24 ms·
Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases
- homero 11y agoClosed loop coming to fruition
- sergiotapia 11y agoDoes Valve cash out the bitcoins immediately because of it's volatile nature, or is Valve large enough (or bitcoin purchases small enough) that they can safely bear the changes?
- verbify 11y agoApparently they're using BitPay, so presumably they don't get any actual bitcoins.
- imrehg 11y agoSplendid! Been doing game purchases for Bitcoin through Humble Bundle, and Kindle Books through Gyft, I hope more providers of electronic resources will get onboard. It even works out better financially, as credit cards charge such a high "foreign currency conversion fee" here in Taiwan.
- KON_Air 11y agoDo i get to sell my digital junk in community market for Bitcoins?
- bdz 11y agoNope. Legally you can't take money out from your Steam Wallet. But there are 3rd party sites where you can sell your items for real money. Tho you should only bother if you have valuable items.
- j-pb 11y agoSeems like bitcoin won't die after all, which is a pitty. It's become a centralised mess controlled by a few ASIC producers. Worst part is that it continues eating it's own children, as long as bitcoin is there, no other crypto currency will gain widespread adoption.
- wcoenen 11y agoThere is talk that the playing field will become more level now that the ASICs have catched up with 14 nanometer process technology. Mining equipment should no longer become obsolete every few months.
- goldbrick 11y agoHardly. Obsolescence is designed into the very system.
- VMG 11y agoIt's doing pretty well actually. It's still less centralized as all viable alternatives.
- 07d046 11y agoAren't there a small group of people who essentially control all of Bitcoin with no oversight? There might be a group of 30 very wealthy early adopters, miners, main developers, people who own the communication channels, and other influencers, who have 90% of the influence in what happens with Bitcoin. Real currencies can't boast to being that centralised.
- VMG 11y agoTheir wealth depends on bitcoin keeping the properties it currently has. For instance they could try to merge a code change that doubles the balances for early adopters, but it would immediately destroy their wealth because people would stop using the currency.
- StavrosK 11y agoI was really surprised that the announcement that Steam may support Bitcoin made waves a while ago, yet the announcement that it actually does did not. I used it to buy a (horrible) game last night, and it worked beautifully. Contrast with PayPal, with which Steam is always confused about where I am and whether it should charge me in GBP or EUR. I'm never not using Bitcoin again.
- Grue3 11y agoWhat about refunds? With Paypal you know you're getting the same amount back, in the same currency, as if you haven't bought anything at all. Given the fluctuating nature of Bitcoin, surely that's not possible?
- fjidodhofjf 11y agoAnother example of how economicly illiterate anti Bitcoin Advocates are. Go look at USD/YEN movement, 1-3% movements occur daily, if you were to purchase YEN with USd and later refund to USd you could end up significantly up or down. But the wealth YEN represents is many many magnitudes greater than Bitcoin. When YEN appreciates by 2% that influences hundreds of millions of people and business, and guess who is pulling that lever, a small cabal of corrupt bankers.
- VMG 11y agoWhy not? You just calculate the refund amount based on the USDBTC rate.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- krisdol 11y agoCan you ever take money out of steam?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- hypron 11y agoSo many bitcoin haters in these comments... we'll see who's wrong in a decade or so.
- clemensley 11y agoI've always wondered why hackernews hates bitcoin so much. Can someone explain?
- mentos 11y agoLike anything in life I think there is a bit of 'crab mentality' here where people don't want to see something succeed if they do not stand to see any reward from it.
- StavrosK 11y agoI think it's more a reaction to the culty "get rich quick" Bitcoin "investors". It seems that very few people are actually interested in Bitcoin for its UX and the things it enables, everyone is either get-rich-quick or anti-get-rich-quick.
- coldtea 11y ago>I think it's more a reaction to the culty "get rich quick" Bitcoin "investors". Are there any other kind? Besides, the fact that among the top 3 exchanges were the crap fests of "a man-week of amateur PHP code" and the like that were taken down speaks volumes about the kind of crap the bitcoin crowd can't see through.
