20 ms·
More Than 40% of Student Borrowers Aren’t Making Payments
- pilom 11y agoDoes google get you around the paywall?
- orange_county 11y agoUnable to read due to a pay wall. Anyways, I wonder if there is a breakdown somewhere of the amount of debt and by schools. It be interesting to look at.
- stevesearer 11y agoI just used the 'web' button below the link and the WSJ article was the first result without a paywall.
- robbiet480 11y agoTo everyone complaining about the paywall, try hitting the "web" link at the top of this page (to the left of the story comments link)
- ars 11y agoThat doesn't work for me - it hasn't in a long long time.
- santa_boy 11y agoThank you. This works for me. Deviation: But why does this technique work? Any idea what is happening in the background that this article becomes readable on clicking the Google link?
- Shivetya 11y agoSorry, but when there is no testing to determine if they borrowers can even complete the course of study they have chosen why should we expect any other result? If you wanted the best example of why college education should not be free this is it. I am all for community style colleges that could be free or heavily discounted but the idea that people can simply choose ask for their degree be paid for without first demonstrating that it is course with a worthwhile career the country needs, they are capable of completing it, and they are also capable of holding a job, doesn't work for me. It isn't a right. When you become an adult you make choices, choices that come with responsibility to your self and others. This does not include demanding others support your flight of fancy, let alone one that may never pay out or benefit anyone other than the person taking the money
- jonah 11y agoIsn't the idea of the college admissions process (ideally) to determine whether "they can even complete the course of study"? Also, couldn't we set the number of (free) admissions to certain areas of study based on the national need for those professions?
- LeifCarrotson 11y agoIdeally, yes; practically, no. The point of admissions has become to determine that admitting a given student will do one of three things: Benefit the school through future press from stand-outs, alumni donations, and better GPA, SAT, and ACT stats in the various rankings (all leading to more enrollment in the future), benefit the school by paying to attend and not really affecting rankings, or whether they can pay and not really hurt ranks that badly. And the number of free admissions to most areas of undergraduate study is 0. Full-ride scholarships are usually athletic, not scholastic, but most partial scholarships are based on test scores and apply regardless of the course of study.
- superuser2 11y ago>Also, couldn't we set the number of (free) admissions to certain areas of study based on the national need for those professions? Philosophically, American universities are meant to 1) search for truth, 2) produce graduates who are educated about the most important findings and methods of the search for truth, 3) contribute to the general or local welfare in the process. Suggest to them that they are workforce training systems and you'll have a mess on your hands [0]. The private ones were doing this among the elite for hundreds of years, the public ones were meant to let the masses join the elite's party. Aside from specifically designed trade schools, neither are intended as (nor do they think of themselves as) servants of business needs for specific kinds of labor. That is why you see people required to take all kinds of "unnecessary" subjects like chemistry, physics, math, art, literature, philosophy, social sciences, etc. and even specialize in those things, regardless of whether they are relevant to career ambitions. And why this proposal is not tenable in the current system. Part of doing this for the masses is being unselective. If public universities became more selective to decrease their dropout rates, it would be seen as a betrayal of their identities and the very purpose of public education. (For some reason people are a lot more tolerant of their children washing out then of their children getting rejected). At the time, teenage/minimum wage was high enough in real terms were high and tuition was low enough (partly because public institutions had lower overhead, partly they had a lot more taxpayer support) that this was economically tenable. White collar employers found that college students were useful enough to put to work, even though their curriculum wasn't really designed at the employers' direction. Even in computing. A philosophically pure Computer Science curriculum (and mine comes close) asks the question, "So we have this model of computation, and these machines that implement it. What does that mean? What can we do with it?" It does not ask the question "How do we best prepare workers for the IT departments of the big local employers?" And this is why you get students learning things like theory of computation, fundamental algorithms, functional programming, operating systems, compilers, programming language theory and design, networking in the general rather than Cisco sense, etc. - things that re meant to be fundamental and timeless - instead of How To Contribute To Local BigCos Java/Win32 Codebases Right Now. Maybe we've outlived the usefulness of this notion. It's less present in Europe, but in Germany at least the college liberal arts curriculum is simply shifted into high school and reserved for the academically inclined (Gymansium). It's not that they don't do it, they just do it differently. [0] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/answer-sheet/wp/2015/02/05/how-gov-walker-tried-to-quietly-change-the-mission-of-the-university-of-wisconsin/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/answer-sheet/wp/2015/02/...
- codeulike 11y agoThats how its supposed to work, in the UK at least. Student Loans are like a distributed tax that only gets paid by the grads who earn enough to repay. edit: Also, in the UK, once you do earn enough, payment is automatic via deductions from payslips.
- sh1ps 11y agoThe article talks about many grads who could repay, but simply don't for whatever reason.
- TearsInTheRain 11y agoThat is because they have other debt they are prioritizing over their student loans
- mmcclure 11y agoRight, but just because they're taking on new debt that they're prioritizing over old debt doesn't mean that they weren't financially able to pay back the original debt. The important piece there is that the new debt has ramifications for non-payment that are much more obvious than the student loan debt.
- gozur88 11y agoThat's a terrible system, IMO. Why should we be rewarding B-Ark people while at the same time punishing people who get degrees in Engineering and Medicine? I can understand the logic for tax-supported universities (not necessarily agree, but understand), but this just seems... intellectually dysgenic.
