10 ms·
> Seattle police spokesman Sean Whitcomb says the department understands how Tor relays work, and they knew Robinson was a Tor host. > "Knowing that, moving in
by LeoPanthera 11y ago
> Seattle police spokesman Sean Whitcomb says the department understands how Tor relays work, and they knew Robinson was a Tor host.
> "Knowing that, moving in, it doesn't automatically preclude the idea that the people running Tor are not also involved in child porn," Whitcomb says. "It does offer a plausible alibi, but it's still something that we need to check out."
> Whitcomb also says Seattle police were "artful" in the way they did the search. Instead of impounding all of Robinson's computers, which the warrant would have allowed, they offered to search them on the premises as long as he consented to turning over his passwords. He did, and they let him keep his machines after they scanned them.
This is the important part. They didn't shut down the exit node. They didn't even take away the computer. This sounds bad, but in all honesty, it could have gone at lot worse.
- homero 11y agoThey installed back doors, he has to trash them anyway
- techthroway443 11y agoBut if the traffic gets encrypted what is the use? Or do you mean they install their own "special" tor exit node on his machine?
- homero 11y agoThey probably used a root kit and a firmware
- okasaki 11y agoSeems unlikely if he was present and had witnesses.
- ArchReaper 11y agoIf you read the article, you would know this is not the case.
- mtmail 11y agoHe wasn't present. Last paragraph reads "he may now have to get rid of his computers because he can't be sure what the police did to them while he was being questioned outside his apartment"
- NoMoreNicksLeft 11y agoThem? The Seattle PD? They're not a spy agency, they're rent-a-cops.
- arjie 11y agoThis was the police, not a private agency.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 11y agoYeh, that's my point. They're incompetent.
- freshhawk 11y agoThe Seattle PD can plug a device they purchased into a USB port as well as anyone else. There have been various public and leaked catalogues of law enforcement tools put online now, these abilities are commoditized and packaged in a user friendly manner. This is pretty old news at this point.
- NoMoreNicksLeft 11y agoPurchased from where? They probably couldn't find their asses with both hands, but if they could it'd cost several hundred thousand dollars, take 48 hours with the roads blocked off, and the scandal of them finding some soccer mom's ass instead wouldn't die down for 3 years. Do you think that they came up with this in their emergency war room, as they planned out the sneak attack on the Tor node, or was this a more general policy developed over the previous months and years and this was just one of the first times they got to practice it?
- freshhawk 11y ago> Purchased from where? Most famously, because they were recently hacked themselves, the Milan based company Hacking Team. The intercept has a good breakdown of their software manual here: https://theintercept.com/2014/10/30/hacking-team/#manuals https://theintercept.com/2014/10/30/hacking-team/#manuals There are many others out there, this cell phone related catalogue is really interesting: https://theintercept.com/2015/12/17/a-secret-catalogue-of-government-gear-for-spying-on-your-cellphone/ https://theintercept.com/2015/12/17/a-secret-catalogue-of-go... Any company considered a "defense contractor" will probably offer tools along these lines. They are in high demand. Of course the FBI, Homeland security and the NSA have their own tools as well. And they share with local law enforcement (probably not the latest and greatest ones). > Do you think that they came up with this in their emergency war room, as they planned out the sneak attack on the Tor node, I don't really have any idea what the Seattle PD methods or procedures would be, but they knew what TOR was and tracked the traffic to his exit node. I doubt it was the same cops who did that part ... so how likely was it that this briefing didn't include anything like "Just plug the CriminalBuster(tm) box into the computer until the light turns green, then coordinate with Bob to get access to the information you want later. You can get things like X, Y and Z from the CriminalBuster. To requisition a unit fill out form TPS-01 and give it to John." The entire reason to commoditize these things is to make it easy to use within an inefficient bureaucracy that doesn't have a lot of tech training or a "war room". Just like they have done with phone taps or gps car trackers for years. > this was just one of the first times they got to practice it? Why assume this was the first time? It's standard practice for all sorts of infosec workers, journalists, etc to assume this was done to their laptop if it was out of their hands. You can literally download one of these and put it on a usb stick yourself (for your own personal use of course, anything else would be very illegal).
- AnthonyMouse 11y agoIt's still stupid though. It's like raiding the mailman's house for delivering an illegal letter with no return address. Sure, it could have been sent by the mailman, but it could have been sent by anyone. There isn't any more reason to suspect the exit node operators than anyone else in the whole world who could also have used the exit node.
- dogma1138 11y agoNo it sounds actually like good police work. Running a Tor exit node shouldn't give you some blanket against police investigations.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- AndrewUnmuted 11y agoI would have said the same, if it were not for the police's unnecessary and demeaning execution of their warrant at 6:00AM. If the police knew he was a tor exit node operator, then surely they could have executed this search at a more reasonable hour?
- homero 11y agoBut a no knock swat raid killing people's dog is more fun
- 11y ago
- ghkbrew 11y agoWhile I applaud the police for being an unobtrusive as they could, this sort of discretionary enforcement is worrying in and of itself. In no small part, because it seems to set a precedent that they could have raided his house and impounded all his computer for no other reason than he was running a Tor exit node.
- Laaw 11y agoBut it does give a judge something to point at and be like, "Why couldn't you do it here (in a different situation) like you did over there (this situation)?" Not much, admittedly, but it's something.
