13 ms·
Developers don't build cheaper housing because we make it illegal (2014)
- achen2345 11y agoMust be a weird California problem. I simply don't see this problem in Texas. I have known several people who have fled California to Texas for exactly that reason. EDIT: Look through the data and ask yourself why you would want to pay more for what appears (according to the data) to be a less diverse, more expensive, and more dense area. What the data doesn't reflect is home size. I paid $125k for a 3000sqft foreclosure a few years ago that is now worth $200k. I couldn't get half a garage for this in the bay area. http://www.bestplaces.net/compare-cities/san_francisco_ca/fort_worth_tx/people http://www.bestplaces.net/compare-cities/san_francisco_ca/fo...
- Moshe_Silnorin 11y agoIt's more of an everywhere-but-Texas problem. Texas has a great tradition of respecting property rights. Most states are not like this.
- bluejekyll 11y agoBut this comes at an expense to nature and or natural preserves for wildlife. California has some of the greatest protected forests and areas like Yosemite. So, yes we pay more and have more restrictions, but a better question is is it worth it? Following the articles car analogy, this is like requiring cars to have airbags for the safety of the people in them, but that comes at a higher cost on the purchase price of the car.
- tomschlick 11y agoAnd SF has some of the highest rent in the country because they won't zone for larger apartment buildings.
- surfmike 11y agoThis is a false dichotomy. We have minimum lot size restrictions, and restrict lots to one housing unit (R1 zoning). These regulations push up the prices of homes (since it increases the minimum amount of land for a housing unit), and do nothing to save forests and national parks. In fact, if we keep building low density neighborhoods, more open space will be used up than if our zoning allowed for denser development.
- gwbas1c 11y agoI think you miss the point: Two words: Eminent Domain. Silicon Valley (and other areas in CA) need to use eminent domain to build high-rises. The housing crisis can be solved without impacting nature preserves.
- mcguire 11y agoDidn't some place in New Jersey get roundly hosed around here when they pulled eminent domain on some properties and then turned them over to developers? Something about property rights?
- ghaff 11y agoOr tech companies could just move to the many areas of the country, such as many areas of the Midwest, where housing isn't so constrained. There's plenty of space in the US. Just not in the Bay area.
- drivingmenuts 11y agoSure, and then they'd be stuck with Billy Joe and Jim Bob, who once used a computer back in the 90's, as a workforce. Or they could offer the same California salaries to programmers, who would live like kings in a small town but wouldn't have the same conveniences, and still spend the same amount of money. Moving to the countryside doesn't always make business sense. Sure, costs to have a business in an urban area, but it's easier to find workforce at all needed levels and the trappings of urban civilization keep your workforce occupied and happier in their off hours. Case-in-point: I work for a cash-strapped startup (for reasons) and sometimes have to live off my savings, but I live in an urban area. I could move to my hometown, where my costs would be about 25% of my current expenses, but then I'd be living in a special kind of hell where there are few good restaurants and the nearest bookstore is 60 miles away.
- douche 11y agoOh my god, the horror of not having five-star restaurants! If Google or Apple moved from the Bay to anywhere else, their workers would follow. Don't doubt that for a second. Or we could just embrace technology and stop insisting that all your workers have to breathe the same oxygen, and allow remote work. There are huge swathes of the United States that are becoming depopulated because industry died and all of the young people have had to leave to find work. I just got back from a trip home to western Maine, and it's disturbing the number of houses that are just abandoned up there.
- Animats 11y agoTexas has a lot of very low value real estate. US real estate is cheap if you're willing to live in Outer Nowhere.
- bdcravens 11y agoYes, there's a lot of wide open spaces in Texas, but there's tons of sub $200K houses in decent subdivisions sub $200k, and within 15 minutes of downtowns $200k-300k. I live in an older area midway between downtown Houston and the upscale Woodlands area in North Houston; my house is value at $105k. (3 bedrooms, 2 baths, corner lot, 1600 sq ft, big fenced yard)
- qdog 11y agoSure, but you have to live in Houston. Austin house prices in good school districts are expensive. I just sold a house for 10k in a small town in a part of Texas with almost no jobs, so you can find houses, but houses close to the biggest job markets in desirable neighborhoods just aren't that cheap. You can, however easily retire in BFE with a cheap house if that's the desire.