- gatsby 11y agoFull text if you don't want to deal with google/paywall workarounds: More than 40% of Americans who borrowed from the government’s main student-loan program aren’t making payments or are behind on more than $200 billion owed, raising worries that millions of them may never repay. The new figures represent the fallout of a decadelong borrowing boom as record numbers of students enrolled in trade schools, universities and graduate schools. While most have since left school and entered the labor force, 43% of the roughly 22 million Americans with federal student loans weren’t making payments as of Jan. 1, according to a quarterly snapshot of the Education Department’s $1.2 trillion student-loan portfolio. About 1 in 6 borrowers, or 3.6 million, were in default on $56 billion in student debt, meaning they had gone at least a year without making a payment. Three million more owing roughly $66 billion were at least a month behind. Meantime, another three million owing almost $110 billion were in “forbearance” or “deferment,” meaning they had received permission to temporarily halt payments due to a financial emergency, such as unemployment. The figures exclude borrowers still in school and those with government-guaranteed private loans. The picture has improved slightly from a year earlier, when the nonpayment rate was 46%, but that progress largely reflected a surge in Americans entering a program for distressed borrowers to lower their payments. Enrollment in those plans, which slash monthly bills by tying them to a small percentage of borrowers’ incomes, jumped 48% over the year to 4.6 million borrowers as of Jan. 1. The Obama administration—worried about taxpayer costs and the prospect of consumers damaging their credit by defaulting—has stepped up efforts to reach borrowers and offer options to enroll in the income-based repayment plans. In some cases, the government is garnishing wages and tax refunds of borrowers who refuse to pay. But officials acknowledge that a large pool of borrowers have essentially fallen off the radar. Loan servicers—companies the government hires to collect debt—say they can’t reach such defaulted borrowers despite hundreds of attempts through phone calls, text messages and emails. The Education Department has assembled a “behavioral sciences unit” to study the psychology of borrowers and why they don’t repay. “We obviously have not cracked that nut but we want to keep working on it,” said Ted Mitchell, the Education Department’s undersecretary. He said many defaulted borrowers dropped out of school and are underemployed. Carlo Salerno, an economist who studies higher education and has consulted for the private student-lending industry, noted that the government imposes virtually no credit checks on borrowers, requires no cosigners and doesn’t screen people for their preparedness for college-level course work. “On what planet does a financing vehicle with those kinds of terms and those kinds of performance metrics make sense,” he said. Some borrowers aren’t repaying even when they can. Research from Navient Corp., which services loans for the government, shows that borrowers prioritize other bills—such as car loans, mortgages and heating bills—over student debt. A borrower who fails to pay down an auto loan might have her car repossessed; with student loans, there is no such threat. Kristopher Mathews, 38 years old, is in deferment on about $11,900 in federal student loans. During the recession he earned a certificate at a Michigan-based for-profit college that teaches media arts, but he wasn’t able to find the well-paying job in radio that he hoped for. Mr. Mathews now works as a logistical analyst for a U.S. auto company, making $46,000 annually. He says he devotes his income to caring for his family—he and his fiancée have three children—and then paying off two credit cards and a car loan. “With all the other necessities in life I just don’t have” funds to pay the student debt, Mr. Mathews said. Once his deferment expires, he isn’t sure if he will feel obliged to pay down his loan. “They promised me everything,” he said of his for-profit college. “And I honestly have nothing to show for it except a piece of paper that doesn’t really do me any good.” Most borrowers who have defaulted owe relatively little—a median $8,900, according to the Education Department. Advocacy groups, some members of Congress and the federal Consumer Financial Protection Bureau have faulted loan servicers for not doing enough to reach troubled borrowers to offer repayment options. But the picture is more complicated. Navient, which also services private loans, says it attempts to reach each borrower on average 230 to 300 times—through letters, emails, calls and text messages—in the year leading up to his or her default. Ninety percent of those borrowers, which include federal borrowers as well as those who hold private loans, never respond and more than half never made a single payment before they defaulted, the company says. The administration maintains that the student-loan program, as a whole, will generate a profit over the long term, but the risk is rising that the revenue won’t meet the administration’s projections. Even many borrowers who are current on their loans are paying very little. More than a third of borrowers on an income-based repayment plan had monthly payments of zero because their incomes were so low, according to a Navient survey last year. The Education Department, through private debt-collection agencies, garnished $176 million in Americans’ wages in the final three months of last year for student debt, federal data show. The administration’s pursuit of troubled borrowers is drawing criticism from student advocates and their allies in Congress. Last week, the American Civil Liberties Union and the National Consumer Law Center sued the Education Department, accusing it of blocking public access to data on the agency’s debt-collection efforts. The groups suggested that the companies collecting debt for the department might be discriminating against black and Hispanic borrowers. Dorie Nolt, a spokeswoman for Education Secretary John B. King Jr., said the agency is reviewing the groups’ public-information requests. “The singular goal of our student loan program is to help all students get a degree that sets them up for success, and we take the treatment of our borrowers—particularly historically underserved students—very seriously,” Ms. Nolt said in an email.
- sooper 11y agoIn New Zealand the Government has started to arrest defaulters at the border[1]. This may not work as well for US as I am not sure of the percentage who travel outside the country versus NZ. [1] http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=11616227 http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objecti...
- Daishiman 11y agoWow, modern-day debtor's prisons making a comeback. Welcome to the Middle Ages.
- ArkyBeagle 11y agoAlex Tabbarok wrote what I consider an extremely good piece about the relationship of this with the trouble in Ferguson, Mo over the last few years: http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2014/08/ferguson-and-the-debtors-prison.html http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2014/08/fer...
- magicGLASSman 11y agoMost our tax dollars go to pay down the interest on our countries debt and you go to prison if you don't pay your taxes. Crazy Days
- Daishiman 11y agoThere's a different between taking your assets and sending you to jail.
- stellar678 11y agoHardly - try 6% of our tax dollars. https://apps.irs.gov/app/understandingTaxes/whys/thm01/les01/ac3_thm01_les01.jsp https://apps.irs.gov/app/understandingTaxes/whys/thm01/les01...
- paulmd 11y agoAbsolutely false, interest payments make up only 6% of Federal spending. https://www.nationalpriorities.org/budget-basics/federal-budget-101/spending/ https://www.nationalpriorities.org/budget-basics/federal-bud...
- partycoder 11y agoAround the world many institutions use factoring. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Factoring_(finance) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Factoring_(finance) This converts receivables into cash by selling them a third party at a discount. This doesn't prevent the educational institutions from getting their cash. Not sure how it works in the US.
- jff 11y agoThe Department of Education sold my loan to a private company within a year or so of graduation. No rate change or anything, I just started logging in on a different web site to pay. Same thing with my wife and with many people I know.
- tropo 11y agoThis is terrifying. Did you get registered mail at least? Did the old web site tell you where to go? If you don't believe the notice you are given, you fail to pay. If you do believe whatever notice you get, you are vulnerable to fraud.
- suninwinter 11y agoMy mortgage has been sold at least 4 times since I got it about 3 years ago. Each time, I get a letter from the old company and the new company. Hopefully, that's what happened here.
- hdctambien 11y agoMy understanding is that the Department of Education was never servicing your load, they contract that out from the beginning. If your load gets transferred. It happens because one of their contractors "goes away" and all the loans that contractor was servicing need to be transferred to another contractor. I wouldn't buzz in on Jeopardy with that answer, though.
- mbesto 11y agoThat doesn't make the problem any less worrisome. Factoring assumes that the company paying for an invoice will have the means to pay off the service rendered eventually (on a net 30/60/90 basis usually). Factoring helps to free up cashflow for the receiver, not necessarily guarantee that a remittance be satisfied. If the core value were the latter, the premiums go up so high that it's not really financially viable for most businesses to use factoring against their receivables. The problem with student debt is default, not cash flow. Further, the problem isn't the educational institution getting paid, it's the lender (in this case the government, and thus the taxpayers) who lent out money to people without any historical context of their ability to pay off a loan. Hence the quote: “On what planet does a financing vehicle with those kinds of terms and those kinds of performance metrics make sense,” he said.
- kdamken 11y agoNot surprising. Lots of kids are holding out hoping that someone will get elected and wave a wand to magically erase the money they borrowed.
- dandanisaur 11y agoSources?
- virmundi 11y agoBernie Sanders' offer of State paid college education. One point is that I've never seen him offer an ex post facto payoff. It is a logical extension of his current platform of making education a right.
- KZeillmann 11y agoI think it's more complicated than that. It's a huge, broken system. 17-year-olds can't fully grasp the burden of their debt when they take it on, and they've been told all their lives that they need to go to college to be successful. You've got a great potion for disaster here: 1) You can't be denied an education loan. 2) Education loans can't be wiped out in bankruptcy because 3) You can't repossess an education. 4) Because of the above factors, there's little incentive for colleges to keep cost of attendance low. I have no idea what the solution should be, but this problem can't continue indefinitely. It's a more complicated issue than just, "Millennials are just looking for handouts and don't want to pay their debts."
- prostoalex 11y ago> 2) Education loans can't be wiped out in bankruptcy because One can opt in for an unsecured personal loan, which are wiped out in bankruptcy, but those come at higher rates to compensate for the risk. The reason for low(er) rates on student loans is their legislatively mandated low rates of default.
- Pinckney 11y ago
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- guelo 11y agoThere's a simple solution, the Feds should cutoff loans for schools that don't get their students jobs. The government are the only ones that are able to accurately calculate which schools are completely worthless. In fact they should take it one step further and advertise to the whole world what percentage of students get jobs in their studied field and the average starting salary. That would finally put some market pressure on schools to do their damn job and teach useful skills.
