11 ms·
Saudi Arabia Warns of Economic Fallout If Congress Passes 9/11 Bill
- hga 11y agoSaudi Arabia has told the Obama administration and members of Congress that it will sell off hundreds of billions of dollars’ worth of American assets held by the kingdom if Congress passes a bill.... Given how they're having to liquidate assets to sustain their low oil price policy, this is partly a hollow threat absent a reversal of it.
- arca_vorago 11y agoIf any of those assets are in the US, isnt that exactly what the proper use of emminent domain is for? That being said, Im guessing they are speaking about US assets in SA. At least 13 of the hijackers were from SA. The wahhabi sect of Islam is the most violent and intolerable. We need to put SA in their place, which really angers me when I realized just how cozy the Bushes and other oil oligarchs are to them, and cover for them constantly. Once again, overthrowing and installing regimes has backfired in the long game.
- dukoid 11y agoOverthrow? I think their gender apartheid regime should just be sanctioned the same way as South Africa was in the 80s.
- arca_vorago 11y agoI dont disagree, but I was mostly referring to the installing of the house of Saud by the British in the first place. How apt you mention another place the Rhodesian Anglo Saxon dominance group did the same thing! I recently learned that some of the first concentration camps, far before the world wars, were setup by the Brits in SA and they put the Dutch in them... I digress though. What I was trying to say is that this pattern of overthrowing a place and installing a dictatorship friendly to our interests has repeatedly backfired eventually, so perhaps we should think of different strategies.
- CPLX 11y ago> overthrowing a place and installing a dictatorship friendly to our interests has repeatedly backfired eventually, so perhaps we should think of different strategies While I fervently agree with you as a matter of principle, as a practical matter letting the people have their say in government and instigating a popular revolution to overthrow a dictator has backfired spectacularly too on many occasions. Geopolitics is hard.
- raverbashing 11y agoSA was never overthrown, I don't see what you mean
- arca_vorago 11y agoHow do you think the house of Saud got its start in the first place?
- eternalban 11y agoBritish Intelligence. We're still dealing with the fallout of the collapse of that empire. btw, since I've noted an apparent acceptance on HN of the official story of "Islamic terrorism", let me merely direct the thinking reader to investigate 14 centuries of history of this religion and correlate patterns of behavior. A good and informative data point is the so called "Great Game", and later (in 70s) the amazing syncro-ballet that over night turned Middle Eastern militant groups from following Marx, Lennin, Trotsky, Mao, and uncle Ho into fervent followers of the Prophet of Islam.
- peteretep 11y ago> overthrowing and installing regimes has backfired in > the long game Those freakin' Japanese with their moderately priced cars and those damn Germans with their data protection laws and fine industrial engineering, eh?
- peteretep 11y ago> Im guessing they are speaking about US assets in SA You didn't read the article carefully enough then: > > Saudi Arabia would be forced to sell up to $750 > > billion in treasury securities and other assets in > > the United States before they could be in danger of > > being frozen by American courts While I've no love lost for the Saudis, this doesn't seem an unreasonable position. If the US passed a law that might make me liable for virtually unlimited damages, you can be sure I'd be looking at moving my assets elsewhere.
- Amezarak 11y agoI can't find that text of the proposed amendment, but based on the description in the NY Times, there doesn't seem to be any explicit mention of Saudi Arabia, just an additional stipulation under which foreign governments can be sued in American courts, the stipulation being something along the lines of "if a foreign government was involved with an attack on American soil killing American citizens, their immunity does not apply." This is the existing law: https://www.congress.gov/bill/94th-congress/senate-bill/3553 https://www.congress.gov/bill/94th-congress/senate-bill/3553 There are already several instances where the immunity already does not apply. For example: > Stipulates that a foreign state is not immune from the jurisdiction of U.S. courts if: (1) the state has waived its immunity either explicitly or by implication; (2) the action is based upon specified commercially related activities; (3) the action is based upon rights in specified property, connected with commercial activity, taken in violation of international law; (4) the issue is rights in U.S. property acquired by succession or gift or rights in immovable U.S. property; or (5) money damages are sought against a foreign state for personal injury or death, or damage to or loss of property, occurring in the U.S. and caused by the tortious act or omission of the foreign state or its official or employee acting within the scope of his office or employment. So, I think this is a pretty small and reasonable change, to which Saudi Arabia is reacting so extremely because, as "everyone knows" and as likely revealed in the unreleased portions of the 9/11 report, the Saudi royal family and/or people in the Saudi government were, in fact, involved in the events of 9/11. The Saudis, of course, have to give a somewhat-reasonable sounding diplomatic explanation of why they would be "forced" to take their assets out of the country - that's how the game is played. Since we know that there are already holes in the immunity that could potentially leave the Saudis open to "unlimited damages" (I don't see any indication the damages are unlimited), we have to conclude the Saudis believe they will, in fact, be found culpable in this instance. Now, you can choose to believe that the Saudis believe that because they believe the US court system is just grossly unfair, or because some of the royal family or the government actually were involved, and they're afraid they would be correctly found culpable. I find the latter more likely, given the information we already have, personally. It goes without saying the Foreign Minister is going to provide a reasonable-seeming cover: that's his job. Selling off 750 billion and destabilizing your own economy is not a rational action. Every billionaire is at the risk of his assets being frozen and seized if he committed a crime. So is every corporation. So, really, are foreign governments, regardless of whether they were complicit in an act of terrorism, given the immunity is not absolute. Nobody else is threatening to take their ball and go home. So why, then, would SA be threatening to do this? Because it makes for a substantial political threat to the US to pressure the US government to not hold them accountable. In the end, I suspect it's really about a loss of face for the royal family, because realistically, even if sued and found complicit, it would be incredible if they were forced to give up a few billion, let alone hundreds of billions.
