11 ms·
How cheap does solar power need to get before it takes over the world?
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoIt says a lot about the progress of solar if the big worry is that it won't provide 100% of all energy by itself. Even cheaper solar would be nice but I'm not sure why it would be better than a radical battery breakthrough or some cheap and cheerful fusion thing or some mix of different solutions.
- Gibbon1 11y agoIf you run the numbers pumped heat storage can likely do the job of time shifting electric power from daylight hours to night time. The pricing structure will flip though, electricity at night costing probably 2-3 times peek daytime rates. One would expect industrial users would adjust and avoid using power at night[1]. That would reduce demand. [1] Think of a mini-mill (steel) that currently runs its electric furnaces at night when rates are cheap. If rates are cheaper in the day they'll switch to daytime operation.
- spacecowboy_lon 11y agoI thought blast furnaces ran 24/7 and if they shut down you need to effectively rebuild parts of them.
- Gibbon1 11y agoYou are correct integrated mills use blast furnaces and thus can't stop. However Mini mills are secondary producers. They process scrap into finished steel. Since they use electric furnaces they can start and stop production.
- omginternets 11y agoMy biggest concern with solar power (which, by the way, may be based on outdated information) is that the production of photovoltaic cells produce more greenhouse gasses than will be spared in the cell's operational lifetime. To ask an actual question: is this still the case? (Was it ever?)
- api 11y agoThis is directly tied to EROEI. If the EROEI of a cell is greater than 1X, it will produce more energy that it took to manufacture it. In that case it's net-negative -- over time it replaces fossil fuels in a net sense. Lately I've read EROEI numbers for solar PV from 10-15X. So no, this is not true, and likely has not been true for a long time. It might have been true back when PV was kind of a lab curiosity and niche item.
- Gibbon1 11y agoThe interesting thing is the EROEI (energy returned on energy invested) for oil and gas has been falling for a century. I remember reading somewhere a claim that historical EROEI for crude oil. Year EROEI 1920 125 1970 30 2010 15 Things like tar sands are less than 10.
- samatman 11y agoAccording to this[0], solar panels are currently net energy producers, and are on track to get 'out of debt' by 2020. [0] http://www.popsci.com/science/article/2013-04/solar-panels-now-make-more-electricity-they-use http://www.popsci.com/science/article/2013-04/solar-panels-n...
- strommen 11y agoI'd like to thoroughly debunk this myth with a more illustrative reference[1]. Over its entire lifecycle, utility-scale photovoltaic power creates 48g of CO2-equivalent emissions per kWh. Natural gas emits 10x this; coal 17x. Furthermore: the majority of PV emissions are dictated by manufacturing processes, which will probably get cleaner and more efficient over time. The emissions of coal and gas are dictated by chemistry, and will never change. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Life-cycle_greenhouse-gas_emissions_of_energy_sources https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Life-cycle_greenhouse-gas_emis...
- paulsutter 11y agoStorage is the /only/ way for solar to provide baseload power. Pumped water storage is vastly cheaper than batteries, and a better example of grid scale storage today. I should add that battery prices are coming down as volume increases (manufacturing learning curve), but not as fast as photovoltaic cells. Elon Musk's goal with tesla is to boost battery production volume significantly to reduce the cost of batteries. This is a really low quality article.
- eru 11y agoPumped water storage is awesome where you have the geography to support it. Alas, that's not everywhere.
- ISL 11y agoFurthermore, mountains, canyons, and valleys are beautiful and valuable as they are.
- tonyedgecombe 11y agoThat hasn't stopped us digging them up for coal though.
- paulsutter 11y agoStorage is the /only/ way for solar to provide baseload power. Pumped water is vastly cheaper than batteries, and a better example of grid scale storage today. I should add that battery prices are coming down as volume increases (manufacturing learning curve), but not as fast as photovoltaic cells. Elon Musk's goal with tesla is to boost battery production volume significantly to reduce the cost of batteries. This is a really low quality article.
- Animats 11y agoInstallation has to get much cheaper. Installation is now more than the cost of the panels for most single family home installations. Home roofs are poor support surfaces. Panels which are the roof have potential. The "solar shingle" vendors are making progress.[1] [1] http://msdssearch.dow.com/PublishedLiteratureDOWCOM/dh_0944/0901b80380944dfa.pdf http://msdssearch.dow.com/PublishedLiteratureDOWCOM/dh_0944/...
