15 ms·
Yes, All DRM
- Aelinsaar 11y agoThe only people winning in this equation are the people making and selling DRM products to suckers, who then inflict it (mostly) on their honest customers.
- kefka 11y agoWell, us pirates also "win". Buying DRMed software is a fool's errand. If I want to keep it without being chained to servers that will go away, I break the law. See https://xkcd.com/488/ https://xkcd.com/488/ : Piracy is the correct answer for DRM works. Better yet, purchase non-DRM works. EDIT: How odd. High karma on al these posts (and the last few days), and still rate-limited. Perhaps my popular opinions are a bit too ... controversial, especially with SaaS and API opinions?
- erelde 11y agoIn 50 years the whole society will have realised the stupidity of DRMs in the early days of the Internet. What we "need" to show how bad DRM are is the bankruptcy of something like Amazon or even Google, and look at the impact that will make if all of those servers were wiped.
- BostonEnginerd 11y agoThis has already sort of happened. We just have short memories. 1) Microsoft kills MSN Music in 2008, removing access from users who purchased albums. http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2008/04/drm-sucks-redux-microsoft-to-nuke-msn-music-drm-keys/ http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2008/04/drm-su... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_PlaysForSure https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_PlaysForSure 2) Amazon removes access to purchased Disney streaming videos for Christmas season: https://torrentfreak.com/amazon-pulls-access-to-purchased-christmas-videos-during-christmas-131216/ https://torrentfreak.com/amazon-pulls-access-to-purchased-ch... https://boingboing.net/2013/12/15/amazon-takes-away-access-to-pu.html https://boingboing.net/2013/12/15/amazon-takes-away-access-t... The industry has moved to more of a subscription model which helps soften the blow when something disappears.
- erelde 11y agoYes, but I meant something like a real disaster like if Google stopped working, at all, all wiped, search algorithms, indexes, APIs, libraries, YouTube (what a sh*tshow that one would be, very large, very front facing). All because we allowed something this big to own so much of our life and still be private, hidden. Suddenly Europe doesn't have a web search engine (it was 90% of europeans who use Google, isn't it?). Suddenly websites all over the world stop working because they used some CDN. I was too young when people really talked and dreamt about everyone owning his own server, hostname. But I do believe in self-reliance, and DRMs are one of the blocks on the road to that goal. People shouldn't have to rely on Amazon's existence to be able to read the copy of Dickens they bought from Amazon. Because in 50 years, I'll still be alive, but there's a high chance Amazon won't, because most companies don't last 70 years. And as all things eventually end, we have to know and anticipate that fact. DRMs think about the very short term, while we should already be thinking about the long term.
- muddi900 11y agoIn 50 years the idea of ownership by individuals will be dead. Trans-genic organism have IP protects, tractors too. The whole of Agricultural production will pretty much become a licensing business. The same will happen to large-scale mass manufacturing plants, small scale manufacturing, Automotive, logistics and communication. If this was, say, Cambodia, they would have been crushed under the weight of competing markets, but we have international trade agreements, essentially allowing certain American laws to apply internationally and the clout to enforce them.
- MereInterest 11y agoWe already have this, just from (effectively) infinite copyright. DRM is just going to make it worse. http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2013/07/the-hole-in-our-collective-memory-how-copyright-made-mid-century-books-vanish/278209/ http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2013/07/the-ho...
- Aelinsaar 11y agoI agree, but lets be fair, pirates are less "winners" in this equation than simply "Unfazed by" the situation in general.