- seivan 11y agoYou didn't overthrow anything that would be stable. Their cult doesn't allow civility. You overplay what you Americans have your hand in as Germany and Japan did well. Other nations are striving to do better as well thanks to the US. You can't help people who won't help themselves.
- dogma1138 11y agoThat's more or less on the point, more likely that the Saudi's need to liquidate those assets anyhow, it just gives them a way to save face. It could also be quite likely that the US also just wants to "save face" by passing this bill and the timing is just right for both countries to get what they want/need. Given the situation between Iran and Saudi Arabia, and the more or less lack implementation of the P5+1 nuclear treaty with Iran I would say that any fallout has less to do with this bill but with something else (that was also mentioned in this article) - potential restrictions on sale of arms to Saudi Arabia (which spent about 100bln this past decade on Arms from US and Canadian companies). "Last week, two senators introduced a resolution that would put restrictions on American arms sales to Saudi Arabia, which have expanded during the Obama administration." If these 2 legislatures are part of the same bill (which isn't uncommon due to how hard it is to actually pass a bill in the US these days) that's more likely to be what actually poked the bear or well the more like the camel in this case.
- cm3 11y ago> potential restrictions on sale of arms to Saudi Arabia It's easy for them to just buy from Russia and China then.
- dogma1138 11y agoNot that easy, their entire military is based on western arms, retooling and retraining your entire army isn't that easy, the retooling part is especially not cheap GL hacking your Russian guided bombs (if they agree to sell them to you) to work with US aircraft, sensors, and command and control tech etc, yes it's possible but it's not like well gosh we can't buy US cars any more, screw GM, MG here we come, you can't just switch over. Also both China and Russia don't just export anything, in some cases it would be harder to buy from them than from many Western nations.
- deathhand 11y agovendor lock-in ftw
- Kinnard 11y agoI'm not so sure. The Saudi low-oil-price policy has been ruinous for some American domestic oil companies. There intentions may be more long-founded than the current flurry of coverage intimates. They may have been preparing for this for the past 2-3 yrs.
- brooklyndude 11y agoDoes anyone think that may backfire? Wow, talk about dumber than a box of burnt hair. We're Saudi Arabia, we rule you American's. Piss us off, and we'll, crush you like "a fly." Oh boy. Can't wait to see Trumps twit on this one. :-) Iran is not perfect, LOTs of major issues there, but think they would be the one for sure we should be betting on.
- dukoid 11y agoWhy is this gender apartheid regime our ally exactly? They finance the breeding ideology of terror worldwide and now flood the world with cheap oil aimed at destroying the American high tech green energy industry.
- TheLogothete 11y agoSo the only ally of the US in the middle east left is Israel? That would be world war 3, for sure.
- dukoid 11y agoWhy do the US need an ally in the middle east? Allies should share values.
- TheLogothete 11y agoIt's a tad bit more complicated than that in real world.
- dukoid 11y ago@TheLogothete I agree. "It's complicated" doesn't really counter any of the arguments substantially though.
- dogma1138 11y agoSo Israel and the US don't share values now?
- Retric 11y agoIt's on the low end, less than Japan more than Brazil. The real issue is they don't share strategic interests largely by being on the other side of the planet.
