8 ms·
Personal info of 93M Mexicans exposed on AWS
- partisan 11y ago> Chris decided to report his discovery to the State Department and let them contact their Mexican counterparts in the spirit of cooperation. When he got no meaningful response, he reached out to the State Department’s Office of Mexican Affairs, who told him they would forward his alert up the chain. When that still didn’t achieve the desired results of getting the database secured, Chris contacted the U.S. Secret Service, Department of Homeland Security, and US-CERT I definitely am all for doing the right thing and I might make a best effort in the same situation, but that's pretty gutsy. My overdeveloped sense of paranoia would tell me that contacting these agencies would put me on all sorts of lists I wouldn't want to be on. Who knows how easy it is for "There is a data breach" could become "I have your data, meet my demands".
- arcticfox 11y agoI agree, your sense of paranoia is overdeveloped.
- astrodust 11y agoGiven how the Department of Homeland Security thinks a tiny bottle of mouthwash is a threat to national security, I wouldn't trust them to understand what a computer does.
- arcticfox 11y agoYeah, but that's theater performed by low-wage employees. I think it's extremely unlikely that sending a tip to help higher-level officials isn't going to accidentally get you on some watch list, as long as you're acting in good faith.
- astrodust 11y agoAny organization that hires these security muppets in the first place is not one I'd put any trust in whatsoever. If some awful, unfortunate thing does happen on their watch I honestly hope the first thing they do is get the hell out of the way so professionals can handle the situation.
- lelandbatey 11y ago> Yeah, but that's theater performed by low-wage employees. The status of the people who act out these policies is much less important than who is setting these policies. And it's not low-wage employees who are setting these policies, it's high level bureaucrats, the same bureaucrats who will be in charge of your fate should you report wrongdoing to them.
- riprowan 11y agoTerribly naive view. "Shoot the messenger" is the norm not the exception in a bureaucracy.
- partisan 11y ago@arcticfox How is good will determined if not through a through a thorough investigation.
- adolph 11y agoWho needs punishment when there is plenty of process to apply?
- astrodust 11y agoIt would be nice if there's a department you can trust to handle your report in a way that's both confidential and reliable about getting results. Picking up the phone and calling random departments is how you get in trouble. All it takes is one person to scream "hacker", which is not unlike yelling "fire" in a crowded building, and you've got yourself in hot water even when trying to do the right thing. If there was a number to report security issues of this sort, or an email address if they're that savvy, it would go a long way towards encouraging people to report serious issues.
- qaq 11y agoYou can relax posting this comment will put you on all sorts of lists you did not want to be on.
- jordigh 11y ago93 million Mexicans? That 78% of all Mexicans, essentially every adult. Wow. I'm kind of glad I haven't registered to vote recently, but perhaps my old registration which I haven't renewed is still there. My only consolation is that most of the troublesome information such as occupation and address would be outdated for me.
- necessity 11y agoHere in Brazil there are websites which will give you info (address, telephone, mother's name, even salary) on basically anyone. They take it from CADSUS, i.e. the SUS (publich health system) registration system, which is available for every public hospital to do queries, but those hospitals receive a default and very common username/password combination which they usually don't change. They also take info from credit protection agencies such as Exparin (presumably some employers sell access passwords). It's completely nuts. I always give fake or incomplete information to everyone, private or public (and you must give info for practically anything here). If it's absolutely necessary to give real info, then I never update it.
- cm2187 11y agoEvery year is a new annus horribilis in term of magnitude of personal data leaks, the "other moore's law"...
- jordigh 11y agoThey've identified who leaked the database to AWS: http://www.diariodemexico.com.mx/inemexico-encuentra-quien-filtro-lista-nominal-amazon/ http://www.diariodemexico.com.mx/inemexico-encuentra-quien-f... The government isn't publishing details, but the article gives the impression that it was some Mexican political party acting out of line who should not have uploaded this data to US servers. It appears that each party receives a copy of electoral registrations. ¿Qué chingados? I didn't know every party got a copy of all voter registrations. This seems grossly undemocratic.
- Aelinsaar 11y agoIt seems like a disaster waiting to happ- oh wait, right.
- arcticfox 11y agoIf the government is relying on outside political parties to keep the data secure, it might as well be public anyways.
