14 ms·
Goldman Sachs Finally Admits It Defrauded Investors During the Financial Crisis
- chollida1 11y agoIf anyone is actually interested in the theory behind the rating of Mortgage backed securities(MBS), have a look at this wired article. http://www.wired.com/2009/02/wp-quant/?currentPage=all http://www.wired.com/2009/02/wp-quant/?currentPage=all It does a good job of explaining the intuition, behind the Gaussian Copula, and of course where it fell apart. I submitted the below article a few days ago and I think at this point this topic can be considered a very dead horse. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11472094 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11472094
- jsprogrammer 11y ago>I submitted the below article a few days ago... That article was submitted yesterday, when the US DOJ released a statement. One day of light beating (didnt even see a link to GS' statement of facts) and this horse is 'very dead'?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jessaustin 11y agoMove along people! Nothing to see here!
- X86BSD 11y agoShocker! Why is Jamie not in prison!
- tanderson92 11y agoOne of the simpler answers to your 'question' is that Jamie Dimon is not and has never been affiliated with Goldman.
- X86BSD 11y agoYou are correct I misread that. But if you think JPM is any different or less criminal you are delusional.
- tomp 11y ago"defrauded"... What a nice word. Why don't we just say "robbed" instead?!
- balls187 11y agoPeople "rob." Politically well connected Corporations "defraud."
- icebraining 11y agoA simple News search shows otherwise. Defraud is a specific term, different from robbing.
- balls187 11y agoTrue. People defrauding is well known. The comment you replied to, however, was made in jest in an attempt to call out how regular everyday people are treated more harshly than corporations. Similar to how if you default on your mortgage, you're an untrustworthy person. But if your business defaults on a business loan, that's "just business."
- mikestew 11y agoIf you look up the definition of "defrauded", you'll likely answer your own question: it's a superset of "robbed".
- tomp 11y agoThe problem is that it sounds less threatening, more sophisticated. It's meant to obscure the crimes that were happening.
- mikestew 11y agoIt's meant to obscure the crimes that were happening. I no more know what the author's intent was than you do, but I'm going to go with a more charitable interpretation: it's meant to clarify the means by which the robbery took place. In other words, the exact opposite of "obscure". But if you have a narrative, by all means stick to it.
- nxzero 11y agoOfficial DOJ statement: https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/goldman-sachs-agrees-pay-more-5-billion-connection-its-sale-residential-mortgage-backed https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/goldman-sachs-agrees-pay-more... Statement of Facts: https://www.justice.gov/opa/file/839901/download https://www.justice.gov/opa/file/839901/download
- joering2 11y agoDon't you love how they say "agrees to pay", like it just some friends where one is trying to convince another one to pick up a bar tab. Them (example Hillary Clinton): FBI will invite Ms. Clinton for an interview sometime next month. You: FBI raided Mr. Johns house and will jail him without bail until next week's scheduled interrogation begins. Them (Goldman Sachs): They agreed to pay a fee. You: Mr. Johns was sentenced to pay a penalty for his crime. Is this really happening in the United States of America??
- talmand 11y agoDave Chappelle had an excellent skit on his show about that very thing. Except, true to Dave's style, it was reversed.
- haberman 11y agoI'll never forget this comment on HackerNews that blamed the public for the financial crisis: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5168312 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5168312 That was the moment that I realized that some of these people live in a reality distortion zone where it really wasn't their fault.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoBut, they had a bunch of really smart people with PhDs.
- cryoshon 11y agoThe useful idiots/bootlickers are there whenever there's any kind of scandal or assignment of blame. Remember: if a person's model of the world favors authority over realism, authority is perpetually blameless in their eyes.
- mtgx 11y agoIt also wasn't that long ago when many people were still saying "the banks did nothing wrong, so why would they be punished?" Well, they clearly did do something wrong. Unfortunately, no one pays with jail time for defrauding their way into the financial crisis, and when they do get punished it's usually for a small fraction of the sums they gained, much less than the public is let to believe they are paying thanks to various loopholes. All of this also after being saved by taxpayer money (they only paid some of it back, but there were other programs, some secret, in which they got even more money).
- forgetsusername 11y ago>That was the moment that I realized that some of these people live in a reality distortion zone where it really wasn't their fault. The idea that there was any single factor that caused the financial crisis is equally delusional. Rewind back a decade and observe the flurry of "Flip this house!" shows in mainstream pop-culture. There were tons of "the public" who were in on the game, or who indirectly benefited from it.
- 11y ago
- beloch 11y agoSo finally they admit a crime was committed. Is anyone going to jail? I didn't think so.
- harryh 11y agoThere was no admission of a criminal offense. Or even an accusation.
- Osiris 11y agoHow does one find out if they qualify for part of the $1.8 billion set aside for those affected?
- mtgx 11y agoThey'll likely pay billions less, because why not? http://www.nytimes.com/2016/04/12/business/dealbook/goldman-sachs-to-pay-5-1-billion-in-mortgage-settlement.html http://www.nytimes.com/2016/04/12/business/dealbook/goldman-... This part is especially infuriating: > On the broadest level, any money that Goldman spends on consumer relief will be deductible from its corporate tax bill. So Goldman Sachs will get a government subsidy for defrauding the American public. The government is literally subsidizing their fraud with taxpayer money.
