7 ms·
Watchya gonna do about it? Amazon makes merchants an "offer they can't refuse." Fear of Amazon cloning your product (whether physical via Amazon Basics, or virt
by chatmasta 11y ago
Watchya gonna do about it? Amazon makes merchants an "offer they can't refuse." Fear of Amazon cloning your product (whether physical via Amazon Basics, or virtual via AWS) is not enough reason to avoid selling on Amazon altogether.
If your product is easily cloned by Amazon, and you cannot afford to sell it for less than Amazon, then you do not deserve to have the dominant market position.
A good, sustainable product is more than just marketing and engineering. It must also be defensible, meaning you need to have an advantage in either product-development (patents, expertise, first-mover advantages) or supply-chain (exclusive manufacturing contracts, access to greater economies of scale). It's almost impossible to beat Amazon in the supply-chain economics, unless you have a highly specialized product and deals with the manufacturer, so you are left to compete in product development. Your product needs to be sufficiently innovative and defensible in order to avoid Amazon cloning it.
- x5n1 11y agoAmazon has economy of scale, it can make deals for more units and therefore drive down the cost. It also has negotiating and brand power to coerce suppliers to give a better price much like Wal-mart. Amazon competing with its own retailers is a stupid idea and will cause many of them to pull away. Say you offer 1,000 products. Do you really want Amazon knowing which ones are popular? Just like everything else is now the case with Amazon. You can't build your own business on someone else's platform. Hell if they start stealing data from AWS from their competitors I would run like hell away from their services. What you are going to do about it is run away from Amazon. That's what.
- chatmasta 11y agoSure, you can run away from Amazon. But then you lose the marketing, fulfillment, and shipping channels offered by Amazon that you cannot possibly achieve yourself. Many customers will only purchase from Amazon, not some janky online store where they need to enter their credit card number. So you lose those. And you could contract with custom fulfillment centers and achieve two day shipping, but you're not going to be able to offer the shipping for free (prime), and the fulfillment will cost you more than Amazon unless you're moving huge volume. If you offer 1,000 products, as you say, then you're in the wrong business. Did you develop every one of those products? I highly doubt it. So you are just a store selling thousands of products from different manufacturers. In that sense, you are a competitor to Amazon. How can you possible beat them? You've already lost. The article is not referring to selling thousands of products, it's referring to developing and selling one single, specialized product, and then getting it "stolen" by Amazon. In this case, you are not originally competing with Amazon, but rather using their platform to sell your product. Once they clone your product, then you are competing with Amazon. At that point, if you have not established defensibility, you deserve to be undercut by Amazon. There are many ways to establish defensibility: patents (Amazon cannot clone your product without paying a license fee); branding (customers will only buy your product, not some cheap clone); custom development (Amazon cannot clone your product without hiring specialized experts). If you are selling some cheap run-of-the-mill product from China, and all you have for defensibility is branding, then you are going to lose to Amazon. But if you have invested years of experience and engineering talent into a custom product protected by strong patents, and branded it well enough that customers know the product is only good if it comes from you, then you will beat Amazon and you can sell to their customers without worrying about getting cloned.
- NicoJuicy 11y agoYour perception will bancrupt 99% of smb's and remove all wellfare for the middle class
- chatmasta 11y agoWhy should consumers pay a tax to keep SMBs alive? If Amazon can offer the same product for cheaper than anyone else, what right does a SMB have to charge consumers more for it?
- llamataboot 11y agohmmm, talking about "rights" might not be the way to look at this. talking about systemic effects might be a better way. consumers aren't just consumers after all, they're also usually employees. What are the effects, both positive and negative of having such a large company be able to dominate supply chains so much that they can often bring equivalent quality products to market for cheaper. It's a complicated question, not as easy as the moralizing on either side. Amazon and WalMart bad! Amazon and WalMart good!
- NicoJuicy 11y agoThen remove all workforce and automate everything.. No seriously, read this: http://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/sustainable-fashion-blog/2015/feb/13/second-hand-clothes-charity-donations-africa http://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/sustainable-... ,It's why second hand clothing is sold in africa and not given away.
- Spooky23 11y agoA robust market is in everyone's interest. See: railroads 100 years ago.
- GFischer 11y agoSMBs need to add value on either location and convenience, or service. It's something that has been long studied by management experts (see Porter's Competitive Advantage): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Competitive_advantage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Competitive_advantage If you want them to compete on Amazon's ground, they will lose.