- khnd 11y agoyes absolutely. this is a great idea. loan defaults by school would be an excellent indicator. more upvotes please.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- Symbiote 11y ago> schools to do their damn job and teach useful skills That may be the purpose of the loans, but it is not necessarily the purpose of universities.
- ryandrake 11y agoDepends on your definition of "purpose". The purpose of the DMV is not necessarily to enable people to drive, but they are the ones who do the test and hand out the piece of plastic, so we're kind of splitting hairs.
- alanh 11y ago> splitting hairs No we’re not! The framing of higher education as a career enabler with positive ROI is the #1 bit of propaganda that has justified and reframed how tuition is evaluated and is directly responsible for the steady and insane yearly tuition hike since the 1980s. Fighting for the essence and purpose of higher education is therefore not trivial but in fact paramount. The fact that we are having this conversation in a thread suggesting that the federal government enforce universities as job mills is, I trust, enough evidence to make my point. For a more in-depth treatment of this topic, see "Colleges are full of it: Behind the three-decade scheme to raise tuition, bankrupt generations, and hypnotize the media" on Salon: http://www.salon.com/2014/06/08/colleges_are_full_of_it_behind_the_three_decade_scheme_to_raise_tuition_bankrupt_generations_and_hypnotize_the_media/ http://www.salon.com/2014/06/08/colleges_are_full_of_it_behi...
- sh1ps 11y agoA big takeaway from this article (for me) is that people are surprised that 17 year old kids don't understand what they're doing when they take out that college loan. Shock and astonishment despite there being little to no preparation for this kind of financial understanding previously in their education. That surprise and shock shocks and surprises me. Honestly it kind of reminds me of the whole Yelp minimum wage thing. Person knowingly takes a minimum wage job in the most expensive city in the world and is surprised a year later when that wasn't very much money and they're struggling. The simplest cost of living calculations would have said "moving to that city and taking that job is a really bad idea." This isn't to say that there aren't things that need to change. Education reform is necessary as well as a living wage, but I'd also argue that basic financial literacy is also a requirement for being an adult and should be treated as such.
- ZanyProgrammer 11y agoWho is supposed to work those jobs then? Even if Yelp relocated their non engineering staff, paying them minimum wage in some other city won't help them.
- fixermark 11y agoActually, it can. It's not just the payment; it's payment against cost of living. $9 an hour might afford a house in the suburbs of a small city, or an apartment in a smaller city. It doesn't scratch the paint on the cost of a basic apartment in the Valley.
- Retra 11y agoAnd that's assuming you can get enough hours to work full time, and also have benefits to cover whatever mishaps may develop. And that you don't have any dependents.
- kelukelugames 11y agoThis is part of the reason zapped moved their call center out of the bay area and into Nevada.
- ameyamk 11y agoI wonder if there is investment vehicle I can short to make some profit if these loans do actually go bad?
- shogun21 11y agoGo to the bank and have them write you up a credit default swap.
- ndesaulniers 11y agoheh, reminds me of The Big Short; "no one bets against the housing market!" (since the implications of the housing market failing are frightening)
- manav 11y ago~90% of student loan debt is federal, but there are private loan companies like Navient/Sallie Mae. You could buy put options on the equity.
- elihu 11y agoI was just thinking the other day, that it would be logical for there to exist something like a mortgage-backed security for student debt. Call it a millenial-backed security. You'd bundle up a bunch of student student loans into a security, then sell shares, paying out the interest as dividends. It'd be like 2007 all over again! What could possibly go wrong? In a sense, I suppose that's not much different than buying stock in a bank that's heavily invested in student loans. You can invest in or short those as you see fit.
- chadzawistowski 11y agoNot really. Shamelessly copying a comment by /u/MasterCookSwag on reddit: THIS is the major piece everyone misses. Mortgages were such a disaster because banks held the debt securities thinking they were safe assets and they weren't. This caused a chain reaction of devaluation of balance sheet assets and paper losses which resulted in the collapse of some major institutions. It then caused credit to dry up so businesses couldn't borrow and a crisis of confidence in the fundamentals of the economy. Student debt won't do any of these things because the underlying structure is not even remotely similar. What student debt will do is represent a long term suck on the taxpayer both directly(through payments) and indirectly(through defaults). This will result in a drag on GDP. There is no way to short this and there won't be a collapse. That doesn't make it not a bad thing. https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/4cj937/eli5_if_the_student_loan_bubble_is_so_certain_to/d1j3wwa https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/4cj937/e...
- igetspam 11y agoMy wife is one of these borrowers. She has a master's degree in teaching. It cost her over $100k to get and she can't find job that would pay her enough that she'd be required to pay anything back. I've seen her loan repayment docs and her minimum payment due is $0 every month. While I think her decision to get a masters in education was a bad one (before we were married) I laugh at an institution that would loan her money for a field that doesn't pay, ask her to pay at least $0 a month and then complain that the loans are not being paid back. I just paid Navient the outstanding $18 they've been bounding her for and plan on paying them nothing again until my houses are paid off.
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoWhile she doesn't have a job that pays enough to trigger repayment, is the loan accruing interest? If so, is the interest rate higher than the one on your mortgage? If so, you might want to reconsider your strategy...
- addled 11y agoSome of these income based payment plans have a forgiveness clause after 20-25 years, so it may still make sense.
- maaku 11y agoSubject to many stipulations. One of them being that you are making regular payments...
- tostitos1979 11y agoRight ... I know many of my wife's friend's making minimum payments. I said no way .. we're paying the loan off first. I won't mention the amount but man, we could have bought a fleet of boats for that (think about what the average med student accrues in debt).
- addled 11y agoBut what if the minimum payment is 0, and you pay it regularly?
- gtrubetskoy 11y ago"About 1 in 6 borrowers, or 3.6 million, were in default on $56 billion in student debt" I thought "default" is technically impossible with respect to student loans, your solvency matters not, you're obligated to pay it off even if takes your entire life (and/or life's earnings)? This problem would get fixed very quickly if students were allowed to actually default on the loan and stop paying it, at which point it becomes a loss to the lender, like it is with any other loan. Then these loans wouldn't be handed out like candy to people who are not mature enough to understand what it takes to pay off $100K and thereby ruining their lives.
- phdp 11y agoDefault just means to not pay back what you promised when you promised. You are confusing this with the fact that, except in relatively rare circumstances, one cannot shed the debt in bankruptcy.
- khnd 11y agoit's these 'for profit college' they have to go. i suspect most are total trash. also - with all these coding bootcamps popping up nowdays, im not sure if people are able to get govt student loans for these or what but it sounds like trouble. ppl are desperate to jump on the coding gold rush and the great salaries and job market. ppl are going to get fucked over big time. first time i saw this[0] all kinds of warning bells went off. im sure there is a way forward so that people can learn and share the value created from software development job market but i think we should move fwd carefully. ppl will definitely get fd over. but yea most of those 'for-profit' colleges are totally shady. do they have everest college in the US? perfect example of this kind of bs. in canada they got shut down, but not before screwing over tons of people out of their money for years[1]. [0]: http://www.inc.com/maria-aspan/max-levchin-affirm-better-student-loan.html http://www.inc.com/maria-aspan/max-levchin-affirm-better-stu... [1]: http://www.cbc.ca/news/business/everest-college-closure-no-surprise-to-some-who-call-it-a-scam-1.2969513 http://www.cbc.ca/news/business/everest-college-closure-no-s...