- kefka 11y agoNot really. I'm a pirate. I have little compunctions about downloading whatever-have-you. Part is convenience, part is I've been burned before, part is I want to spend money on tangibles, part is literally just 'fuck you drm'. Is it wrong? Well, it's certainly a tort. I'm not doing it for some morally superior good. I'm doing it for myself and my family. We can curl in bed, and watch XYZ movie. And if it stinks, it gets the delete. I don't have to deal with any number of factors from screaming kids to DRM; I just double-click and it plays in VLC. I was watching MASH on netflix..... until they removed it from the live collections, 8th season in. Am I buying it? Nope. Downloading. If anything, the biggest draw to me is open source stuffs. I can get and give it, and use it for my files. There's no reason for lock-in, so they play nice. Edit: And yes, I do pay for Netflix. Bang for the buck, it ~is~ easier than finding links online. Even if I can't store and download locally, it's great for watching filler fluff I don't want a copy of. Media I want to have, I just download anyways.
- x1798DE 11y agoI think the point is that you don't actually benefit from DRM, you just aren't adversely affected by it. The only benefit to DRM for pirates is that it makes more people interested in consuming pirated works, and to the extent that there are network effects that's a benefit, but I suspect the number people turning to piracy because they can't get non DRMed content is minimal.
- crdb 11y ago> If I want to keep it without being chained to servers that will go away, I break the law. I was thinking of that today as I had to download (for the 6th time since I started) a Kindle book I'm reading to my Android. I'm another 1-2 downloads away from going on a torrent site and grabbing a DRM free copy that will actually stay on my local storage, be read on an app that does not take 30 seconds to boot, and not require large downloads with every open. The natural evolution of that is to buy a copy on Amazon to support the author and industry, then download a free copy somewhere so you can actually read it in peace.
- vidarh 11y agoIt's a bit painful, but set up Calibre with the right plugins and you can strip the DRM easily enough. It's the only thing that keeps me buying Kindle books - the DRM goes of a few minutes after I've bought it. The moment I meet resistance in doing so will be the moment I stop buying stuff at the Kindle store.
- dublinben 11y agoIf you are opposed to DRM, please do not encourage companies like Amazon by purchasing their DRM products. If you want to pay for the book, buy the paperback and then download a pirated copy.
- vidarh 11y agoI agree with you in principle. In practice, I've decided that as long as they don't escalate and make the current solutions more difficult I'll tolerate the current situation but buy elsewhere whenever I have alternatives (e.g. I have spent more on books at O'Reilly than Amazon over the last few years lately explicitly because of O'Reilly's DRM policy). Meanwhile, DRM is the reason I've only ever bought one Audible audio book, and buy DVDs rather than "buy" downloadable video, for example. DVDs have the same consideration for me: As long as the protection is mostly ineffective and everyone knows it is mostly ineffective, they can continue to pretend to protect them all they way.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Johnny_Brahms 11y agoI have always said that DRM protection should automatically void all copyright protection. If you make it impossible for your work to enter public domain, you should not have the same protection as works that will.
- neikos 11y agoThat's an interesting thought.
- Johnny_Brahms 11y agoHeck: Let's change copyright while we are at it. I have never heard any good arguments why copyright should be longer than 20 years. That is of course never going to happen, but I have a compromise: 20 years exclusive rights. After that: 50 years commercial rights + dual license as CC-BY-NC-SA. That way content creators can earn money by licensing/selling their work for commercial use, and the public can use it non-commercially.
- chris11 11y agoI'm also bothered by the fact that most copyright extensions are retroactive. If something is going to lose its copyright protection in a few years, that work should lose it even if copywright protection is extended.
- Klathmon 11y agoThat's what bothers me the most. If the purpose of copyright is to incentivize new creation, applying changes to it retroactively only serves to hurt the public.
- tagrun 11y agoExtension of copyright law been "sponsored" by MPAA and corporations. So better yet, they should make lobbying illegal again, and treat it as a form of bribe.
- 11y ago
- jordigh 11y agoBtw, yesterday was international day against DRM. Maybe if we make more noise about this, next year it will get more attention: https://www.defectivebydesign.org/ https://www.defectivebydesign.org/ http://www.defectivebydesign.org/dayagainstdrm/2016 http://www.defectivebydesign.org/dayagainstdrm/2016
- dfrey 11y agoEvery day is "day against DRM" for me.