- jonknee 11y ago> So Goldman Sachs will get a government subsidy for defrauding the American public. The government is literally subsidizing their fraud with taxpayer money. That's not a fair shake at how deductions work. They aren't getting paid a subsidy, they are paying less tax because of higher expenses. No money is going from "the taxpayer" to Goldman. The government wanted it this way because they can point to a bigger number and get money to where they want it without having to get Congress to do anything (which they won't).
- karmelapple 11y ago> They aren't getting paid a subsidy, they are paying less tax because of higher expenses. They broke the law, but get to claim it on their taxes as an expense. That's like deducting my speeding ticket payments as an expense on my tax return.
- jandrese 11y agoI'm sure you wouldn't be the first person to try that, especially if he tries to justify the speeding as a business need. The difference of course is that you would get audited and maybe go to jail. Goldman Sachs's friends in government have written the law such that it's not even illegal for them.
- karmelapple 11y agoAs the other replies indicate, it's less about them writing the law in this instance, but rather having the government prosecution be complicit in boosting the dollar number they can publicize in exchange for a lower overall cost to the company. Both sides win in this arrangement, even though I'd argue most Americans do not want Goldman Sachs to do any kind of winning as a result of this very necessary legal action against them.
- __abc 11y agoand the penalty is ..... ?
- SeanDav 11y agoUntil people actually go to jail for like 30 years and until fines far exceed any profits, companies will continue to indulge in this type of behaviour. The rewards are just too good and the downsides too easy to live with.
- jbattle 11y agoOr even having their massive bonuses clawed back. Ignoring the motivations of the company for a second, employees at places like GS are clearly incentivized to push the limits. Personally collect big bonuses now, let the company as a whole pay fines in several years. Not a good dynamic
- talmand 11y agoYep, give me $100 with maybe having to give back $1 while admitting it was wrong and I'm sure I'll never do that deal again.
- InclinedPlane 11y agoIf you steal a slice of pizza 3 times you can go to prison for a very long time. If you steal billions over years and years and wreck the economy while doing so, you won't face any personal consequences.
- Godel_unicode 11y agoThis is not true in the majority of the United States unless you already had felony convictions unrelated to your pizza caper. The misdemeanor petty theft only gets upgraded to a felony if you have a pattern of behavior, and that upgraded felony would only be your first strike.
- slg 11y agoI wonder what people here would say if non-tech folks started talking like this about the tech industry. For example, how many stories have we heard about data leaks involving complete incompetence or negligence by the company involved? How many of them have ended up in jail or even with a fine?
- bogomipz 11y agoThey will pay a 5 billion dollar fine out of the hundreds of billions of dollar they made. That's just the cost of doing business then isn't it. If a regular person is found guilty of fraud they generally wind up inside a jail cell. If a wall street bank does the same, its settled by writing a check behind closed doors and then everyone goes to lunch.
- epicureanideal 11y agoFor the last 5000 years there has been a different legal system for the peasants and the nobility. This is just ongoing proof that that hasn't changed.
- slavik81 11y agoBut they haven't actually been found guilty of fraud. They agreed to a settlement. To send them to jail, the SEC would have to prove they're guilty in a court of law. Maybe the SEC could do that, maybe it couldn't. The question is if you want to take a $5B sure thing for some shady behavior or spin the roulette wheel of justice and hope it was actually illegal.
- talmand 11y agoConsidering that $5B is a drop in the bucket compared to the damages done, I'd rather they spin the wheel.
- alexqgb 11y agoExcept they won't even pay the $5 billion. After "qualifying" for various deductions listed in the fine print and taking advantage of the tax benefits (no, I'm not kidding), the final payment will be closer to $2-3 billion.
- tma-1 11y agoGS makes around $10 billion a year, are you saying that the profits for the last 10 years or more came purely from sales of MBS? I know no one has been imprisoned over the financial crisis mess, but settlements like these truly show that the justice department and the SEC are doing a pretty good job at penalising the banks. Combined, the fines probably add up to hundreds of billions, my personal opinion is that this is way more than the banks did from selling these securities.
- kauffj 11y agoThe one thing I can never wrap my head around in the banking industry is why this kind of behavior is tolerated by _customers_. Imagine if wherever you work had to settle with the SEC / FTC / ABCXYZ for fraud. Wouldn't this devastate your customer base? Yet when a bank gets fined, it seems simply like business-as-usual. Even when a government agency levies a fine for fraud, or emails are released in which employees actively mock their customers for being suckers, investment banks' abilities to find customers seems unhindered. 1) Are my perceptions wrong? Do these events damage reputation more than it seems? 2) If banks acting in this manner is the standard... why? Why isn't a firm carving out the "niche" of not being assholes?
