16 ms·
Internet hyperlinks do not infringe copyright, EU court advised
- sschueller 11y agoSo the pirate bay is legal?
- overlordalex 11y agoThis was my first thought, however there was this at the bottom of the article: The advocate general added that this also depended on whether the link was indispensable in making the photos available, a matter which he referred back to the local Dutch court. I believe the argument is that while The Pirate Bay only links to copyrighted content, they are integral to making that content available (since very few sites have these link listings). If widely available search engines indexed magnet links then I think TPB would be legal under this opinion.
- saulrh 11y agoThere are widely available search engines indexing magnet links; it's just that they're all other torrent sites. Each individual site isn't integral to making that content available, but the class "torrent site", taken as a whole, may be. I'm not sure how the interpretation would work here - "would be integral if it were the only extant illegal source"?
- semi-extrinsic 11y agoI'm not sure TPB is what they're thinking about. I think it's closing the loophole where EU sites could host all their infringing content under another jurisdiction which doesn't care about copyright, and then just linking to it.
- the8472 11y ago> they are integral to making that content available (since very few sites have these link listings). What is "very few" in your opinion? There are dozens, even hundreds of torrent sites out there. They often also meta-index data from each other, serving as a sort of ad hoc replication.
- pbhjpbhj 11y agoSo, if Google is the only site that has spidered my content and my content is infringing then Google is also infringing? Obviously Google are too rich for the argument to work against them, but say a popular blogger finds a website with little traffic and some great content and links to it; they then would seemingly become responsible for the original site's infringement? One can see why the media lobby would want to leave in the option to declare TPB illegal but it seems an unworkable reservation if we're to hold to the rule of law. Kinda like (stealing someone else's analogy up-thread) if you charge someone with public indecency for pointing out there was a person being indecent - inappropriate nudity, say - if not many people had noticed the indecency prior to the declaration. Seems pretty mad to me.
- jdright 11y agoIt was morally always "legal". The paid inquisition may have made it illegal (and looks imoral), but things should get back to the rightful state of legality sometime in the future.
- sp332 11y agoIn its original jurisdiction of Sweden, yes.
- herbst 11y agoYes it is. Always was. For freedom loving countries at least.
- amelius 11y agoWhat if I put base64 encoded content into the hyperlink? Will it be legal still? :)
- tome 11y agoPerhaps you should read the first paragraph of the article to receive clarification on this :)
- Natanael_L 11y agoTry magnet links instead. The opinion only really covers pointers.
- __john 11y agoIt was a joke, magnet links are base64 encoded hashes of the content iirc.
- jasonjei 11y agoWhile I am not a lawyer, I suspect that a reasonable person would say that encoding the content in a string turns the link into the content rather than leading one to the content.
- mtgx 11y agoThis comes at the right time, because the EU Commission was just preparing to put "copyright infringement by hyperlinking" into law: https://juliareda.eu/2015/11/ancillary-copyright-2-0-the-european-commission-is-preparing-a-frontal-attack-on-the-hyperlink/ https://juliareda.eu/2015/11/ancillary-copyright-2-0-the-eur... France was also planning to ban "hyperlinking without permission": https://openmedia.org/en/amendment-ban-hyperlinks https://openmedia.org/en/amendment-ban-hyperlinks
- zerocrates 11y agoOf course, an opinion that hyperlinks aren't currently copyright infringement by themselves could be seen by some as evidence that a new law is actually necessary.
- michaelmrose 11y agoOr a sign that European nations need to stop propping up an obsolete business model with internet breaking laws.
- ricksplat 11y agoOh thank god I'll be able to link to Irish news websites again without fear of prosecution! http://boingboing.net/2013/01/02/newspapers-demand-to-be-paid-i.html http://boingboing.net/2013/01/02/newspapers-demand-to-be-pai...
- nkrisc 11y agoReminds of when Spain tried something similar: http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2015/07/new-study-shows-spains-google-tax-has-been-a-disaster-for-publishers/ http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2015/07/new-study-shows-s... However in this case I believe it centered on snippets of the news content itself, not only a link.
