next-gen memory" when it talks about Navi? At first I thought it means that HBM2 would be available across their whole lineup, but I think if that was the case they would've just said so. I've also read a bit about how Nvidia wanted to go with HMC (Hyper Memory Cube) instead of HBM, but it seems it's still at least twice as expensive/GB, and they needed to go with high-end GPUs that have at least 16GB. HMC is not even at 8GB yet. Intel also seems to have adopted HMC for some servers. So is the "next-gen" memory HMC, or something else? AMD is supposed to come out with it in 2018, hopefully at 10nm.
- Szpadel 11y ago> The GP104 Pascal GPU Features 2x the performance per watt of Maxwell. And > The GTX 1080 is 3x more power efficient than the Maxwell Architecture. I think that someone get carried away by imagination. I found that 980 has 4.6 TFLOPs (Single precision) And assuming that 1080 performance (9 TFLOPs) is also for single precision and new card has the same TDP, this is 1.95x increase, so it is ~2x EDIT: I found that 1080 will have 180W TDP, where 980 has 165W, so correction it will be 1.79x increase
- frik 11y agoI am waiting for the Nvidia GTX 1070, and sincerely hope NVidia doesn't fuck it up again like the GTX 970. GTX 970: It was revealed that the card was designed to access its memory as a 3.5 GB section, plus a 0.5 GB one, access to the latter being 7 times slower than the first one. -- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GeForce_900_series#False_advertisement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GeForce_900_series#False_adver...
- nness 11y agoI have a GTX 970 and have not yet noticed any issues as a result of that memory issue. Maybe I'm not pushing the card hard enough...
- frik 11y agoWeird comment. Like a grandma driving a Ferrari with a broken gearbox: "I am perfectly fine driving at moderate speed, maybe I am not pushing the car hard enough. I am perfectly fine that the mechanic deactivated the malfunctioning higher gears". You may not notice it nowadays because several games received patches and newer nVidia drivers limit the memory consumption to just below 3.5 GB. Otherwise you would experience a major slowdown. Also a major problem for CUDA.
- mynameisvlad 11y agoIf games truly don't need access to the last .5GB (and they seem to not in most cases if there's patches there) and all the parent does is game (which is what I do on my 970) then why would it even matter if the last .5GB is slow, or that the card wasn't being "pushed hard enough"? It's a gaming card, and using it for gaming seems to be working just fine, in my anecdotal experience at least. Gaming benchmarks have also been great for the card. Just because not everyone writes CUDA applications that need access to all 4GB does not mean that people are using it wrong, or that they should mind that the last .5GB is slow. If it works for others' use then that's great for them.
- ozi 11y agoI see you point, but I use a 970 and just finished Dark Souls 3 on max settings without a single hiccup. No doubt that with future games the 970 will not perform as well as it should, but I will have a different card by then. What they did is a shame and shouldn't happen again, but I haven't noticed any real-world ramifications yet.
- neverminder 11y agoWhat really blew me away is that they went straight for Displayport 1.4 (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DisplayPort#1.4 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DisplayPort#1.4) that was only announced on 1st of March 2016. DP 1.3 was approved on 15th of September 2014 and as of today there are no cards supporting it except this one (with backwards compatibility). The bad news is that there's no news about new gen displays that could take advantage of this graphic card. I'm talking about 4K 120Hz HDR (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-dynamic-range_rendering https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-dynamic-range_rendering) displays. This is a total WTF - we have a graphic card with DP 1.4 and we don't even have a single display with so much as DP 1.3...
- memonkey 11y agoWhat cable transfers 4k 120-144hz? What are the benefits of DisplayPort 1.4 over something like Dual Link DVI or the newest HDMI?
- neverminder 11y agoDisplayport 1.4 is a standard for socket and cable, so it will transfer 4K 120Hz. Advantages over other standards: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DisplayPort#Advantages_over_DVI.2C_VGA_and_FPD-Link https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DisplayPort#Advantages_over_DV... Also, another major advantage - USB Type-C compatibility (http://www.displayport.org/what-is-displayport-over-usb-c/ http://www.displayport.org/what-is-displayport-over-usb-c/)
- tronreg 11y agoWhat is the "founders edition"?
- yohui 11y agohttp://www.anandtech.com/show/10304/nvidia-announces-the-geforce-gtx-1080-1070/2 http://www.anandtech.com/show/10304/nvidia-announces-the-gef... > There will be two versions of the card, the base/MSRP card at $599, and then a more expensive Founders Edition card at $699. At the base level this is a slight price increase over the GTX 980, which launched at $549. Information on the differences between these versions is limited, but based on NVIDIA’s press release it would appear that only the Founders Edition card will ship with NVIDIA’s full reference design, cooler and all. Meanwhile the base cards will feature custom designs from NVIDIA’s partners. NVIDIA’s press release was also very careful to only attach the May 27th launch date to the Founders Edition cards.
