8 ms·
Instagram insists littergram app is renamed
- kagamine 11y agoLucas should have his lawyers send a telegram to Instagram's lawyers explaining where the gram part of the name comes from, and ask them to change their name. The idea that large companies can own a word, that they themselves have appropriated, is at least egotistical, at worst unethical (imo).
- sschueller 11y agoSadly the one with more money wins in these situations even if they are in the wrong.
- nitrogen 11y agoYes, which is why you can't call a window-based operating system *indows, paint your delivery trucks brown, or use the letter I.
- kristofferR 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Corp._v._Lindows.com,_Inc https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Corp._v._Lindows.com....
- nitrogen 11y agoHN removes the final period from the URL. Try https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Corp._v._Lindows.com,_Inc%2e https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft_Corp._v._Lindows.com...
- ianpurton 11y agoNot if you're bankrupt and represent yourself.
- Grabbeh 11y agoI don't think trade mark ownership is in itself the problem. Trade marks serve a useful economic purpose in helping consumers to easily distinguish between products in the marketplace. I have no issue with companies using trade marks for this purpose as without them consumer confusion would be rife, and there's a legitimate interest in allowing companies to police use of their brand names. The problem arises when a company looks to abuse its trade mark rights and prevent usage of other brand names which to most reasonable people would never actually be confused with the trade mark owner's brand. I always want to be in the underdog's corner, but I have sympathy with Instagram here I must admit. The origin of 'gram' is irrelevant. The fact is that we are dealing with two apps with very similar functionality, who both share the word 'gram'. On that basis, I think there is a high likelihood of confusion in relation to the origin of the app. There's a decent chance that a certain proportion of the relevant population could think that Littergram is an official offshoot of Instagram. It's also likely that the name was also chosen to free-ride off Instagram's goodwill to attract attention to the app. To be fair though, he has got good publicity for the app as a result of the cease and desist, which if he hadn't named it Littergram he would never have got. I doubt Instagram would pursue a damages claim and so both parties can presumably walk away if he changes the name.
- kagamine 11y agoGiven that the use of something-gram is likely to cause confusion in the eyes of some, perhaps instagram ought to have given more thought to naming their product to begin with. I mean, any fool could see where this was heading if the app in its infancy was expected to be successful. Car manufacturers and other industries spend fortunes on branding, app manufacturers by contrast appear to feel obligated to choose a random word and then scream "this is mine now talk to legal la la la I can't hear you". Ianal but I would (theoretically and against my real lawyer's advice) argue in court that Instagram should have had better foresight than to use an already established word that is taken to mean "short message of indiscriminate content". Of course the easy way out here is for Insta- i forget, oh yes gram, to pay the littergram bloke's costs for changing the name of his app and then help him to promote the new name. Saying as he is actually doing something a lot more worthwhile than sending shitposts from teen to teen. But why let decency get in the way of POWERSTRIDES THROUGH THE OFFICE LIKE A TRUE TECH-CONQUEROR SPITTING ON THE COMMONERS ... I FEEL SO STRONG NOW, NO-ONE CAN CHALLENGE ME. I mean, the guy is trying to stop littering, he's not doing anything untoward.
- drb311 11y agoHere's how the BBC describes the product: "Littergram invites people to share pictures of rubbish." It's pretty clear that -gram here is used to signal that this is a picture sharing app. If Instagram didn't exist it's unlikely Lucas would have called his app Littergram.
- surreal 11y agoIdentical usage to Instagram, then. But yes, I agree, the similarity in app functionality suggests that the name derives/can be confused with Instagram as opposed to a telegram, and so there may well be merit in the C&D.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- kagamine 11y ago> "Littergram invites people to share pictures of rubbish." I think they put the wrong app name in there. Given that sentence, they are identical apps.
- chris_wot 11y agoLOL!
- hellbanner 11y agoWhat fascinates me (coming from a programming background) is this is essentially a namespace collision. If you or I put up a banner "littergram kitchen" inside of our kitchen and no one knows about it but friends and residents.. there's no problem. Hell if "littergram" becomes used by a few dozen people, no problem. Enter the same marketplace as "instagram" and voila, namespace collision. (Well almost, littergram != instagram but you see what I mean). I wonder what the world would be like if copyrights used proper namespaces? Maybe we there would be a dearth of companies missing vowels in their title..
- kagamine 11y agoCompanies should also be named according to type, so publicly listed companies should use camel-case and private companies dashes, faceBook and face-book could co-exist. _FACEBOOK_ too, they're a gloabal insustry. /s
- cowsandmilk 11y ago(a) it is trademark law (b) trademarks are namespaced, both by business and geography. As a quick example, different Otto pizza chains ran peacefully in NYC and in Portland, ME. There only was an issue when they both tried to expand to Boston at the same time. (c) missing vowels has nothing to do with collisions. I cannot create a company called flicker that hosts photos. I also cannot create a social network called facbook. Present or missing vowels do not make a difference. Missing vowels started with getting a web address, then became a fad.
