10 ms·
Study: people who grow up poor have a harder time regulating their food intake
- pbhjpbhj 11y ago>higher socioeconomic households What does this mean, is it a standard definition in the field? Do they just mean "rich" or something else?
- oldmanjay 11y agoIt's an interesting connection. Too bad the article veers off into fantasy land so they can posit vastly complicated triggers for the observation.
- qntty 11y agoIsn't making sense of data by proposing possible explanatory frameworks the essence of scientific theory? Are you just anxious to see evidence that could possibly support or deny their theories? Or are you categorically opposed to thinking beyond the most literal interpretation of data? Where do ideas for experiments come from if not somone's unsupported fantasies?
- jessriedel 11y ago> Where do ideas for experiments come from if not somone's unsupported fantasies? They come from small, modest guesses in accordance with Occam's razor. You have got to be able to distinguish between (1) reasonable hypothesis generation and (2) unhinged fantasies with a thousand moving parts unsupported by data.
- qntty 11y agoThe fact that a single experiment needs to be an attempt to test a modest guess doesn't mean that this is how every scientist experiences the process of coming up with ideas for experiments. There is nothing about doing science that requires you to refuse to fantasize about the big picture, even if the big picture has a million moving parts (which it always does in social science).
- jessriedel 11y agoAs a physicist, sometimes I sit in my bathtub and fantasize about the possibility that the entire observable universe is a big simulation run by aliens. But I don't publish it in the Washington Post. The social sciences do not have a good track record when it comes to their unhinged theorizing.
- qntty 11y agoI don't think that this article says anything that could really be called unhinged for a popular exposition of psychology. Plus, some fields of social science would do better if they existed merely as a way of giving people more accurate fantasies of how the world works. Better than existing as think tanks for political causes.
- jacinda 11y agoYou may not, but other people do. --- Bostrom goes so far as to say that unless we rule out the possibility that a machine could create a simulation of a human existence, we should assume that it is overwhelmingly likely that we are living in such a simulation. “I’m not sure that I’m not already in a machine,” he said calmly. http://www.washingtonpost.com/sf/national/2015/12/27/aianxiety/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/sf/national/2015/12/27/aianxie... ---
- stordoff 11y ago> unless we rule out the possibility that a machine could create a simulation of a human existence Even if we rule that out, doesn't the possibility that we are in a simulation still exist? Maybe the creators of the simulation exist in an n-dimensional space, and the reality we experience is a gross simplification of that. TBH, I find the idea comforting in a weird sort of way, as it gives a structure to everything (e.g. Of course quantum states only collapse when observed - why bother simulating something no one is looking at?).
- skybrian 11y agoI don't see any complicated hypotheses in the article. They are all fairly simple and plausible enough to be worth testing.
- tehwebguy 11y agoMaybe it's just the snacks
- ktRolster 11y agoShe also says that just because the pattern exists, doesn't mean it's not something we can change. "There's no reason to think we can't help them override this."
- slicktux 11y agoYes, I learned about this behavior in Introduction to Psychology; ever since I find myself learning more from people's behavior than ever before; after all that is psychology, the study of mental processes and behavior. The article is spot on. . .Overall, I think more emphasis should be put on the aspect of nature and nurture side of science to the application of understanding the people around with inclusion of holistic treatment for individuals; that is if one grew up poor can we than maybe attribute the cause of obesity to the psychological aspect and if they did not grow up poor then maybe we can attribute obesity and over consumption to sedentary lifestyle and relaxed selective pressure and mal-adaptation to the new environment. . . that is thrifty hypothesis. . .
- mattmurdog 11y agoI knew a guy who grew up poor and as a result he didn't have much to eat growing up. So whenever he had free food he'd eat/steal as much as he can because he'd never know when his next meal might be.
- nsajko 11y agoThe cause could be that people with poor SES still have worse nutrition (lack of some nutrients) and thus the urge to consume. (I mean, in addition to the urge caused by malnutrition in childhood.)
