8 ms·
People talk about institutional evil. This is an example of it. You can almost trace their thinking "Oh, so solitary is bad now. We'll fix it. Put two people in
by rdtsc 11y ago
People talk about institutional evil. This is an example of it. You can almost trace their thinking "Oh, so solitary is bad now. We'll fix it. Put two people in a 10x4 cell. See, not solitary anymore, and we doubled the capacity too. Bonuses for everyone".
Ideally you'd think those who made those decision would be disciplined, pensions would be cut, etc. But nothing like that is gonna happen. Even if the family wins the lawsuit, it will be taxpayers paying for it.
One a deeper level, I wouldn't be surprised if many of those involved in running the prison would be thinking things like "well good, less people less worries. So what if he kills another one". Even more perverse, in some countries, prisoners who are known to kill and attack their cellmates are used as a coercion tool. That is effective against political prisoners and other undesirables who need to "confess" or be punished -- "behave or you'll end up in Sesson's cell <wink-wink>". On paper it looks completely by the rules and clean.
- superuser2 11y agoThis is also what happens when well-intentioned people are vastly more successful at fighting prison construction than fighting mass incarceration. Our prisons are routinely at 1.5x, 2x, 3x capacity. Being against the prison industrial complex feels good, but in doing so you become directly, personally responsible for the fact that there are now 3 people in a cell meant for one, people living on cots in a gymnasium with no privacy whatsoever, in such close quarters that even the most patient people would be at each other's throats. Until the prison population actually declines, we ought to at least be building prisons fast enough to stay at design capacity. Google your state - you'll be amazed. Prisons aren't designed to be comfortable, but they sure as hell get a lot less comfortable with too many people in them.
- gnaritas 11y agoThere's a simple solution to that, set people free. We don't need to build more prisons, we already imprison more of our population than any other country in the world, we have too many prisons and too many people in them. We need to imprison less people. Release all inmates who committed victim-less crimes, if more room is needed, release all inmates who committed non violent crimes-there are better ways to deal with them than prison. Prison should be for violent criminals only. Release all drug users, release all drug pushers, none of those people belong in jail.
- XorNot 11y agoYou miss the point. It's easier to stop prisons being built then to set people free. But it would probably be easier to deal with the whole problem if in fact we were a lot stricter about ensuring proper prison capacity, construction and staffing were followed. But then again, doing any of that is a lot harder then egging on the narrative that prison is actually meant to be a mad max wasteland, and pretending we're totally not responsible for turning a blind eye to the rape, murder and gangs we let happen there.
- gnaritas 11y agoNo, I don't miss the point, I just don't agree that building more prisons is acceptable.
- zanny 11y ago> victim-less crimes I think I found the double-think. But absolutely, incarceration is used as a tool of suppressing "undesirables" according to the writers of law. The co-conspirator of Watergate is making waves online again this past week for having talked about how the Nixon administration planned the war on drugs as a means to destroy hippie and black communities through mass incarceration and prosecution.
- rtpg 11y agoI agree that we should have less people in prison. In order to be lucid about the situation though, it's important to realise that a very large part of the prison population is in there for violent offences. Even knowing this, I still believe we should be reducing sentences (I have a hard time justifying putting anyone in a cage for 15 years as a punishment...) but there probably needs to be some alternative things going on too.
- lkbm 11y agoTo put some numbers on the part of the prison population there for violent offenses: * Bureau of Justice Statistics says 53% of state prsionsers and 7% (what?!) of federal prisoners (2014): http://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/p14_Summary.pdf http://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/p14_Summary.pdf * Federal Bureau of Prisons says 46.5% drug offences (no specification on violent v. non-violent) and 9.2% immigration as the third largest group. Second largest is more violent sounding, though: Weapons, Explosives, Arson 16.9% (2016): https://www.bop.gov/about/statistics/statistics_inmate_offenses.jsp https://www.bop.gov/about/statistics/statistics_inmate_offen... I don't think non-violent crime should always mean no prison, but I suspect there are better ways of dealing with the majority of them. Also, since you mentioned shorter terms, here are the BOP's numbers of sentence length: https://www.bop.gov/about/statistics/statistics_inmate_sentences.jsp https://www.bop.gov/about/statistics/statistics_inmate_sente...