- chronid 11y agoProbably a way to mask limited availability at launch.
- rasz_pl 11y agoit means its another paper launch by nvidia
- tormeh 11y agoI'll buy when there's Vulkan/DX12 benchmarks and real retail prices for both AMD and NVIDIA next-gen cards. Buying now seems slightly premature. But oh man am I excited!
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- rl3 11y agoI'm somewhat dismayed that the GTX 1080 has only 8GB of VRAM considering that previous generation AMD products already had 8GB, and the previous generation Titan model had 12GB—the latter of course being outperformed by the GTX 1080. Then again, rendering a demanding title at 8192x4320 on a single card and downsampling to 4k is probably wishful thinking anyways. However, it's definitely a legitimate concern for those with dual/triple/quad GPU setups rendering with non-pooled VRAM. On the bright side, 8GB should hopefully be sufficient to pull off 8k/4k supersampling[0] with less demanding titles (e.g. Cities: Skylines). Lackluster driver or title support for such stratospheric resolutions may prove to be an issue, though. It's possible Nvidia is saving the 12GB configuration for a 1080 Ti model down the road. If they release a new Titan model, I'm guessing it'll probably weigh in at 16GB. Perhaps less if those cards end up using HBM2 instead of GDDR5X. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supersampling https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supersampling
- rl3 11y agoCorrection: 7680×4320. Accidentally multiplied DCI 4K, not UHD 4K.
- mtgx 11y ago"GTX 1080" "10 Gaming Perfected" Seems like a missed marketing opportunity to make it a 10 GFLOPs card.
- Kephael 11y agoThere is likely to be a GTX 1080Ti with a significantly larger GPU (GP200) that will exceed 10 GFLOPs.
- tasnent 11y agoAny idea when it'll be released?
- mdda 11y ago(nitpick) actually 10 TFLOPs is a more appropriate target. Doesn't make sense to aim to cripple your performance by a factor of 822 for marketing reasons...
- rasz_pl 11y agoand still not fully DX 12, oh nvidia
- bpye 11y agoMaxwell currently leads when it comes to DX12 feature support (along with Skylake), see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feature_levels_in_Direct3D#Direct3D_12 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feature_levels_in_Direct3D#Dir... . I don't know what Pascal has but I doubt it'd be a regression.
- tostitos1979 11y agoI was helping a friend put together a Titan X "rig" and we realized that case space, power supply and motherboard slots were some mundane but frustrating challenges. For someone building out a new rig for personal/hobbyist work in deep learning, any recommendations? Is the best setup to get two 1080s, 16-32 GB of RAM and a 6th generation i7?
- antimora 11y agoI was just pondering about this too. I would love to get some inputs from HN.
- kmike84 11y agoI built a rig a couple days ago; it works nicely both for deep learning and for RAM and CPU-heavy tasks: http://pcpartpicker.com/p/GvTGsY http://pcpartpicker.com/p/GvTGsY - two 8 core xeons, 128GB RAM, slots for 2 GPUs for ~2000$. Currently it has gtx970; likely I'll add 1080 at some point in future. I've heard 6th gen i7 is not good for deep learning because its PCIe performance is crippled (16 PCIe lanes instead of 40 in previous generations, it should matter for dual GPU use case). Don't quote me on that ;) Used xeons 2670v1 are dirt cheap on ebay now, and they are modern enough. Single-core performance is worse than in modern desktop CPUs, but not too much, multi-core performance is great, and these xeons allow to install lots of RAM. If you don't want that much RAM then for the same price a single desktop CPU (i7 5th gen?) could work better because of a higher clock rate.
- dweekly 11y agoNeat, I hadn't heard of PCpartPicker before. The Xeon 2670 you listed for $90 goes for >$1500 on NewEgg; that is quite a retail / eBay price split! Any idea why there's such a gap?
- brynx97 11y agoI found there was a lack of supply at traditional online parts retailers for Xeon brands (consumer v enterprise processors). I picked up a Xeon 2620v3 last year at Microcenter for under $300 b/c of a sale. Also, the 2670 is older, I'd presume he picked it up second hand at that price.
- science404 11y agoNo word on double-precision performance? Could replace the Titan Z and Titan (black) as a good CUDA-application card..