- wadetandy 11y agoExcept in the study they found that people who were in higher socioeconomic status now still had the issue. This wouldn't apply most likely, as they most likely more healthy and well nourished now
- usrusr 11y agoNot necessarily, wealth alone may not be enough to change established habits. The overeating could be related to "bluff food" that tastes like it would supply much of a given nutrient which it actually lacks. In that case, the direct cause would be the body trying to compensate a low level of that nutrient by eating more of the food that tastes like it would contain it. And while wealth might help to not even start with that bluff food trap, getting wealthy after establishing a habit for it will just allow to buy more.
- im3w1l 11y agoI've been idly thinking about bluff food as well, thanks for putting a name on it. Is there evidence for the concept, do we crave bluff food that corresponds to our deficiencies? What are the most common kinds of bluff food and do you think anything could be done about it?
- usrusr 11y agoSorry, no citable sources, just reading between the lines of "processed food is bad" and the dissatisfying explanations usually given in that context. What we do know is that animals and humans have a natural ability to balance their diet (by developing seemingly random cravings?) and that this ability is increasingly breaking down in "western civilisation". It is a small jump from that to the idea that market driven "yummy engineering" could be the perfect setup to find the fault lines in our diet balancing instincts.
- harryjo 11y agoCan we get a mod practice to rewrite WaPo's clickbait titles into proper summary headlines?
- dang 11y agoAbsolutely. That's the practice universally (i.e. not for just one publication, but all). https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11516590 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11516590 It just takes a while for us to see them sometimes. You can always email hn@ycombinator.com if there's one we haven't seen yet.
- cubano 11y agoFrom my experience in addiction therapy, one thing has become very clear to me and that is much of the compulsive behavior caused by faulty brain wiring began during early childhood. In my case, I was abandoned by my biological parents for a three month period as an infant and was mistreated by Aunts and Uncles. I still have fleeting horrible memories of this event. Eating without regards to health or other consequences is simply a form of addiction, as you are doing it for emotional reasons and not because of hunger. All sorts of emotional traumas happen to infants and young children in poverty that are far less likely to happen to those in a more financially and, lets face it, emotionally stable environments. Poverty, of course, stresses everyone involved in it. I am not sure how groundbreaking this research is as it has been well-known for many years that seriously stressing infants causes the brain's reward system to change.
- sjg007 11y agoThe emotional part is huge.. Children are like sponges and soak up everything. If anxiety and depression are not genetic I definitely learned it from one of my parents.
- pdkl95 11y ago> early childhood I think this is a property of neural net style memories. Old data isn't "deleted" from the network; instead, new reinforcement makes older memories less accurate. This means memories that were particularly strong can persist for a long time; a lot of "overwriting" with unrelated data is necessary to dilute out a traumatic memory. This can start at any point in life, but memories that happened in childhood have more time to cause the problems you mentioned.
- awinter-py 11y agoFascinating. No surprise that stress has a major developmental effect. Mouse models have shown various kinds of stress (including food stress) causing epigenetic changes that are passed down more than one generation. And in reptiles, temperature conditions (a form of stress) control the male-female split of offspring.
- shockzzz 11y agoFair article, but definitely suffers from ethnocentrism. I'm pretty sure they'd find very different results in India, China, Egypt, etc.
- richcollins 11y agoA twin study to look for a potential common cause between poverty and poor food selection might yield interesting results.
- wadetandy 11y agoIt's not so much poor food selection as poor access to quality and affordable food. You can eat for a lot longer on $10 if you're buying things on the McDonald's dollar menu than if you're buying fresh produce at Safeway or giant.
- maxerickson 11y agoPasta costs $1 a pound (if you price watch just a little). Potatoes often cost less than $0.50 a pound. I think those are very valid comparisons, potatoes are even more nutritious than anything McDonald's sells. Sure, you have to cook them both for 10 or 15 minutes, which means you have to have a working stove top, but McDonald's is not more affordable than the grocery store, especially if you are buying things that are only comparably nutritious (rather than for flavor or better nutrition or whatever).