- api 11y agoDifferent reasons for different people. There are several camps of BitCoin haters: (1) There are people who think it's a pure speculative bubble or pyramid scheme. (I disagree because it has utility.) (2) There are also people who point out that it's a deflationary currency and therefore broken. (I sympathize a bit with this view but it's not enough to make me dismiss it completely. I think this might be a solvable problem.) (3) There seem to be some who just take a contrarian position against things that have received a ton of hype or that are too fashionable.
- joosters 11y agoSo you buy bitcoins with dollars, Bitpay exchanges the bitcoins back into dollars, and then they hand the dollars over to Steam. And this is meant to be a good thing?
- ZenoArrow 11y ago> "So you buy bitcoins with dollars, Bitpay exchanges the bitcoins back into dollars, and then they hand the dollars over to Steam." You don't have to buy bitcoins directly, you can mine them.
- VMG 11y agoOr sell other goods and services.
- joosters 11y agoThen I'm converting dollars to bitcoin via my electricity bill, with even more inefficiency.
- lsadam0 11y agoThen don't?
- ssharp 11y agoExactly. Most people logically arrive at this conclusion when considering Bitcoin's merit as a currency. And that's before they even learn about the deep security issues, how hard it is to protect, how most Bitcoin services cannot be trusted, etc.
- lsadam0 11y agoDeep security issues? Like what?
- 11y ago
- Destreza 11y agoThis is interesting.
- coldtea 11y ago>Steam now accepts Bitcoin for purchases Translation: cheap publicity in tech media and goodwill from some geek sites with no impact whatsoever on its actual revenues and 99.999% of payments.
- mbrock 11y agoPlus, uh, actual value for people who want to pay with Bitcoin. > Valve reached out to us because they were looking for a fast, international payment method for Steam users in emerging gaming markets in countries like India, China, and Brazil. While more users are coming online in in these countries, traditional payment options like credit cards often aren't available.
- coldtea 11y ago>Plus, uh, actual value for people who want to pay with Bitcoin. Yeah, there's always that, too.
- ultramancool 11y agoMight be able to use this to buy games at massive discount on Russian VPN too. Bitcoin doesn't demand I upload a passport to make a Russian account. This may help drive down prices on RU/CIS versions of games on secondary markets like G2A too.
- iammew 11y agostop with this bitcoin bullshit. fuck that.
- dang 11y agoWe've banned this account for repeatedly violating the HN guidelines. If you don't want it to be banned, you're welcome to email hn@ycombinator.com.
- aliakhtar 11y agoIn other news, I live in Pakistan, and I used a debit card to buy a steam game 3 days ago and it worked instantly + frictionlessly, without having to worry about confirmation times + exchange rates + getting scammed + getting on a government list.
- exo762 11y agoSteam/bitpay don't wait for transaction for put money into your steam wallet. Also, no exchange rates are involved in any meaningful way. This offer is for people who can handle few percent exposure on their 100USD "investment" into BTC. A lot of people don't have debit cards. A lot of kids can't own debit cards legally. For them Bitcoin might be the only option.
- aliakhtar 11y ago> Steam/bitpay don't wait for transaction for put money into your steam wallet The guy who made the reddit announcement had to wait 1day+ because his txn didn't get the 6 confirmations. Compared to that, my visa txn took approximately.. 10 seconds? While I was in Lahore, Pakistan. > No exchange rates are involved in any meaningful way. That's a dishonest statement to make. > A lot of people don't have debit cards. That's what you think. Its trivial for anyone who wants to get one (and doesn't have a criminal background) to get one. If you mean people who don't know how to open a bank account, they're even less likely to know how private / public key encryption works and use bitcoin. > A lot of kids Gift cards.
- ryanlol 11y ago> without having to worry about confirmation times Card payments take far longer to process than bitcoin payments > exchange rates Just as much as with bitcoin. > getting scammed Why?
- easuter 11y ago> Card payments take far longer to process than bitcoin payments I can't remember the last time I stood in line at the supermarket for an hour because VISA was clogged with "dust" transactions. Hmm.
- hannes2000 11y agoDoes that mean Germans can buy uncensored games now?
- Shorel 11y agoNo, the actual price and restrictions are still local.