- brbsix 11y agoAt least the coding bootcamps are subject to market pressures that keep tuition (and subject matter) within the realm of economic reality. The fact that guaranteed subsidized loans are not available for them is probably of massive benefit.
- pkulak 11y agoBlendle link: https://blendle.com/i/wsj-com/more-than-40-of-student-borrowers-aren-t-making-payments/bnl-wsj-20160406-SB11182712333752343323104581645301231942680 https://blendle.com/i/wsj-com/more-than-40-of-student-borrow...
- 650REDHAIR 11y agoQueue Xzibit meme "I heard you like paywalls so we put a paywall in front of your paywall"
- rdtsc 11y ago> The Education Department has assembled a “behavioral sciences unit” to study the psychology of borrowers and why they don’t repay. Ha! There is a bit of a hypocrisy there -- if big banks / companies piss away money and choose to strategically default then (and some even get bail-outs), it is just business. If people do it for whatever reason, well clearly the are immoral, deficient somehow, their psychology needs to be studied by a special committee. > Some borrowers aren’t repaying even when they can. Yap, makes sense. They see banks get bailouts, why shouldn't they get bailouts. Now maybe they shouldn't have been allowed to borrow to start with. But maybe so shouldn't have banks and insurance companies been allowed to leverage to unsustainable levels. > The singular goal of our student loan program is to help all students get a degree that sets them up for success One a separate note, that needs to be reviewed and re-evaluated. There are deeper issues here. Simply handing out billions of dollars for degrees like Masters in Basket Weaving from Phoenix University cannot possibly be seen as solution to anything (except well, handing out tax payer money to Phoenix University...)
- letitgo12345 11y agoThe TARP bailout was not money just handed out to banks. It was loans to banking and other industries which was repaid in full overall. And in fact it was the auto industry which failed to repay the loan, not the banking industry. I'm not a fan of the financial sector but let's keep the facts straight here
- kaonashi 11y agoIt was backstopping shitty loans with the full faith & credit of the gov't. Note that the person who received the shitty loan still got foreclosed on and lost their equity. The persons responsible, who made the loan, don't have to take a loss.
- oldmanjay 11y agoWhat sort of belief should I start from to be able to decide that people taking a loan they can't afford bear no responsibility? I imagine it's the same sort of thinking that leads to calling a property they never actually paid for theirs but I am not sure and when I am not sure, I ask.
- jamesblonde 11y agoFor a really interesting take on student debt, read commentary by the financial historian, Russell Napier, such as this: http://moneyweek.com/russell-napier-give-everybody-in-china-a-credit-card/ http://moneyweek.com/russell-napier-give-everybody-in-china-... He believes that deflation is coming (along with a recession) and the solution to deflation will not be monetary stimulus (negative interest rates or bond-buying), but rather political. First on his expected list of measures is a write-off of student debt in the US, to help reflate the economy :)
- tyre 11y agoWe have set students up to fail. On the one hand, we tell them that everyone has to go to college and that more education is better. Regardless of whether more education has any financial return. Is that the only metric? Absolutely not, but there is a point at which education is a luxury.[1] My entire high school education was focused on how to get into the "best" college. On the other hand, in order to get that education, they have to take out significant loans. At 17 or 18, they have little to no understanding of—let alone, ironically, education—about personal finance. So financially uninformed take on large amounts of debt with no gauge of whether that is a positive investment. Sound familiar? We did the same thing to uninformed mortgage buyers until they started to default in 2007. [1]: I say this having majored in Philosophy. It was a luxury that, coincidentally, is immensely valuable. At the time, however, I didn't know that, I was just interested.
- roymurdock 11y agoInterested to hear what you think some possible solutions might be.
- jonlucc 11y ago> Regardless of whether more education has any financial return. Interestingly, this is a difficult problem to crack, because it is valuable to have the degree. In 2008, people without a college education were hit the hardest in terms of jobs lost; the jobs for college educated went to basically no growth, but didn't quite tip into job loss. So if I'm a kid trying to make this decision, do I choose high debt with some chance of having a stable future or a cheap barrier to entry for a job that is likely to crap out as soon as the economy looks bad again? > they have little to no understanding of—let alone, ironically, education—about personal finance This is also important to me. Having lived with my parents until college (which I think is the norm), I don't think I would have really understood what it means to pay $500 or $1500 a month on my loans.
- serge2k 11y ago> My entire high school education was focused on how to get into the "best" college. and? The alternative is closing doors.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- thearn4 11y agoIf graduates had the option to discharge their student loan debt in bankruptcy in exchange for revoking their degree, I wonder how many would end up taking that option.
- nly 11y agoHow do you 'revoke' a degree?
- thearn4 11y agoThe scenario that I proposed was entirely hypothetical, but I image that they are revoked in the same way that any credential is revoked: if asked to verify that an individual holds it, indicate instead that they don't. I mean, this has happened a number of times to doctorate degree holders when it was later discovered that they falsified research for their dissertation.
- nly 11y agoYeah, but publishing a statement that announces that you're a cheat, and that your education is a sham, actually damages your reputation and your career. Cutting up some paper so you can be debt free would just show that you're not a complete nit. Even if you actually needed that paper to prove that you are in fact qualified, an entire industry would appear overnight dedicated to providing certified copies. The free market ultimately decides what credentials to trust.
- randyrand 11y agoYou'd need to drain them of their college memories too, somehow, for the hypothetical question of "was it worth it/can I give it back?" to have merit.
- autotune 11y agoYou steal the knowledge back of course. http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/20578712-chimpanzee http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/20578712-chimpanzee
- 11y ago
- nothrabannosir 11y agoThe Education Department has assembled a “behavioral sciences unit” to study the psychology of borrowers and why they don’t repay. “We obviously have not cracked that nut but we want to keep working on it,” said Ted Mitchell, the Education Department’s undersecretary. He said many defaulted borrowers dropped out of school and are underemployed. This is surreal. Could they be any more patronizing?
- DanBC 11y ago"behaviour sciences" sounds like they're looking at nudge-like approach to see if they can make more people repay, rather than just being clueless about the fact that unemployed people have no money.
- brbsix 11y agoAnd people still say there's no higher education loan bubble. I suppose it's the same logic that argues the U.S. Federal government can never become insolvent (as it's the world's reserve currency and can simply print money to pay off it's debts).
- surds 11y agoThat is a sad state of affairs, though I must say I have seen worse numbers back in India. Last time I talked with them, I was told that I was one of the 3 active accounts out of 20 granted ones that was repaying the loan. That's 17 out of 20 in default - a massive 85%. Some of them were actually not in a situation where they could pay back the loan. Others didn't want to. This was the situation at that single bank branch. Don't want to imagine how large the total default amount must be.
- thearn4 11y agoI'm curious, how does the cost of higher education in India compare to the U.S.?
- drl42 11y agoDepends upon the university, if it is publicly funded or not. Tuition for private universities ranges from $1000-$10000 per year. Public universities - Less than $1000 per year, in many cases no tuition.
- surds 11y agoHighly varies by the program and university. When I started my graduation program in 2013, higher education from good universities in India would have had a fees of around 20k to 30K USD, or even more. Of course, graduating from a good university here meant a lot more fees. Unfortunately, and it is something that I really hate is that, the education loan system in India can really use an update - at least in terms of the loan amount that is offered to prospective students. As the bankers told me, there is a limit of roughly 25K USD that can be allowed for education within India. For those who want to get the loan for international programs, the limit is roughly 33K USD. Now, for local education, that is a decent amount, though might not be sufficient in many cases. For international education, it is NOT sufficient. This restriction applies to government banks and they usually follow it. Private banks have made a lucrative business out of this, and offer much larger loans to students at nasty, and often floating, interest rates (17% or so would be average.) That becomes a hell of a loan to pay back even if you are earning in USD and returning in INR.