- keketi 11y agoIt's almost as if there is no competition in banking... whistles the x-files theme
- nickff 11y agoSome time ago (>>10 years) SEC fines were rare and they did carry the stigma you speak of, but the SEC's enforcement actions have now increased to a point where all the banks regularly pay out fines whether or not they did anything wrong; the stigma is now gone, and the fines are just a cost of doing business. Fighting regulators is a very dangerous game for any company, as the government will usually settle for much less than the potential fine (, usually less than the cost of fighting the fine), and the looming threat of an ongoing prosecution adds costly uncertainty to the business. In addition, the executives have a large incentive to settle because this is just the shareholders' money, and a failure to comply could be met with a criminal prosecution.
- abakker 11y agoIIRC and IANAL, there is also a strange problem that if criminal charges are brought against companies, there is a lot of fallout, and potential for the company to barred from operation. https://www.justice.gov/sites/default/files/criminal-fraud/legacy/2010/04/11/charging-corps.PDF https://www.justice.gov/sites/default/files/criminal-fraud/l... Section IX B. seems to be the relevant one there, suggesting that regulators and prosecutors attempt to weigh the fallout that such a charge might have on innocent 3rd parties.
- malloreon 11y agoFine them all their profits from the fraud then triple the penalty. Then realize solution to financial crimes is to put people in jail for 1 year for every multiple of the median yearly household income. Steal $1M when the median income is $50K? 20 years. Steal $1B? Enjoy dying in prison.
- chishaku 11y agoIf there is any silver lining... "The settlement expressly preserves the government’s ability to bring criminal charges against Goldman, and does not release any individuals from potential criminal or civil liability." https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/goldman-sachs-agrees-pay-more-5-billion-connection-its-sale-residential-mortgage-backed https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/goldman-sachs-agrees-pay-more... Who may or may not do something about it? http://www.opensecrets.org/industries/recips.php?cycle=2016&ind=F http://www.opensecrets.org/industries/recips.php?cycle=2016&...
- alexqgb 11y agoNo silver lining there. This is just pro for a bullshit to keep the pitchforks at bay. To see just how seriously these "deferred judgements" are taken by parties on either side of the table, see HSBC (found guilty of massive and very deliberate money laundering for Mexican drug cartels), which has continued to rack up offences with impunity while operating under one of these agreements.
- rdtsc 11y ago$5B - not pocket change, but operating on $40B revenue not exactly too damaging either. Its stock hasn't nose dived. Nobody is going to jail. Investors think they are ok. This is just business as usual. They have 0 incentives not to do it again. In fact they'd be stupid not to do it again. Given they know better how fines are calculated and can just fold that into the total equation.
- talmand 11y agoIt's already being done again, just under a different name. It started again as soon as the bailout checks cleared.
- dguaraglia 11y agoActually, it looks like they'll be able to discharge about $2.7B as "expenses". So effectively they'll only be paying around ~$2.3B for completely destroying the American economy. I call that a bargain.
- harryh 11y agoGoldman Sachs completely destroyed the American economy?
- rayiner 11y agoFraud has a very specific meaning, and what Goldman admitted to wasn't fraud (especially not criminal fraud). Here is the actual statement of facts: https://www.justice.gov/opa/file/839901/download https://www.justice.gov/opa/file/839901/download. They admitted to doing what companies do every day: overselling a product they knew was crappy while having shoddy Q&A. It's also worth noting the procedural posture of the government's case against Goldman. It's under FIRREA, which allows the government to bring a civil action for violation of 14 specific criminal laws. The burden of proof in the civil action is the lower civil standard of proof, instead of the high "beyond a reasonable doubt" standard.
- cm2187 11y agoI think misrepresentation is fraud, particularly when we are talking about selling listed, US securities, but I am not a lawyer.
- tptacek 11y agoIt is! But to bring a felony case that would survive the standard of proof in criminal court, prosecutors would have to convince a jury that the people at Goldman who decided to or actually made some flawed statements knew that those statements were categorically false --- could not under any circumstances have been true --- and that the specific things about which they were knowingly and categorically wrong were material: that reliance on those statements benefited Goldman and harmed the people who relied on them. That's an argument that we penetration testers would say "has a lot of attack surface".
- gozur88 11y agoThis. There's a big difference between what you think is probably true and what you can prove, particularly when the law stipulates a state of mind. Prosecutors don't usually pursue these kinds of cases unless the defendant was dumb enough to brag to his friends or leave an email trail.
- chishaku 11y ago
- pasbesoin 11y agoDear DoJ et al.: No jail? You fail.
- xupybd 11y agoSo many people should be in jail for what happened here. I'm not sure how we got here, but capitalism some how turned into socialism. Only it was not the people that the government redistributed the wealth to, it was the failing businesses. I know the reasoning was to prevent a bad recession, but I don't know how capitalism is going to work with that sort of interference from the governments.
- known 11y agoGovt will do nothing due to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stockholm_syndrome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stockholm_syndrome
- riprowan 11y agoAs long as a politician can say the words "Too Big To Fail" with a straight face this will continue. "Too Big To Fail" should mean "Too Big To Be Allowed To Exist" but apparently it still means "Open Checkbook to Taxpayer-Funded All-You-Can-Eat Buffet"