- programmer_dude 11y agoDP will be better than maxwell cards but you need to wait and see if it can beat kepler (IMO it will).
- p0nce 11y agoGeForce cards have a driver with reduced pinned memory performance...
- amelius 11y agoWhy are these coprocessors still positioned as graphics cards?
- ChrisLTD 11y agoBecause consumers buy them for video games.
- amelius 11y agoBut you can perceive this as: if from a business (money) perspective it becomes interesting to lock down these graphics cards to specific games, then the computational folks lose their processing power. They were not a market in the first place (relatively speaking).
- romanovcode 11y agoYou can calculate many small things in parallel on GPU way-way faster then on CPU.
- broodbucket 11y agoBecause their primary purpose is for gaming. You can use these for CUDA, but you can't use server GPUs for gaming.
- rl3 11y agoBecause they have display output.
- interdrift 11y agoThis will be pretty nice for VR cause it will push older generation cards back in price
- onli 11y agoThis article buys in in the hype. It reads like they just copied statements of the press release. The article on anandtech[0] is a lot better. Also, do not forget that benchmarks made by Nvidia mean nothing. How fast the cards really are will only be clear if independent people do real benchmarks. That's true for games, but it will also be true for all the speculation found here over the ML performance. [0] http://anandtech.com/show/10304/nvidia-announces-the-geforce-gtx-1080-1070 http://anandtech.com/show/10304/nvidia-announces-the-geforce...
- ultramancool 11y agoAnandtech also has extremely good benchmarks, if you're ever looking to optimize bang for your buck when it comes to GPUs they have an excellent comparison tool.
- onli 11y agoI know, I use them in my hardware recommender ;) They also are very accessible under http://anandtech.com/bench/GPU15/1248 http://anandtech.com/bench/GPU15/1248, it is a nice tool.
- varelse 11y agoFair enough, but when neither Intel nor AMD is bothering to put out competitive software/hardware solutions for deep learning, which is apparently going to be a ~$40B market by 2020, I predict continued dominance here. That said, since AMD is getting beaten by a factor of 2-3 in performance while Intel's Accelerator/FPGA solutions are getting beaten by a factor of 5-10, AMD has a real opportunity to be the competitor to NVIDIA here. And despite questions about it, GTX 1080 will be a fine deep learning board, especially if the framework engineers get off their lazy butts and implement Alex Krizhevsky's one weird trick algorithm, an approach which allows an 8-GPU Big Sur with 12.5GB/s P2P bandwidth to go toe to toe with an 8-GPU DGX-1 on training AlexNet. http://arxiv.org/abs/1404.5997 http://arxiv.org/abs/1404.5997
- nl 11y agoPretty sure most frameworks support "one weird trick" style learning. Eg Caffe: https://github.com/BVLC/caffe/blob/master/docs/multigpu.md https://github.com/BVLC/caffe/blob/master/docs/multigpu.md
- lovedj 11y agoToo expensive.
- partiallypro 11y agoI'm more interested on the impact it will have on the 10 series as a whole. I literally just bought a 950, now I'm wondering if the 1050 will be priced just as reasonably and offer big performance gains. Also, what is the time table for the rest of the 10 series?
- touristtam 11y agoBased on the previous gens (since 400 series) you can expect about 20-25 % gain from one generation to the next. Traditionally the release have been: April to June: paper release (reads very limited supply of the top of the range). July to October: x70/x60 range (which are the main gaming GPU). November-December: rest of the range released with ample supply for the end of the year festive season. January to March: annoncement of the next generation. Rinse and repeat.
- kosmic_k 11y agoDoes anyone know why video cards have stayed on a 28nm process for so long? It's appears that a significant factor in this incredible leap of performance is the process change, but I'm puzzled as to why 22nm was skipped.
- msbarnett 11y agoTSMC doesn't have a 22nm process -- they offer a 20nm process instead, but it was heavily delayed, had huge yield issues, and most of its production capability was double-booked with Apple, all of which meant it wasn't feasible to use in time for Nvidia's previous generation (Maxwell) launch. Maxwell had been planned as 20nm, but when TSMC couldn't solve their process issues the first Maxwell was taped out at 28nm (GM107 aka the GeForce 750), while they waited on the rest of lineup. 6 months later, with TSMC still having issues at 20nm, the GM204(GeForce 980/970) was launched at 28nm. 16nm FinFET wasn't subject to massive delays (it launched early, in fact), and seems to have better yields than 20nm early on, so Pascal skipped right down to it.
- kosmic_k 11y agoThanks for the explanation! I haven't been following fab process news for some time so I've been very much out of the loop.