9 ms·
Oculus Rift Review: VR’s Rising Star Isn’t Ready for the Mainstream
- therobot24 11y agoThe review read like he was expecting it to be the iphone version of VR. Complaints about using an expensive computer, the cord, having to use muscle memory, etc. come off like the type of person who wouldn't be interested in the Oculus in the first place. While I agree that it looks clunky, really it's the performance that most would-be buyers are interested in.
- vernie 11y agoThe operative word here is "mainstream"
- nyolfen 11y agofor a first gen 600 dollar headset that requires a 1000 dollar pc, i'm not sure this is really true
- Retric 11y agoIs ~50 million people "mainstream"? Considering he complained about downloading drivers this must be very easy to setup. Gaming PC's used to be ~2,000$, this is 600 + 950PC = 1550$. https://www.oculus.com/en-us/oculus-ready-pcs/ https://www.oculus.com/en-us/oculus-ready-pcs/ Which is not free but hardly going to break most people. Don't forget this is just a mid-range gaming PC which many people are going to get anyway which drops this down to the cost of a high end cellphone. PS: IMO, WoW was mainstream as a PC only MMO with a few million subscribers in the US.
- minimaxir 11y agoWorld of Warcraft went mainstream because it didn't require a gaming PC to play in 2004.
- Retric 11y agoThere are more than 10x as many active Steam accounts (125m) vs active WoW accounts at it's peak (12m) in 2010. Sure, a mid to low end PC could play WoW in 2004, but it only broke 2.5 million subscribers in late 2005. http://cdn2.ubergizmo.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/wow-subscribe-640x215.jpg http://cdn2.ubergizmo.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/wow-sub... And 10m in 2008. Give it 4 years and a GTX 970 will be a very low end graphics card.
- minimaxir 11y agoComparing the number of Steam accounts to WoW accounts is comparing apples to oranges. (And also makes an implicit assumption that everyone who has a Steam account has a gaming PC, which is not a good assumption.) In 2004, Steam had no noteworthy buzz and its only purpose was Half-Life 2 DRM.
- Retric 11y agoSteam survey actually provides good hardware numbers. The important thing is with the number of Steam Users each 1% is more than 1 million people. Thus < 50% can still be a lot of people. (4.39% own a 970 GTX GPU, 0.92% own a 980 GTX GPU, 0.72% own a GTX 980 Ti ~= 7.5 million people who don't need to upgrade graphics card, now add ATI and SLI.) PS: Active Steam account = bought something from steam AND logged on in the last 2 weeks. Which IMO is a much higher hurdle than most website tracking. And clearly not all gaming PC's are on Steam.
- duaneb 11y agoSteam often logs in on boot. I don't see this as a very interesting metric and certainly not related to the popularity of the first generation of a VR device.
- Retric 11y agoHow else are you going to estimate the number of PC's used for games that don't need to upgrade? Or even the number of PC gamers?
- MBCook 11y agoIf any go mainstream it will be the PS VR. Sony has 30m consoles out there, and it only costs $500 to get setup with PS VR. Total price is about $800-900. Plug and play, games work great because they're designed for the system. On the other hand with the Rift and the Vive you need a PC which has to be up to spec, the hardware is more expensive, etc.
- Retric 11y agoI was looking though the Steam Survey and on the nVidia side ~7.5 million people have a nVidia GPU fast enough for the Rift. Add ATI and people upgrading this year and I think the market may be similar sized. The real question IMO, is if you own both which do you add VR to?
- MBCook 11y agoFor me the answer is easy. I don't have a good PC (just a 5 year old laptop that I don't use much) so going with a Rift or a Vive is a huge investment and requires me getting back into keeping a PC setup just for VR. The PS VR is cheaper and I already keep that equipment setup. I don't need to worry about specs/etc. Plug and play. Plus the PS VR is cheaper. For me I'd go with PS VR and see how that goes. If I really liked it then I might buy a Vive for my (we'll pretend I own a) gaming PC. I could sell the PS VR to offset the cost. Don't own a console? Already hard-core into PC? Then just going straight to Vive/Rift makes plenty of sense if you're willing to buy in.