- dangravell 11y agoRight. And that works for new build. But for the vast majority of dwellings that means removing a roof, which doesn't exactly lower the installation cost...
- Gravityloss 11y agoI'm amazed that they aren't integrated much more. Roof materials already have a cost. For example, one could create big roof tiles that are mostly solar panel. Edges have to overlap so it's a good idea to not have the panel extend there. One could lay them like other traditional flat panels, in an overlapping fashion. Since the actual panel is so cheap, that shouldn't bring up the cost of the roof panel much. The wiring can be on the underside and can be then connected after construction. (By some other team than roof constructors). After 30 years, they can be swapped. There might be some new technology then. Another alternative would be roll-out plastic panels on ordinary roof materials. External wiring. Everything should be laughably easy if you don't need to deal with snow and ice. They are a whole new design problem. To best limit CO2 emissions, the manufactured panels should be installed in places with best production ability, so freezing tends not to be among the first problems.
- jimrandomh 11y agoThere's an economics caveat to interpreting solar prices, which I think may have put a lot of people on the wrong track. Suppose solar panels were priced such that, after accounting for installation costs and subsidies and everything else, solar was much cheaper than grid power and paid off quickly. Then pretty much everyone would want one, and the manufacturer would have a huge backorder. So the manufacturers wouldn't do that; instead, they'd price the panels a little higher, sell everything they could produce but not have the backorder, and invest the extra money into expanding their production capacity. I think this is where we're currently at; solar power is in fact cheaper than grid power, it's just priced to support investment into expanding the manufacturing/installation capacity to properly take over.
- losvedir 11y ago> Suppose solar panels were priced such that, after accounting for installation costs and subsidies and everything else, solar was much cheaper than grid power and paid off quickly. Then pretty much everyone would want one, and the manufacturer would have a huge backorder. So the manufacturers wouldn't do that; instead, they'd price the panels a little higher, sell everything they could produce but not have the backorder, and invest the extra money into expanding their production capacity. That's what finance is for. I assume if this were actually the case, wouldn't the manufacturers _take_ the backorders and separately raise money for expanding their production capacity? I don't buy it.
- eru 11y agoManufacturers will sell as expensive as they can get away with. Of course, there's decent competition in this market to counteract that. jimrandomh's scheme would require a significant amount of collusion between all major producers.
- jimrandomh 11y agoNo, it's just that building a solar-panel factory is really expensive and has a longer lead time than customers will wait.
- martinald 11y agoI think the issue is that OK, say we managed to get to 100% electricity being solar when the sun is shining. You'd still have the time the sun is not shining, which would likely be more expensive than before (a gas powered plant would only be running half the time - effectively doubling its capital/construction cost per kWh). So you'd definitely have an improvement on some levels but I'm not sure that would really help that much. The real big breakthrough would be somme big improvement on storage. I'm not convinced this will happen quickly (at least not in anyway similar to the declining cost of PV panels). The consumer electronics industry has been paying $$$ for decades for better batteries/battery r&d and has seen pretty poor gains. I think Tesla and the electric car manufacturers will definitely rapidly get the price down by say 30% because of economies of scale but will then hit a brick wall as more of the cost becomes raw materials, transport, etc which will set a floor on the cost of batteries. Happy to be proved wrong though :)
- oolongCat 11y agoIf the whole world could get their s* together, we can perhaps have a worldwide grid.
- CapitalistCartr 11y agoElectricity transmission is constrained by line loss, which is proportionate to amperage. To minimize it, voltage is raised to as much as over a million volts, keeping amperage down. This makes for very serious cross-country transmission lines, and electric companies still lose a quarter of the generated power to it. In my opinion, the two great strengths of solar are cleaner power and localizing power generating with its use.
- marshray 11y agoProportional to the square of current (amperage). Or alternatively, inversely proportional to the square of voltage.
- almostarockstar 11y ago
- coredog64 11y agoThere's another large effect that is left out of this story. As solar gets cheaper, and as we get more of it, it reduces the marginal pressure on fossil fuel production. That, in turn, makes fossil fuels cheaper and forces solar to get cheaper still to compete.