- samdung 11y agoTelegram and Instacart are next.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- taneq 11y agoWow, I can't believe those Telegram people thought they could get away with making up a name out of 'Telephone' and 'Instagram'.
- pferde 11y agoI'm more appalled at Alexander Graham Bell for his blatant ripoff of Apple's "iPhone" trade mark.
- chris_wot 11y agoSure hope they never go through a merger...
- Intermernet 11y agoTelecart? Taken (on Facebook) https://m.facebook.com/mytelecart/ https://m.facebook.com/mytelecart/
- SixSigma 11y agoThey should send a bunch of anagram digram via telegram, cabelgram or sonogram, possibly including an angiogram or mammogram to tell that what tits they are being. Perhaps they could contact Polygram and use paper with a monogram of a decagram, hexagram, octagram, parallelogram, trigram, or pentagram. If we prapared a cartogram or histogram it could serve as a diagram of their foolishness. It would certainly serve as an epigram to this whole program and then even an engram will not find a memory of it.
- venomsnake 11y agoCalling lawyer and C levels executives tits is very offensive for the mammary glands and their bearers. Tits are awesome. They nurture life, they look pretty and they are instant antidepressant for a sizable chunk of males (and a lot of women in my recent environments, but that is another story). And they are also forbidden from Instagram - so I guess people working there have no idea how they look like.
- DiabloD3 11y agoIts also offensive to a certain type of bird.
- chris_wot 11y agoNot to mention feathered animals!
- reinhardt 11y ago> (and a lot of women in my recent environments, but that is another story) Sounds like a titillating story, I'd be love to read it if you post it.
- venomsnake 11y agoNothing too spicy. Just all the women I am friends with turned out to be bi or bi-curious. And their success rate with women is ... enviable.
- chrischen 11y agoInstagram also insisted we change our name from Instapainting.com to something else or remove all Instagram references (we used filestack.com which includes Instagram as an upload option). When I complied and removed the Instagram reference they then decided to extend it to all Facebook references (like button, Facebook upload, etc) on the grounds that people might get the insta prefix confused with Facebook since it owns Instagram.
- dandare 11y agoI see you complied, did it hurt your business?
- chrischen 11y agoSomewhat hard to measure. Not allowing uploads from Facebook or Instagram through file picker.io probably had no effect since almost no ones uses it, but not having a like button may have had some effect. Google also considers likes for search ranking. It would have been much worse if we already had a Facebook following. To compensate we focused on Twitter and other ways to gain SEO.
- charlesdm 11y agoI have built apps that integrate closely with known popular video streaming services (hint, hint), and I've dealt with both their legal departments. 1. Most people are clueless about the law / their rights. Companies will try and bully you into taking your site down, without any legal basis. 2. Read up on nominative fair use of a trademark. You are allowed to make use of a competitors trademark, even for commercial purposes. 3. You probably didn't have to make any of those changes. While I'm not a lawyer, both legal departments backed off after sending them a well-argued reply to their bullshit (sorry, that's the only way to describe it) arguments. I do work with an excellent IP law firm, but I didn't even have to contact them to handle this. 4. I highly doubt a tech company would sue you in a meritless case. Even a simple case will cost them $30-50k. The in house lawyer contacting you is often a paper pusher that has to scout the internet for "possible infringements" of the mark. They'll need to get approval to sue you, and risk vs. reward will be considered. If you're based outside of the US, even better. They'll usually have to sue you in your local jurisdiction. 5. Obviously, be prepared to fight if they do come after you.
- lxw 11y agobe renamed. Really a careless error for BBC.
- blowski 11y agoSo "Insists it be renamed" vs "insists it is renamed". IMHO the first option sounds formal and archaic. The second sounds more in tune with contemporary English. That said "insists they rename it" would get rid of the passive and avoid the problem entirely.
- livatlantis 11y agoYeah that was the first thing I noticed as well. I'm somewhat surprised (a little sad, even) that the BBC chose not to write it in the subjunctive mood, which is precisely what is required here. I thought when I read the headline that Instagram was insisting (that is, reiterating) that Littergram was already renamed.
- dempseye 11y agoThe subjunctive is ingrained in my internal English grammar model, as is the who-whom distinction. I've been thinking about dropping them, though. They have started to sound a bit elitist.
- livatlantis 11y agoWell, you can always adapt your speech to your audience. But I don't see why it should be seen as elitist.
- pritambaral 11y ago> in tune with contemporary English Contemporary American English, sure. The former form is still quite popular in British English
- blowski 11y ago
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- kamilszybalski 11y agoLatergramme just changed their name to later.com....
- hashkb 11y agoInstacart has photos... Instapaper has social features... FB is instadumb.
- chris_wot 11y agoInstapaper was on the scene well before InstaGram...
