8 ms·
> the idea that everyone in Brazil can be denied the freedom to communicate the way they want is very scary in a democracy Says the person (in name of the comp
by lucb1e 11y ago
> the idea that everyone in Brazil can be denied the freedom to communicate the way they want is very scary in a democracy
Says the person (in name of the company, I assume) whose company blocks things they don't "like", such as messages containing telegram.org or telegram.me[1].
Now Facebook is not a democracy and they can block and censor pretty much any message they like, but now they go on to tell Brazil how it should run its judicial system. That's like giving people free beer and then asking them to take up pitchforks and come along to put some pressure on a third party you don't like very much.
[1] https://i.snag.gy/9KBPGR.jpg https://i.snag.gy/9KBPGR.jpg
- nxzero 11y agoMaybe this is obvious, or that I'm wrong, but the issue in Brazil is that most Brazilians are left-wing conservatives AND within in recent past put the current government in power. Long term this is the issue, not these "cyber attacks" - which are to me very problematic, but only a symptom of the issue.
- lucb1e 11y agoI'm not sure which "cyber attacks" you are talking about. It's about a judge ordering Whatsapp to be taken offline for 72 hours for not complying with a court order, or am I missing something?
- nxzero 11y agoQuotes infer that it's a hyperbolic metaphor - and is used to express the degree of my disgust for a country "legally" attacking itself without good cause. __ * Hyperbolic metaphor: https://sesquiotic.wordpress.com/2011/02/02/can-a-metaphor-be-hyperbole-too/ https://sesquiotic.wordpress.com/2011/02/02/can-a-metaphor-b...
- dublinben 11y agoWhat does "left-wing conservatives" mean?
- neves 11y agomaybe the same as right-wing liberals, that is, complete nonsense.
- camillomiller 11y agoIf you try to think out of the U.S. politics box where labels are strictly enforced, it make a lot of sense. The communist party in italy during the 60s and 70s was pretty much the epitome of left-wing conservatism.
- ptaipale 11y agoI interpret it as socially conservative, but preferring strong state involvement in economy. Personal liberty is not very important. There can be rich people, but they are to be humbled by a powerful government. A very extreme example of such a regime is the National Socialist Germany.
- dublinben 11y agoThat description, and your example, are in no way "left-wing."
- ptaipale 11y agoI think that "preferring strong state involvement in economy" is a very traditional "left-wing" policy. Regarding social conservatism, even extreme left-wing governments have often been socially conservative in many issues, even if they wanted to shake power structures. Consider, for instance, how stalinist Soviet Union related to homosexuals.
- guiporto 11y ago> Facebook is not a democracy and they can block and censor pretty much any message they like, but now they go on to tell Brazil how it should run its judicial system Yeah, Facebook is a company - not a country. You can't compare apples to oranges. Facebook can do whatever it want and people are free to chose to use it service or not. Brazilians had no choice on this case.
- clvx 11y agoBrazilians can use other apps if they want them too. I don't see your point of freedom to communicate being blocked. You're complaining as tcp/ip would've been blocked and it's not. The point here is Whatsapp is not cooperating with authorities, and surely that's not remotely plausible in a state government. I'm not saying they have to weak encryption or putting backdoors, but a reasonable way to help any government with investigations which hurt society in general.
- visarga 11y ago> Brazilians can use other apps if they want them too. Having a country change like that does not do good for people. People using dumb phones might have WhatsApp, but not alternatives.
- Dylan16807 11y agoOther apps with proper user-controlled encryption would also be blocked. It is impossible to help the investigations in the way they were asked to while also having proper user-controlled encryption. You are asking for weaknesses or backdoors if you don't recognize that Whatsapp gave up all the information they had, which was nothing.
- danenania 11y ago'I'm not saying they have to weak encryption or putting backdoors, but a reasonable way to help any government with investigations which hurt society in general.' What is it with the "I'm not saying they should have a backdoor, but there should really be [some rhetorically obfuscated equivalent to a backdoor]"? This is cryptography, not politics. There's no middle ground here. You either have secure communications or you don't. If the data can be provided to the government, that also means it can be leaked, stolen, purchased, spied upon, etc.
- make3 11y agoThat's fucking dodgy/unacceptable. I know they did this for another site that gave money to people for spamming their connections with links to their website, which I guess is borderline acceptable. In the case of telegram though, there is no redeeming circumstance of any kind, they're just censoring for a business advantage [without it being directly visible to the user, which is even worse], and that's just really unacceptable for me
- SEMW 11y ago> censoring Classifying a recipient receiving a message containing exactly what the sender sent as 'censorship' just because they don't auto-link it is taking the word to new heights of rhetorical meaninglessness. Dodgy and scummy, sure. Mildly inconvenient for the recipient, definitely. Censorship, no.
- sangnoir 11y ago> just because they don't auto-link it is taking the word to new heights of rhetorical meaninglessness Whatsapp not only blocks auto-linking, but they also prevent the link from being copied to the clipboard. "Censorship" sounds about right.
