6 ms·
Jobs told the world he would do this at the 2007 MacWorld keynote introducing the iPhone: "We filed for over 200 patents for all the inventions in iPhone and w
by jimbokun 17y ago
Jobs told the world he would do this at the 2007 MacWorld keynote introducing the iPhone:
"We filed for over 200 patents for all the inventions in iPhone and we intend to protect them."
http://www.engadget.com/2007/01/09/live-from-macworld-2007-steve-jobs-keynote/ http://www.engadget.com/2007/01/09/live-from-macworld-2007-s...
- swilliams 17y agoTrue, but my question is, why not go after HTC et al sooner? There were iPhone knockoffs within months of its announcement that could have been sued. And why sue HTC, and not Google or Motorola or Palm?
- zefhous 17y agoMaybe they want to scare hardware makers out of using Android.
- frederickcook 17y ago"True, but my question is, why not go after HTC et al sooner?" Nobody sues if they can avoid it. Lawsuits are extremely expensive, and companies will exhaust all other options first. The lawsuit means Apple demanded more than HTC was willing to pay, and decided they would fair better in court. Also, "iPhone knockoffs" doesn't necessarily mean patent infringements. Without doing in-depth research into the specific claims infringed, you can't say for sure whether any infringement took place. Patents and patent law are incredibly complicated. There is no simple answer to _why_.
- boucher 17y agoWhile that may be logical, it may not be true in this instance. Apple has a track record of filing lawsuits it knows it almost certainly won't win. I don't think they're afraid of losing money on a lawsuit.
- GHFigs 17y agoApple has a track record of filing lawsuits it knows it almost certainly won't win. Examples?
- vetinari 17y agoWell, starting with the famous UI lawsuit... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Computer,_Inc._v._Microsoft_Corporation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Computer,_Inc._v._Microso...
- GHFigs 17y agoThat's an example where they didn't win, but I know of no reason to think that they knew they certainly wouldn't. It was definitely not obvious at the time that copyright could not apply to interfaces as a whole, and Microsoft's prior consent to a licensing arrangement suggests that both parties had at one time considered it a real possibility. I'm not saying Apple should have won or that that case isn't in some ways relevant--only that it wasn't certain that they would lose.
- jsz0 17y agoBait & switch. Apple wanted these technologies to be adopted and define what a modern SmartPhone is. Now that it's established it's very unlikely HTC or anyone else will ditch these technologies. Easier to just pay Apple some royalties. Even if they do design around Apple patents there are millions of these phones out there already to ensure a good settlement for Apple and it will put their competition at a disadvantage. This is of course assuming Apple wins. HTC was probably a target due to their relationship with Google and strong support of Android. HTC relies on Android for the bulk of their handsets these days so they might be more likely to reach a deal with Apple. Moto only has a couple Android handsets and likely has their own patent war chest to fight back with. Palm isn't selling enough handsets to be a good target at this point. They'll probably fall into line if HTC loses. (or they'll be out of business)
- megaduck 17y agoGoogle, Motorola, and Palm all have large patent portfolios to defend themselves with. Motorola literally invented the cell phone. Palm has a ton of important patents from the Treo days. Google has been gearing up for fights with the likes of Microsoft and Amazon. For example, Engadget ran an analysis on Palm vs. Apple a while ago. They found that both companies infringed heavily on each other's patents, for things from list scrolling to three-way calling. Starting that particular food-fight would probably end badly for both companies. HTC is a much softer target. HTC is relatively new in the business, with a smaller patent portfolio. They're also a foreign corporation, which may give Apple some home advantage in the courtroom. At its core, this is all about Google. Every single Google developer phone has been HTC, as well as the G1 and Nexus One. If Apple prevails, that would be a pretty big blow to Google just as Android is beginning to spread its wings.
- jonknee 17y agoHTC is not new to the business, Apple is new to the business. HTC has been around since before the iMac.
- megaduck 17y agoHTC was founded in 1997, and was strictly an ODM for the first few years. They're extremely new in comparison to a company like Motorola. Not all of the complaints are cellphone specific. Some of the patents in the filings are from the NeXT days, long before HTC was around.
- ryanhuff 17y agoThe timing is a strategic move by Apple. If they went after HTC early, there would have been little damage to them (and Google), and given them time to adjust their strategy. Now, both parties are "all-in", and by attacking now, Apple can hurt both companies badly, and put the competition back 2-3 years.
- itistoday 17y agoI fail to see how Apple stating their intent to be an asshole makes them any less of an asshole. Patents are, in the words of @lapcat: anti-competition, anti-free market, anti-consumer. First to market is already a huge competitive advantage. Patents are a huge part of the reason you're paying so much for health insurance right now. They play a large role in stifling innovation. Imagine you have a great idea that hasn't been done before, but you suddenly discover parts of it have been patented. The patenter isn't doing shit with the idea, yet they have a 20-year monopoly on it. Oh, and they also happen to be a huge monolithic organization with thousands of employees worldwide that is patenting thousands of ideas every year, yet actually implementing only a small fraction of those ideas. Don't think this happens? You don't know much about patents then. The patent system is one of the best examples of an idea backfiring on itself that I know of. It was supposed to protect the guy toiling in his garage on the next best thing (read: Apple in its infancy), but today it's doing the exact opposite while screwing consumers over to boot.
- grellas 17y agoI can remember once representing the principal architect of the ScriptX language used at Kaleida Labs (a 1992 joint venture between Apple and IBM) and, when going for meetings at Kaleida, constantly being made aware of the role within the company of a team whose sole job was, day in and day out, to scour everything that was being done for patentability. Given such a focus, you can be assured that countless patents were filed from that effort, not so much because they were useful as because this helped build an IP arsenal to use against competitors. Intel used patents in this way for years to intimidate and harass potential competitors in the desktop platform that it effectively monopolized for years. Apple is doing the same thing now with respect to its platform. What amazes me is not that Apple is being a jerk about this but that so many believed it would be otherwise. While Apple may in many ways be a rebel company (or at least has cultivated its image this way), when it comes to IP protections, it plays strictly by the standard script.
- sutro 17y agoI wouldn't call it the standard script. Most tech companies actually do show restraint and use patents for defensive purposes only. In fact I heard a heart-warming story at lunch today about how one of the top guys at a large well-known software company recently shut down an internal proposal to start using its IP more offensively. This is, however, the standard script for Apple, originator of the long, infamous, ultimately unsuccessful attempt to sue Microsoft for "look and feel" infringements. For a company that stole so much of its own core technology in the early days from Xerox, Apple has never been shy about making overly broad IP ownership claims. Their legal department has historically been one of the most aggressive and overreaching in the industry. I agree with you that it is surprising that so many people are only now seeing Apple in this light.