- quantum_nerd 11y agoAs someone who has been paying upwards of 20% or more of my monthly take home pay to student loans, I am surprised the figure of delinquent payers isn't higher. I count myself one of the lucky ones(CS degree, gainfully employed...) and I have college friends making close to minimum wage, with more students loans than I and struggling to make payments. Who thought a $25,000/year(and rising) public university education was a good idea ?
- pink_dinner 11y agoWe really need to educate students potentially starting college that they shouldn't major in something that pretty much has no chance of ever paying it back. This applies to most liberal arts programs. A college education is a major investment. It's sad that culturally, our financial education is this poor. I majored in a science and had all of my debts paid off within 5 years. I have friends that majored in things like history and still haven't paid their debts off after 10 years. The popular thing to to is blame society, the university, or even high school teachers for recommending someone go to college. But, students need to take personal responsibility for taking out a loan and being unable to pay it back. When this happens, we will have less students making foolish decisions.
- whitegrape 11y agoEducation on the individual level just doesn't work. People are too dumb. (I had the pleasure of rereading this recently: http://www.overcomingbias.com/2009/07/stupider-than-you-realize.html http://www.overcomingbias.com/2009/07/stupider-than-you-real...) Those that aren't too dumb lack personal responsibility, which is a separate problem I fully agree is pretty big, so more education might fix that, but that's sort of something you can't learn from a book, and arguably the game of chicken at teaching responsibility by making it illegal to discharge student loans in bankruptcy has just made things worse. The solutions I think have the best shot are those that involve authoritarian decrees one way or another (that is, going full free-market or going full nationalized colleges), but that requires a government with an actual interest in governing.
- pink_dinner 11y ago"Education on the individual level just doesn't work. People are too dumb." Honestly, If this is the case, drugs should never be fully legalized. People just can't handle the responsibility. Will addiction be the fault of the company that sold it to you? "and arguably the game of chicken at teaching responsibility by making it illegal to discharge student loans in bankruptcy has just made things worse." It hasn't really made things worse. If it wasn't illegal to discharge loans, students would know full well that they most likely would never have to pay it back and just declare bankruptcy when they graduated. That would be a much worse situation for our economy. On top of this, banks would never even take on these loans knowing full well that they would probably never get their money back. The student debt problem has been bad for at least a decade. Students continue to knowingly put themselves in this position and then cry afoul when they can't pay the debt back. Lack of knowledge is no longer an excuse. Anybody with half a brain and an Internet connection can clearly see the risks (and nearly everyone now is connected to the Internet 24/7 through their phone). I see it more as a millennial problem: the culture is to no longer take responsibilities for your own actions and blame others for all of your failures. "full nationalized colleges" I can't see this working out with the current climate, unless it completely ruins the intent of a university. Fully national colleges aren't based on money any longer, they are based on making the grade. IE: if you can't pass the entrance exams, you won't get into school (as seen in pretty much any country with nationalized universities). The system we have setup now was a response to people complaining that not everyone has a chance to go to school (back in the 50s, college was a luxury only the wealthy could afford). Now that pretty much everyone does have a chance, there are further complaints that some people made an irresponsible decision. You can't force someone to major in something that will make the ma decent living. When I was in college, I met many people that really had no business being there (didn't care, didn't put the effort in, or just couldn't handle any of the subjects). With the dumbing down of the SATs and many other measures to make it easier to get into school not based on academics, it seems we are well on our way to ruining our institutions. The ultimate form of anti-intellectualism.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- manav 11y agoIt would be interesting to explore what kind of short positions are possible. The majority of student debt is federal, so you would probably be looking at the big private issuers like Nelnet and Sallie Mae/Navient (https://www.navient.com/about/investors/debtasset/ https://www.navient.com/about/investors/debtasset/). I don't know if there is much of a CDO/CDS market anymore for student-loan debt because subsidies ended some years ago. Lending standards have probably tightened as a result, but it's possible that there are some student-loan backed securities out there with a high probability of default. I've thought about shorting Navient/Sallie Mae directly, but their ties to the federal government make me think that they could possibly benefit from a government bail-out or takeover if it came to it. There's also the possibility of taking a short position on the for-profit education industry. Institutions (or rather Companies) like DeVry and University of Phoenix probably have some of the highest debt and default rates. If they lose federal funding, their future is grim.
- BackPropagate 11y agoDisgusting. There should be NO MORE government-backed student loans. Watch tuition prices drop, too.
- jbkkd 11y agoWe're headed toward a financial crisis. Borrowers not being able to pay loans.. Awfully sounds like the mortgage crisis.
- tsunamifury 11y agoExcept the government owns most of the debt, and can easily adjust it since it also mints the money.
- shostack 11y ago/EDIT/ Would love to know why I was downvoted for pointing out what seem to be very real differences in the circumstances and asking for some backup in the form of data as to why this will lead to the disaster that the parent stated without supporting facts. ----- I'm not sure they are equatable. - Don't pay your mortgage, lose your house. This partly caused some of the panic that made a lot of people try to sell when they couldn't make payments. Don't pay your student loans...give back your knowledge? If I recall correctly declaring bankruptcy won't get rid of these loans, but it isn't like people are on the streets. - A big factor in the mortgage crisis was how these bad loans were packaged into all number of convoluted and intentionally misleading securities products, and then dumped on the public markets where they became a large part of the portfolios of Main St. and Wall St. investors. Are there similar securities products around college loans, and is there data that suggests that repayment issues with them could have anywhere near the same impact? I'm genuinely curious for some data on this. It ultimately looks like the ones left holding the bag would be the government (not good, but they have more flexibility in how they deal with things that doesn't necessarily tank the economy) and other loan institutions/banks. I don't think anyone will shed a tear if the banks get hurt as long as it doesn't cripple the economy, which again, it doesn't sound like it would.
- ausjke 11y agoWe have 47 million on food stamps, that's about 15% of the whole population. 47% does not pay a penny for tax, now even for those who are luck to have college educations that 40% of the borrowers are not paying back, I'm just wondering, where will the money come from to fill up the holes? Adding on the military expense etc, the country is so totally financially broken. How sad.
- nkurz 11y ago47% does not pay a penny for tax That's not actually true. The (mostly) correct version is that 40-some percent of the adult US population does not pay federal income tax. The number of "working age Americans" who actually pay no net federal taxes is actually less than 5%: http://zfacts.com/47-percent http://zfacts.com/47-percent When you factor in state taxes the number drops even farther. Include sales taxes, and it's probably zero. Saying that "almost half don't pay federal income tax" is still striking, but should be kept in context.
- Abundnce10 11y agoCan somebody compare this (let's call it a Student Loan Bubble) to the Subprime Mortgage Bubble? I'm trying to get a sense of how big the problem is by comparing it to the last bubble we just experienced.
- jpmattia 11y agoYou can get a sense of the scale for the subprime/Alt-A market here: http://bp3.blogger.com/_pMscxxELHEg/RxzD0s_7EYI/AAAAAAAABB4/ljDSXZhMG3o/s1600/IMFresets.jpg http://bp3.blogger.com/_pMscxxELHEg/RxzD0s_7EYI/AAAAAAAABB4/... That graph shows you the size of the actual loans, but there was also a sizeable amount of money tied up in derivatives of those loans, which multiplied the effect.