- Qworg 11y ago"Which is not free but hardly going to break most people" - most people make ~$4500 a month or less (pre taxes). $1550 is a big chunk of cash for most people.
- Retric 11y agoDepends on context. You can get a reliable used car for ~12k. Look at how many people spend 2+K more than that.
- duaneb 11y ago> Is ~50 million people "mainstream"? Where is this number coming from? Even the people I know interested in VR aren't exactly leaping to buy this first generation, and that's exactly what the review should (and does) reveal—you should continue waiting unless you want to deal with typical early adopter issues.
- cableshaft 11y agoYep, pretty big gamer here, have three of the current gen consoles, even bought a simple Google Cardboard peripheral to get a feel for VR, but I'm probably not going to drop serious cash on anything that's out there for at least a year, and until I see which way the wind is blowing. I'm excited for it, but it's too much money for me to spend right now.
- givinguflac 11y agoIsn't "the iPhone version of VR" exactly what would be considered mainstream though? That's what took smartphones mainstream as well.
- nawitus 11y agoThat sounds like the review is valuable for most people, since most people would be interested in knowing about these complaints when making a purchase decision about the product.
- VikingCoder 11y agoIt IS the iPhone of VR. The first iPhone didn't have over-the-air updates, over-the-air app installs, over-the-air music downloads. The screen was crap (compared to today).
- SquareWheel 11y agoMore than that, the first iPhone had no third-party apps period and still ran on the EDGE network. Even with all those limitations, it was still groundbreaking. The iPhone made everyone wake up and rethink what we were doing. The comparison to VR is apt. It really is a game-changing technology.
- VikingCoder 11y ago"Game-changing" is a good way to think about it, too. This ISN'T the future - but it's changed the game - we now how a different vision for what the future will be.
- cmiles74 11y agoAnyone off the street could pick up an iPhone and do something productive in a couple of minutes. Everyone who bought a first generation iPhone was pretty impressed with the product itself; it took me at least a week before I really wished I could install more software on it. And even so, it was still really useful. Compare this to the Oculus Rift, the average person doesn't even have a machine they can plug it into. I mean, who even has a desktop computer anymore? Everyone I know has a laptop. The product is clearly aimed at serious gamers who have the money to sink into serious gaming rigs. The iPhone-of-VR it certainly is not.
- Karunamon 11y agoWhy is everyone using the with-PC price when talking about the Rift? It's a peripheral, not a console. The target market for this thing already has a gaming machine. It would be like releasing a really awesome gaming keyboard for $100, and having it characterized as costing $1500 since it implies the use of a powerful PC. Is this bugging anyone else?
- empath75 11y agothe 'mainstream' doesn't own a pc capable of running vr.
- empath75 11y agoI totally think VR is The Future, but I don't disagree with anything he said. It's an expensive toy for early adopters and developers, still. They're not going to sell millions of these in the first generation. The Vive won't either. I got to try it last week, and it's mind-blowing, but a) it takes up a lot of room and b) there are going to be casualties from room scale VR. Injuries and loss of furniture at least. I only watched people playing for 3 hours, and the guy doing the demo took an elbow to the ribs, and the 1500 pc they were using was tripped over.
- cracell 11y agoThat's the problem though. The VR PR machine is making it sound like these new VR headsets are something anyone can just buy, plugin and play with! But it's more complex than that.
- rwmj 11y agoHow does it work with glasses? The original DK1 had an awkward set of lenses that you had to place inside the headset.
- A-F1V3 11y agoI tried the consumer version while wearing glasses a few weeks ago. No lenses were changed out and the device just sat over top of the glasses, it was fairly comfortable but I only spent less than 5 mins with it on.
- mpd 11y agoA player with glasses is on Giant Bomb's stream as I type this, and says "it ain't great". He's been at it 20-ish minutes.