- candeira 11y agoIn Spain they illegalised links to infringing content (mostly movie/music downloads) by creating a "Commission of experts" which would rule on takedowns. The reason for this, of course, is that judges and courts were deeming hyperlinks were legal. This is El Pais singing praises: http://elpais.com/elpais/2012/05/01/inenglish/1335894807_391833.html http://elpais.com/elpais/2012/05/01/inenglish/1335894807_391... Techdirt is second-hand reporting, but fair: https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20120104/04252517273/spanish-government-adopts-its-own-version-sopa-sinde-law-approved.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20120104/04252517273/spani... If you can read Spanish, google "Sinde-Wert jueces". This one is good: http://www.eldiario.es/zonacritica/ComisionSinde-jueces_6_169793025.html http://www.eldiario.es/zonacritica/ComisionSinde-jueces_6_16... (its author is David Bravo, a copyright lawyer who's recently been elected to Spanish Parliament, and one of the most vocal personalities on copyright in Spain).
- nkrisc 11y agoThanks for the good info. I can read Spanish, but too rusty at this point to be reading about law.
- alva 11y agoI wonder how this would have affected the UK TVShack.net case [0]. Richard O'Dwyer was subjected to the absolutely awful UK-US extradition agreements over linking to copyrighted content. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_O%27Dwyer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Richard_O%27Dwyer
- hmmdiggy 11y agoA link to a website which publishes photos without authorisation of the author does not in itself constitute a copyright infringement Sorry for my naivety here but the way this is worded is creating confusion for me. Does the article mean: 1) Linking to photos that you don't have authorisation to use on your website isn't copyright infringement. 2) Linking to a website that doesn't seek authorisation to use photos on their website. To me it reads like the latter, in which case how is one meant to know if a website has sought and gotten authorisation for each photo they use?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- blktiger 11y agoIt sounded to me like the latter as well. I think the Advocate General is saying you can't ban hyperlinks unless they are the only way to access a copyrighted work. As an example, I would think a link that allowed someone to get around the requirements to login to view something (maybe username/password as query parameters or something?) would be considered illegal.
- calgoo 11y agoThere was also the comment about being freely available already. So a page behind username / password would not be freely available and you would be breaking the law. Now, if a user on a private page, marked something as public, but did not publish the link, then it would be legal as you could argue that its freely available.* * Not a lawyer, so just my own understanding.
- clort 11y agoI read it more that if the GreenStijl website which was in the EU jurisdiction was posting the links to the pages hosted on a computer within another jurisdiction, but that the pages were not generally available (ie they weren't being hosted on an actual website where they were part of that that website) then GreenStijl would be liable for copyright infringement because the only way to access the published content would be through them. so GreenStijl can't just host the pages anonymously on mega.com and link to them.. in that case they would deemed to be part of their website.
- pwenzel 11y agoThe 90s are back! Clinton is running for president, and the legality hyperlinks are up for debate again. In 1999, a similar lawsuit was brought up against 2600 Magazine over the issue of linking to source code that could have the potential to violate copyright: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_City_Studios,_Inc._v._Reimerdes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_City_Studios,_Inc._v... http://www.cnn.com/1999/TECH/ptech/12/28/dvd.crack/ http://www.cnn.com/1999/TECH/ptech/12/28/dvd.crack/
- delinka 11y agoAnd don't forget the renewed crypto wars ...
- jim-greer 11y agoIt's the 90s on the European internet in other ways, or almost. For instance broadband penetration in Belgium is about where it was in 2003. There are lots of internet cafes. Edit: This is incorrect. European broadband is fine.
- efdee 11y agoI think you are reading the wrong statistics. What has stagnated in Belgium since 2003 is the percentage of broadband connections that are ADSL. Between 2003 and 2008 alone broadband penetration more than doubled.
- TheManuell 11y agolink to the CJEU press release, with details (PDF) http://curia.europa.eu/jcms/upload/docs/application/pdf/2016-04/cp160037en.pdf http://curia.europa.eu/jcms/upload/docs/application/pdf/2016...