- techthroway443 11y agoIt's not worrying at all. Running a Tor exit node in itself isn't a problem. The problem arises when the exit node operator knowingly is giving up control over the traffic going through his connection. If you run a tor exit node you need to accept the fact there is a chance something illegal is passing through and that when it happens (as it did here) you are going to get investigated. It would be irresponsible and neglectful for law enforcement not to raid this man's home.
- EdHominem 11y agoThey probably sent the picture in the first place.
- peppaz 11y agoThis probably isn't wrong, the FBI is the largest holder of CP in the world, last time it was reported on.
- Godel_unicode 11y agoThey have copies of CP collected as evidence, therefore they are distributing it? By this logic, the DEA evidence locker might make them the biggest crack dealer in the US.
- djsumdog 11y agoThis is why I run full disk encryption. I wouldn't have given them a damn fucking password.
- kbenson 11y agoAnd they would have impounded all your computers. That's your choice to make, but I don't think it's obvious it's the correct choice. There's a lot of variables that go into that decision.
- MichaelGG 11y agoThe only real variable should be "can you afford to get another machine right away?" I guess in truth it might be "do your backups actually work", but if that's false then you're already in trouble.
- kbenson 11y agoWhat about: I can afford another machine right now, but will that put a monetary strain on other areas of my life that are important to me? I can afford another machine, and I have backups, but the restoration of the backups is painful enough that I would prefer to avoid it. I would prefer this episode be over with as quickly as possible as I'm not guilty, so should I comply to speed this process along? (note that I think this isn't necessarily guaranteed to be a good strategy). Depending on what the police believe about the situation may greatly affect what is the path of least resistance and problems, but you unfortunately have very little insight into exactly what that is. In some cases, talking to and cooperating with the police is the easiest way to extricate yourself from the situation, and in other cases it's the easiest way that they can twist the situation to implicate you in some way. The safest way is to always have a lawyer present and never voluntarily give up information, but not everyone is in a situation that makes the safest choice easy to take.
- fizgig 11y agoAnd they would have likely taken all your shit as a punitive measure had you not complied. (I, too, run FDE on everything I own at home.) All things considered, this dude dodged a bullet. I don't know if he was acting under the advice of counsel, but he came out relatively unscathed. This time. This might be a shot across the bow designed to frighten those without the deep pockets of Apple. Just a reminder that The Man still has teeth when it comes to the 99%.
- FussyZeus 11y agoIt went "ok" because he consented to giving them unfettered access to his computers without his oversight when they had no reason to be there. This is more akin to police searching you car with no evidence of drugs, not finding drugs, and then letting you keep your car. It's still a hideous violation of your privacy for no reason.
- homero 11y agoBut they let him keep his life
- FussyZeus 11y agoWe're in a weird place as a society when the police not shooting you dead is regarded as a "nice" thing for them to do.
- maxerickson 11y agoYeah, that's not the place we are in. If you take anything but a ridiculously short term view, the expectations of how police will treat people today are far higher than they have been in the history of the US. We still have to recognize and confront the remaining problems, but national media attention and prosecution of police who commit murders is a step up from police committing murders with no consequences.
- krapp 11y agoConsider the bias of people making such statements. Society hasn't actually moved to that point, but many anti-police advocates want you to believe it has. In actual reality, most encounters with the police don't result in arbitrary killings.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoMoreover, repeating such statements only makes the situation worse - especially if its repeated on the (inter)national media scale. Most police officers are normal people (just like most people in general), but when the society in general starts treating them as enemies, it doesn't help them doing their job in peaceful and responsible manner.
- gist 11y ago> They didn't shut down the exit node. Although my view won't be popular, running an exit mode and having to deal with this is not a smart thing to do. What is the upside vs. having to deal with this type of raid and perhaps police who are not so accommodating at some point? Why draw attention to yourself in this way? Also assumes that some rogue cop won't plant something on your device if it does get hauled away. Seems dangerous the way I see it.
- Spivak 11y agoThat's what full disk encryption is for. It's not just a privacy tool but tamper protection as well. IANAL but I sincerely hope one would not be compelled to unlock their device only in the presence of a police officer and prohibited from having a camera, lawyer, witness, judge, internal affairs officer, etc. present.
- njharman 11y agoI'm happy with this level of response. It's a little bad in that they essentially coerced password disclosure and I'm guessing they would have acted on any other crime (say copyright violation) they happened to find during search. But, overall this is how Police should work / act. They need to investigate and they should investigate with consideration, care, moderation, and assumption of innocence until actual evidence indicates otherwise, they should ask for cooperation rather than assume hostile/adversarial stance. They don't need to have SWAT no-knock the place. They don't need to seize and confiscate everything and make it very hard to recover. They don't need to handcuff anyone. They don't need to act like smug assholes. Etc.
- tibbon 11y agoAnyone else suspect they didn't just scan them, but installed some back-door/fork?
- ultramancool 11y agoExcept now he has to wipe everything because their "search" likely involves plugging in a USB drive and infecting his machines with a RAT at the very least. Just given how many companies are out peddling RATs to LEAs like this I think we have to consider it a likely possibility. Not exactly a best case.
- pc2g4d 11y agoWhat's a RAT?
- ultramancool 11y agoRemote Access Trojan or Remote Administration Tool, depends who you ask. Basically a small tool that runs hidden and allows remote keylogging, upload and download of files, screen capture, etc. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DarkComet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DarkComet is a good example of a free one.