- kin 11y agoI also noticed while doing taxes that if I borrow money, I'm going to pay interest on that money I borrow. One of the incentives to this self investment is that I can deduct the interest that I pay. However, apparently, if your salary is above a certain threshold, you don't qualify for education deductions and credits. It's a first world problem, I know, but I just found out and it kind of sucked.
- Unklejoe 11y agoThe same thing happened to me. I think they phase you out of the student loan interest deduction after you pass $65,000 taxable income. I'm actually going to increase my 401k contribution to try to retain more of that deduction.
- relaytheurgency 11y agoI did not know this. I guess I will be doing the same or starting an IRA.
- relaytheurgency 11y agoYou can only deduct 2,500 dollars of student loan interest (Hilariously, even if you're married this doesn't go up. My spouse has no student loans, but I still can only deduct 2,500 filing jointly). When I went back to school to finish my degree I put my loans into deferment, so now I am paying a bunch of interest back. Seems like a shitty situation. Before I got my degree I was making less than a third of what I make now, even though I worked more and got paid overtime. That was at a job I had worked at for five years and was likely maxed out of earning potential in that industry. I made little enough to have almost no federal tax burden. By providing loans the government has essentially turned a tax burden into a revenue generator. In just two years I am making this much more money, paying a bunch more in taxes, and my lifetime earning potential has increased significantly. But they still try to screw you from both ends, of course.
- selimthegrim 11y agoCue this recent hit from Baton Rouge: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JqbXQa05Z6c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JqbXQa05Z6c
- roymurdock 11y agoHere is an interesting comment on reddit in response to someone asking how they could profit from a mass student loan default scenario: You bring up a really interesting point, my buddies and I have been mulling this over. Three important distinctions between student loans and mortgages: Mortgages are backed by an underlying asset (the house) for which there is a liquid market and transparent price discovery, so it's easy to determine when the borrower's position is insolvent (i.e.; loan balance > home value; negative equity) For many student loans, the Federal government assumes the risk of default; also, Sallie Mae dominates the secondary market, and shorting them entails political risk (you're betting against a bailout) While painful, defaulting on a mortgage is a realistic option for borrowers: declare bankruptcy, give up the house keys to the bank, have shitty credit for 7 years, and you're out from under it; by contrast, student loans survive bankruptcy (and the principal keeps growing) Student loans are far more insidious precisely because it is difficult for the market to take a natural short position and put downward pressure on prices. What would a bubble 'pop' look like? For housing, the slow-down/decline in home prices simultaneously bankrupted hundreds of thousands of over-leveraged owners. It's hard to imagine a scenario where a significant portion of student loan borrowers simultaneously stop paying, and even if they did the loan owner can chase them through bankruptcy and garnish their wages. That looks like a recipe for a long, slow, toxic drag on the economy. https://www.reddit.com/r/finance/comments/3y39x2/just_saw_the_big_short_what_if_someone_shorted/ https://www.reddit.com/r/finance/comments/3y39x2/just_saw_th...
- josephjrobison 11y agoWondering if it would help at all if the parents saved up enough for each kid to fully fund their private college, and then when the kid hits high school tell them - when you graduate, you'll get $50k/yr towards your college. If you go to a private school it will cover it, but not leave much. If you go to a good public school, the extra $20k/yr is yours. If you get a full ride scholarship, the $50k/yr is all yours. Would that work? I'm assuming for some it would.
- joe5150 11y agoPeople with the means of fully funding their kids' private educations (even if they've "saved up") don't tend to have student loan defaults by definition, so I don't see how that's even relevant. If even a plurality of parents in America could afford to do that, we'd live in a different world.
- meric 11y ago>> If you get a full ride scholarship, the $50k/yr is all yours. Would that work? I'm assuming for some it would. Bitter personal experience taught me using extrinsic motivation destroys intrinsic motivation. The kid will get that scholarship to pocket the $50k/yr. But then the kid won't be motivated to do much more than that afterwards. Now all he or she's thinking is how fast they can spend the $50k.
- douche 11y agoSave money for college, and most schools will just take that directly off the top of your financial aid package...
- Overtonwindow 11y agoI wonder if there is any school that shows students how much money they are expected to earn after graduation for their selected major, compared to the amount of debt they will have. I work with several people who have large amounts of student debt, but when I ask about their studies at college, the average income for their degrees pale in comparison to any salary they might ever earn that will help them conquer that debt. I think students should be made aware of a cost benefit analysis for their chosen majors.
- roymurdock 11y agohttp://www.payscale.com/college-roi http://www.payscale.com/college-roi
- dv_dt 11y agoI this comes out of the flawed meme of private enterprise efficient/gov't inefficient. Thought it's true in some areas, in the area of funding education in society, it's terrible. The loans push money to unsophisticated buyers (kids and their parents), who use it to make a huge amorphous transaction which is only performed once in their lives and plays out over years. There's insufficient buyer information to provide price discrimination for the asset being purchased - so it's just inflating college prices. On the other hand, if we took the same amount of money and goverments directly funded public schools - there's a lot of attention over time and many transactions that can be administered by a gov't department to provide funding discrimination and control over the quality of what is provided. (BTW this is how many low cost public schools were funded in the boomer generation... at least in California) Edit: BTW, Does any reader here know of any interesting economic theory on how to predict if a market will act efficiently? I'm imagining there must be some way to model the structure of a given market with information, quality and quantity of transactions between nodes representing persons/companies/institutions in a market.
- prostoalex 11y agoThat strategy seems to work for Year 1, but what happens when (a) universities expand to cover this newly created demand, thus requiring larger budgets, (b) people enroll only to find out that the classes they are interested in are full? To quote http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2015/05/the-upwardly-mobile-barista/389513/ http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2015/05/the-upwa... "When it comes to college, the central challenge for most Americans in the 21st century is not going; it’s finishing. Thirty-five million Americans now have some college experience but no degree. More Americans than live in Texas, in other words, have spent enough time at college to glimpse the promised land—but not enough to reap the financial bounty. Some are worse off than if they’d never enrolled at all, carrying tens of thousands of dollars in debt, not to mention the scar tissue of regret and self-doubt. President Obama’s recent proposal to have the federal government and states pay for two years of community college is elegantly simple, and would surely prompt more students to enroll. But community college is already close to free for most low-income students, and still only 4 percent of all community-college students earn a two-year degree in two years. (Yes, 4 percent.) Money is just part of the problem."
- skywhopper 11y agoThis headline is misleading. 40% of borrowers "aren't making payments or are behind". Those are two entirely different categories.
- Overtonwindow 11y agoA serious problem with student debt that is not talked about enough is the inflated cost of classes, schoolbooks, and the pile on of all of these extra classes that university forces you to take and pay for, that are there only to pay graduate students. It's crazy how many pointless labs you are forced to take now, classes that have never had labs before. I think we need to dramatically reduce the number of classes that students are required to take to get a degree.
- williesleg 11y agoDoesn't matter. The parents are responsible. Even if they didn't sign for the loan or have any knowledge of it. Next they'll be going broke and we'll have to wait for more handouts from the government. Feel the Bern! Thanks Obama!
- NTDF9 11y agoThe predatory education system basically did the following: - Find the most gullible segment of human population - Lend them money with false advertising and without making sure they understand what a loan means And now they want them to repay? Humans are not rational actors, certainly most aren't. No 18 year old knows the repercussions of a six-figure debt.