- profmonocle 11y agoSeems absurd to legislate this when there's a simple technical solution. If you don't want to allow "deep links" on a public web site, simply block any request where the HTTP referrer isn't from your domain (or from domains whose owners have paid you for linking rights, if you can find anyone inclined to do so.) You could go even further by encoding a base64-encoded expiration date + HMAC into the URL, so that your deep URLs can't be saved at all. I think doing either of these things is silly - why even run a public web site if you're going to do this? But it's their site, and their right to make bad decisions with it. If a site owner chooses not to do this, it's safe to assume they intended to allow deep links, since links are a fundamental, well-known feature of the medium they chose to use.
- tokenizerrr 11y agoLots of people block referral headers. Browsers also drop them across HTTPS->HTTP boundaries.
- nacs 11y ago> Lots of people block referral headers Source? I would think most people run stock browsers that don't manipulate referrer headers.
- tokenizerrr 11y agoJust take a look at the amount of times https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/referer-control/hnkcfpcejkafcihlgbojoidoihckciin?hl=en https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/referer-control/hn... has been installed. And that's just one extension for one browser.
- nacs 11y ago100K users out of 3B+ internet users [1]? I don't think that qualifies as 'lots of people'. [1]: http://www.internetlivestats.com/internet-users/ http://www.internetlivestats.com/internet-users/
- caractacus 11y agoThis is NOT a court ruling and NOT law. Yet. Note the word 'advised'. This is a legal opinion from an important individual who looks at the case and tells the court what he thinks. But (i) the court can ignore it or look at the case themselves and make their own opinion; and (ii) any ruling they do make does not bind any EU government to implement it (though it should strongly decisions in EU countries). It's like asking your mechanic friend what he thinks of the car you've got lined up to buy. As the CJEU press release states: > NOTE: The Advocate General’s Opinion is not binding on the Court of Justice. It is the role of the Advocates General to propose to the Court, in complete independence, a legal solution to the cases for which they are responsible. The Judges of the Court are now beginning their deliberations in this case. Judgment will be given at a later date. http://curia.europa.eu/jcms/upload/docs/application/pdf/2016-04/cp160037en.pdf http://curia.europa.eu/jcms/upload/docs/application/pdf/2016...
- arviewer 11y agoYou're correct, but the practice is that the advice of the Advocate General is followed by the Court of Justice. So normally it's just a matter of time.
- aurora72 11y agoThe same page says that it would be detrimental to the Internet if hyperlinks were fallen under such restrictive laws
- jim-greer 11y agoFWIW my wife puts the odds of victory on this at something like 70% at this point. She's a director at Stanford's Center for Internet and Society, working on freedom of expression. That's based on this study: http://eulawanalysis.blogspot.com/2016/01/measuring-influence-of-advocate-general.html http://eulawanalysis.blogspot.com/2016/01/measuring-influenc...
- a3n 11y agoAnd since it's not ruled, there's still time for bribes to judges.
- talles 11y agoOff-topic: anyone else find the article picture really odd? (who uses a laptop that way?) http://s2.reutersmedia.net/resources/r/?m=02&d=20160407&t=2&i=1130943189&w=644&fh=&fw=&ll=&pl=&sq=&r=LYNXNPEC360F3 http://s2.reutersmedia.net/resources/r/?m=02&d=20160407&t=2&...
- jonbaer 11y agoI have always found this particular photo odd and showing up in a few strange places ... ie: https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2015/10/how-can-international-security-keep-up-with-technology https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2015/10/how-can-international... http://www.newsweek.com/cia-having-xfiles-fun-ufos-421407 http://www.newsweek.com/cia-having-xfiles-fun-ufos-421407 http://www.ndtv.com/world-news/britain-to-unveil-plan-for-new-internet-spying-laws-1239812 http://www.ndtv.com/world-news/britain-to-unveil-plan-for-ne...
- OscarCunningham 11y agoPeople with no tables or chairs?
- jchendy 11y agoIf I was in that situation, I'd sit on the floor.
- shoveljump 11y agoAnd if the floor was really dirty?