- steveax 11y agoAssuming of course that you have a grocery store in your neighborhood.
- maxerickson 11y agoIt would be an interesting map, to see how many people lived substantially closer to a McDonald's than to a place that sold pasta for reasonable prices. I guess you might have to toss in Subway. Here, the decent groceries are a bit over a mile away, two are a bit closer than the McDonald's, one is a bit further. 2 Subways beat them all. I guess such a map would have uninteresting regions where it was more of a choice (rural residential lots).
- matwood 11y ago
- ghufran_syed 11y agoShouldn't there be a control group, with a task not involving food, to see if the issue is food-related, or generally with impulse control? Maybe ask them to do some boring task they were told was important, but have Facebook, TV,sports or some other distraction immediately available too. I suspect the same people who had trouble with controlling food intake would also have trouble with other self control or delayed gratification tasks.
- notacoward 11y agoThe explanation that first leapt into my mind (as someone who grew up poor and is now not-poor BTW) didn't seem to be considered. For some kids, snacks are a luxury. For others, they're an unremarkable part of the background. This is going to make a huge difference in people's responses, but not as a matter of hunger vs. satiety. There's a whole different part of the brain associated with status and self-image; I'll bet that's the part that lights up differently for the once-poor vs. never-poor. An fMRI should shed some good light on the matter.
- zuck9 11y agoFrom https://www.facebook.com/yudkowsky/posts/10154144677734228 https://www.facebook.com/yudkowsky/posts/10154144677734228: > "Hill singles out childhood poverty, because she and her team asked participants not only for their socioeconomic statuses as children, but also their current socioeconomic statuses as adults, and, rather incredibly, the abnormal eating patterns only correlated with the former." What a ridiculous and bizarre taboo it is that causes people to only ever consider psychological explanations of eating behavior and obesity. Could it maybe be that growing up poor changed something to do with adipose tissue or insulin regulation or God knows what? Obviously not, because obesity can only ever be caused by the Sin of Gluttony, which by basic just-world theory must ultimately reduce to a personal choice in some way, even if we pat you on the head forgivingly and talk about your traumatic childhood. I would ordinarily wonder if the researchers were really this stupid or if it was the journalist, but unfortunately so far as I know most-not-all of academia is also still running on the rule that causal explanations for obesity must be somewhere intermediated by the Sin of Gluttony.
- KON_Air 11y agoWell, probably because sins of gluttony and sloth are much more common causes then some "God knows what" condition, which become more serious when combined.
- zardgiv 11y agoWhen did it become acceptable on Hacker News to post someone else's comments wholesale without any other contribution? I usually only see this with Yudkowsky or Scott Alexander quotes, so is it something from the LessWrong community?
- zuck9 11y agoI see this as similar to submitting links on HN. This is not related to LessWrong. A lot of top-level comments here are just that: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3078128 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3078128
- hyperpape 11y agoIt's true that there are some psychological hypotheses being offered, but they also mention the possibility of biological changes that make it harder to self-regulate. This comment (or quote, I guess) seems like a complaint looking for a target.
- BadassFractal 11y agoI wonder if there's a general theme here. Parental love, relationships, food, money, shelter, if you don't have access to those as you develop then you end up having a rather unhealthy relationship towards them in adulthood that might never be fixed without therapy.
- MilnerRoute 11y agoIronically, I couldn't read this article because I was too poor to pay the Washington Post for a subscription.
- Trufa 11y agoStrange, I'm not subscribe and I can see it no problem... Maybe it's a country thing?
- WalterBright 11y agoA bit missing from these studies are my parents' generation. My father grew up in hard times during the Depression, my mother grew up in WW2 ravaged Europe and spent some years with severe food shortages. Neither had any sort of obsessive relationship with food. Ok, 2 people is not data. But this happened to tens of millions of people. As I understand it, that generation was less obese than later generations.