- dogma1138 11y agoI think you are confusing values with interest. EDIT: You seem to edit that part in, well if the US some how manages to strip any interests in the near east then yes they do not have that many strategic interests (outside of trade, research and industry). However as far as values go the are more or less on the same page, the only difference it's considerably more easy to commit to your values when everyone around you plays by the same rules. That said the US is probably the worse as far as it comes to actually living by their values of most western nations.
- chinathrow 11y agoPublic extortion on a nation state level. Welcome to 2016 - we haven't learned a thing.
- Maarten88 11y agoThere is the International Court of Justice to handle cases like these, but US has never recognized it, I think. Probably because other countries might have similar complaints about illegal US behaviour.
- wozniacki 11y agoHere's the recent 60 Minutes piece on the White House's potential declassification of the "28 pages" [1] of the 9/11 Commission Report [2]. http://www.cbsnews.com/videos/28-pages http://www.cbsnews.com/videos/28-pages [ Warning : Auto play video ] It also comes at a time when the White House and intelligence officials are reviewing whether to declassify one of the country's most sensitive documents -- known as the "28 pages." They have to do with 9/11 and the possible existence of a Saudi support network for the hijackers while they were in the U.S. For 13 years, the 28 pages have been locked away in a secret vault. Only a small group of people have ever seen them. Tonight, you will hear from some of the people who have read them and believe, along with the families of 9/11 victims that they should be declassified. [1] 28 Pages http://www.cbsnews.com/news/60-minutes-911-classified-report-steve-kroft/ http://www.cbsnews.com/news/60-minutes-911-classified-report... [ Warning : Auto play video ] [2] 9/11 Commission Report https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/9/11_Commission_Report https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/9/11_Commission_Report
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- chvid 11y agoThanks New York Times. All of a sudden Trump's foreign policy is clear and reasonable compared to the current administration's.
- riyadparvez 11y agoPeople make the excuse that the West needs an ally in Middle East. Yes, it needs an ally in ME. But SA is not an ally, it's a back-stabber. They are exporting extremism all over the world (I didn't use the words terrorism because someone will come and start arguing there is no proof SA has funded terrorism and they have issued a diplomatic condemnation when a terrorist attack happened). The West has the diplomatic power over SA to force it to stop exporting its extreme ideology all over the world, it's late, the damage has been done, but further damage can be stopped. Not a single politician or all the altruist medias even call out SA, let alone do something about their back-stabbing. Decades ago, my country was liberated from Pakistan on the value of secularism. Then SA started to fund madrassas, mosques filled with their extremist ideology and now we are heading back to being another Islamist country. As a third world country with majority of people living in poverty what can we do more when Saudis fund terrorism with their unlimited petro-dollars and the West being their ally. Like many, I find the West has contributed to Islamic terrorism. But not in the way that the West has invaded other countries, but it has been allies with extremism-exporters like SA and let SA export extremism all over the world.
- atmosx 11y ago> But SA is not an ally, it's a back-stabber. I can assure that whatever SA is doing is under explicit or implicitly allowed/permitted maybe even planned by the US long time ago. It's like being pissed with the 6-year old kid for acting like an idiot when you should really blame the parent for giving him fireworks. Maybe the US/NATO interests in the area are not the ones you think?! Just saying.
- jessaustin 11y agoSaudi haven't been "given" any weapons, and they're rich enough that they could easily have purchased from parties other than USA. You are right to imply that national interests that are commonly understood and discussed differ sharply from the personal interests of those agents charged with pursuing national interests.
- y04nn 11y agoI don't know what the 9/11 Bill imply for SA, I'm not from USA or SA but when another country try to dictate your laws, I think that's totally inappropriate. But, to be fair, that's what USA and IMF have been doing since the end if WWII.
- dogma1138 11y agoThat's also what every European country, and every other country with even the slights political weight does every day. This isn't some how limited to the US or OPEC countries.
- catwithribbon 11y agoGender apartheid? Are men and women required to live in different suburbs to each other? Are they forbidden from marrying each other. At least read up on apartheid before throwing the term around in a context that makes no sense.
- dukoid 11y agoYou may also want to fix the corresponding Wikipedia article then: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender_apartheid#Saudi_Arabia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender_apartheid#Saudi_Arabia
- tomp 11y ago> The term gender apartheid refers to the economic and social sexual discrimination against individuals because of their gender or sex. I hate these post-modern redefinitions of terms. By this definition, US is gender apartheid (men are subject to involuntary draft), as well as the UK and many other EU countries (men have to work longer to get pension). That's as ridiculous as when some people equate rape with drunk sex or sexual harassment with catcalling. It really reduces the the victims of actual crimes (rape, harassment, and apartheid).
