7 ms·
The folly with arguments blaming San Francisco for the problem is the fact that the entire Bay area is priced at an insane level. Take another look at this [1]
by ModernMech 11y ago
The folly with arguments blaming San Francisco for the problem is the fact that the entire Bay area is priced at an insane level.
Take another look at this [1] BART map with corresponding home prices for each stop. Yeah, it's cheaper to live outside of the city, but it's still crazy expensive. The median sale price for a house in Pittsburg is $430,000, with a 62 min commute into SF. If you live 62 minutes outside of say, Pittsburgh PA, you can certainly expect your median home will cost ~$120,000 or less [2].
It's been my experience that while square footage cost may go down outside the city, you really end up paying around the same rent for a larger space. So if you can't afford a $3000/mo rent in the city, you probably still can't afford the $2800/mo rent you'll pay in Daly City.
I expect what would really happen if SF just went all in building new housing, is that prices would drop in the city slightly, allowing people to move back into the city, thus increasing demand and increasing prices back to where they were. The places where rent would drop are the suburbs, where people were pushed out to initially.
A way to look at it would be that SF's sphere of rent influence would end up shrinking, but the magnitude of the epicenter remains unaffected.
[1] - http://www.estately.com/bay-area-home-affordability-transit-stop http://www.estately.com/bay-area-home-affordability-transit-...
[2] - http://files.zillowstatic.com/research/public/realestate/ZHVI.Pittsburgh.394982.pdf http://files.zillowstatic.com/research/public/realestate/ZHV...
- ZanyProgrammer 11y agoYep, the East Bay is quickly losing its status as the cheap overflow for San Francisco. A lot of the Peninsula and Santa Clara County is bad too.
- runchberries 11y agoYeah. In Palo Alto my crappy 1 bedroom apartment that I was living in 3 years ago was in the middle of suburban jungle (no restaurants or shops for a few miles in any direction) and was $1650. I looked last week and it was $2500. That was a crappy place. If you want to live by downtown PA (university Ave) its right around $2800-3000 for a 1 bedroom, for places with 20 year old appliances and no upgrades. The peninsula is just as bad because of school preferences, etc. New engineers getting hired in MV and PA literally can't afford to live by themselves in a 1 bedroom. That is fucked.
- ZanyProgrammer 11y agoWell what they really do is live further out, displacing poorer people. Places like Sunnyvale and Santa Clara are more doable.
- shostack 11y agoCan you clarify where in PA you were that had no restaurants or shops for a few miles in any direction? PA is relatively small, and there aren't any apartments further west in the really nice parts. Further east there are still stores and shops and such (albeit not as nice as near downtown).
- ZanyProgrammer 11y agoLike down El Camino towards California Avenue and beyond, I'd think.
- runchberries 11y agoPast past California ave about 2 miles near el camino. It was a little over 2 miles to California Ave and maybe 2 miles to the san Antonio shopping center. They weren't pleasant walks the most direct way (along el camnino) and even longer if you decided to take the scenic route and everything is spread out. Not an impossible feat to bike, but the energy is low and there are much better ways to spend rent money.
- zt 11y ago(I'm the author). You make excellent points, and I don't mean to minimize the regional issues. Sure, if I had a magic wand then I'd increase housing being built across the Bay Area. In fact, I'd like consolidate the jurisdictions in the Bay Area, but that's a whole other argument. I don't quite know how to play out the claim that demand is infinite. One, I don't believe that. And, two, it seems like an argument that has us throw up our hands and do nothing. It's large problem that needs a large solution -- I've heard estimates in the 100-200 thousand unit range -- but I'd rather shoot for that goal than do nothing at all.
- jacobolus 11y agoKinda off topic in context of this thread, but if you’re organizing panel discussions about this, you should try to get someone from http://www.spur.org http://www.spur.org in your panel. See http://www.spur.org/policy-area/housing http://www.spur.org/policy-area/housing and http://www.spur.org/policy-area/regional-planning http://www.spur.org/policy-area/regional-planning
- zt 11y agoThanks! I know SPUR well, I'm actually on their housing policy board.
- batbomb 11y agoI'm not saying this is your motivation, but when it's a proposal to the housing problem is framed as "Let's Fix San Francisco" it feels like the proposer believes they must live in San Francisco, especially when the proposer isn't a native San Franciscan. It feels tribal, and this issue is extremely tribal, and anyone who appears to belong to a specific tribe chimes in with a "We need to fix San Francisco" undoubtedly people from other tribes chime in and complain about how that tribe is the problem and the conversation usually devolves into name calling at some point. When the proposal is a bit broader, i.e. "Let's fix the Bay Area", then, at the very least, it doesn't feel like a claim is being made on San Francisco by a specific tribe. More than anything, it's the tribal nature of this issue that really sucks and it really stalls the things for everyone.