- fredley 11y ago> The shift in downloadable music from proprietary and locked formats to mp3s that play anywhere The MP3 codec is not free, yet (in the US, until 2018)
- Vespasian 11y agoIn the rest of the world it is (and even in the us, 2018 is not so far out), so this statement is mostly true. ;)
- RobAley 11y agoI think the important fact there is that the music provider is independent of the "format provider". I.e. I can download an MP3 from itunes, and Apple has no control over which MP3 compatible device I move it to or play it on (or indeed that I even can move it beyond the "purchasing" device). Granted (legally) not all devices I want to play it on may be MP3 compatible when they technically could, but that restriction isn't Apples to (directly!) control. In the rest of the world without silly software patents, it is free!
- tomp 11y agoRight, but the music within mp3 is free (or, at least, freely accessible).
- canistr 11y agoI don't know if I am wholly against DRM because I do like streaming services like Spotify for their convenience. I'm just tired of pirating things. And I do make money as a developer as a result of protected APIs/content. Is this hypocritical?
- kefka 11y agoYes, it is. Spotify is saying "You may download this, but this program under someone else's control will forcefully delete this data from your machine" My machine is my own. If I wish to grant other users access to the machine or data on it, cool. That's my choice. If I buy a program to do a task, good. When your program starts taking orders from "nameless faceless someone else", we have problems. Locked in APIs are just as much as a scourge. When you use them, you're locking yourself into an ecosystem that will go away. It's not a matter of if, but when. I'm less hesitant when these APIs used are standards compliant (where I can go 'down the street' and plug in their credential info)... But that's not where money is. Lockin is where the money is. And I'll fight it tooth and nail. I already am doing the fight against bad IoT.
- caractacus 11y ago> My machine is my own. If I wish to grant other users access to the machine or data on it, cool. That's my choice. If I buy a program to do a task, good. When your program starts taking orders from "nameless faceless someone else", we have problems. And the content you are streaming through 'nameless faceless someone else' is not your own. You pay to get access to it. Are you saying that because you install a program on your machine, you should have complete control over what it can and can't do to the content it provides?
- kefka 11y ago> And the content you are streaming through 'nameless faceless someone else' is not your own. You pay to get access to it. Are you saying that because you install a program on your machine, you should have complete control over what it can and can't do to the content it provides? By hook or by crook, yes. I've admitted that I'm a pirate. Look at my comments and you'll find it. If it's convenient enough I'll buy. I'm not under spending money on media. And I do have complete control what the program can and cannot do. It's called a debugger. The encrypted files and keys are right there. It's nothing more than a bad obfuscation technique.
- tacos 11y agoThere remain significant markets where DRM improves ROI. There are countless others where it doesn't and the people involved are too stupid to see the writing on the wall. Regardless of the end game, the people playing the DRM game are making more money in a day than the EFF raises in a year.
- russdill 11y agoEverytime I see a commercial for a content provider about how they amazing provide the ability to play back content on multiple devices timeshifted, I die a little inside. I think some of them actually refer to themselves as superheros for providing this capability.
- pavel_lishin 11y ago> the ability to play back content on multiple devices timeshifted I don't think I've seen these commercials, because I'm not sure what this means.
- russdill 11y agoSorry, "You can watch your favorite show anytime you want on a number of different devices."
- strictnein 11y agoSteam, Netflix, Spotify, etc show that DRM can work properly when users are given the easy access to the media/content, and they've been a boon to content creators as well. And, no, none of those sites using DRM are "a danger to our rights and our security" as the article breathlessly claims. I'm sure it's not a popular opinion around here, but I used to be a donor to the EFF and no longer am. I feel they've gone off the deep end on too many issues and they're increasingly using hyperbole and hysteria to make arguments against relatively small issues. I mean, come on: > "That proposition ranges from unpalatable on a gaming console, to repulsive on laptops and phones loaded with sensors and personal info" Repulsive? With those scary "sensors" sensing things and you know what happens when DRM and sensors get together!?! Oh, that's right, nothing.