- hoorayimhelping 11y agoThere is a huge difference between "the government of Brazil denying everyone the freedom to communicate the way they want" and "facebook not auto-linking to a competitor's site in a chat program." You're comparing a government making communication through a specific (and popular) channel illegal, and a company not providing a link to a website as they send your message to your recipient. I know Hacker News enjoys getting riled up at Facebook, but come on. You're not comparing apples to apples, you're not even comparing food to food, it's like saying this rock isn't like this sandwich.
- neves 11y agoI think it is a fair comparison. Facebook isn't for free expression, they are for their business. The Brazilian Gov can be questioned in the Justice System, but doing so against "Freedom". Facebook dubious position about the right to be informed and the desire to control the information we access is a greater menace to freedom of expression than any ignorant Brazilian lower judge.
- Dylan16807 11y agoEvery business is there for themselves. But laws or rulings blocking access to any business are anti-freedom. It's pretty simple. Sometimes there are legitimate reasons that overcome that. But not with a simple communication channel.
- Loic 11y agoI don't know in which country you live, but I am very happy we have rulings here in Germany blocking access to businesses if those businesses are not following the law. WhatsApp, even if a US based company, is defacto providing a service in Brazil, it means they have to follow Brazilian laws. Dura Lex Sed Lex. You have more context on the other submission[0] showing that WhatsApp had way enough time to take the requests of the judge into account and act on them. They preferred to go the "we are too big to be shut down" way, which is not the way the law works and then complain about freedom and democracy. [0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11614116 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11614116
- x0054 11y agoAm I missing something? Just tried it on my phone and it works fine in on my end, is this something that just doesn't get converted to a link on the other side? Not converting something to a link is a far cry from outright censorship, still pretty shady in a mostly meaningless way, though.
- twoarray 11y agoMark Zuckerberg "urged" Brazilians to tell Congress to "ban bans of online services" in the name of democracy. Am I an irrational nationalist for believing he shouldn't get into the politics of any country (especially outside of the US)? Last time someone tried to help us (Brazilians), we got a military dictatorship.
- chrischen 11y agoOh but this isn't even the first time. See this: http://www.theverge.com/2015/8/5/9099897/facebook-india-internet-org-banners http://www.theverge.com/2015/8/5/9099897/facebook-india-inte... Facebook put up a banner for Indian users to try to influence the passing of a law to allow Facebook to break net neutrality in India. Acts like these aren't limited to communications companies though. American multinationals have a tendency to exploit poor underdeveloped countries, like Papua New Guinea, and countless African countries. It's part of the reason why China takes a highly protectionist stance especially with regards to foreign internet companies.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- r3bl 11y agoIt's not just Indian users neither. Once an Indian user saw that banner and signed it, every single one of his friends got a notification about it. In fact, that chained reaction somehow ended up in my notifications too by one of my friends signing it. I was furious! See: https://twitter.com/r3bl_/status/679093130080161792 https://twitter.com/r3bl_/status/679093130080161792 (notice the checkmark that's checked by default). In my opinion, they managed to accomplish exactly what they wanted to with this campaign: make the whole online call for discussion by the India's regulatory authority meaningless.
- gotchange 11y agoI think that this is your congress not the US Congress but I get your point and I'd be offended and irritated if someone special interests driven like Zuckerberg stuck his nose in our politics and internal affairs like this. Also, I wouldn't rule out that Zuckerberg could resort to astro-turfing tactics and fund those "internet freedom" groups in Brazil to do his bidding. Unfortunately, Zuckerberg turned his tech empire into a big political machine and started to influence or subvert (However you choose to view his actions) politics in foreign countries and should be treated as such not just some harmless business.
- mirimir 11y agoBut wait, if WhatsApp is end-to-end encrypted, that failure to URL convert must be a local operation. And if it's a local operation, maybe there's a workaround. But maybe apps are locked down too tightly. In any case, going from telegram.org as text to https://telegram.org/ https://telegram.org/ is not exactly rocket science, no?
- the_ancient 11y agoLast i checked Facebook does not have the authority to arrest, kill, put people in cages.. these are all things a governments do to citizen their violate their laws. So no facebook censoring telegram is aboslutely nothing like a government doing anything. It is extremely ignorant to ever compare a companies action to a government actions. A person can stop using (or never start like me) facebook, a person can not quit their government, or refuse their government ...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dmd 11y agoLinking to telegram works just fine. http://imgur.com/FOnR6ls http://imgur.com/FOnR6ls
- hacksonx 11y agoJust tried it with a couple of guys at the office, seems it is only blocked on Android. It works on WhatsApp web, Windows phone and on the iPhone.
- jim-greer 11y agoI can't reproduce the censorship of telegram.org. http://imgur.com/qUjmS2n http://imgur.com/qUjmS2n