- drzaiusapelord 11y agoMy reading of this is that he's unhappy with using a gamepad for VR, which is understandable. I think the Vive is going to be much more impressive. Oculus launching without proper touch controllers was a very risky move. I think ultimately its going to hurt them, and people will be pissed that they need to spend another $200 to get what anyone would consider a proper VR experience. https://www.reddit.com/r/Vive/comments/4cagl1/giant_bomb_live_stream_vr_with_gamepad_is_fucked/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Vive/comments/4cagl1/giant_bomb_liv...
- nice_byte 11y agoIt works almost fine. I had to adjust the headset position on my face a couple of times to get better focus.
- VeejayRampay 11y agoI always think about the people developing such groundbreaking technology, sweating for years to craft something revolutionary, putting everything you got into a product, just to get some guy from the Wall Street Journal declare that it's not ready for mainstream. A guy that knows nothing of the challenges, the hurdles and quite frankly, nothing of the actual success the produt will actually have. But just because Wall Street Journal, that person is somewhat a "voice that matters" even though he's just some random columnist, with no experience in the domain and nothing to back it up but his personal opinion and factoids. How annoying that must be.
- forrestthewoods 11y agoI doubt they'd disagree. It's not ready for the main stream. But It is ready for the hardcore niche audience that will build $1000+ dollar machines to power a $600 headset. All is according to plan.
- BillinghamJ 11y agoWhen you've been deep into R&D and then translating that into a shipping product, it's very easy to not realize that you've been building a product which simply nobody wants or just isn't right. Not saying that's necessarily the case here, but that's why you often need external pragmatic perspective, like from the WSJ.
- rwmj 11y agoThere's nothing particularly new in this article. All of these criticisms have been obvious for years. Oculus/FB seem as if they don't care and are deliberately targeting hardcore gamers. Presumably they know what they're doing.
- nawitus 11y agoHe wrote a review for the mainstream person, who is not interested in the challenges of building the product, but rather how good it is.
- weego 11y agoThis is a major logical fallacy I've faced in "engineering". Technical challenges and effort are irrelevant to the consumer: their contract is the exchange of disposable income for something that they get pleasure / function out of in a way that is measurable against the investment. If you've spent years and invested everything in something that sucks, then it sucks until someone evolves it into something that doesn't. That is why first to market is not always the golden ticket.
- msabalau 11y agoMany interesting technologies aren't for mainstream users initially. Not everything is a messaging app that can scale to billions of users with dozens of engineers. It is okay to get things right with early adopters before crossing the chasm.
- Sir_Substance 11y ago>There’s already another VR rig that doesn’t have a tether—and it costs a fraction of the Rift. Samsung’s $100 Gear VR, made in partnership with Oculus, is powered by a smartphone that you physically insert in front of two lenses. The extra costs of the Rift (monetary and otherwise) would be justified if its image quality were dramatically better than the Gear’s, but it isn’t. I already got the sense that the author really hadn't done much research before writing the piece, but that statement is very telling. The key benefits of a rift over a gear vr are in it's motion capture, the processing power made available to it by the attached computer and not being time restricted by limited battery life, and I would expect a critic to know that. As it stands I respect the dudes view, and it'll be one shared by a lot of non-gamers, but this is basically a lets-play, not a critical review.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jsprogrammer 11y agoCan't you attach your phone to a computer and grid power with a USB cable?
- Sir_Substance 11y agoOff the top of my head I don't think you can with the gear vr (doesn't the USB port get taken up by the headset?), but even if you can, one of the authors key complaints leading into that statement was that the rift was not wireless. If you told him to wire up his gear vr, he wouldn't be impressed.
- kitcar 11y agoCorrect, the interface between the phone and the headset is the charge port, but there is an additional port on the Gear VR itself to allow for charging while being used. The original Gear VR ("Innovator edition") could not be charged while used though if I remember correctly.
- jsprogrammer 11y ago
- Xero 11y ago"Another big-picture VR problem: It’s boring to be around people who are using it." This sentence is pretty emblematic of the product the author of this article was expecting vs the Rift that Oculus pitched in their kickstarter video.
- bcook 11y agoHis complaint seems just plain wrong... are these VR systems incapable of mirroring the image to a TV?