- hyperpape 11y agoIt may make a difference that your grandparents grew up before the sharp increase in daily calories consumed post-1960. One thing that sometimes gets neglected is that food was just way more expensive and so were normal portions. And to add to that: most people's appetite starts to decline sometime in adulthood.
- capote 11y agoInteresting, same here but my parents are likely your generation. Grew up in 70s-80s communist Eastern Europe, lots of food shortages from government obsession with self-sufficiency. Stories of waiting in line for 3 hours for a maybe loaf of bread. No sort of unusual relationship with food, especially compared to mine—I grew up with all the food I wanted and I stuff my face with pointless garbage every 30 seconds.
- WalterBright 11y agoMy mother wasn't in the eastern bloc, but would recount that many times her "breakfast" was a carrot. I have family letters where they'd list their rations and various struggles to obtain food. Things were bad throughout Europe for many years.
- turnip1979 11y agoI think your folks may have these issues if healthy food was "expensive" but sugary processed foods would be "cheap" and plentiful. By expensive/cheap, you can substitute waiting in line for price.
- zxcvvcxz 11y agoHere's a thought: this pattern probably applies to other natural human needs as well. That is, developmental scarcity leading to brain re-wiring that compels overcompensation. It almost sounds Freudian (probably is), but people who lacked love early in life probably tend to try and get more of it later on, and have a harder time being on their own, often feeling more lonely.
- dang 11y agoEt tu, WaPo? We changed the title to a representative sentence from the article.
- downandout 11y agoThanks for this. These clickbait headlines are getting out of control.
- jrapdx3 11y agoOver the many years of assisting people seeking treatment for excess body weight, I'm constantly amazed by the endless complexity of the condition, not surprising given the crucial importance of energy intake and regulation for biological survival. Unfortunately the research full report is behind a paywall, and the abstract/summary leaves out a lot of info. However the findings are interesting in linking the dysregulated eating behavior to childhood SES. The details of the full report are needed to clarify some questions, like the demographic composition of the sample populations. It's been observed for a long time that some minority groups (e.g., black and Hispanic) have higher rates of obesity. The fact that these groups are also over-represented in lower SES population segments could be a factor in the results. It's not clear how such variables were accounted for. Perhaps a key was the last experiment discussed in the article, where there was reduced response to blood glucose level. Ordinarily increased glucose acts as a feedback signal of nutrient status turning off the drive to keep eating. Problems with satiety (sense of fullness) are common in obesity, though how it works is incredibly intricate and poorly understood. There are dozens of genetic elements and a vast array of hormones and other body messenger systems implicated, ultimately it involves most every part of the body. No wonder theorizing about causes of eating/metabolic disturbances is frustrating and unsatisfying. I'll take a stab at it anyway. IMHO nutritional factors should be a major suspect. A big change in diet over the last few decades has been the substantially increased intake of sugars put into processed/convenience foods. Fructose in foods has increased the most and thought to play a prominent role in higher rates of obesity. It's conceivable that early life exposure to high levels of sugars could bring about enduring abnormalities in body systems responsible for metabolic regulation.
- pm90 11y agoIf the last part is true, it is rather shocking! It really should be better publicized.
- jrapdx3 11y agoAs usual the facts are messier than any single assertion will ever be, even my own. Here's an interesting review, more or less reflecting "the state of the art": Okręglicka K, Health effects of changes in the structure of dietary macronutrients intake in western societies. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26024397 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26024397
- jakubp 11y agoWhy would it still surprise anyone that being poor frequently leads to emotional and health issues of all kinds?! Good food is more expensive. Sugar is cheap (and causes huge problems when overused). Good veggies, fruit, meat, fish, olive oil and spices (just some random examples) are simply inaccessible to billions of people. Emotional traumas mentioned by other commenters here may or may not be more prevalent in poorer social circles, but multi-faceted support systems definitely are less prevalent (money=resources of all kinds, especially health services and broader social support through extended connections). What would be really interesting is research on specific methods to fight emotional behaviors resulting from such life experience (i.e. what specific things you can do to [learn how to] regulate your food intake)... Because if there are millions of people with that problem, then actual source of that problem is unimportant at the moment.. unless nobody knows of a way to change thigns for the better and the only hope seems to be in uncovering the actual reasons.
