5 ms·
> Not exactly a fight, is it? We silenced the pounding dance music, but you get the idea. Yes, I do. You intended to obscure relevant information to purposefu
by kbenson 11y ago
> Not exactly a fight, is it? We silenced the pounding dance music, but you get the idea.
Yes, I do. You intended to obscure relevant information to purposefully misconstrue or obfuscate the event.
The point of the cameras is that they are additive. That video, even without audio, as an addition to a statement that says something to the effect of "we danced with each other" would be viewed in an entirely different context. If it was in addition to one party stating "we never got close to each other" then it means something else.
In the end, it's additional information. If you have no information about the event whatsoever from the parties involved, just some footage without sound, then you have much larger problems.
- sammermpc 11y agoOne of the author's here — you're nailing the exact point that we were trying to emphasize. In real cases, we often have incomplete or obscuring documentation, and draw conclusions from that. The addition of another perspective can radically change our perception of an encounter. Granted, it's artificial to the point of absurdity in this case, but the point is made.
- themodelplumber 11y ago> One of the author's here I'm feeling so conflicted all of a sudden and it's even April 1
- brebla 11y agoReasonable person standard. A civilian does not typically get that close to a police. If I got that close to a traffic cop, I would probably be in jail.
- simoncion 11y agoA few things: ...do you live in the US? > A civilian... Police are civilians. Some people see this as hair-splitting, but it's a very important distinction. > If I got that close to a traffic cop, I would probably be in jail. In the US, if you're jailed just for being in close proximity to a police officer, then you've been jailed illegally. (If, however, you refuse to give the guy some room when he asks for it, then you can be detained and (maybe) jailed.)
- woodman 11y ago> Police are civilians ... it's a very important distinction. The misuse of the word is a symptom of the real problem, it is deeply ingrained in police culture that they are fundamentally different. I think it was one of Dave Grossman's books, an author that enjoys a military and LEO following, that put forward the idea that they are sheepdogs - protecting the flock from the wolves. So that is a big problem, as the idea has gotten picked up in popular culture. I don't really mind cops insisting that they aren't civilians, because I agree with them to a point - the root word doesn't seem to apply anymore. That is unlikely to change without a major overhaul in the standard escalation of force model, where the officer is taught to control a situation by being one level of force above everybody else - making them aggressors by default.
- simoncion 11y ago> The misuse of the word is a symptom of the real problem... Agreed. > I don't really mind cops insisting that they aren't civilians... I do. ;) Because... > [Police use as a] standard [situation control mechanism the] escalation of force model, where the officer is taught to control a situation by being one level of force above everybody else - making them aggressors by default. Military police use de-escalation of force by default when interacting with non-combatants. It is drilled and drilled and drilled into their heads that the very fact that they are armed and/or armored automatically escalates the situation, so they MUST continuously work to de-escalate the situation from the microsecond that they arrive on the scene. Civilian police would be so much more competent and so much more reasonable if they had the same training that actual military personnel receive.
- woodman 11y agoThe only difference between what I said and what you said is that you've added that MP training emphasizes deescalation. Both MPs and civilian police observe the same force continuum, but it seems to me that MPs are simply more disciplined. I don't think it is realistic to try and bring regular cops up to that standard of discipline, it would be much easier to simply provide a less flexible justification for violence. Many years ago when I was in USMC security force I remember being trained on actions that nudge the escalation of force - which was likely the first time I heard the phrase "furtive movement". While I'd seen a fair amount force applied subsequent to that period of instruction, I never heard that justification used. It seems to be the go to justification outside of the military. My point is that giving cops the latitude that the escalation of force provides is like giving the CEO's 15 year old nephew the commit bit and letting him write safety critical software in non-MISRA C.
- kbenson 11y ago> Granted, it's artificial to the point of absurdity in this case, but the point is made. That was what I was pointing out. Unfortunately it was before I had finished the article, otherwise my approach would have been different. Mea culpa. > In real cases, we often have incomplete or obscuring documentation, and draw conclusions from that. The addition of another perspective can radically change our perception of an encounter. And that's a really good point, and good on you for making it. The article got stronger as it went on, I juts thought it was pretty shaky in the beginning, because of that first video and how contrived it feels. Granted, I can see it may be problematic to show that situation well while including sound, but that it is possible for it to happen (large crowds, heavy traffic, malfunction, etc). I'm not sure if that calls for a different example, moving it from the first example to a later one, or both, but I think that would make for a stronger start. As an aside, while it's a bit outside the scope of your article, I think it's very important that all the different perspectives (including participant accounts) be gathered before they've had a chance to see/hear/read others. That one participant describes the experience very differently than others is very important, and can convey a few different things. For example, beyond purposefully misconstruing events, it may just be that the state of mind (terror) of one of the participants kept them from acting rationally. That's information that may be lost if people are allowed to review other sources before giving a statement.
- PantaloonFlames 11y agoGlad you're exploring the issue, but... your scenarios are completely contrived. In the ACTUAL scenarios where there is video, we see dashcam video of officers shooting a suspect who is on the ground, and no threat, 9 additional times. We see officers shooting fleeing suspects in the back. We see officers taking 0.75 seconds to decide to murder a "suspect" who is holding a toy gun in a department store. Your story is talking about theoretical risks to interpreting video. In the actual facts, we have already seen that video can add a great deal of clarity to a situation, and often that clarity directly conflicts with sworn statements by the officers involved.
- jobu 11y agoIt can also help corroborate times, distances, and other hard facts that tend to be exaggerated or distorted by the mind when remembering stressful situations.
- random_rr 11y agoThe whole point of the article is that you can misconstrue video evidence with a lack of context. That's exactly what you're saying as well. So I don't really understand your comment unless you're just argumentatively agreeing with the author?