3 ms·
> Given that they must disburse their income eventually in the form of dividends, salaries, payments to vendors, etc. Apple is just sitting on $300 billion (wi
by jandrese 11y ago
> Given that they must disburse their income eventually in the form of dividends, salaries, payments to vendors, etc.
Apple is just sitting on $300 billion (with a b!) dollars currently, and they are just one company.
If anything we should be taxing those war chests higher because sequestering that much money is bad for the economy as a whole.
Also, eliminating the corporate income tax would open up a gigantic loophole in tax law. People could simply incorporate into a single person corporation, then make sure the corporation makes all of their money and just happens to provide services that help the person (like buying food and shelter).
- abawany 11y agoThat is a fair point. I guess since one can't count on a corporation to spend a significant portion of its income every year, the corporate tax provides a mechanism to pull some money out of their income instead of waiting for their expenses to trickle down to the economy.
- whatok 11y agoApple or any other company is going to sit on that much cash if they don't have anything productive to do with it. I don't know how you would come up with a non-arbitrary threshold for taxing "war chests" and punishing companies (in the form of increased taxes) seems very perverse for what could be the most rational decision for a company to make. If the US had a sane repatriation system and rates were not so low, Apple would have used overseas cash instead of issuing debt for recent buybacks and dividends. They will also likely use some of the cash to eventually buy back debt if it makes sense for them to repatriate.
- ksdale 11y agoThere actually are laws that impose much higher tax rates on cash in "holding companies" but convincing the government that you might need that much cash is pretty easy.
- bpodgursky 11y ago> Also, eliminating the corporate income tax would open up a gigantic loophole in tax law. People could simply incorporate into a single person corporation, then make sure the corporation makes all of their money and just happens to provide services that help the person (like buying food and shelter). Given that corporate income tax is basically completely ineffective right now, I don't know why you think this would possibly be any harder to enforce against. > If anything we should be taxing those war chests higher because sequestering that much money is bad for the economy as a whole. If you eliminated the corporate income tax, this money would instantly be some combination of (a) disbursed in dividends (b) brought back into the US and spent on expansions or acquisitions or (c) spent on stock buybacks, which would then be captured as capital gains tax. There's no need to make this more complicated.
- abawany 11y agoThank you - that was sort of the source of my question as well. It seems that since the current complicated scheme has perversed incentives to make the corporate tax ineffectual, why not try to simplify.
- seanmcdirmid 11y agoI think (a) and (b) only lead to taxes if the stock holders are American. I have a lot of non resident alien friends who hold the same stock as I do and their tax rules for dividends and capital gains are very different, it isn't clear to me that they have to pay anything. Much of corporate war chests are spent on R&D abroad, which is necessary to garner favor in some countries. The money wouldn't necessarily flow back to the US even if it could unhindered.
- privong 11y ago> Apple is just sitting on $300 billion (with a b!) dollars currently, and they are just one company. > If anything we should be taxing those war chests higher because sequestering that much money is bad for the economy as a whole. Just to play devil's advocate, is there a chance they're sitting on it because they'd be taxed for using it to finance R&D, acquisitions, or for other uses? And I think you really mean "beginning to tax those war chests", because I don't think corporate holdings continue to be taxed, post income-tax. Am I right that you're essentially advocating negative interest rates for corporate-held cash?
- jandrese 11y agoI think it's more because they just don't know what to do with it. Tax avoidance is an additional incentive, but probably not the main one. I wasn't entirely serious about taxing corporate cash holdings, but as I think about this more may not be the worst idea in the world. Obviously you would set the bar high enough that the tax wouldn't kick in until the corporation went beyond reasonable (maybe at a billion dollars? Not too many corporations make capital investments larger than this do they? And even those would probably be financed for tax reasons.) Make it more expensive to sit on excess cash than to actually use it. Punish complacency.
- abawany 11y agoI would argue that activist stockholders are already on this case for their own self-interest: witness Icahn et al compelling Apple to give back some of their cash as additional dividends.
- kspaans 11y agoWouldn't Apple have to repatriate the cash to the US in order to pay it out as dividends? (And thus pay both corporate income tax and dividend tax on it.)
- abawany 11y agoIn the current scheme of things, I believe Apple was able to pay the extra dividends using its income. The activist shareholders agitated for a bigger return to shareholders and Apple complied, as I understand it. I don't believe cash repatriation was required in this scenario. It seems that Apple was also "encouraged" to perform stock buybacks by these investors. ref: http://learnbonds.com/124673/apple-inc-aapl-is-preparing-to-give-carl-icahn-27-5-million/ http://learnbonds.com/124673/apple-inc-aapl-is-preparing-to-...
- maxerickson 11y agoIn kind personal income is already taxable.
- lg 11y agoi'm guessing it's invested or deposited in a bank, and banks loan money out against their deposits, so still productively used.
- refurb 11y agoPeople could simply incorporate into a single person corporation, then make sure the corporation makes all of their money and just happens to provide services that help the person (like buying food and shelter). What's stopping people from doing that now? I'd love to incorporate and call my salary "revenue" and deduct all of my expenses from it. But I can't due to tax laws. I don't think anything would change.
- ikeboy 11y ago>If anything we should be taxing those war chests higher because sequestering that much money is bad for the economy as a whole. That's what inflation is for. If you think saving is bad, make inflation go up and saving will decrease.
- zo1 11y ago>"because sequestering that much money is bad for the economy as a whole." What exactly do you mean they're 'sequestering' the money? Short of them keeping it hidden away in a locked vault somewhere, surely that money is being circulated through the economy in one form or another.