- plcancel 11y agoWhen I clicked on the link, I thought the article was going to be about a dispute about an app highlighting all of the digital junk on Instagram/Facebook feeds. It occurs to me that my brain now readily connects these brands to trash. There was a time when that wasn't the case.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dandare 11y agoAs somebody pointed out, Telegram want's Instagram to change their name :) Actually, this may be one of the best things that could happen to LitterGram from the marketing point of view, I too had tweeted to FB and Instagram asking them not to be so narrow minded.
- Intermernet 11y agoWe could invent a new app where budgies could vocally send selfies to each other and call it tweetfacegram...
- jaaames 11y agoThey need to take a page out of this guys book. http://www.slutsofinstagram.com http://www.slutsofinstagram.com Link is SFW, about a magical duck named Slutsof and his tales in the land of Stagram.
- chris_wot 11y agoIf he wanted a holiday he should visit http://gotahoe.com http://gotahoe.com
- poooogles 11y agoPrevious 'discussion' https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11587265 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11587265. Not sure how the dupe detection works here, but I submitted the same exact link yesterday.
- parenthephobia 11y agoI believe HN's algorithm discounts links which didn't attract much attention last time, so as to allow for interesting links that happened to be overlooked to get a second chance.
- mafro 11y agoThis story has been posted multiple times - as is often the case on HN. It's just one of the posts that get noticed and voted up by the masses.
- tonylemesmer 11y agoIs Instagram's problem that they think people might accidentally think Littergram is Instagram?
- chris_wot 11y agoThat's not what I meant when I called your photos rubbish!
- ungzd 11y agoAll *book words should be banned because of Facebook trademark.
- coldcode 11y agoAs well as face*. Clearly Mark owns all marks.
- EugeneOZ 11y agoLooks like Facebook wants to be next "evil corporation" in developers minds. Microsoft already knows how difficult is to wash out this reputation.
- chris_wot 11y agoThat was established years ago when they got rid of all Facebook apps. At that point, Favebook was actually pretty cool - in fact it was an extensible platform and you could do cool things. Now it's a pure advertising machine. If Facebook disappeared tomorrow, not much would be lost.
- ianpurton 11y agoInstagram sounds like an appropriation of Telegram (invented 200 years ago?). So proof of prior art in my opinion. If they plan to do this in a UK court then he can represent himself pretty cheaply. Think of all the publicity. I'm not a lawyer but I've been watching Suits (3 Seasons), I could definitely win this for the guy.
- drb311 11y agoI've been listening to a lot of Rumpole on Radio Four Extra. Let me know how I can help.
- skoczymroczny 11y ago200 years ago? First version of Telegram Messenger was released only two years ago...
- rolfvandekrol 11y agoAm I the only one here who thinks Instagram has a point here? This guy named his photo sharing app littergram which clearly is a reference to Instagram. There might actually be people in the target audience of littergram or Instagram who think these apps are related. If Instagram is evil for doing something about this, I really have no idea what constitutes as good trademark protection.
- pbhjpbhj 11y agoSo if I advertise my kissogram service using that word then people will think it's from Instagram? How about my hydraulics company BigRam? Suppose you think Apple are infringing Facebook by using the term face-time? Good TM protection is stopping people from using your trademark in a way that confuses the origin of goods/services of theirs as being yours. Littergram if surely a reference to sending a message (-gram) about litter. Similarly, FWIW, Instagram aren't ripping off Instapaper either in my opinion but they're a lot closer to it than the Littergram service. If Instagram wanted a more unique name they should have chosen one that wasn't the combination of a well-known prefix and suffix.
- kitd 11y agoI find the case a bit borderline, but I can see Instagram's point. It's not just the -gram ending context-free. Unlike kissograms, or even the Telegram app, Littergram is specifically about photo sharing, which risks confusing people into believing they and Instagram are related. TBH I think the guy has done a good job of getting publicity. He should use this opportunity to get some goodwill, and use the publcity to change the name to something close enough but not infringing. I'll offer LitterBot ;)
- personjerry 11y agoWho is going to mistake "Instagram" with "Littergram"? And what about my valentine's day Candygrams from 10, 20 years ago? Should we rename those too? This seems a bit ridiculous.
- chris_wot 11y agoSince when do candygrams take photos?
- roddux 11y agoAny clues as to what Littergram's legal position would be if they were to completely ignore Facebook? Would Facebook really bother with blackmailing (court fees are expensive) a small nonprofit into changing it's name?
- chris_wot 11y agoThey have to I'm afraid. Trademarks can only be made on words that are not considered generic. If the trademark does end up being used by the general public as a common or class name for a particular product, then you lose the exclusive right to the mark. You therefore have to defend it, even when you'd really rather not.
- cmdrfred 11y agoMy favorite childhood cereal Golden Grahams should demand Instagram change their name.
- tdkl 11y agoFuck Facebook.
- zoidb 11y agoIf they think they will win this fight they should talk to the old Lindows linux distro/company..
- dreamdu5t 11y agoI can't believe people are defending Instagram here... They haven't got a case but are bullying with their lawyers as all big companies do. How pathetic! Queue the armchair lawyers saying Instagram has to because trademarks require enforcement and other nonsense.