- bdcravens 11y agoDefinitely, though Dallas prices are on par with Houston. However, even in Houston, there are expensive homes (such as in the medical district, River Oaks, The Woodlands, etc) My mom lives in a little $20k house about 90 minutes north of Dallas. (and it's not necessarily BFE, but in an older part of a 40k city)
- nickpsecurity 11y agoNah, it's more some parts of the U.S. are just ridiculously expensive. In many areas of South and East, you can get quite affordable homes within 20-30 minutes drive of the areas (eg "downtown") that have the big businesses and expensive homes. Local example is nearby properties at $80k-200k half-hour away from condos costing nearly a million right next to businesses. Locals working there spend most of their day, lunch breaks, and some free time on weekends around all those people. No need to live over there even for networking. And then there's Texas doing it's own thing with its own cost-benefit analysis. As usual. ;)
- coroutines 11y agoNice try, Rick Perry.
- bdcravens 11y agoPull up Zillow for Houston or Dallas, pick a home a random - sub $200k is pretty easy to find.
- mullen 11y agoYou are not paying for Earthquake proofing your house and space is more limited because of mountains and hills. Plus, houses in the middle of BFE California are cheap too.
- achen2345 11y agoI am not talking about the middle of nowhere. I am talking about actually within the boundaries of a city of similar population size. Houses in Texas are far cheaper than that in the middle of nowhere as well.
- bmay 11y agoSeems like a bit of a clickbaity title when this is the only part of the post that mentions laws: > In reality, housing construction is very limited; it’s being restricted by zoning and permitting laws.
- cgrubb 11y agoYep. In LA Large empty lots are hard to come by. A 6k square ft lot might be 100k for an undesirable location in an undesirable nbhd, but 400k is probably typical. Not sure how much cost "zoning and permitting" really adds on top of that.
- nevdka 11y agoZoning can affect how many residences you can build on that block. If the zoning laws say you can only build one on that lot, then the land cost is $400k per residence. But if you're allowed to build a 5 floor building with two apartments per floor, then the land cost is $40k per residence.
- wcummings 11y agoDing ding ding! Single family zoning is the problem.
- newjersey 11y agoWhy can't we just build a little farther? I am not local to the area (as you can probably tell from my name) so I'm not trying to criticize anyone. I am genuinely curious if that is a possibility. Also I've never bought, sold, built a house. Are these single family zoning everywhere?
- throwaway_xx9 11y agoThe Silicon Valley area is surrounded by either hills or ocean, so "a little farther" is a difficult commute with varying delays of hours on a couple roads. Nobody wants to raise a family in Oakland. Also, my understanding is that the Central Valley is a flood plain.
- wrong_variable 11y agoThis is one of the reasons why I have zero interest in wasting my hard earned money propping up the insane housing bubble in western cities. Building a simple house is a 5000 year old technology. I know that since we brought a small piece of land outside the city - brought the raw material and paid some local laborer to help us put our family home together. It cost us a grand total of 10,000 dollars. The only difference was - we did it in india where there are no nonsense housing regulation. Getting internet was supposed to be hard, but we were allowed to just use the telephone pole to get copper internet ( instead of fibre ). From a business perspective - no wonder it temping to offshore - when putting a roof over your head eats so much into your income.
- superuser2 11y agoIt should converge on eating about the same percentage of your income - people in lower cost of living areas are typically paid less. Markets remove arbitrage opportunities eventually.
- rtpg 11y agoSuper pedantic but some niceties (good insulation! Double paned windows) are less than 5000 years old ;)
- jacalata 11y agoReally, you went with insulation rather than indoor plumbing and electricity? :)
- Pxtl 11y agoI'm a Canadian and my first thought was insulation, too. Also heat. Natural gas piping isn't something you'd want to DIY.
- msandford 11y agoNatural gas piping is done at such low pressures in residential environments that it's basically a joke. I think it's about 0.5psi (or 14" of water column) which in the grand scheme of pressures is very low. People can generate greater pressures with their lungs. http://hvac-talk.com/vbb/showthread.php?1587361-What-is-typical-natural-gas-pressure-supply-to-a-residential-regulator http://hvac-talk.com/vbb/showthread.php?1587361-What-is-typi... http://www.personal.psu.edu/ref7/apparatus/2003%20competition/deardorff-LC.htm http://www.personal.psu.edu/ref7/apparatus/2003%20competitio... EDIT: I'm not saying that one should do their own natural gas piping as in many places it's technically illegal unless you're a licensed plumber. But it's certainly not rocket science. The only reason it's "harder" than plumbing compressed air is that if compressed air leaks a tad, it's no big deal. You have to get rather tight on gas piping because of the consequences of a leak, not because it's so difficult to get it tight.