- afshin 11y agoWhen social and political phenomena are examined more closely, they need classification and designation. Disliking a new term for an old or previously unexamined phenomenon seems curmudgeonly.
- tomp 11y agoNo, I disagree. I think it makes sense to use different terms for normal, reasonable, moral behavior (draft, drunken sex), and for objectionable, inexcusable behavior (apartheid, rape).
- blowski 11y agoApartheid refers to the idea of 'separateness', the state treating a particular group differently in a significant number of ways purely because of some identifying characteristic. Clearly, there are ways in which all states do this and for different reasons. Men having to work longer to get a pension is a historical relic, and one which most countries are moving away from. The laws covering conscription in the US also date back to the early 1980s. Since there has been no involuntary draft since the 1970s, it has hardly had an effect on life for most Americans. Compare this to Saudi Arabia where women continue to be severely punished for breaking laws that apply only to women, have much curtailed rights compared to men, and clearly have very 'separate' lives to men in Saudi Arabia. Whether you call it segregation, apartheid, or whatever you want - there is much greater gender inequality in Saudi Arabia than there is in most of the EU and USA. Women in Saudia Arabia are subject to severe repression, in the same way that blacks suffered from severe repression in South Africa during the Apartheid era, and in a way that few people could genuinely complain in the USA or EU.
- sidcool 11y agoThere's cost to having bad company. Somehow I feel it will be brushed under a rug inside Dick Cheney's home.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- xienze 11y ago> Several outside economists are skeptical that the Saudis will follow through, saying that such a sell-off would be difficult to execute and would end up crippling the kingdom’s economy. So it sounds like a win-win situation.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- maxaf 11y agoHow did this riveting political discussion make it all the way to the front page? It seems to be abjectly off topic for HN.
- adventured 11y ago> It seems to be abjectly off topic for HN. So long as enough people here are interested in the topic, there's almost no such thing as off topic. In my opinion, HN is the better for that. Even if it doesn't lead to a discussion central to HN, the diversity of discussion is critical. There are also very frequent cross-over impacts in the world of politics, that involve technology, security, encryption, tech companies, et al.
- jimrandomh 11y agoWhat does the bill actually, you know, do? The article has neither a link to its text nor an identifying number, and the name, "9/11 bill", is not a good enough search term to be able to easily find it. It's kind of absurd to try to discuss the bill, or political machinations surrounding it, without getting that basic information down first.
- jakebaker 11y agoIt appears to be the Justice Against Sponsors of Terrorism act: https://www.congress.gov/bill/114th-congress/senate-bill/2040/text https://www.congress.gov/bill/114th-congress/senate-bill/204...
- jakebaker 11y agoVice mentioned it in their article: https://news.vice.com/article/this-bill-would-allow-a-lawsuit-over-saudi-governments-alleged-role-in-911-to-proceed https://news.vice.com/article/this-bill-would-allow-a-lawsui...
- rayiner 11y agoThe vice article is way better than all the other coverage. As a bit of additional background context, the historical rule has been that foreign nations cannot be sued in each others' courts. In the US, that rule is subject to the whim of Congress, and Congress is allowed to create exceptions.
- studentrob 11y ago> the historical rule has been that foreign nations cannot be sued in each others' courts You mean, most countries abide by this? Why is that? Is it possible this type of behavior is viewed as a gateway to sanctions at best, or stifled communications and war at worst? I'm not saying I agree or disagree with the proposed law. I'm just curious what the consequences might be when one developed country (Saudi Arabia) inevitably rebuffs another country's (USA's) judgement of it. I mean, that's point of separate countries right? Sovereignty.
- outside1234 11y agoGreat! Bring on the fallout - I would gladly pay higher interest rates than have blood money from Saudi Arabia.
- strooper 11y ago“The only way they could punish us is by punishing themselves,” Mr. Truman said. The perfect solution to this situation!
- runarb 11y agoInstead of a big selloff they can probably do what the soviets did. Move their assets to a foreign bank and then the foreign bank stor its assets in the US. Any assets in the us is then owned by the foreign bank, and can not be taken. This did becom so popular that we still have something called an Eurodollar: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eurodollar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eurodollar
- chris_wot 11y agoYeah, they will dump $750 billion into a reasonably free market. That will work! There are other things that would concern me before I would worry about Saudi Arabia essentially crippling itself...
