21 ms·
If there is legislation on the statute then how can Merkel have it ignored, does she have some sort of absolute authority to contradict the rule of law? >"In a
by pbhjpbhj 11y ago
If there is legislation on the statute then how can Merkel have it ignored, does she have some sort of absolute authority to contradict the rule of law?
>"In a country under the rule of law, it is not up to the government to decide," Merkel said. //
Which seems exactly right; there's no decision she made other than to not attempt to interfere with the established rule of law - who would allow that to happen??
>Germany just gave an authoritarian state a seat at the big kids table. //
Which seems to be nonsense. Instead Germany allowed someone to bring a private prosecution to court as is the right according to that country's legislation; not doing that would a complete breech of democratic process and the rule of law. Just because someone brings a frivolous prosecution doesn't mean you suddenly tear down the basis for open society and create a sui generis action against them, you let the law work, that's the exact opposite of giving in to authoritarianism. Acting like an authoritarian state to counter authoritarianism would be moronic.
Playing this out as "Erdogan has won against Merkel" seems really ignorant to me. Why are you doing that, don't you believe in the rule of law?
- searine 11y ago>If there is legislation on the statute then how can Merkel have it ignored Because Erogadan is not a German Citizen. >don't you believe in the rule of law There is no international rule of law between Turkey and Germany.
- germanier 11y agoThis is not how it works. First, citizenship is not important in front of a German court barring very few exceptions. Second, there is a law which specifically protects foreign head of states. Third, German courts ruled before in the past this specific provision is part of international law in the German legal system. You don't need to be a German citizen to be protected by German law (why should you?).
- pbhjpbhj 11y agoSlander/libel are about the country of the alleged infringement. As with other torts the person allegedly damaged doesn't need to be present otherwise it would be easy to just cross a border to avoid prosecution. Indeed I didn't realise initially but the German statute includes a law particularly protecting foreign heads of state.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]