6 ms·
People commenting here need to work on their reading comprehension. Apple is not dropping support for IPv4. They are simply requiring that all apps also support
by chatmasta 11y ago
People commenting here need to work on their reading comprehension. Apple is not dropping support for IPv4. They are simply requiring that all apps also support IPv6. The headline is confusing because of "only." But it's way different than if it read "iOS supporting only IPv6" as some comments seem to be implying. The change is that when a network is IPv6 only, apps must function properly, whereas previously Apple tolerated apps that only worked on IPv4. A better headline might be "Apple bans apps that only support IPv4." (*Edited, guess it's not so easy to write the headline. :) )
- Aloha 11y agoYou hit the nail on the head - and as someone who works in the telecom industry (and an early advocate of IPv6) I'm pleased to see it.
- jdeibele 11y agoOr "Apple bans apps that support only IPv4." "Apple bans apps that support IPv4 only." could be interpreted as banning apps that support IPv4. Although that'd be reaching. Want to hear my rant about "No smoking allowed" when it should be "Smoking not allowed"?
- Dylan16807 11y agoI don't see how you could parse the smoking message the wrong way. "Non-smoking allowed" would be the wrong message. With "No smoking allowed", can you explain the problem?
- prdonahue 11y agoHe's trying to imply that one would actually read this as "no smoking [IS] allowed".
- Dylan16807 11y ago"No smoking is allowed." is the correct message.
- lstamour 11y agoBut "smoking isn't allowed" or "smoking is prohibited" is a clearer way of putting it...
- sosborn 11y agoYou are allowed to be "no smoking." It doesn't say that you can't smoke, which is the only possible interpretation of the second option.
- Dylan16807 11y agoYou cannot be "no smoking". You can be "not smoking". You can be "non-smoking". "no smoking" is not an adjective.
- paulddraper 11y agoYou no smokey!
- mistersquid 11y agoDidn't Smokey say "Only you…"? [0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Smokey3.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Smokey3.jpg
- mistersquid 11y ago"No smoking" is a gerundive phrase which serves as the sentence's subject, with the copulative verb "is" implied: "No smoking [is] allowed". Considered differently, the sentence is not in the imperative mood with an implied subject. The sentence is in the declarative mood with an implied verb. The possible misunderstanding is that this declarative sentence merely identifies one action (of many) which is allowed, "no smoking", which does not necessarily prohibit other activities including "smoking", "singing", "no singing", "dancing", etc. EDIT: grammar and readability
- Dylan16807 11y agoI strongly disagree. "not smoking" is an action. "no smoking" is not an action. You cannot parse the sentence as allowing a specific action without replacing the word "no" with something else. Edit: Also, I treat the sentence as being declarative with an implied 'is' even when interpreting it correctly.
- headShrinker 11y ago"No smoking is allowed." (!smoking == true) It's short hand. > "Apple bans apps that support IPv4 only." could be interpreted as banning apps that support IPv4. the word 'only' is quite important in english. If an app supports IPv4 they will not be banned. That's not what we are measuring here. If they "don't" support IPv6, they will be banned.
- AckSyn 11y agoNo one learns proper contextual clues in written media OR grammar usage anymore. Christ, it was bad when I started university in the late 90s and it's only gotten worse! Fuck common usage. Ignorant fools drag everyone down.
- copperx 11y ago"Apple bans apps that don't support IPv6". It isn't that hard.
- Negative1 11y agoThat's incorrect. Check out figure 10-3 here: http://j.mp/1NkSBaF http://j.mp/1NkSBaF If your App does not support IPv6 on the official rollout then you will no longer have network connectivity. If you use native platform functions you're fine. If you use unix/bsd sockets, you're in trouble. From the backend perspective however, IPv4 will be allowed... for now. Basically what happens is the client is expected to send an IPv6 packet to the phone carrier which then will translate it to IPv4 if needed. Since many big cloud providers (like Amazon) still don't support a proper IPv6 solution this approach will likely be around for quite some time.
- eloy 11y agoOut of curiosity, why would anyone use Unix or BSD sockets on iOS if Apple provides way better APIs?
- mosburger 11y agoMaybe familiarity? Porting existing UNIX code to iOS (seems like that'd be pretty rare)?
- eloy 11y agoHmm, good point. I guess that most of the apps that use BSD/Unix sockets are libraries then.
- Negative1 11y agoThink game engines or legacy C++ projects there were ported to the platform and already have their own network implementation.
- chatmasta 11y agoOh I see. So Apple is moving all its local sockets to IPv6 format? That's what you mean by "no longer have network connectivity?" You seem to be implying that every IPv4 packet will go through a carrier NAT64... but what if my ISP does not use NAT64? Will my iPhone send a regular IPv4 request, or will it prefix IPv6?