- muddi900 11y agoCan you use Spotify with you iPod classic? Can you iTunes movie work on your Android phone? At some point, corporations convinced consumers that buying a whole service contract everytime you play a song is more convenient than just playing a song. Also, phone sensors contain vital biometric data that the user has no access to.The repulsive thing that happens is that the device is locking your information from you. This is spreading out in other industries like autombiles and medical devices. Now you will have to buy a whole new service contract everytime you drive a car or check your blood pressure. So convenient.
- strictnein 11y ago> "Can you use Spotify with you iPod classic?" The original iPod had no wifi so that would be tough. And iTunes is more locked in than I like, so I use Amazon for my media purchases. > "At some point, corporations convinced consumers that buying a whole service contract everytime you play a song." Well, no one is a buying a new contract every time, but I assume you mean that I'm agreeing to a contract when I listen to a song. If that's the case, yes, it's better than it used to be. I have access to millions of songs. We have on demand radio where I can pick every single song I listen to and I pay next to nothing for it. It's something we've dreamed of for decades. > " is more convenient than just playing a song" And are these companies supposed to just provide these songs for me for free to listen to? How would that work? And I can still buy music if I want, which I do for the artists I enjoy. > "Now you will have to buy a whole new service contract everytime you drive a car" I will?
- pessimizer 11y agoI can't help it, but I'm simply not against DRM. My problem is with the laws that make it illegal to break it. DRM is an art, and a form of expression. If someone wants to use it to delay alternate distribution channels, or to keep people from looking at things, I find that intriguing and mysterious. To keep it from being broken within a couple of years would involve an enormous amount of creativity and effort, and be well deserved. If we could end copyright, I'd be happy with DRM wherever people could manage it. Ending DRM feels to me like ending riddles. Buying a locked box isn't morally bad - the badness comes when the government threatens to drive you to prison with guns and sticks for trying to open the box that you bought, or helping someone else open the box that they bought. Yes, all copyright.
- jalami 11y agoI think this is being kind of pedantic. I don't think DRM should be banned and I don't think most people do. I just don't think it should be facilitated on the web or legally protected against tampering. It's one thing to say 'DRM should be legal', quite another to say 'DRM is a good practice'. In the end, let the consumer decide whether it's a good practice or not, aka don't touch it legally. So I'll agree with you there, certainly don't give it any protections against the consumer. However, I can still say, as a consumer, DRM is a bad practice and I would always take a DRM-free alternative to it. A lot of bad things are artsy and clever. The demise of DRM should be more of a consumer advocacy thing than a legal battle anyway, IMHO.
- amelius 11y agoThis is why I hate SaaS software that could also run as an ordinary application on a local machine. Basically, it has DRM built-in by means of the cloud.
- tonyedgecombe 11y agoI'm selling software that runs on a local machine and piracy is a problem for me, my next product will be SaaS for that reason.
- Silhouette 11y agoIt's hard to argue with that policy, IMHO. Even on HN, where discussion is usually quite reasonable, there are people in this thread openly admitting to piracy. The top post as I write this argues that trying to protect the rights granted by law through technical measures should mean giving up those rights altogether. There is very little respect shown towards the people who are creating new content, and even less remorse about ripping them off. It's hardly surprising that when people are so unrepentant about these things, the people actually doing the work will take steps to protect themselves. It's sad that it's come to this, but too many selfish people have spoiled it for everyone now. I think it's inevitable that for the next few years at least, we'll see content providers increasingly locking their works up either through devices where you don't have full access even if you bought it or through keeping critical parts of the system online where customers can't copy or control it. For some of us, piracy isn't a morally acceptable alternative to paying for a legitimate copy of a work, but DRM still sucks and often makes what we do get worse than what a pirate would get. I hope there will at least continue to be enough of us around who will make a point of supporting DRM-free alternatives that they continue to be available, but I fear we will be a small minority and so will those willing to distribute their work DRM-free.