- morgante 11y agoDo you really think Amazon's proprietary data is that essential? Even if this product were not sold on Amazon it would be easy to see that pursuing it would be profitable. It's high margin and obviously popular. It's hard to keep those facts secret for long. The fact that the project was originally sold through Amazon is really just a red herring. Companies have been entering competition with high-margin incumbents for centuries. This is just capitalism at its finest: the world does not owe you a business model, and you cannot expect to capture excess profits on stable product lines for long. Either scale or innovate (preferably both).
- blakeyrat 11y agoApple's done this for years. Most recent case I can recall is that f.lux program on iOS. AFAIK, people kind of mildly call them out on it and then forget about it a week later. It certainly hasn't seemed to actually damage Apple's business at all.
- MBCook 11y agoThe term for that is Sherlocking, referencing a 3rd party tool they 'integrated' in either OS 8 or OS 9 (sorry, don't remember exactly). I'd argue the f.lux case is a bit different. Either way, haven't big retailers (Walmart, BestBuy, etc.) always done this?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- chc 11y agoFor anyone curious: The third-party tool was Karelia's Watson, which was a tool that let you search websites, with the ability to add support for new websites through plug-ins. In OS X 10.2, Apple added the same functionality to their "find file" tool Sherlock (and IMO made the program worse than either Sherlock or Watson were on their own).
- MBCook 11y agoOh, I thought it was earlier than that. I also couldn't remember if Sherlock was the Apple tool or the 3rd party one. I didn't come back to the Mac until a hair before 10.4, so I don't have first hand experience.
- mesh 11y agoThey have also done this with Spotlight, taking over functionality of app launchers / utilities like Quicksilver and Alfred.
- chc 11y agoFunnily enough, Apple also got into competition with Karelia's next product, Sandvox, when they released iWeb. That didn't seem to kill Sandvox the way Sherlock did Watson, though.
- capote 11y ago> It's almost impossible to beat Amazon in the supply-chain economics, unless you have a highly specialized product and deals with the manufacturer Yeah. And the opposite of a highly specialized product is exactly the example the article gave--a piece of metal to hold up your laptop. I don't think there's anything we stand to lose from this happening to products so simple and generic. Or is there?
- tryitnow 11y agoThe biggest risk is that Amazon will act as a monopoly and jack up the prices of the products once it's destroyed competitors. Honestly, I don't think that's too likely as amazon's business model is built around razor-thin margins.
- MichaelBurge 11y agoA monopoly on pieces of metal shaped a certain way? I feel like both of your sentences are unnecessarily abstract here.
- perezdev 11y agoThat's super unlikely to happen. At least with a product like this. Jacking up the price would just encourage other manufacturers to do the same as Amazon: release a cheaper product. What Amazon has done is best for the consumer.
- adventured 11y agoThat isn't going to happen. See: Walmart's Great Value brand products. Walmart has used it for a long time to hold consumer prices in check. If Nabisco attempts a large price hike, Walmart deploys their Great Value brand right next to said Nabisco product and undercuts them down to a price they regard as reasonable. Despite Walmart's extreme size and market dominance in traditional retail over the last ~20 years, they've never used - at a wide scope - their Great Value brand as an opportunity jack up prices or destroy competitors.
- dragonwriter 11y agoNo, the biggest risk is that Amazon will kill innovation by reducing the expected returns to product development expenditures so that investment in product development is reduced.
- lcfcjs 11y agoThis bit: "If your product is easily cloned by Amazon, and you cannot afford to sell it for less than Amazon, then you do not deserve to have the dominant market position." This is exactly how people should view it. If you want to compete in a competitive market, then you have to be prepared for competitors.
- dragonwriter 11y agoWhat to do about it? One thing might be to not invest in any company that is dependent on a retail sales channel that doesn't have a specific plan to avoid getting Amazoned this way. Amazon's basically found a great way to free ride on other firms product and market development -- which is fine, up until the reduced expected return from those investments dry up capital to invest in those areas for products that might be exposed to Amazon's tactics. Oh, you mean what for existing firms with business models that are threatened...
- bencollier49 11y ago> Whatchya gonna do about it? Break up Amazon a la Bell. It's an abusive monopoly. I'm sure the European Union will get around to doing this before long.