- bluejekyll 11y agoThis article is a little all over the place: > at the expense of people living in Lagos or rural Appalachia or San Salvador Which is at the end, but seems to have little to do with the points earlier about restricted building laws in cities. I get the argument, it's been made in many economics books, but I don't think it comes at the expense of the people in Appalachia. It comes at the expense of people living in the expensive areas. The people in Appalachia have other issues dealing with jobs and investment in the local area. Is the alternative that we allow people to build however and wherever they want until there is not quiet nature within driving distance of anyone?
- maxsilver 11y ago> "In reality, housing construction is very limited; it’s being restricted by zoning and permitting laws." So what about all the small cities where there are no enforced zoning/permitting laws and developers get literally anything they ask for? If zoning/permitting is the issue, why do all these areas without zoning/permitting have the same problem?
- marincounty 11y agoAre you talking about cities/towns in the middle of nowhere? Meaning cities, and towns that business left years ago? I've found small towns overly red tag heppy, and these small towns realized they could make a lot of income by enforcing building codes--to the Teee. In my small town, we have building inspectors who are literally looking for errors in the permitting process. Why--the extra fees it brings in. Oh, they will always claim it was Safety, and just following procedure, but these fees are outragious. The average person has no idea how the permitting process works, or just how difficult/expensive it has become to do any building. Let's talk about small town zoning. In my little town, it's tight. Fine--we have a way fight the rigid system. You fine a Variance! You pay $1000 fee. That's if you can fill out the paperwork. In my small town, since the invention of the internet, I don't believe they have ever passed a variance. They look at it, and deny it, but keep the fee. A fee for what? Five minutes of their time? People don't realize how little towns keep bringing in money. A lot of it is fees/fines--and is going up yearly? No inflation, but constantly going up? Don't get me started on our little town Revenue Squad--also know as public safety, or the people in blue. They are literally just collecting revenue now. Crime has never been a big problem here, and they will always claim they are the reason. The real reason is it's too expensive to live here, but you can't argue. Just pay the ticket! It's not about the ticket, it's the financial punishment you take. (I got off topic on that last paragraph--sorry, this is an important topic. I just see it getting worse. Every new law/regulation adds to the problem. I've lost hope actually.)
- maxsilver 11y agoI'm talking about small cities, like Toledo, Milwaukee, Rochester MN, South Bend, Lansing, Kalamazoo, etc. They are in the middle of nowhere, but they still have people and jobs. I live in Grand Rapids. There's lots of zoning and permitting rules. None of it is ever enforced. All a developer has to do is ask, and they get literally every non-safety rule waived. - Don't want to build kitchen or bathrooms in your studio apartments? Just say your "micro-unit focused" and the already-tiny minimum unit size no longer applies to you. People are so desperate for housing, they'll pay luxury price premiums, even to live in door rooms. Extra money, for free! - Annoyed about having to pay for your tenants parking? No worries! Just say you are a "transit-oriented design" and all parking requirements are waived -- you can dump infinite cars on the street for free! (Despite the fact that, like most mid-west cities, we only barely have transit at all) - Want to skip out on your make ready costs? Just claim your lot needs "brownfield redevelopment" and the city will reimburse the developer for all of the make-ready expenses in cash. I get that in California, the zoning and local governments are the major roadblock. But I have a hard time believing "zoning/permitting" is the root cause for this issue. Because there are places where developers have no rules and get literally anything they ask for, anytime they ask. And yet even these places still only get luxury apartments.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- RangerScience 11y agoSo, if the problem is that real estate in cities is too expensive to build affordable housing... isn't the solution to build more cities? There keep being more people and those people keep wanting to live in the same places. But, the people already in those places don't want them - charitably, because it gets too crowded. Turns LA or SF into Manhattan, where you pay a lot for a mediocre shoebox. Better transportation gets us a ways - when you ask someone in LA how far away something is, they tell it to you in time, because that's what matters - not the physical distance, but the temporal one. Better transportation means more physical space is accessible within the same "city". But, it strikes me that this is nearly the same problem as corporatism and monopolies - as power concentrates, power concentrates faster. I guess that extends past money and politics to society and populations. So if the government needs to redistribute power - wealth (universal basic income), politics (democracy vs autocracy), access (mass transit, education)... does it need to build more cities? Not build existing cities larger, mind you - but cause more cities? The west coast grew later than the east coast. We have, what, three major cities / metropolitan areas? San Francisco, Los Angeles, Seattle? Five if you move the bar to include Portland and San Diego? East coast has more than a dozen MAJOR metropolitan areas, and how many more when you move the bar? Maybe the answer isn't higher density housing in the cities we have where everyone wants to live. Maybe the answer is getting more cities where everyone wants to live. Sure, it's not exactly like New York has a monopoly on metropolitan-ness, and we need to go all anti-trust on it... But you get the idea, yeah? Make me think of Dublin. What was Dublin two decades ago? What is it now? Makes me think of - what was it called, where you make a city with different laws, one part test bed, one part diversity? Happened in the Renaissance, and it's what Hong Kong is.