- Retra 11y agoIf piracy is this common, why should people be ashamed to admit they do it? >It's sad that it's come to this, but too many selfish people have spoiled it for everyone now. This statement applies both ways. Human culture is a necessity. Humans are social animals. If my friends and family literally talk about Game of Thrones or Star Wars every day, do you think I'm just going to voluntarily exclude myself from my own community in order to protect the wealth of some small cabal halfway across the world? Of course not. That's not a tide you want to fight against, no matter how much you might want to trivialize the costs.
- nsxwolf 11y agoI like that DRM exists in exactly one use case - online movie rentals. They wouldn't exist otherwise.
- kemiller 11y agoThis doesn't get enough discussion. The way I think about DRM is that you can't in any real sense say that you own something with DRM, because it only works at the pleasure of someone else. You are effectively renting it. But that's appropriate when renting is exactly your intention.
- caractacus 11y ago> every bit of media that is “exclusive” to DRM-encumbered formats shows up, every single time, unlocked on file-sharing networks and torrent sites. Incorrect. PC games, software, console games - many of these have not and likely will not be cracked. That's not to say there aren't many out there but if you have paid attention to information dripping out of cracking groups, you'll see it's becoming much more difficult to get around DRM. Similarly, Cinavia works. RTMPE works. It doesn't mean they should be there. It doesn't mean that adding the DRM doesn't cause annoyances to legitimate consumers. But that blanket statement that whatever DRM you add is ineffective is simply wrong. Edit: quick example - ps4 released Nov 2013. Can you play pirated games on it? Nope. You can install linux but it's likely a number of years before piracy can happen. https://fail0verflow.com/blog/2015/console-hacking-2015-liner-notes.html https://fail0verflow.com/blog/2015/console-hacking-2015-line...
- mordocai 11y agoI can guarantee that as available computing resources increase every DRM available now will be broken and new ones will have to be created to keep up. That's not what the EFF meant though.
- rhino369 11y agoAlso, DRM doesn't have to be infallible to be worthwhile. Sure you can get MS Office on pirate bay, but 1) most people don't know how to use torrents and 2) can't install the cracked version (or worse authenticate with that fake sever). But if MS didn't have DRM on the DVD version people would just pass it around to their friends and familes.
- riprowan 11y agoSay what you want about DRM, but at least in the audio world, the best software is still DRMed, even after more than a decade of horror stories. In 1999 I reviewed the Waves (http://www.waves.com/ http://www.waves.com/) Native Gold audio plugin bundle on the old ProRec.com. This software was protected by PACE AP DRM software (https://paceap.com/ https://paceap.com/). The thing about Waves is that it's a staple in the audio world and had already become a staple by 1999. Everyone uses Waves plugs. So Waves had a fairly inelastic demand function, but a small overall market. Enter DRM. The hateful anti-piracy software they used had some process that snooped around in memory, and if it found anything that it didn't like, it just warm-rebooted the computer. You'd be recording a vocal take, and BAM! the screen would go black, there'd be a beep, then the BIOS screen, and here comes Windows. No warning, no option to save, nothing. Recording session lost, files left open, disk state inconsistent. This is unacceptable even once, but the frequency of these intentional crashes was horrifying. In a normal day of use the workstation might crash 20 times or more, typically with some sort of consequential damage (lost work, lost files, corrupted disks, etc). Waves was unable to address the problem successfully for more than a year. Lots of professional workstations were affected, and a lot of customers were very angry. Nobody wanted to see Waves go under: everyone LOVED the products and wanted to continue to support development. But at the same time nobody could afford to install what amounted to horrible malware on their production workstations. So the pro audio community had simply evolved a workaround: buy the licensed software, but run the pirated software. Because the pirated software, lacking PACE AP, was perfectly stable. To this day, most good products in the pro audio community have DRM - many of them still run PACE software. Fortunately, problems are less horrific these days, but everyone in the industry knows the pain of showing up at a session without your Pro Tools dongle, or being at a gig and needing to reinstall a plugin, and there's no internet at the gig with which to validate your license. TL;DR it amazes me how much pain customers are willing to endure
- bediger4000 11y agoSay what you want about DRM, but at least in the audio world, the best software is still DRMed, even after more than a decade of horror stories. We don't really know what the presence of DRM means. It could be that DRM works in the audio world. Or it could mean that there's not that many producers of audio world software, and they're taking advantage of the situation. Or it could mean that there's some pernicious and near universal mental fault, a cognitive bias, so that DRM makes some kind of emotional sense if you're licensing software, rather than actually selling something. Or maybe there's a "gentleman's agreement", like the Apple/Google No Poaching pact amongst the vendors. Personally, I'm in favor of the cognitive bias theory. I think that the concept of ownership, extended to non-physical things, puts the producers of movies, music, software, etc into some weird psychological position where DRM just makes sense to them.