- foota 11y agoAs less oil is produced though it will also likely decrease the returns to scale that I assume exist.
- dredmorbius 11y agoSolar doesn't much compete with petroleum. Its main effect is to reduce prices for coal. You'd expect that this might start to affect the profitability of coal companies eventualy.... For solar to affect petroleum, whose primary use is transport, we'll need to solve the storage problem. Tesla notwithstanding that has not happened. Electric vehicle sales were 0.66% of unit auto sales in 2015, and actually represented a sharp numeric decrease from 2014. (The dollar volume is higher given the higher price of electrics, but it's unit sales you want to watch.)
- pdonis 11y ago> For solar to affect petroleum, whose primary use is transport, we'll need to solve the storage problem. The obvious solution here is solar-generated biofuel, such as the algae projects now being investigated.
- dredmorbius 11y agoHANNP is still your limiting factor. Algae offers at best about 1,000 gallons/acre/yr. That's good, but small relative to utilisation. https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/2cvap7/the_intractable_problem_of_biomass_for_fuels_is/ https://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/2cvap7/the_int...
- ThrustVectoring 11y agoThat's not necessarily the correct solution - there's competing chemical processes like Fischer-Tropsch.
- Spooky23 11y agoA: It needs to get efficient enough and paired with storage to survive the regulatory kickback. Power companies and non-solar ratepayers will get increasingly unhappy with net metering customers. That joyride will end.
- alexc05 11y agoI think the biggest impediment to widescale solar adoption is legeslative. If you follow hackernews, you'll regularly see articles about places like Florida (and possibly Nevada if memory serves) where solar could easily power homes, but disingenuous legislative instruments and manipulativly worded ballot initiatives are housed to effectively block solar adoption. This is an example of the top result in Google news http://www.miamiherald.com/news/local/news-columns-blogs/fred-grimm/article69905142.html http://www.miamiherald.com/news/local/news-columns-blogs/fre... Not the greatest example I've seen, but again, if you follow HN you've seen variations on this story dozens of times. Lobbyists protect big utilities instead of facilitate solar. It's tragic to think how much further along we could be.
- kitsunesoba 11y agoAnother example of what you mentioned: http://arstechnica.com/science/2015/12/north-carolina-citizenry-defeat-pernicious-big-solar-plan-to-suck-up-the-sun/ http://arstechnica.com/science/2015/12/north-carolina-citize...
- alexc05 11y agoThat reads like satire.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Osiris30 11y agoThis is a poorly researched article with many inaccuracies. (1) Utility Scale Solar is already less <$1/W installed in India, and heading for sub $1.5/W in US. (2) The price of Solar PV panels is already at $0.40/W. US-based $FSLR is has a roadmap to get to $0.25/W by 2019. In addition PV efficiency is increasing by 10% yoy. This is just from purely riding the 'industrial learning curve'. See [1]. (3) "Value deflation" is a policy issue that has a simple policy solution. As a tech that produces an intermittent product, but has high fixed-costs but zero-marginal costs - solar (like wind) should be financed (and paid for) via a fixed tariff (feed-in tariff or FiT). See [2]. This is how Solar is financed in the rest of the world outside the US. If 'value deflation actually became an issue - then my guess is that regulators in the US would step in (but one can never say with US regulators who tend to get captured by various lobby groups). (4) Solar will account for 30% of all new capacity power additions going forward globally. This is happening - now. There is over 100,000MW installed globally already. In addition - every time solar or wind comes up for discussion on HN or elsewhere, the same misconceptions and confusions about baseload, intermittency and costs arise. To summarise the counter-points again: (1) Renewables does not need to be base-load or compared to 'base-load'. 