- Smirnoff 11y agoI think the article pretty much answered its question about why people growing up poor have hard time regulating their food intake -- it's because their parents weren't smart and/or because these kids weren't taught about sugar overuse and calorie counting. I'm not sure why the following psychological reasons were offered: formerly poor people lose ability to understand when they are not hungry anymore or that these people have to keep eating because of psychological disorders. I think really it comes down to this -- people growing up poor (and becoming better off because of better economic conditions) as a group were not taught or concerned about proper nutrition. What I'd really like to know if the participants knew how to do counting (calorie counting) and how many guys were part of the study. Having only female participants in the first 2 studies is kind of picking very narrow and unrepresentative pool. And females these days count their calories a lot, so it's not surprising they refused to drink soda and instead went for water. PS: the final study did include men, although didn't state how many.
- pink_dinner 11y agoMy theory is that many poor families have a lack of self-control/discipline and they pass these habits onto their kids. It's difficult to break out of a family culture when you get older. Especially if this is what you have known your entire life and you have pressure to stay that way. Just like with money, it takes a ton of discipline to make continued long-term minded decisions rather than short-term emotional ones that make you feel good. Of course, this doesn't apply to everyone. Humans are complicated.
- unclebucknasty 11y ago>lack of self-control/discipline >long-term minded I'm not sure how I feel about these statements, but they sound awfully indicting, even if there might be some truth to them. Maybe it's their sweeping nature that makes them seem naive/presumptious. Poor people frequently don't have the luxury of engaging in long-term planning because they are consumed with day-to-day survival. Moreover, being poor itself requires a certain discipline, though not necessarily the kind non-poor people might readily recognize or appreciate.
- notacoward 11y ago> poor families have a lack of self-control/discipline I know you said that was just a theory, but it's a variation on a too-common theme that I - and many others - find offensive. The experiment specifically involved people who have the same current socioeconomic status. Some had been affluent all their lives, while others had become affluent from poorer beginnings. If self-discipline is what allows some to become richer than others, don't you think those who became wealthy by their own efforts might know a bit more about it than those who had their wealth handed to them? Why, then, would they still exhibit this distinct reaction to offers of food? I don't think your theory has any explanatory power at all.
- reddytowns 11y ago> The experiment specifically involved people who have the same current socioeconomic status Where did you see that? I can't find it anywhere in the article, the article the article is based on, or the abstract the article the article is based on references.
- geggam 11y agoThe timing of the poor people getting fatter seems to coincide with the timing of high fructose corn syrup being introduced. We had 2 fat kids in my school class.... look around now
- makemoniesonlin 11y agoThis study is dumb. I grew up in upper middle class and have no problem controlling my food intake (I almost have a six pack). However, whenever there is an abundance of snacks out for eating without any limits, I will go crazy and consume upwards of 2000 calories. I surely would have not been able to regulate my food intake during this experiment, even though I can in general at home.
- walrus01 11y agoOne of the amazing things about the US is that poorest 15% of the population (by gross household income) is also the FATTEST segment of the population. In developing countries where the poorest 15% are truly living a bare existence lifestyle (Pakistan, India, Bangladesh) you would never see a poor obese person.
- lacantina 11y agoOf the 0.2% of the population that is homeless, few are fat. Their level of poverty is closer to the poverty in developing countries.
- AndrewGaspar 11y agoSurely you're not serious. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1925022/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1925022/
- known 11y agoOne reason why we need https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basic_income FTW
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]