5 ms·
It would be nice to link to the original pdf rather than scribd. Their buggy website wouldn't work under Chrome, so I had to fire up Firefox to read the articl
by btilly 17y ago
It would be nice to link to the original pdf rather than scribd. Their buggy website wouldn't work under Chrome, so I had to fire up Firefox to read the article. Which let me page forward through the article, but not backwards.
Yes, I know that scribd is a YC company, is what the cool kids use, etc. But. It. Doesn't. Actually. Work. The pdf reader I have does.
That said, I liked the article. Once I actually managed to read it.
- matrix 17y agoYou know a product is bad when people prefer to PDF... (apologies for going off-topic - I just couldn't resist this one)
- jpablo 17y agoPDF is not that bad as long as you have an good enough reader (i.e. no acrobat)
- joe_the_user 17y agoEvidence? I'm on Linix, I've tried the default readers and they are all horrific. What would you recommend, seriously. I have never found a pleasant PDF reader on any platform but I'm open to the idea they might exist.
- boucher 17y agoPreview is a pretty solid app. Unfortunately, I've never across anything remotely well done on any other platform.
- ecuzzillo 17y agoExcept when you have pdfs that use certain funny image-compression things that make it look fantastic in Acrobat and xpdf-based viewers; Preview does horribly on those. I agree in general about Preview, though. (It might be jpeg2000; I just know that when my dad scans a book, it looks good in acroread and xpdf, but in Preview it's very slow and pixelated.)
- weaksauce 17y agoPreview is good but I like skim a bit more. It has the note taking features and smooth zooming with trackpad pinch gestures. I cannot believe how fast it is too! Great app. One thing I wish it had though is the pdf editing commands that preview had to remove a page and concatenate different pdfs together. Also: foxit reader is a great reader for window. Not quite as polished as skim but still the best reader I have come into contact with on the windows side of the fence.
- Niten 17y agoI guess you've never tried PDF-XChange or Sumatra PDF, then.
- sreque 17y agoI like okular, the default KDE reader, a lot actually.
- btilly 17y agoI'm not sure what you mean by "pleasant" but xpdf gets the job done.
- chronomex 17y agoI like FoxitReader. It's non-free, but it does do facing pages continuous, which is great for reading on widescreen monitors.
- sliverstorm 17y agoCall me crazy, but acroread really worked pretty well for me.
- d_c 17y agoIt's true for me anyway.
- smokinn 17y agoI hate scribd too but it seems she uploaded the slides there herself: http://twitter.com/pamelafox/status/9873479432 http://twitter.com/pamelafox/status/9873479432
- btilly 17y agoGood point. I've sent her an email.
- boucher 17y agoYou've sent her e-mail to complain that she used Scribd? I have to say, that's both selfish and obnoxious. Especially because you can just click the download link and get it in whatever format you want.
- btilly 17y agoI tried clicking the download link. It forces you to register. I was not willing to register with a non-functional website I didn't want to use. That was the point I pulled out Firefox instead.
- pamelafox 17y agoApologies; I hadn't had issues with Scribd myself (Chrome/Linux), didn't realize others did. It is also on slideshare, and I can upload to other desired formats. It is originally a Microsoft PPT, as that makes the 15 seconds timing easy to enforce and practice.
- lambda 17y agoFor viewing slides, I generally prefer a PDF (as Preview an Safari's built in PDF viewer are generally pretty decent), or Google Docs. The problem with Scribd and SlideShare is that they require Flash, which is slow and buggy (it's crashing every time I try to view your slides on Scribd), and they generally have interfaces with lots of extra junk and ads all over the place.
- enf 17y agoLooks like the original author actually chose to post to scribd, so the reposting isn't to blame: http://twitter.com/pamelafox/status/9873479432 http://twitter.com/pamelafox/status/9873479432 But I'd always rather have a PDF too.
- llimllib 17y agoI did indeed just take the link from her twitter.
- DannoHung 17y agoWoot! Found an alternate: http://www.slideshare.net/wuzziwug/im-a-barbie-girl-in-a-cs-world http://www.slideshare.net/wuzziwug/im-a-barbie-girl-in-a-cs-... I can't even view the scribd page properly. All the scripts and CSS are broken.
- snowmaker 17y agoHey - what browser/OS are you using? Could you explain/screenshot me what is broken?
- DannoHung 17y agoFirefox 3.6 on Windows XP. It was on my work computer, which I don't have access to right now. If the problem persists (it's working on my Chrome OS X home computer right now), I'll see if I can get you a ss tomorrow morning.
- DannoHung 17y agoHere's the ss: http://i.imgur.com/VRWg9.png http://i.imgur.com/VRWg9.png I'm also running the Vimperator plugin, which is why my chrome looks weird. It has literally never caused a problem in any other site though.
- notaddicted 17y agoI had the same problem: the place where you click determines whether you go forward or backwards. right edge of the slide = backwards (but not on the 1st slide.) The only way to go forwards I could figure out is clicking on the right side of the slide.
- fnid2 17y agoA bit OT, but might I suggest it's Chrome that is buggy? If it works in all the major browsers except Chrome, then might it be Chrome's responsibility to make it work? My general test is, if it works in 3 of the 5, then it's the other browsers' fault. There are simply too many browsers now and a I wonder sometimes if google did more harm than good by not putting more effort into one of the existing browsers than by releasing a completely new one and increasing the workload on developers. Are they trying to further innovation or hinder it by creating one more hurdle for web developers to jump? We could make all our sites work in all the browsers, or we could spend time making more sites and bringing more value to the world. I have four browsers installed on my machine, ie, firefox, opera, and safari. I test sites in all of those. Making it work in a 5th means it might break in the other 4 and that's just ridiculous. At some point, you have to say it's "good enough".
- joe_the_user 17y agoIt's broken for Firefox on Ubuntu too.
- X-Istence 17y agoDoesn't work right here on Safari on Mac OS X either. Might have to do with my ClickToFlash plug-in or something, but overall I have not noticed issues elsewhere. Also, Flash takes up insane amount of resources. The built-in PDF reader I have works perfectly.
- nollidge 17y agoI just read the whole thing in Chrome. What doesn't work for you?
- btilly 17y agoTrying to get to the next page. I tried clicking. Double clicking. I tried the arrows at the bottom. (They even have nice mouse overs that say Next Page/Previous Page.) I tried changing the view type. None of these let me scroll through the presentation. Based on other comments in this thread I tried putting my mouse on the boundaries of the image. OK, that works. It is a cool idea. But it is an interface that is different from how everything else on the web works. Once you know to do it it is easy. But it isn't exactly the easiest interface to discover when you aren't looking for it. That would be OK if it was just a backup shortcut for people who realized it. But the traditional interface that should be the primary one for people who don't know the site doesn't work. Hence the problem. The reason that Firefox worked for me is that the browser is in a different place on the screen and therefore I naturally was over the right area of the page. So pure luck. Incidentally this is the kind of deficiency that is better caught with usability testing than A/B testing. Take 20 people, sit them down with your website, and ask them to complete a task. See what they have trouble with. If you've never done it before you'll likely be shocked at the result.