- T3RMINATED 11y agoLong Live http://www.thepiratebay.se/ http://www.thepiratebay.se/
- nkrisc 11y agoThis is at least reassuring. I don't think it's a big leap from saying that a link to a site with infringing content is itself an infringing act to saying a link to a site that links to a site [... etc] is itself infringing.
- Esau 11y agoI honestly can't believe this is even being debated.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- kzrdude 11y agoThis doesn't really go into hotlinking, does it? What's the legality of hotlinking? = embedding an image in your page by using an URL directly to an image that is hosted & controlled by someone else.
- extra88 11y agoNo, not hotlinking. I don't think hotlinking inherently could break a law, I think that would require some understanding that the host provides the content for one particular use and any other use would be a violation. There probably are sites with license agreements/terms of service that state as much in which case hotlinking would be breaking the contract. If ad blocking were illegal, it would be for the same reason. Hotlinking could be involved in criminal or civil actions, e.g. used to perpetrate fraud or used maliciously (intended to use up host's resources or even DDOS).
- pcr0 11y agoI'm no lawyer, but from an end user's perspective if you hotlinked an unauthorized image instead of linking to a page containing the image, then you aren't just "pointing" to the image anymore, you're practically displaying the image on your website.
- michaelmrose 11y agoThe content you have merely contains a link to the provided resource. The user can fetch your page without violating the law, the user can also legally fetch the image from the owner. So neither you nor your user have committed a crime. You could try to argue that the user requires a license to combine the 2 in ways not considered by you however this has several problems. - Its laughably unenforceable - In the us it would probably be fair use - It would make literally the entire internet illegal - It would make adblocking on your end illegal - It would make you a world wide source of negativity and scorn. Basically there is a technical solution to most hotlinking issues and every imaginable legal solution would be a cure worse than the disease.
- icebraining 11y agoThe Ninth Circuit says hotlinking is not infringing: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfect_10,_Inc._v._Amazon.com,_Inc https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfect_10,_Inc._v._Amazon.com....
- greglindahl 11y agoI wonder if this will have an impact on DMCA takedowns against search engines?
- criddell 11y agoSo I guess card catalogs in libraries are safe as well.
- sspiff 11y agoSo does such an advise also include things like magnet links, which do not include the content, or its location, but instead a description of the content by means of a hash or checksum?
- pvaldes 11y agoGiven the legal uncertainty introduced by the new Spanish law, I think that is not worth the risk to put links to spanish webs anymore in the 90% of the cases. Definitely, not more free linking to news on online journals related with AEDE by now. Unless absolutely necessary, I now give just a couple of clues and let people find the page for themselves in google if they want. Stupid measures for stupid times... Just my opinion.
- lutorm 11y agoI don't understand how a link could ever be judged to infringe copyright. No copy is made, any more than if I tell my friends, in person, to go and check out the cool, copyright-infringing photo that one of us have.
- rwjwjuwjudf 11y agoThe text of the link itself could contain copyright material. Google says the practical limit 10 years ago was ~100Kb, not sure now.
- brightball 11y agoThings like this are why I often wonder why people hail court verdicts so much. We've clearly established that courts are rarely even close to logically consistent, yet a court ruling in favor of or against an issue being discussed is often hailed as absolute truth.
- known 11y ago"If I have seen further it is by standing on the shoulders of giants" --Isaac Newton
- domergue 11y agoI saw a video from EU parliament where Gunther Oettinger urged that paper pritning news industry will die thanks to hyperlinking and so we, the EU, must do something about it (ratify this law). I think it's pretty clear where his second wage is coming from. Or he's absolutely stupid and doesn't have a clue about economy and prosperity.
- thirdsun 11y agoAh yes, Oettigner, EU commissioner for digital economy and society, no less. From the country that brought you greatest hits like "Leistungsschutzrecht".
- pluma 11y ago> I think it's pretty clear where his second wage is coming from. Or he's absolutely stupid and doesn't have a clue about economy and prosperity. Look into his relationship with lobbies and consumer rights' organisations some time. Also, his speech about the Taliban-like evils of net neutrality (yes, really). EDIT: And if you understand German, there's even a great remix: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fkORC6FcSH4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fkORC6FcSH4