- 6stringmerc 11y ago>But while it may not be as intuitive yet, DRM on digital media that you don’t own is also a major threat. Yeah, and what this article completely glosses over is that as the creator of *.mp3s by 6StringMercenary, I own the digital media, by law[1], and I should have a say in how it's distributed, copied, or exploited, legally speaking. In a lot of cases, the music that's being "purchased" has never been owned by the person holding the LP, the cassette or the CD. They own a licensed copy. There's a fundamental, important difference. This article does absolutely nothing to rectify that the internet doesn't automatically own my creations as soon as I put them out there. I'm allowed control, legally, and I don't think it's fair - appropriate, moral, or ethical - to try and strip those rights away from me. Nowhere is this even touched upon as a parameter of this "NO DRM EVER" postulation. Just because the EFF thinks its business model of begging for money is a good one doesn't mean other pariticipants in society and commerce feel the model is appropriate for other endeavors. I get they have a mission, and at times we see eye to eye. Other times, like this one, I think they're woefully un-prepared for the implication of the position they espouse to take. [1] This does not include unlicensed remix projects, works-for-hire, or other nuanced undertakings outside the scope of this discussion
- pjc50 11y agoDo you believe that gives you the right to control every other computer and prevent the writing of entire categories of software?
- 6stringmerc 11y agoYour question is a hyperbolic straw-man, which means I will obviously answer "No" because I'm specifically talking about one particular item. Do you fundamentally mis-understand my right to not have some teenager from The Bay simply grab my track from iTunes and use it as the soundtrack to their Kickstarter video simply because technology makes it possible?
- pjc50 11y agoIf I say yes .. what does it imply should be done about it?
- stcredzero 11y agoThis won't be a very popular position, especially here, considering the high population of tech people and those who might be running servers this might affect, but I think it's important for people to realize that the simplistic "DRM is Evil" position is misguided. Imagine an alternate universe where government and huge corporations started using data encryption on its records in the 80's, as a way of defeating the FOIA and other demands for transparency. There is a public hue and cry, and with righteous indignation, people start thinking of "encryption as evil." To help prevent the repeat of such high profile abuses by large organizations, people work to ban data encryption. That's not how history played out, however. In real life in the 90's, due to the PC revolution, ordinary people outside of academia started to become aware of the potential benefits of encryption over computer networks. There is a fundamental asymmetry of power between large institutions and individuals. What is a public good in the hands of the public can be horrible when it allows organizations to exercise dangerous degrees of centralized control. So it is with DRM. DRM restricting access by individuals to the software we fairly bought and to our shared cultural experiences is horrible. However, DRM protecting individual data against the depredations of companies and other institutions would be a tremendous pubic good. Imagine a world where companies could no longer say about your personal data, "It got out somehow. Who knows? There's nothing anyone can do about that sort of thing. Privacy is dead." DRM won't be foolproof. Nothing like that can be. (Which is precisely why it's unsuitable for centralized control, in a particular way that it causes lobbying money to request stupid legislation.) However, it will greatly increase the cost and legal risk of companies doing bad things with our personal data. The same asymmetry that makes DRM horrible makes it absolutely wonderful when you reverse it by 180 degrees! That asymmetry is this: Any given company, no matter how large, can't ever match the level of knowledge and man-hours that can be mustered by the internet at large. This precise economic asymmetry that makes DRM an unworkable idea that incentivizes oppression also makes DRM the perfect tool for helping the public to keep large organizations in line. One whistle-blower, one hacker's discovery, and that errant company can be prosecuted under the DMCA. (1) Why aren't we requiring companies that handle vast amounts of private data to use DRM -- Digital Rights Management -- to protect the rights of individual human beings? After all, the rights of individual Homo sapiens should be the priority. (1) -- Occasionally, some people will have their information breached, and their information could be disseminated beyond control. However, the bulk of the populace would still be protected.