- alanh 11y agoI posted this deeper in the comments, but since it’s so directly relevant to the topic at hand: http://www.salon.com/2014/06/08/colleges_are_full_of_it_behind_the_three_decade_scheme_to_raise_tuition_bankrupt_generations_and_hypnotize_the_media/ http://www.salon.com/2014/06/08/colleges_are_full_of_it_behi... This Salon article says: “Tuition is up 1,200 percent in 30 years. Here's why you're unemployed, crushed by debt -- and no one is helping: “Reading back over journalistic accounts of the tuition spiral from the ’80s and ’90s, you get the impression that all concerned felt it was a wee bit uncouth to dig too deeply into a university’s pricing practices or suspect the sachems of higher learning who presided over them of anything inappropriate. These were the journalists’s beloved alma maters, after all: surely they had our best interests at heart. … “And so, beginning in the ’80s, university administrators, their words dutifully transcribed by journalists, blamed utility bills for soaring tuition. They blamed libraries, which made a certain amount of sense until libraries went dramatically out of fashion in the Internet age—and yet still tuition prices went up. “They blamed professors, of course, since professors are the most visible part of a university and because it’s easy to hate professors … until the outside world figured out that universities were actually using graduate students and adjuncts to teach their courses and yet still tuition prices were mounting at an insane clip. “Administrators also blamed tuition inflation on onerous government regulations … On society … on declining student population … “Unlike tenured faculty, university administrations actually have grown by 369 percent since the mid-1970s. … But blaming administrators proved difficult for journalists, perhaps because administrators were the very people journalists had been going to for explanations in their tuition-outrage stories. Could their sources actually be the culprits? No way. And so, less than a year after the Inquirer’s series appeared, USA Today ran its own big tuition-shock tale in which the blame was pinned on all the familiar blame-objects: Professors, student demands, technology, gummint regulation. A 1997 cover story in Time magazine—‘How Colleges Are Gouging U,’ the illustration shouted—barely mentioned administrators at all. “What were journalists to do after ringing the alarm bells for so many years without effect? Well, there was one easy answer to this frustrating situation: To discover that there wasn’t really any problem in the first place. That the tuition spiral was entirely reasonable, even if no one could actually explain it. How so? Well, if you examine what has come to be called the 'college wage premium'—the difference between what is earned by college grads and high school grads—it becomes clear that someone who finishes four years at a university will eventually earn far more than they spent to go there, even at the crazy tuition prices of recent decades. Today this is a universal way of considering the situation, always leading us to conclude that going to college is 'worth it'; that it is a 'bargain'; that it 'pays off.' But it only seemed to enter journalists’ consciousness in the 1990s, as on the occasion when Gaston Caperton, president of the College Board, explained matters thusly to the Los Angeles Times in 1999: “He said there has been too much focus on the cost of college and too little on the lifetime returns for four years of investment. Because a college graduate today earns about twice as much as a worker with only a high school diploma, he said, ‘a college education is worth about $1 million over a lifetime.’ “The mind reels when confronted with this kind of smugness. One wonders: Is there some identifiable aspect of a college education that yields that million dollar prize—exposure to advanced literary theory, for example? Is there a way to isolate that particular 24-carat nugget and leave the dross behind—all the plush dorm carpeting and the many layers of assistant deans? My guess, though, is that Caperton’s statement meant exactly the opposite of this—that there was no need to inquire any further about the tuition outrage. What it implied, by extension, was that since we now know the final value of a college degree (one million dollars!), the colleges can simply keep raising tuition prices and student indebtedness until they have extracted that amount from their graduates—and only after they have hit that figure will we have cause to complain.”
- bbarn 11y agoThis is a problem that only this generation, and maybe part of the one after it will need to face. The answer is simple, and we're on the cusp of getting there. Like any other industry, education needs to be unbundled. The idea that you need to live in a dorm, in a psuedo-society, for four years, taking a broad set of courses is dated and helps nobody but those offering that experience. I predict in a generation we'll have the people making hiring decisions more and more jaded about the value of these educations and less likely to keep perpetuating the myth that you need a degree from a school to do a job. Instead, we'll see more and more certification programs, or micro-degrees, specializing in subjects that matter to the student. I believe it to already be happening - I don't look at education except as an afterthought when reviewing resumes. I don't have a degree, and I'm doing well in my field. The types of jobs where I've ever been discriminated for not having a degree I don't think I would have enjoyed anyway. Working at a 5000 person company that cares more about your score on an HR system than what you could really offer them? No thanks.
- poorleno111 11y agoMicro-degree are already a student... they're called an associates.. Nurses used to really only need an associates, however some hospitals are now requiring RNs to obtain a bachelor of science in nursing.. Getting a tad ridiculous.
- devanti 11y agoI suspect the same will happen to all the p2p lending startups soon
- aosmith 11y agoThis is a bad situation that's going to get worth. Student aid is great and all but I see a lot of people with useless degrees. If someone can expect to make $35k/year after graduation they shouldn't be able to borrow $200k to get there, it just doesn't make sense.
- Zigurd 11y agoIt will be interesting to see if this creates economic migrants. When I was traveling to China regularly, I met a few Americans fleeing debt. They didn't have much to lose if it turned out to be a bad idea. The plan was typically to teach English in a 2nd tier city where visa enforcement might be lax.
- mathattack 11y agoMy impression as someone who went to a large public state school for undergrad, and an expensive private for grad... Most undergrads (more than 50% less than 80%) spend 4 years doing enough to get by, and do a lot of socializing. This is cheap at in state publics, expensive otherwise. The people who get in-demand majors are fine no matter what. Those with other majors who really apply themselves need grad school and more debt to break out. An English major at Yale or an in state school is fine. The Yale student will manage no matter what. The in state person got off cheap. Everyone else he an expensive lesson in literature. Despite that, life in most fields is much tougher without he degree. The guidance counselors are partially wrong in suggesting loans for overpriced schools. They are also wrong for suggesting soft majors at mediocre schools.
- 20years 11y agoLots are talking about the tech bubble but I feel this is a much bigger bubble.
- quicklyfrozen 11y agoIt certainly seems likely to break many of the private-but-not-elite schools as more students choose state schools. Many seem to cost just as much, if not more, then the ivies.
- relaytheurgency 11y agoI made a comment to this effect as a reply, but I don't understand why the government charges so much interest on these loans (and then only lets you deduct a small portion of it from your taxable income in some cases). Let's assume you actually do end up bettering your life by taking out student loans and getting a degree. Although it seems almost memetic these days that you'll sink 100k into a school and wind up flipping burgers, in my situation it was actually the opposite. I was a cook for a catering business making very little money such that my federal tax burden was virtually nonexistent. After finishing school I make quite a bit more money, but I'm paying very high student loan payments (not complaining really, I was aware this would be the case) and the interest on my student loans is higher than on my mortgage! These are federal loans as well, not private. By providing me a loan the government has essentially won! They've turned a tax burden into a source of revenue. My lifetime earning potential is much, much higher than when I did not have a degree and was working as a cook. Why are some of these interests rates as high as 6%? It seems insane!
- thegasman 11y agoso how do I make money from this?
- michaelbuddy 11y agoSome universities have, and this surprised me, a ratio of student to employee 1:1 On top of that you have the upkeep, all the program costs facilities costs are insane. This is not sustainable. It simply cannot work when many people haven't seen a legitimate increase in their wages for years.
- transfire 11y agoFYI Student loans are federally guaranteed. The original lender does not loose money. If default occurs, the tax-payer pays them off. The debt is then sold by the government to credit collectors at a discount, who can seek the entire principle, plus interest, plus steep fees. So the typical defaulted student loan, if ever paid back, procures two to three times the original cost of school. Consequently, the student has no credit, so it is basically impossible for them to fully function in our highly debt-oriented society. This includes not being able to go back to school to finish their education if it not yet complete. Meanwhile $200 billion is the cost of two-months in Iraq.