- transfire 11y agoI thought Bitcoin had run into a fundamental problem that transactions were now taking hours co complete. And that an internal battle among developers on the fix remained unresolved. Did I miss something?
- gruez 11y agoBitpay (steam's payment processor) accepts 0-confirmation transactions
- dragontamer 11y agoDoesn't that open Bitpay up to double-spending attacks?
- homero 11y agoThey watch the network for red flags, good propagation fights new transactions
- Natanael_L 11y agoBitpay tells Steam it was paid right away. Steam gives you access. Bitpay tells Steam when it get confirmed, and then pays out. If it gets doublespent, they tell Steam that, and Steam simply revokes the sale, because it is digital and linked to the account.
- wraithm112 11y agoNah. That was just media insanity. Bitcoin functions just fine in the face of crazy politics. The whole point of it is to be unkillable.
- mbmott 11y agoThe Bitcoin network works perfectly fine and always has. The issue you are referring to was during a DOS attack on the network, which still wasn't an issue if you paid slightly higher fees to prioritize your transaction. The developer split on the blocksize increase was pretty heated for a while, but has largely blown over due to Bitcoin still working and the sky refusing to fall as some predicted. However, scaling is still a major issue that some very smart people are working on.
- mbmott 11y agoI could see this as Steam testing the Bitcoin waters. Steam games created an entirely new market of digital items changing hands for real world money, and this is done globally across all currencies--bitcoin would be an ideal fit. I could also see value in using bitcoin to reward content creators (modders). Obviously this is crazy speculation, but seem to be solid use cases.
- clemensley 11y ago> could also see value in using bitcoin to reward content creators Me too. That's basically the mission of yours.network btw. Best way to keep in touch is the slack channel https://yours-slackin.herokuapp.com/ https://yours-slackin.herokuapp.com/
- mbmott 11y agoI follow you guys. Looking forward to trying yours out!
- clemensley 11y agoCool! Can't wait to try it myself tbh :)
- drzaiusapelord 11y agoI don't think this was done for any political or idealistic reason. I imagine bitcoin makes it a lot easier for purchases in countries with unreliable banking, high levels of fraud, etc. Try transfering a non-trivial amount of money to Eastern Europe, Africa, Russia, Brazil, etc. Steam deals with this millions of times a day with fraud credit attempts, legitimate credit cards being turned down, etc. Legitimate buyers can just use bitcoin and not worry about credit card shenanigans. The "omg futurist" brownie points are just a side-effect. Steam/Valve isn't terribly progressive. Heck, its only recently that they put in a refund policy and started putting in common sense limitations on trading to stop fraud. Someone did a cost/benefit analysis here and it simply worked out. I guessing this is part of a larger anti-fraud initiative at Valve.
- justaman 11y agoFinally something to buy other than drugs.
- timlyo 11y agoI've also bought some TF2 hats with bitcoin. Now we just need some things that are less addictive :/
- taesu 11y agoOh man, this is really good. Have about 4 btc just sitting there. Won't have to spend money for games now.
- stegosaurus 11y agoI find the vitriol towards Bitcoin kind of odd. If I posted an article about Linux 4.1 or something, I wouldn't expect to see comments saying 'meanwhile, I used Windows yesterday, and played GTA5, and it was good'. What gives? Are there forums in which people have this sort of reaction to, I dunno, HTML5? From some of the posts here you would think that it's IED control software.
- ebbv 11y ago> If I posted an article about Linux 4.1 or something, I wouldn't expect to see comments saying 'meanwhile, I used Windows yesterday, and played GTA5, and it was good'. Back in the 90's when there was more of a religious fervor around Linux the way there is around Bitcoin right now, yeah you would have. The vitriol is no mystery, it's an obvious reaction to the way so many people have rapturously talked about Bitcoin as if it's going to make governments irrelevant. We're at the beginning of Bitcoin being treated more like the novelty that it is, and possibly finding a niche where it can be useful over the long term. As it enters this phase where the hype around it dies down, the vitriol will as well.