- 83457 11y agonope, mirroring was actually the default setup for the rift and still possible
- VikingCoder 11y agoAnother big-picture problem with the news: It's boring to be around people who are reading it. I also find it's boring to be around people who are Google Searching, or using Facebook.
- Pfhreak 11y agoNot to mention that mirroring the VR experience to a TV or monitor is absolutely delightful to watch. I've had people come over to play Alien Isolation, Dreadhalls, or Volo Airsport, and watching them play was a huge delight for everyone. The responses you get from someone who is trapped in a room with an alien are much more visceral.
- astrodust 11y agoYou may as well lock people in an isolation pod. This is the problem, isn't it?
- Pfhreak 11y agoThey aren't isolated, though. If you know you've got an audience only a foot or two away, you do behave differently. In my experience, people often run their mouths constantly -- "Oh god, what's that, what's over there, is that the alien?" And there's feedback from the audience, "Oh shit, watch out!" Not to mention the occasional breath on someone's neck or tap on the shoulder. When the experience is over, you pull the headset up -- an action not too far removed from looking away from a monitor -- and immediately start sharing. "Man, in that room with the shadows, I was watching the alien for a good 20 seconds before any of you saw it!"
- tryitnow 11y agoWas anyone expecting it to be really ready for mainstream use?
- mattmanser 11y agoIn case you missed it, there's another review linked in the article for a hardcore gamer's take: http://blogs.wsj.com/digits/2016/03/28/oculus-rift-is-built-for-gamers-but-needs-better-games/ http://blogs.wsj.com/digits/2016/03/28/oculus-rift-is-built-... It, too, is negative.
- kzhahou 11y agoAbsolutely!! I mean, we can quibble over the exact meaning, but the oculus team took so long precisely in order to have a wide-adoption product instead of a tech demo, which was available over a year ago. The Big Question we all have right now is precisely this: will VR enter mainstream or will it be a gimmick? Oculus is supposed to be leading that charge. If they can't break into some huge number of homes, then the VR ecosystem will die before it gets started. Goodbye JauntVR, etc.
- radicalman 11y agoThis has been my suspicion. The new kids on the block are actually really fucking great. In fact, they have so much hardware expertise and ready audience to launch it mainstream, for example, ps vr
- carc 11y agoI've heard the PS VR is very lacking. Source: http://www.gizmag.com/best-vr-headset-gdc-2016/42377/ http://www.gizmag.com/best-vr-headset-gdc-2016/42377/
- M4v3R 11y agoI've tried PS VR. Nice gimmick, but the low-resolution and problems with controller tracking didn't make a good impression to be honest.
- hartator 11y agoI am bit jealous that this journalist get the ocolus in advance. Specially when he doesn't seem to care that much about it.
- drzaiusapelord 11y agoMany have had it in advance, its just the review embargo was lifted today, so we're finally seeing some third-party reviews.
- KayL 11y agoI tried Gear VR before and very disappointed by Display resolution. Hoping someone can tell the different between these 2 devices.
- spriggan3 11y agoVR itself isn't ready for mainstream period. The problem isn't Oculus Rift but the tech itself. Who can really spend an hour with a VR headset on ? very few people.
- tluyben2 11y agoOculus is meant for the more non causal gamer; I know quite a few of those and when they are playing they might as well have a VR set on. A friend of mine, when she is playing (and she plays for 3-4 hours per day) seems dead from a distance: when you come closer you see only her eyes and fingers move slightly while on the screen she is walking through large worlds wielding spells and weapons. Very few in % might be right but that is a lot of sales for the solutions that work for these people. I have a few of them (oculus backer, few simple ones that can be uses with a mobile phone) and I see uses as I do enjoy the experience and I do see the opportunity to, when the hardware allows, have enormous virtual screens when focusing on code or other work. My biggest issue for now is that all off them start to physically hurt when the weight of the device pushes the plastic into the cushioning in one location on my face after about 30 minutes.