- lossolo 11y agoFinally! everyone knows they (Saudi Arabia) sponsor terrorists. US maybe finally will end with hypocrisy, you are against terrorism with zero toleration rule? or you are against it only when it's not against your interest. Democratic, western values are much more important in this case than couple of $.
- riyadparvez 11y agoWhat I find surprising is lack of awareness among people regarding SA. Stopping SA is a very effective strategy to mitigate terrorism. The politicians and media are brought by SA money. But why people in the West are not doing anything about this, they are not getting money from SA. EDIT: Why the downvote?
- adventured 11y agoI didn't downvote you, however this: > What I find surprising is lack of awareness among people regarding SA There is not a lack of awareness. It's widely known that 1) Saudi is not any sort of friend to the US 2) it exports Islamic extremism 3) nearly all of the hijackers were Saudi 4) the Saudi kingdom, to some extent or another, had an involvement in enabling 9/11 5) Saudi Arabia is extremely backwards and oppressive when it comes to human rights I've yet to meet an American that didn't have some knowledge of one or all of those points.
- wahsd 11y agoSounds like we need to seize those assets that the terrorists are threatening to sell.
- csense 11y agoIf Obama's so dead-set against this bill, why doesn't he simply say he'll veto it if Congress passes it?
- privong 11y ago> If Obama's so dead-set against this bill, why doesn't he simply say he'll veto it if Congress passes it? Saudi Arabia might not appreciate it if Congress passes the bill, even if Obama vetoes it. So trying to convince congress not to pass it in the first place might be a foreign relations move. Also, Obama might be worried they could override his veto (though I don't know how widely supported this bill is in Congress).
- HillaryBriss 11y agoPolitical optics. The Saudi Arabia fan club in the US is pretty small. Most American voters are either apathetic or antipathetic about Saudi Arabia. Suppose Congress passes this bill and American voters say, "Great. That's fine with me. Let's sue these Saudi Arabian funders of terrorism." And now Obama vetoes it. How's that going to make him look to American voters? "I wonder why he did that? Looks pretty suspicious to me ..." Plus, how's that going to reflect on the Democratic presidential candidates?
- nacs 11y ago> How's that going to make him look to American voters Would he care what the American voters think of him towards the end of his last and final term?
- HillaryBriss 11y agoStrictly speaking I guess you're right. But, still, I think Obama cares that American voters vote for a Democrat in 2016 so that Obama's signature accomplishments and legacy are preserved. I believe he also cares what Americans in general think for the sake of his long term reputation -- the usual presidential narcissism, "my great legacy" etc.
- noobie 11y agoIsn't their currency linked to the US dollar? That would make it a suicide attack. No one is that..Oh wait..
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- njharman 11y agoThis is blackmail. I hope my government has sense to not set president by submitting to UT.
- williesleg 11y agoEverybody's got an agenda.
- jackfoxy 11y agoIn the age of WikiLeaks and Snowden, how do 28 pages of a Congressional report stay sealed for 14 years?
- vadym909 11y agoNothing better to get bill passed by the US than a threat. What were they thinking?
- nacs 11y ago> Nothing better to get bill passed by the US than a threat. Money is always a very large factor in politics like it or not and SA's $750 billion is a sizable amount/threat.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoInteresting article along with the ongoing coverage of the push to declassify the 20 some pages of the 9/11 commission's report. I expect that Saudi Arabia has more to lose economically than the US does, but I also don't think that is the real issue here. Rather there are some really deep and intertwined politics in the middle east and Saudi Arabia is hip deep in them. I wonder what happens if the rest of the region sees the US as no longer willing to back the kingdom.
- dismal2 11y agoAny ideas why this would be happening now? Just an excuse for the Saudis to sell their treasuries and fix their deficit?
- Kinnard 11y agoIt seems there's more at play than that.
- pknerd 11y ago> if Congress passes a bill that would allow the Saudi government to be held responsible in American courts for any role in the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks. Saudis have right concerns. After all, how a dacoit can punish a thief?
- leroy_masochist 11y agoWill be very interesting to see how this plays out. It looks like there may be enough support in Congress to make passage of the bill veto-proof. If the Saudis follow through and dump $750bn of assets, it will basically be economic warfare. If anyone has any links to estimates of how much the yield on Treasurys would go up in that contingency, please share. I wonder if they would actually follow through, because a natural response would be for the US to withdraw military support, which would be very bad indeed for the Saudis if done to a meaningful extent.