5 ms·
And still no discussion on the value of pissing away our planets energy reserves, just to create imaginary points in a paranoid game. In one view, all the elect
by JoeAltmaier 11y ago
And still no discussion on the value of pissing away our planets energy reserves, just to create imaginary points in a paranoid game. In one view, all the electricity burned to make bitcoins is a crime against the planet.
- eganist 11y agoWell, unless you replace furnaces with bitcoin mining hardware. But then again, I'd rather replace a furnace with a more productive set of hardware anyway.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoHeat pump. EDIT: Unless you live somewhere where the ambient temp goes below ~0F, get a heat pump.
- eganist 11y agoHence furnaces. Unless someone's managed to create servers which become cooler upon load, I'd assume these boxes wouldn't be able to substitute for heat pumps. But in general, I agree with you. :)
- martindevans 11y agoWhat's special about 255K (0F) in relation to heat pumps?
- toomuchtodo 11y agoJust a number I picked from domain knowledge. Almost all newer heat pumps can still efficiently pull heat out of that temperature, although some more expensive ones can go all the way down to -20 - -30F ambient air temp. EDIT: If you're in a colder climate, in-ground coolant loops are preferred over an air transfer heat pump.
- martindevans 11y agoAh I see. So it's nothing fundamental, just a limit on our current heat pump technology.
- wlesieutre 11y agoA couple of things: 1) With electric heat you have to account for the energy production and grid transmission being around 30% efficient. Even though an electric heater or bitcoin miner is converting electricity to heat 100% efficiently, a majority of the thermal energy released in the power plant was already thrown out as waste. 2) Even using electricity, a heat pump beats the electric heaters. They're 2-3x as "efficient" in terms of how much heat it pushes into the house vs how much electricity it takes to do it. Technically this is measured as "coefficient of performance" instead of efficiency, since it's a ratio of heat transferred / energy consumed, rather than energy released / energy consumed (and efficiency >100% wouldn't make much sense). 3) Gas furnaces can be >90% efficient, which also beats the bitcoin miners. Even the lowest efficiency allowed by law (78%) is better than resistive electric. 4) There's more "embodied energy" in building a bitcoin miner than an electric heater, and it has a very short life as a useful miner before it's obseleted by newer chips. Resistive electric heating only makes sense if you're looking for a low cost solution in a climate with a very minor cold season. And I highly doubt anybody's going to buy a bitcoin miner with the intent to only run it 3 weeks a year when it gets chilly outside. Bitcoin is basically a giant scheme to extract as much value for the miners by dumping a bunch of externalities on everyone else in the form of fossil fuel subsidies and greenhouse gas production. Not a fan.
- codyb 11y agoI totally agree, but I'm also curious how expensive in terms of resources distributing paper and metal currency is? Presumably mining zinc, copper, aluminum, etc must have pretty big costs to the environment? Paper is mostly paper but isn't it also some special silk? At least here in the US. Those seem slightly more renewable for paper. But yea, creating an extra power plants worth of fumes is pretty shitty over time. I believe there's one currency which at the very least does some sorts of scientific calculations with the processing power? Maybe we should at least encourage those types of coins.
- icebraining 11y agoBitcoin is basically a giant scheme to extract as much value for the miners by dumping a bunch of externalities on everyone else in the form of fossil fuel subsidies and greenhouse gas production. Not a fan. How is that different from any other of thousands of energy-intensive services?
- cookiecaper 11y agoThe difficulty mechanism has proven to be the Achilles Heel in bitcoin's design and is responsible for the blocksize impasse as well as the waste of infinite CPU-millennia. I'm sure that more interesting negative effects will be observed before the project concludes.
- VMG 11y agoThese "imaginary points" have very useful properties that cannot be achieved any other way. Bitcoin mining is still vastly more efficient and sustainable than gold mining. Edit: dear downvoters, rebuttals are welcome
- icebraining 11y agoI think the belief that they're useful is not widely shared.
- VMG 11y agoDo you know any other "imaginary points" that are scarce and can be transacted in an open system?
- icebraining 11y agoThere are many things that I believe not to exist, which doesn't mean they've be useful if they were, in fact, to exist.
- VMG 11y agoDo you think money is useful? How about digital money?
- icebraining 11y agoThing is, digital money already existed - when my employer pays me, he's not physically handing me an envelope of bills or even writing a check. It is, and has been for quite a few years, digital money.
- VMG 11y agoAnd for a lot of applications trusted third parties are completely sufficient, but in many instances you're better off without.
- ethanbond 11y agoI think it's a worse crime to say that because you have access to a stable, relatively apolitical currency, that no one else needs one. Bitcoin could be hugely beneficial for fledgling financial systems, and robust financial systems can be hugely beneficial for billions of people. Our energy crisis was not created by, and will not be solved by, Bitcoin. Numerous monetary crises could be addressed in serious ways by it, though.
- a_humean 11y agoI think many people would say that bitcoins aren't apolitical, but a new kind of gold buggery. Making it difficult in principle for a government treasury or a central bank to make certain kinds of decisions about monetary policy is political.
- VMG 11y agoI guess it's political in the same was as encryption is. Encryption makes it difficult for the government to make certain kinds of decisions as well.
- a_humean 11y agoYes, but in the case of encryption we have competing issues relating to commerce, privacy, crime, and national security that have to be considered and weighed - which is a political process. In the case of gold buggery all we have is a political ideology of unrelenting suspicion of government trying to enforce through law or technology ideas about monetary policy that fall well outside of the economic mainstream all in service of depriving government of tools we know to be very effective at influencing the economy.