- k-mcgrady 11y agoI'm generally anti-DRM but I don't see what the issue is applying it to streaming media. Why should I care the Spotify uses DRM? I don't own that content, I pay for streaming access which I get. I'm not paying to be able to download the tracks, move them to different mediums, back them up etc. Could someone explain the issue? Because the article didn't.
- ef4 11y agoThat streaming DRM only works if you give up control of the hardware you own.
- k-mcgrady 11y agoSorry, I don't understand. Could you provide more info or a link to something showing this? I can't understand how I'm giving up control of my laptop hardware when I stream a movie on Netflix for example.
- parenthephobia 11y agoWhen you stream a movie on Netflix, either the DRM doesn't work, or you no longer have unrestricted access - from inside the computer - to the pixels on the screen, or the audio being output. i.e. If you try to screenshot the movie, or redirect the audio into a file, you won't be allowed. The video and audio quality may be downgraded if you attach non-HDCP (a DRM system for local video and audio) outputs to your laptop. Sometimes Netflix will simply refuse to stream anything if it isn't sure that the path from the video decoder to the monitor's screen is secure. e.g. https://www.reddit.com/r/apple/comments/3j0vck/whats_hdcp_and_why_cant_i_play_netflix_on_my/ https://www.reddit.com/r/apple/comments/3j0vck/whats_hdcp_an... You don't have permission from Netflix to prevent this. If you're in the US or UK - and many other jurisdictions - it is illegal for you to do so, even if it's very clearly within your fair use (or equivalent) rights. In the future, it's likely that DRM will extended to add and detect watermarks to restricted video and audio output, requiring you (and those around you) to cede full use of any other devices with microphones and cameras that might happen to capture that output.
- 11y ago
- yuhong 11y agoI wonder what would happen to record companies if DAT tape existed in the 1970s (before they really consolidated).
- vibrolax 11y agoWell we do know what happened when DAT was introduced in 1987: nothing. DAT was rejected as a consumer audio format. One reason often cited for the rejection was the inclusion of DRM features (called SCMS, or Serial Copy Management System) for pre-recorded content. The subsequent Mini-Disc format was also rejected outside Sony's home country market, largely for the same reasons
- yuhong 11y agoYes, I know the history and how SCMS got created. The point is that there was a lot of consolidation of the record industry back in the 1970s and 1980s.
- anotherevan 11y agoVery first sentence of the article has an error: "Everybody knows that the digital locks of DRM on the digital media you own is a big problem." If it has DRM, you don't own it, you are leasing it. Agree or not with the use of DRM, I object to buttons that say "Buy Now" instead of "Lease Now" on web-sites.
- Endy 11y agoWhenever anyone discusses this topic, to shut down anyone who is strongly against copyright, they come up with "Oh, I don't see a way the artists get compensated." Maybe that's right. Maybe art needs to lead the way toward a sharing style pay-what-you-want economy.