- frogpelt 11y agoMore cities? This sounds like a solution China would come up with.
- RangerScience 11y agoThat's a very good point, although I don't think I'm taking it the way you're intending it. I'm taking it as "here are case studies". I've been to a couple of planned cities (Astana and Pavlodar in Kazakhstan - that was a trip!), and I've been to suburban developments, and there IS a distinct difference, but neither has that... /something/ that established cities have. Ironically, Pavlodar, I felt, had it more, and what I think it it is, is... ...Space for the people to own what they bring. Planned cities don't let you own it, and HOAs don't necessarily give the you the metaphorical space to bring it. If you don't own it - and not in the simple legal property sense, but the sense of "if I invest myself in this thing, it's not going to be taken away one day" - you won't work on it. If there's no "space", only one vision (and likely one that isn't even present) can exist. Need both. I think you CAN make a city. )*( does it every year, after all, and while much of that event can't persist year-round, some of the ideas about how to make a city definitely could (I would expect).
- Animats 11y agoIt's not illegal. It's not even expensive. Take a look at this catalog of manufactured homes.[1] [1] http://www.claytonhomes.com/find-homes.cfm?categoryID=1 http://www.claytonhomes.com/find-homes.cfm?categoryID=1
- petra 11y agoAren't there cities close to silicon valley, with nicer zoning laws enabling sane housing prices ? And if so, why don't they become the 2nd silicon valley ?
- raincom 11y agoBecause major employers of the valley don't open offices in Modesto, Stockton, Tracy, Fairfield, Gilroy, etc.
- pascalxus 11y agoThe founders of the companies that employ the most employees already have housing in the prime silicon valley, so it's not their problem. And as long as they can still find plenty of software developers in the prime silicon valley, they have no reason to move to other areas.
- evv555 11y agoThe problem isn't just building affordable houses but building affordable houses in locations people want to live. But how essential would location be if an autonomous vehicle could take your child to a quality charter school beyond your district? How essential is location if long commutes can be turned into productive time because you don't have to focus on driving? All those construction regulations holding back affordable housing; they don't apply if it's on top of a set of wheels. I have my doubts that the status quo is sustainable for too much longer.
- spo81rty 11y agoSoftware developers these days can move to many other major cities and find a job instantly. They are in very high demand. They don't have to live in the Silicon Valley area and pay 3x the price for rent. If I was a property investor, I wouldn't want to build properties there either. The risk would be extremely high that property values are going to come crashing back down to reality at some point. There is a serious property value bubble out there.
- rrss1122 11y agoProperty investors aren't the ones building properties. It's the property developers. I read this in an article explaining Miami's development boom, in spite of the possibility that rising sea levels could inundate much of the new construction in the next century. The property developer's only concern is selling the property. Once it's out of their hands, they are no longer exposed to risk on that property. As long as they can continue convincing property investors that the boom will continue, developers will continue building right up till the moment that property values come crashing down.
- bdcravens 11y agoI lease a home in North Houston owned by an attorney in LA - all of his real estate investments are here and Brownsville, Tx. (And I pay $1150 for 1600 sq ft with a giant yard, stand-alone home, not an apartment)
- EGreg 11y agoI have predicted this for a long time (not just me, but a lot of people). The demand for human labor is going down on average, so wages are going down - and have been on a decline since the 70s. Capitalism relies on employers to value their employees for the money to trickle down and the system to work. Our grandfathers used to work for the same employer for decades and got a pension. Today, that loyalty is unheard of from either side. We have the rise of temps and the contractor economy and unemployed living with parents. Yes, the cost of mass produced consumer goods is going down. So the wage repression is mitigated. With the explosion of consumer credit in the 80s and 90s, the unsustainability of consumer spending was also masked. Now it has come to the fore, in exactly the areas where costs are not going down: rent and real estate. In every major city including NYC and SF, the costs of rent are sky high relative to wages. Wonder why? Look at the rest of the country and it's true too -- the rents are slightly lower but the wages are lower too. So the predictions are borne out... automation has reduced demand for human labor, reduced wages for the average worker (or they got laid off / became temps), reduced the prices of mass produced goods, but the cost of real estate keeps rising.