- 6stringmerc 11y agoComing from a background with thousands of hours of hardcore multiplayer gaming, I'm very dis-interested in VR as a gaming platform, most specifically Oculus due to cost. The competitive field sounds like it needs some time to work through which device(s) get the best market traction (flashbacks to HD-DVD vs. Blu-Ray). I think the author of the article knows his audience pretty well and meets the review expectations as stated - what is the 'mainstream' use case? I think one of the most relevant parallells - for now, at this stage of development - is with a projetor. Relatively high cost of entry, takes effort and space for setup, and for basic day-to-day entertainment, kind of overkill. Sure it's great from time to time to take a projector and game rig outside and play Forza on a two-car garage door with a screen so big landing planes can probably see it, no doubt. It's actually nice to have one when other people are over, so it's a more engaging device, unlike putting on a headset. Honestly I think about the time VR will be considered 'mainstream' is when the more customary (and accessible) entertainment forms start generating in-demand content. Think major motion picture studios, TV networks, and concert-type footage (Rolling Stones in Cuba probably in development as I type this). Or, as one more comparison, once the VR platform is as dynamic and simple as the iPhone environment (games, communication, media) then more people will adopt in turn and the market will diversify in beneficial ways (serious vs. casual gamers, etc). I'm really excited to see what the 'traditional' creative platforms like music and storytelling are going to do in the environment over time.
- justifier 11y agomy main complaint with the rift is often overlooked, (edit: this is simply untrue, it appears since i walked away from the stereoscopic vr world the issue of ipd has certainly been addressed and efforts have been made to assuage the problem) and unfortunately i think will only start to be addressed when the number of people who spend more time with the device increases, the headset is one size fits all the center of the split screen, the stationary lenses, and i'm assuming the stereo render all presume everyone's eyes are the same distance apart and perfectly level which is simply untrue, and without configurable variables those minute discrepancies will result in peoples' brains working much harder to compensate my eyes went cross for an hour after taking off the headset the last time i ever used my dk2, i wonder if i will be reading someone else's similar story in the near future
- lfowles 11y agoQuick google for "oculus interpupillary distance": http://www.roadtovr.com/oculus-says-consumer-rift-has-ipd-adjustment-and-better-design-for-glasses/ http://www.roadtovr.com/oculus-says-consumer-rift-has-ipd-ad...
- justifier 11y agoi stand corrected, and your linked article is even from june of last year as well i commend the oculus team for addressing the issue for the consumer product that said, i think digital stereoscopy is the wrong direction for vision manipulation there are many minute issues similar to ipd that need to be addressed, an engineering analogue to the curse of dimensionality if one looks at the history of stereoscopic viewers it is clear they failed to usurp their two dimensional counterparts and i think it of interest to question why that may be
- Pfhreak 11y agoI have an unusually wide IPD (about 73mm), and I struggled with this on the DK2. The image would not focus properly because the alignment of the lenses. I was able to address this fairly easily with a 3D printed set of adjusters. The consumer rift, however, has a IPD adjustment knob on it for exactly this reason. In playing with the prototypes they had at PAX last August, the IPD was much, much less of an issue.
- lisper 11y agoLet me see if I have this straight: the advantage of the Rift over the Gear VR is that the Rift lets you move around and the Gear doesn't. But the Rift has a (fairly short) cable, and the Gear doesn't. Is that right? Because the problem seems so obvious that I almost feel a little foolish pointing it out: cables and movement don't play well together, particularly when, by design, you can't see the cable.
- 83457 11y agoThe rift has cameras that track your movement. That is the main difference that you are looking for. I've used the rift dk1 with extension cables and can actually move around quite freely, though obviously not as much as a wireless setup. With gearvr you can move around but the headset/game doesn't actually know you are moving around as there is no external tracker or reference point like with the rift.
- Suttonian 11y agoThe positional tracking is useful even if you don't walk around though. Imagine you lean to the side in your chair but you view doesn't change at all - how weird would that be? Or you're stood on the edge of a building, and try to lean over to see below, but you can't because your viewpoint doesn't change. Positional tracking means that would work as expected - it's good even for seated experiences (where a cable isn't really a problem). Besides from what I hear, users get used to the cable after a while, even though all recognize that it's not ideal.