- VMG 11y agoWould you say the suspicion is justified in, say, Venezuela or Zimbabwe?
- 11y ago
- gnaritas 11y agoBecause that point is just silly, far more energy is burned on the old system making paper bills than on bitcoin; don't hear you complaining about that. If energy is such a big concern to you, why aren't you screaming to replace the old energy inefficient system with the new more energy efficient bitcoin?
- VMG 11y ago> Because that point is just silly, far more energy is burned on the old system making paper bills than on bitcoin; Plus they still manage to destroy economies with hyperinflation. They're more wasteful in providing a worse product.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agocitation needed. There is no limit to the energy burned to create bitcoins; it is increasing by design. And, other digital currency implementation don't require 'mining' at all; just the paranoid ones.
- EdHominem 11y agoThe ones that don't involve a small list of nodes that you are required to trust to get anything done.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoExactly. Its a matter of trust (i.e. the paranoid part), and we're burning the planet's limited resources so that we feel better about that.
- EdHominem 11y agoDo you know how many resources we "waste" making non-copyable bills, staffing the Secret Service, running payment networks, etc?
- gnaritas 11y ago
- blah5432 11y agoall the electricity burned to make bitcoins is a crime against the planet Actually I'm happy to have a chance to say this: Fuck the planet.
- CyberDildonics 11y agoThis is so misguided I can barely think of a place to start. Do you think the current financial system is optimal? The financial industry currently makes up 8% of the entire US economy. Do you realize that bitcoin mining hashes and the number of transactions they can process are not linked?
- icebraining 11y agoOne may believe that the current system is not optimal, yet not believe that Bitcoin is improvement. As for the transactions vs hashes correlation, while technically true, in practice the two are inevitably linked, as the currency must be protected proportionally to the sums it manages. As more value is stored and transacted, so the incentive to attack it increases, and so an increase in the cost of attacking it is required. Though it might trail off at some point, Bitcoin's history has shown this relation to exist.
- MichaelBurge 11y agoDoes the 'financial industry' include loans, insurance, and stock brokers? Or - this being compared to Bitcoin - are you strictly speaking about 8% of the economy being devoted to maintaining point-to-point transfers of money using credit cards, checks, or wire transfers? In practice ACH transfers within the United States are free and clear within a few days(giving you time to catch fraud). There's also very little technical barrier to transferring money abroad, although there is risk to the bank. Credit cards are a different matter. They have to clear instantly so the merchant is guaranteed payment(excepting a chargeback). Bitcoin (usually) clears in an hour, or at least 10 minutes, so it's unsuitable for realtime financial transactions unless you build a financial industry on top of it to mitigate risk.
- brighton36 11y agoYou're correct. The problem is that bitcoin exists due to holes in the regulatory structure. People mine because people need anonymous value transfers. If you allow people to purchase drugs/gamble/capital-flight/etc with credit cards, then this externality cost will go away :)
- VMG 11y agoEven then, you'd still need a fair way of distributing the initial value. Mining provides censorship-resistance and transparent issuance.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoBut the 'transparent issuance' is 'give value to those that piss away the most resources'. That's got to be the worst solution for the planet we could imagine. Other solutions: issue more value to those already holding more value. Issue more value to those holding less value. Issue more value in the form of credit transactions within the community. In fact, since imaginary value points are real numbers, just revalue what's there? Its not like we'll run out of fractions. Imagine if you will that only 1 bitcoin was ever issued. Folks trade around ever-decreasing fractional numbers (milli-coins? nano-coins?).
- VMG 11y agoBelieve it or not, people have thought about these things. Mining wasn't chosen because the developers love destroying the environment, but because it's the only way to bootstrap the system and keep it going. It's a system to distribute scarce tokens as fairly as possible. At the beginning, you could just do it on your own computer device. Now the space is much more specialized, the barriers to entry is much higher, but anyone can still participate. > issue more value to those already holding more value Again, how should the initial units be distributed fairly? Besides, this system is not attractive to latecomers and will end even more centralized that the current system. > Issue more value to those holding less value. So I just create free new identities out to get the scarce tokens? Then the tokens are not that scarce, are they? > Issue more value in the form of credit transactions within the community. Not sure what you even mean here. > Imagine if you will that only 1 bitcoin was ever issued. A Bitcoin already is divisible into 100 million Satoshis. Mining is a solution to the question who gets the tokens.
- codehalo 11y agoSomewhere out there some God is cursing another God for pissing away an entire sun just for some puny humans.
- 27182818284 11y agoI've never mined, but the serious miners I did know because energy is expensive, sought other means to power it like sheds with solar etc.
- hasch 11y agominers do more than just burning energy, and without this mechanism, the price can't be justified. a really forward looking perspective is, how a structure on top could be created to leverage bitcoin without mining. if you figure out something clever, you can call yourself the saviour of the planet :-)
- nostrebored 11y agoSavior of the planet? Bitcoin without mining is just fiat money sans government. Bitcoin is not necessary. The environment is. Easier solution is stop operating a power plant to play speculator on play money.
- schmichael 11y ago> miners do more than just burning energy, and without this mechanism, the price can't be justified The price is based on utility of the commodity and speculation about its future utility, not mining costs. Put another way: more hash power does not raise the value but more value may raise the hash power (by making it profitable for less efficient miners to mine). > how a structure on top could be created to leverage bitcoin without mining. There's lots of activity around alternatives to bitcon's proof-of-work based mining: proof of stake, proof of activity, etc. Just search "proof of work alternatives"
- Shorel 11y agoIt could be argued that the electricity burned to make and watch reality shows is an ever bigger crime, in both terms of total energy wasted and the utility to the human species.