- hibikir 11y agoThe student loan system lies in the special place that brings in the worst of private and government sectors. General loans work pretty well out there: Loan costs are aligned with loan risks, because nobody wants to loan money to those that can't pay. But student loans are guaranteed by the government, so for all intents and purposes, anyone can get a loan, whether they'll be able to pay it or not. At the same time, it never goes away, and it's given to people who probably still live with their parent. They bear a bigger risk than I do with my mortgage, but they might get tens of thousands of dollars in debt without deciding on a major first! What really makes this pernicious is that, since everyone gets access to the loans, in practice, this means college can be far more expensive than it'd be otherwise: Without all the loans, most colleges would have to be cheaper. Same thing if colleges also bear the risk of non-payment. And it's not as if this money is being spent enriching teachers: It's mostly administration and facilities. So now we have a system where everything is very expensive, and most students get huge loans that they can't afford, and where ultimately, the taxpayer will end up having to foot the bill: The only winners here are the universities themselves. Just think of what this is doing to medical schools and law schools: They know that even the poorest student will be able to max out on their loans! So dropouts, and in the case of law school, graduates that went to the wrong school end up in a worse situation than they would have been 30 years ago. The country must choose: Either stop giving money to private colleges, and just focus on good, cheap, no loans, public universities, or let people pay for their own college with no guaranteed loans: Less people will even go to college, but those that do will afford it, because colleges would have to adapt to lower budgets. Guaranteed loans to pay for expensive, private universities? This just makes sure that millennials will end up worse off than their parents for the first time since the industrial revolution.
- gambiting 11y agoWell there is a way that combines best of both - look at UK. Basically you have a similar deal like the US, so everyone is guaranteed a loan no matter which university they are going to, but at the same time, the government has limited how much universities can charge per year. So it doesn't matter if you go study at Oxford or a some tiny university no one heard about. The maximum you have to pay is 10k a year. And you don't have to pay anything back unless you make more than a certain amount per year after graduating.
- chrischen 11y agoTaking out massive loans to study, so that you can work, so that you can repay the massive loans over 20-30 years. Sounds like indentured servitude.
- taurath 11y agoEveryone in my generation is split, those who went to college and now are paying off ridiculous debt, those who have rich parents, and those who are trying to make it on their own. College does give you a step up, but its really screwed a lot of people. Those of us who just want to learn but don't want to be saddled with debt have to make due outside of our 'institutions' of learning, which is too expensive to consider when you already have an OK job.
- vs2370 11y agoRead this, been through this and thought about this .. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11444810 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11444810 What do you guys think ?
- jeffdavis 11y ago1. College is useful for education. 2. College is useful for meeting people. 3. Most of the time and money spent attending college is used to meet people, and very little on education. Let's just admit those three facts, and then we can start to have sane policy discussions.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- tempodox 11y agoDebt is the new currency.
- reuven 11y agoI have several reactions to this report. First of all, I think it demonstrates that American university tuition is way too high. So much of that money goes toward things like sports teams, climbing walls, emotional support dogs, and other things that just don't have to be a part of the college experience. American universities have an unbelievable amount of staff that isn't about education or research. The thing is, there's little incentive for universities to cut back, because no matter what they charge, they have willing customers. And those customers aren't paying the bills -- not at the time of purchase, and perhaps never at all (as this article states). Secondly, the notion of work -- not work-study programs, but real work -- should probably become more prominent among US students. In Israel, where I now live, most students work at part-time jobs, and juggle both work and school. It's not ideal, especially since many of them also have families, but it does help to keep debts relatively low. Thirdly, I think that it's too easy to take out loans. I took out loans for my undergraduate degree, and was fortunate to pay them back within a few years of graduating. I then took out loans for my PhD, and while I've been managing to pay them back faster than expected, no one ever asked me at the time, "Are you sure you'll be able to pay these back?" A bit of discussion at the time of taking out loans, and looking at options, or even giving financial counseling, might have helped me or others to take out less. Finally, the notion that you cannot ever get rid of your government-sponsored tuition loans is crazy. I'm not saying that people should declare bankruptcy at the drop of a hat, or that there shouldn't be consequences. But people have issues, and excluding student loans from bankruptcy -- which is intended to give people a new start -- seems extremely unfair to the people who need this tool most of all. No wonder people are just not paying their loans back; if declaring bankruptcy isn't an option, and they can't pay, then they'll just not pay.
- jawilson2 11y ago> So much of that money goes toward things like sports teams, climbing walls, emotional support dogs, and other things that just don't have to be a part of the college experience. Just to nit-pick (I agree with everything else), but athletic department finances are usually separate from the rest of the university, at least in D1 sports. And, having a good football or basketball team will increase applications and enrollment (e.g. see the 2nd sentence in http://www.northwestern.edu/newscenter/stories/2005/02/applications.html http://www.northwestern.edu/newscenter/stories/2005/02/appli...). I think the thought is that if a university doesn't have these amenities, their enrollment will decrease and be lost to those that do. It is a vicious cycle.
- jlgaddis 11y agoAt least part of the problem, in my opinion, is that youth receive basically zero "financial education" in high school. My girlfriend is 21 years old and just a couple of years out of high school. I can only recall being taught the basics myself: how to make a budget, balance a checkbook, etc. She apparently did not even receive that. I'm much older than her (37) and, while I'm certainly not "rich" by any means, I'm financially stable and everything I own is completely paid for (ironically, my only remaining debt is my student loans). She has only recently became interested in the basics of financial matters, such as her credit report and credit score, how loans and credit cards work, etc. Initially, I was amazed at her lack of knowledge in this area. It's not that she's dumb or stupid, she was just never taught anything about finances. She is, fortunately, relatively mature for her age and manages her money well. She has worked since she was first able to and has maintained steady employment and, for some reason, lately acquired an interest in her credit score and increasing it (although it's actually pretty decent for her age). So we've recently started working on her credit history which, of course, was completely non-existent until she took out a small loan from her credit union for a cheap, used vehicle (with her father as a co-signer) about a year ago. She shops at Victoria's Secret often, so we got her a store credit card from there with a small ($500) credit limit to help her started. I've explained how credit utilization, payment history, etc. factors into her score, so she'll put her purchases (always < $100 for a statement period) on her card and then pay it off in full every month and I've been looking around recently for a good "starter" credit card for her to get. I've considered adding her as an authorized user to one of my high-limit Amex cards (to give her utilization, payment history, and average age of accounts a little boost) but I've read recently that nowadays those accounts don't get reported to an AU's credit report (although AmEx does ask for SSN and DOB when adding an AU so maybe they still do). She completed a vocational program in high school and is already a licensed cosmetologist; we've talked a bit about whether she'll go to college or not (she's already somewhat "behind", in that she didn't go straight to college after high school) but not how it will be funded if she does. If or when that time comes, I'm glad that I'll be around to help her come up with a plan that won't require her to spend the next 20 years paying for it. I can easily see how a typical 18-year-old about to go off to college just blindly signs up for student loans without any true understanding of just what they're committing to financially and without any idea of how long after they complete their education that it will continue to them. TL;DR: I got kinda sidetracked there for a minute but my point was that today's high school students receive nearly zero financial education or guidance before heading off to college. I am not surprised at all by the facts and figures detailed in this article.