- agildehaus 11y agoThe GearVR doesn't do positional tracking at all, just basic head tracking. It also has to use your smartphone GPU, which means games are severely limited in comparison to a Rift connected to a GTX 970 or 980.
- keypusher 11y agoIt's strange to have a non-gamer do the review for this, as he seems to know very little about the field, or computer gaming. I guess they are aiming for a mainstream opinion, but Occulus is not a mainstream device. It's a high-end gaming peripheral. For instance that the author mentions incredulously multiple times that his high-end PC requires two power cables, which I just don't understand. I found his colleague's review (which is referenced in the article, also wsj) much more informative. His take was that it's a pretty cool piece of technology, but needs more games. http://blogs.wsj.com/digits/2016/03/28/oculus-rift-is-built-for-gamers-but-needs-better-games/ http://blogs.wsj.com/digits/2016/03/28/oculus-rift-is-built-...
- atonse 11y agoIs that how the Oculus team has marketed it? That it's a peripheral only for hardcore gamers, and not at all mainstream? I doubt it.
- sp332 11y agoIt's not about hardcore gamers if you mean FPS or something. But it's not aiming at the middle of the market. It requires a high-end PC just to drive it, and it's an expensive peripheral, so it really can't be "mainstream". It's about people who are the most interested in VR gaming.
- Animats 11y agoRead what Zuckerberg had to say when Facebook bought Oculus.[1]: "This is really a new communication platform. By feeling truly present, you can share unbounded spaces and experiences with the people in your life. Imagine sharing not just moments with your friends online, but entire experiences and adventures." He's talking about VR as a social medium, like Facebook. Sort of like Second Life. Second Life has supported the Oculus Rift since late 2014. Nobody cares.[2] I can see using one for FPS games, but beyond that, it's not that compelling. There's still no killer VR app. [1] https://www.facebook.com/zuck/posts/10101319050523971 https://www.facebook.com/zuck/posts/10101319050523971 [2] http://www.roadtovr.com/second-life-now-official-oculus-rift-dk2-support/ http://www.roadtovr.com/second-life-now-official-oculus-rift...
- intrasight 11y agoThe general theme of discussion here ("Gaming") completely validates the author's statement that it isn't ready for the "Mainstream"
- nice_byte 11y agoI got a chance to try out both Oculus and Vive at GDC this year. Oculus' image quality was exactly the way the author described - like looking through a screen door. Vive seemed to be much better (and its controllers had mind-blowing force feedback, which added some realism). Overall, though, I have two major concerns about VR. The first is limited range of movement. All VR experiences seem to require the player to either be seated or move in a confined space. But think of all the virtual miles you've walked in Fallout or GTA - it's not going to be possible with VR. I mean, sure, you could use a controller, but it's a solution similar to putting fake buttons on a touchscreen. The second is that I'm afraid that this is as good as VR is ever going to get because of hardware limitations. People sometimes compare the current state of VR to the early days of gaming consoles, implying that it's going to get much better. But the NES and PS4 are separated by 30 years of moore's law, which is predicted to end in 2025 (only 9 years away). The pace at which hardware is getting better/faster is slowing down.
- ipsum2 11y agoWith all due respect, all of these are known problems, with known solutions. Problem 1: Check out the Virtuix Omni, as well as software-only solutions. Problem 2: See foveated rendering.
- todd8 11y agoThere are quite a few comments on price here. I will wait for more games or at least a compelling game or app before buying one. I'm sure I will though. Consider the price of the HP LaserJet III. It came out around 1990, and I remember a conversation with a salesperson that said that the price had already come down so much since the HP LaserJet I that it probably wouldn't ever get much cheaper. It was a complex machine, motors, belts, gears, laser, etc., and in today's dollars it cost about $4400. High quality printers today are everywhere and can cost under $100. It's interesting to consider where VR will be in a decade or two. It seems like an important development; one I've been waiting for since 1977. I was in a graduate-school computer graphics course and I described an idea that I had for a helmet that would capture motion and position of one's head and through two small CRTs present a rendered 3D virtual view. The rest of the class (and the professor) seemed skeptical, but I've always remembered that feeling about VR like there was an idea that was eventually coming.