- jensen123 11y agoI guess there could be more than one single thing causing this problem. So, overly restrictive zoning might contribute to the problem, but so might reduced demand for human labor and the government/banks printing too much money.
- JDDunn9 11y agoAnother solution would be improvements to transportation. If we had something like Hyperloop, ET3, skyTran, etc., we could increase the radius we could live from work. It's traffic jams that drive up the value of land in the inner city. If you can get to work in 20 minutes, you don't care how far you have to live from the city.
- ild 11y agoIf you want affordable, build dense, urban cities; not NY style rows after rows of 2 story building, separated by roads, but USSR style large 4-6-9 story blocks, build from concrete (longevity, privacy) with no eventually moldy drywalls, closed for through traffic, with parking garages, public places, playgrounds etc. American university campuses can be good models for residential neighborhoods.
- clock_tower 11y agoBuildings which are just residential (and, for that matter, ones which are just commercial) still tend to produce dead zones, with little to no street life; and it's street life (and walkability) that makes a city, at least if you ask me. I'd say that the best kind of city -- or district/neighborhood, more accurately, since cities tend to be a patchwork -- is an area of multi-storey buildings with businesses on the ground floor and apartments above them. My understanding is that this is the usual pattern in the Old World; in the US, the North End and Allston-Brighton in Boston, Seattle's Chinatown, and of course Vancouver are among the examples. This isn't a common pattern in the US; I know that parts of NYC fit it (although I don't know that city particularly well), but I've heard that even Manhattan Island is all office buildings, and becomes a wasteland after dark. I certainly agree, though, that 4-9 storeys is a pretty good height. Smaller than that and you don't get enough density to support interesting streetscapes; larger, and you get wind tunnels and the need for more parking. Of course, sometimes geography (San Francisco, Tehran, most of Japan) or politics (Singapore) force a denser population, and require a more built-up area...
- ild 11y agoUSSR has always had ground floor shopping on the street facing residential buildings, also major bus stops have convenience stores attached.
- clock_tower 11y agoIt sounds like I should visit Russia, then! Whatever else can be said about them, it sounds like the Soviets really knew how to build a city.
- crdoconnor 11y ago>In reality, housing construction is very limited; it’s being restricted by zoning and permitting laws. Because developers can only build a few new units, they’re building luxury, since that’s the most profitable. Having more space thanks to laxer regulations would just mean that they build even more and even bigger luxury housing because it would still be the most profitable. Besides, one of those permitting laws they absolutely loathe are laws that say that they must build a certain percentage of affordable housing (not mentioned in this article because that would be inconvenient). These articles are so disingenuous. They're telling you that the solution to your housing woes, caused by and large by the ultra-wealthy, is to give into the ultra-wealthy's demand that they shouldn't face laxer regulation. We know how that story always ends. The solution to housing shortage in high cost of living cities is and always has been to build high quality government housing. Singapore provides a stellar example of what that would look like. Literally the day a program like that is announced prices and rents would tumble. >The global elite argument really falls apart here. No it really doesn't. The global elite will happily swallow up all available prime real estate in their portfolios and A) tell you to fuck off to cities with no jobs if you complain about the house prices and B) tell you that the lack of jobs in nowheresville is your problem since you chose to move there. THEY'RE the problem.
- CalRobert 11y agoAnd this is why almost all US cities are incredibly hostile to anyone walking. Also, while this is subjective, they're unattractive as well. This is a helpful illustration of how parking minimums raise rents by several hundred dollars a month and make the streetscape less appealing. http://www.portlandoregon.gov/bps/article/420062 http://www.portlandoregon.gov/bps/article/420062
- 16bytes 11y ago> One of these vehicles offers the possibility of huge profits off rich d-bags. The other one, not so much. I stopped reading when I reached this caption. Companies exist to make profit, not act in the public interest. Demonizing normal business behavior is counterproductive. There's a huge gap between Goldman Sacks/Enron/etc and most companies.