- 11y ago
- davmre 11y agoYou're right that the same arguments apply throughout the Bay Area. That fact that SF needs to build more and denser housing doesn't excuse Palo Alto, Mountain View, Berkeley, Oakland, etc. from doing the same. But even the housing policy you describe, in which SF acts unilaterally, would still be a great good. Tens of thousands of people previously priced out of SF would now be able to live in the city. And those who still couldn't afford the city would find it much easier to live within a reasonable commute.
- iolothebard 11y ago70 story high rise in Atherton and Belmont! That will be the day :-) I quite liked the Peninsula. SF wasn't really my cup of tea. God forbid people like me that lived on the Cliffs of Despair (Pacifica) and were relatively happy.
- ChiCommTroll 11y agoThey finally demolished the cliff buildings a couple of weeks ago!
- iolothebard 11y agoYeah, I saw that on the NYTimes. Glad they did it before it fell into the ocean :-)
- api 11y agoIn some cases it's cheaper to live in another city and fly to/from SF every single day than to live in SF.
- aetherson 11y agoName some of these cases.
- nkurz 11y agoI think it's mostly a "thought exercise", but here's a treatment looking at the costs of commuting to SF from Las Vegas: http://mobile.businessinsider.com/its-cheaper-to-commute-from-las-vegas-to-san-francisco-than-it-is-to-live-there-2015-10 http://mobile.businessinsider.com/its-cheaper-to-commute-fro...
- mikeyouse 11y agoSome employees at UCSF do this -- They can get on a 7-on/7-off schedule, fly in from somewhere more reasonable (often Denver or somewhere in the Midwest), stay on a couch for a week, earn a SF salary then fly back to a $1,500/month mortgage somewhere else.
- epa 11y ago'Stay on a couch for a week' - pretty large pre-requisite here..
- baddox 11y ago> I expect what would really happen if SF just went all in building new housing, is that prices would drop in the city slightly, allowing people to move back into the city, thus increasing demand and increasing prices back to where they were. That seems unlikely to me, based on intuition and my admittedly elementary understanding of economics. It seems very unlikely that a significant increase in the quantity of housing units would cause no change in the price of housing units.
- rsync 11y agoIt would indeed cause the pricing to drop, but just temporarily until all the new housing stock was filled. Basically, the author is suggesting that (within practical bounds) the demand for housing inside SF is unlimited. I think it's a fair assessment.
- baddox 11y agoI really don't think so. If demand is effectively unlimited, then I highly doubt it is only unlimited at exactly the current housing prices. Some significant portion of the housing is not under rent control (most people I know don't live in rent controlled units) and some portion of the supposedly effectively unlimited demanders should be willing to pay more than the current prices.
- sambe 11y agoMaybe they switch to alternatives (larger, further away) at around this price level. Other commentators have noted that you don't pay much less further away, just get much more house than you need. An increase in supply and subsequent drop in prices would be absorbed immediately given the other conditions (appears to be the claim).
- lazaroclapp 11y agoIs it, really? The entire current population of the Bay Area is tiny (7 million people across 101 cities, less than a million in S.F. proper). Compare: Tokyo metro area: 37.8 Million Mexico City metro area: 21.2 Million NYC metro area: 20 Million If demand where truly unlimited, then building up S.F. to Tokyo standards or above over the next few decades should be practical, since that level of demand would provide the funds for the growth. Of course, what is really going to happen is that demand will likely stabilize around or below the 15 million threshold for the entire Bay Area.
- saint-loup 11y ago>> A way to look at it would be that SF's sphere of rent influence would end up shrinking, but the magnitude of the epicenter remains unaffected. This is roughly the conjecture of Marchetti's constant :https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marchetti%27s_constant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marchetti%27s_constant See also induced demand https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Induced_demand https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Induced_demand & https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jevons_paradox
- pinaceae 11y agoBART now designates high-cost areas. You can see it in the tri-valley, the new Whole Foods in Dublin is a good indicator. Now they want to build an IKEA next to it. Poorer, non-tech people are getting pushed out to Tracy and made-from-scratch exurbs like Mountain House. SF is just the center, Oakland/Berkley is getting hit hard now. The Uber acquisition of that large office complex in Oak has set off a bonanza. The hipster brigade is already popping up in weird places in Oakland. Really not sure where all the poor people will go. There is one, weird, and very not pc observation though: old home owners get pushed out, but in the East Bay you see a lot of Indian newcomers moving in - and not highly paid executives, but Indian fresh out of rural areas in India, men in sandals (no socks, ever) and women in full garb. Where is that money coming from?
- khuey 11y agoHow exactly do home owners get pushed out? Who is making them sell their properties against their will?
- imtringued 11y agoIt doesn't matter how much housing you build. The landlords will still charge as much as the market can bear.
- b3550943 11y agoFuck off with your downvotes. You retards don't even understand basic supply and demand.