- Spooky23 11y agoIn the US, voter registration is completely open. You can walk down to your Board of Elections and look at the full register, including party registration and whether you voted or not. For contested elections, party inspectors will note active voters who haven't voted yet and report, which generates phone calls or even volunteers dropping by to drive voters to the polls. IMO, transparency is required for democracy.
- jordigh 11y agoAddress and occupation and whether you have any twins is open too, for the whole country? Can you look this up right now for any adult estadounidense? In Mexico, this isn't transparency, as only the political parties get a copy. This is surveillance, probably used for more effective targetted campaigning, which has historically been used for buying votes. I'm not sure I will ever renew my Mexican voter registration.
- 11y ago
- Aelinsaar 11y agoThe INE really screwed the pooch this time; 93 million is essentially every adult Mexican!
- verelo 11y agoThis title seems a bit off. Mentioning the hosting provider like this almost implies the leak is the fault of AWS, which to me feels like blaming Lexmark for someone printing sensitive info and then leaving it in the printer for others to find it.
- ihsw 11y agoThis happened the same time a while ago -- at the time it was a misconfigured S3 bucket but the title was worded in a way that AWS to blame. This seems to be a misconfigured MongoDB server hosted in AWS but details are scarce. Personally, with the vast swaths of PII data being leaked, I am interested in whether there is a global database of these people yet. Not for nefarious purposes, mind you, but for global legal representation not limited to voting.
- nathancahill 11y ago> misconfigured.. > MongoDB server.. unheard of
- ryanlol 11y agoIt's not misconfigured, this is how mongo is intended to work.
- skj 11y agoIt's misconfigured in that you can reach the host at all.
- kapad 11y agoAny details on what exactly was the misconfiguration in mongo?
- rbanffy 11y agoFor one, it should never have a publicly accessible IP.
- mattbeckman 11y agoMongo used to not support authentication, so it's probably an old version coupled with a public IP or elastic IP.
- username223 11y ago"MacKeeper[1] security researcher?" It's good to know that the crapware you have to remove from your parents' computer, which they installed thanks to dishonest pop-unders, is funding something useful. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mackeeper https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mackeeper
- nathancahill 11y agoHoly shit, I keep removing MacKeeper from my parents computers. Every time I visit. And my dad always gives me a guilty look and says "I shouldn't have installed that again right?"
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- antoncohen 11y agoThat was my reaction too. I looked into it, the MacKeeper security researcher is Chris Vickery. In December 2015, while not employed by MacKeeper, he discovered a database of 13 million MacKeeper usernames and passwords [1]. MacKeeper then hired him in January 2016 to create a "Analytical and Security Center" [2]. [1] http://krebsonsecurity.com/2015/12/13-million-mackeeper-users-exposed/ http://krebsonsecurity.com/2015/12/13-million-mackeeper-user... [2] https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/mackeeper-chris-vickery-launch-security-research-alliance-corp- https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/mackeeper-chris-vickery-launc...
- cstejerean 11y agoAs far as I can tell the article is worded poorly. He doesn't work for MacKeeper, he is the researcher that found a similarly exposed database of 13 million MacKeepe users. http://krebsonsecurity.com/tag/chris-vickery/ http://krebsonsecurity.com/tag/chris-vickery/
- flying_dutchman 11y agoDoes anybody have contact details for Chris? My wife is a journalist in Mexico and looking to get in touch. I have the admin@databreaches.net address
- antoncohen 11y agocvickery@kromtech.com, found at https://mackeeper.com/blog/post/197-the-danger-of-apps-that-die https://mackeeper.com/blog/post/197-the-danger-of-apps-that-....
- imaginenore 11y ago> "and their unique voting credential code (number/identifier)" I find this the most interesting. I thought of a voting system where every citizen gets a unique voting key. It obviously would be a huge mistake to vote directly with such a key. Signing your voting decision makes a lot more sense. This way only the government and you know the key. I wonder what will happen now, looks like they will have to reissue 93M codes.
- icebraining 11y agoIf you sign your voting decision, wouldn't that destroy the anonymity of the vote?
- holiveros 11y agoIt's not a signing code, votes are truly anonymous; it's the unique serial of the physical card and one of the various citizen IDs used in the country. These numbers are typically abused in mass fraud for government monetary/physical goods assistance programs.