'Base-load' is spectrum not a point. See [3] (2) There is a difference between intermittent and 'unplanned'. Planned vs unplanned is the main issue. Even nuclear has unplanned shut-downs - no tech has a 100% 'capacity factory' running 24/7 365 days. see [4] (3) Renewables can get to 60-80% penetration via: (a) increasing efficiencies (happening now) (b) increasing energy storage efficiencies with declining prices (happening now) (c) geographical grid-integration (happening slowly) (d) more flexible software-led demand-side and supply-side management (happening). See [5] [1] http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-04-14/first-solar-making-panels-more-cheaply-than-china-s-top-supplier http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-04-14/first-sola... [2] http://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/3-ways-renewable-energy-can-grow-in-a-21st-century-grid http://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/3-ways-renewable... [3] http://cleantechnica.com/2016/03/02/base-load-power-is-a-myth-used-for-defending-the-fossil-fuel-industry/ http://cleantechnica.com/2016/03/02/base-load-power-is-a-myt... and http://cleantechnica.com/2014/08/08/rmi-blows-lid-baseload-power-myth-video/ http://cleantechnica.com/2014/08/08/rmi-blows-lid-baseload-p... [short video in article] [4] http://www.energypost.eu/dispelling-nuclear-baseload-myth-nothing-renewables-cant-better/ http://www.energypost.eu/dispelling-nuclear-baseload-myth-no... [5] Links on renewable energy penetration potential - NREL Analysis of how to achieve high-penetration renewables in US http://www.nrel.gov/analysis/re_futures/ http://www.nrel.gov/analysis/re_futures/ - Ramez Naam http://rameznaam.com/2016/01/31/how-far-can-renewables-go-pretty-darn-far/ http://rameznaam.com/2016/01/31/how-far-can-renewables-go-pr... - California http://ww2.kqed.org/science/2016/04/04/what-will-california-do-with-too-much-solar/ http://ww2.kqed.org/science/2016/04/04/what-will-california-...
- alok-g 11y ago>> 25 cents per watt by 2050 — down from around $3 per watt today Can I trust a report that does not even have the units right?! Price should be proportional to energy (i.e., Joules or Watt-seconds) not power (Watts).
- acchow 11y agoBoth are relevant. The government and companies probably build capacity in watts (power), but consumers purchase actual joules (energy).
- smac8 11y agoHuh? What's wrong with measuring in price/watt? Price/watt is actually the standard for comparing electricity generation due to not having to create arbitrary units of time to compare with
- _fizz_buzz_ 11y agoNo, it shouldn't be Ws. It's the ratio of the manufacturing cost per rated power of PV-modules.
- ScottBurson 11y agoYou're mistaken. Fuel is sold by price/energy, effectively, but generating capacity is sold by price/power. Since in the case of solar PV, the "fuel" is free, the only cost worth mentioning is the capacity cost.
- gozur88 11y agoInstalled capacity is normally measured in watts. It's really only valuable for trending within the same technology, though, unless you include the capacity factor.
- jwingy 11y agoA significant impediment is handling peak usage power. Maybe solar can provide most of our energy needs, but for those times where peak power is needed, it's probably more sensible to take a more balanced/mixed approach. *edit looks like the article has a convenient link to another article talking about this exact problem: http://www.vox.com/2016/2/12/10970858/flattening-duck-curve-renewable-energy http://www.vox.com/2016/2/12/10970858/flattening-duck-curve-...
- InclinedPlane 11y agoPeople are comparing the wrong things when it comes to solar, and that leads to solar not showing how expensive it truly is. For one, there is nowhere where solar is the baseload power, because it can't be, so it gets a bit of a "free rider" advantage. For another, solar plants depreciate like any other, but those costs aren't really factored in to a lot of solar power costs yet. We'd need to build out a significant amount of energy storage capacity and change a lot of the grid as well in order to fully adopt solar as a baseload power source. And that would increase its cost by non-trivial factors. Would it still be worthwhile? Maybe?
- RNiK 11y agoRight now there are 2 different articles on Hacker News front page stating the opposite (almost). Bloomberg article (http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-04-14/first-solar-making-panels-more-cheaply-than-china-s-top-supplier http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-04-14/first-sola...) states the following: "First Solar is producing panels for as little as 40 cents a watt, or about 15 percent less than China’s Trina Solar Ltd. In 2019, First Solar’s module cost could be as low as 25 cents a watt, according to analysts’ models.". VOX article (http://www.vox.com/2016/4/18/11415510/solar-power-costs-innovation http://www.vox.com/2016/4/18/11415510/solar-power-costs-inno...) states the following: "How cheap? Sivaram and Kann argue that the industry should set a goal of pushing the installed price of solar to 25 cents per watt by 2050 — down from around $3 per watt today."