- brighton36 11y agoMoney is a religion
- echelon 11y agoI have no stake or interest in Bitcoin, and I wrote it off some years ago. I find it kind of annoying when there are stories about it or altcoins in my news feed (in lieu of other things). It's noise in my signal. This is just my own personal feeling; I wouldn't go as far as to describe my feeling towards Bitcoin as hate. I can't explain the feelings or motivations of those who actively detract from the technology. It's probably similar to Apple "hate". Or inverse "fanboyism".
- kbenzle 11y agoI saw Bitcoin as another Second Life, great for smart young programmers to have a new sandbox to play in, but not actually useful for working adults. I was similarly "annoyed" by all the Second Life media hype happening after I had written it off.
- johndevor 11y agoIn other news: https://i.imgur.com/3ncet7I.jpg https://i.imgur.com/3ncet7I.jpg
- taberiand 11y agoOnly the match is over before the transaction clears
- Shorel 11y agoThat picture is two years old and custom decals are no longer possible.
- VMG 11y agoThis is amazing.
- abrkn 11y agoThat's incredible! No one would ever spray their PayPal address, Venmo or ACH details. The next logical step is to create a medic bot automates the process ;)
- StavrosK 11y agoWhat does "pocket medic" mean in the TF2 context?
- lwelyk 11y agoMeans you as the medic character stick to healing that one person, becoming their "pocket medic." Commonly people pocket medic heavys, the biggest characters who have a large spray weapon and high max HP.
- elmigranto 11y agoI guess he'll pick a medic class and will heal you constantly for a small compensation in bitcoins.
- ijks 11y agoIt means a player playing the medic class will prefer healing you to other players, and will stick around your position, i.e. stay in your pocket, hence 'pocketing.'
- cwyers 11y agoOh wonderful, now the world's two most popular all-digital currencies can be used in the same place -- Bitcoin and TF2 hats. Russian criminals and Chinese investors looking to get money out of the country can work together in a new age of unity and togetherness.
- ChemicalWarfare 11y agoCool. This type of market is perfect for Bitcoin: 1. worldwide - which gives them large customer base without access to other methods of payments (unlike US where it's really hard to convince customers to use BTC instead of Credit Cards); 2. Digital goods with licenses that can be revoked - so the merchant doesn't have to worry (too much) about confirmations/double spends and is able to "ship the goods" instantly. They obv have to factor the potential case of tx not going through into their flow to catch these but it can be done without impacting their users whose txs do get confirmed.
- seanalltogether 11y agoDoes steam have to worry about transaction confirmation? I would've assumed that bitpay guarantees the funds to their partners regardless of any potential bitcoin shenanigans.
- ChemicalWarfare 11y agoLooking at bitpay's docs (this is a pretty typical setup), merchant is getting IPNs (aka Webhooks) with invoice statuses based on what is happening with that payment on the Bitcoin network - https://bitpay.com/docs/invoice-states https://bitpay.com/docs/invoice-states. So yes, as a merchant it's up to you if you want to wait until the funds are there (invoice status == 'Complete') or ship as soon as the payment is detected ('Paid' status). Bitpay will obv guarantee for the funds to be there when status moves to 'Complete' otherwise they are risking to get hit with a double spend.
- the_rosentotter 11y agoA transaction would have to be worth thousands of dollars to be worth the effort of setting up a successful double spend attack. For the vast majority of use cases this concern doesn't enter into the picture at all, and an immediate 0-conf transaction is fine.
- ChemicalWarfare 11y ago
- shmerl 11y agoHumble Bundle did in the past, but stopped for some reason. GOG never did so far.
- iso-8859-1 11y agoThe Hacking books Humble Bundle includes a Bitcoin book, and bitcoin is available for payment also. https://www.humblebundle.com/books/no-starch-hacking-books https://www.humblebundle.com/books/no-starch-hacking-books
- shmerl 11y agoInteresting, but I don't see that option in the Humble Store.
- magicfractal 11y agoHow would the DRM zone controls Steam currently have work with this? Before, you needed to have a credit card of the country you're buying the game from.
- pointsphere 11y agoProbably "not at all". I can only assume that the number of buyers using both Bitcoin and a VPN to buy cheaper games is too small to worry about.
- j_s 11y agoSorry I don't have time to dig into their choice of implementation but one way would be for Bitcoin to be a secondary payment option for those who have already registered a credit card.