- deepnet 11y agoInsufficient security at a national level has been frontpage of hnews all this week from various countries: Turkey, USA, Malaysia, Mexico, &c. From this and many other leaks and breaches from companies, governments & institutions one could deduce security is imperfect & digitally massively so. Identity theft is rampant; Biometrics are irrevocable - yet the solution is used by most people everyday. Cryptography solves both the problem of identity and privacy simultaneously. It is establishable as persona via chains of trust, e.g. PGP signing. Apart from societal control there seems no good reason not to adopt a system whereby everyone is issued a private and public key - which signs every email, bank instruction, comminucation & vote. Akin to good practice being to store only password hashes so only the individual posses the secret. Ones identity would be ones own responsibility and huge leaks like this would reveal nothing but a list of public keys obtainable by crawling the web. One can imagine a dystopian future nation where individuals must fight to protect their basic fundamental rights from state level adverseries operating outside the law - punchline is the worst threat is their own government. Ever since Gibson the best science fiction is set in the present.
- ghughes 11y ago> Apart from societal control there seems no good reason not to adopt a system whereby everyone is issued a private and public key - which signs every email, bank instruction, comminucation & vote. Privacy and key loss are two reasons that come to mind.
- deepnet 11y agoI am not sure I follow your reasoning. Key loss would require re-issue - under the present system that uses real details or a biometric these cannot be revoked so cryptography seems better. The current system the UK uses is a Nation Insurance Number, which is just a key in a government database but once issued it is not revokable either. Solutions like a back up reissue key, or quorum of those who signed you key verify it is lost and then it can be resissued, or an trusted official like ones lawyer - or you have to take some ID to a post office. It may be inconvenient but less inconvenient than identity theft today. As for privacy this is solved by crytography too, so I don't follow your first point. If I wanted to message you privately, I encrypt the message with your public key and then you and only you can read it - just like PGP today. Of course this hypothetical system unbackdoored cryptography would be fully legal so we could have keys just for privacy between us / or verification. A bank could issue a key per account, the key ensures your banking cannot be eavesdropped and ensures the identity for this account.
- savrajsingh 11y agoSearchable database for Oklahoma: http://www.badvoter.org http://www.badvoter.org
- yoo1I 11y ago> Amazon’s automated system for reporting abuse was equally frustrating to navigate, Vickery said. It repeatedly asked him to submit irrelevant information. [0] This is generally a problem I've come across multiple times. Small hosters are usually quicker to respond ( or they don't at all), and then actually try and handle malicious hosts on their networks. The large ones like Amazon or CloudFlare (especially CloudFlare) have a semi-automated process, where the impression I get is that I am talking to a really stupid bot. Or when I get through to a human, that they are so overworked that they aren't able to comprehend the sentences that write to them in plain english, so nothing get's resolved. Or they just forward my info to their customers, which in many cases is a real security risk. [0] http://www.dailydot.com/politics/amazon-mexican-voting-records/ http://www.dailydot.com/politics/amazon-mexican-voting-recor...
- known 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cloud_computing#Private_cloud https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cloud_computing#Private_cloud could have prevented this mess
- jbpadgett 11y agoAccording to the world bank, 2015 population of Mexico is around ~125 million. This means that roughly 75% of the population could be affected. http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.POP.TOTL http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.POP.TOTL
- jeffdavis 11y agoCan someone explain the significance of AWS in this story?
- akerro 11y agoNew ground breaking application written in NJS!
- alex_g 11y agoCan someone explain how MacKeeper was the one to figure this out? I thought all they did was spam the internet with popups.
- SeanDav 11y agoChris got lucky - he is lucky he is not under criminal investigation for hacking or even spying. It is a sad fact that all too often the people who bring attention to data breaches and security issues, get targeted and accused of hacking. The people involved do not want to admit they are at fault, so try to justify this by saying the whistle-blower / good Samaritan are criminally accessing the data. If one discovers a security issue or data breach, it is best to either do nothing, or at most raise the issue very anonymously.
- amelius 11y agoI think it is surprising we didn't see any breach of data from an advertising network yet, given the shady nature of that industry.
- batat 11y agoSomeone should make MongoRoulette.com at last.
- cddotdotslash 11y agoThe article isn't entirely clear how AWS is as fault here. Usually, it comes down to misconfigured AWS settings which are the users' responsibility in the shared security model. A shameless plug, but there are ways to scan your account for these misconfigurations which can lead to leaks like this. I've been working on CloudSploit (https://cloudsploit.com https://cloudsploit.com), an open-source and hosted scanning service that can continually check your accounts for these kinds of risks.