- Karunamon 11y agoThought experiment: What would happen if the laws were amended so that, should someone be sentenced to prison time, and all prisons within a reasonable radius are at capacity, that either the person with the lowest amount of time to serve in that prison (barring violent offenses) is automatically set free, or the sentence is commuted to probation or such? There's an argument to be made here that cramming two people into a parking-space-sized cell is unconstitutionally cruel and unusual, so the state really should have to decide if placing Joe Potsmoker in for a year is worth releasing Bill Burgalar five years early. Just saying "fuck it, throw 'em all in" shouldn't be an option. (This is assuming that prison has any reformative value at all, of course...)
- superuser2 11y agoThis happens. Not on a 1:1 basis, but early release to alleviate overcrowding somewhat is not unheard of. The careers of the politicians responsible are eviscerated, spectacularly, when the people they released go on to commit violent crimes.
- gcb0 11y agothen you get a interesting, new, prisoner dilemma puzzle. if you are the leader of a big gang, and still have power on the people outside, you can make enough gang-newcomers go to jail until you are free.
- Dylan16807 11y agoThousands of them? And they'd all have to get longer sentences than you? Not going to work.
- brianwawok 11y agoHow about shifts? Prison holds 1000? Make a gang of 4000. You can each serve a week a month to criminalize with impunity.
- Dylan16807 11y ago
- trhway 11y ago>Being against the prison industrial complex feels good, but in doing so you become directly, personally responsible for the fact that there are now 3 people in a cell meant for one if you trace whom prison guard unions support you'd notice that it is the prison-industrial complex who is a major player responsible for incarcerating more people. Having crowded prisons helps a lot to overcome any opposition to new prisons exactly because of the logic like yours.
- chishaku 11y ago> Being against the prison industrial complex feels good, but in doing so you become directly, personally responsible for the fact that there are now 3 people in a cell meant for one... Is there any evidence that people "against the prison industrial complex" are directly responsible for the rate at which new prisons are being constructed? I'm not sure but I'm inclined to think that this would have more to do with strained budgets than any successful activism. Edit: I looked into this a bit with California as an example. In 2011, the Supreme Court affirmed a lower court ruling that required California to dramatically reduce its prison population. "Justice Kennedy, citing the lower court decision, said there was 'no realistic possibility that California would be able to build itself out of this crisis,' in light of the state’s financial problems." http://www.nytimes.com/2011/05/24/us/24scotus.html http://www.nytimes.com/2011/05/24/us/24scotus.html The opinion of the lower court: "Relying on expert testimony, the court ruled that the California prison system, the nation’s largest with more than 150,000 inmates, could reduce its population by shortening sentences, diverting nonviolent felons to county programs, giving inmates good behavior credits toward early release, and reforming parole, which they said would have no adverse impact on public safety." http://www.nytimes.com/2009/02/10/us/10prison.html http://www.nytimes.com/2009/02/10/us/10prison.html
- vacri 11y ago> but in doing so you become directly, personally responsible for the fact that there are now 3 people in a cell meant for one I've not met anyone who is against prison construction that is not also against long sentences and against sentences for trivial crap. It's the state's half-arsed job that's responsible, not the people who are trying to make the place better. We definitely shouldn't be building prisons just for capacity, because then when they are slated to close, it become another political football: "jobs", "soft on crime", so on and so forth. The solution is to stop jailing people to such a ridiculous degree - in the US it's basically j-curved since the '90s.
- Nutmog 11y agoIt's fair for taxpayers to pay for it because they're also the voters who voted for the system. Most people actually want more horrible prisons, they want solitary confinement, they want prisoners to kill each other, they want long sentences. That's why it happens. So isn't it quite reasonable to push the cost back onto those people when they get sued?
- chillwaves 11y agoTo me a more accurate statement would be, per your response, that the system is failing at multiple levels.
- superuser2 11y agoThe system isn't failing - it's working exactly how the people who control it (the voting public) want it to. Out of sight, out of mind, cheap. The only way the prison system could be "failing" in the eyes of the electorate is if there were a lot of escapes, and there aren't.
- jMyles 11y ago> Most people actually want more horrible prisons, they want solitary confinement, they want prisoners to kill each other, they want long sentences. Source?
- coldcode 11y agoIf this is true we should simply be killing them until the population is reasonable. I find it hard to imagine people supporting such a horror. Then again in Soviet Russia no one objected to mass killing of people in Siberian prisons either. /s
- abalashov 11y agoThen again in Soviet Russia no one objected to mass killing of people in Siberian prisons either. Soviet Russian here -- that's just ... false.
- gozur88 11y ago>Oh, so solitary is bad now. We'll fix it. Put two people in a 10x4 cell. See, not solitary anymore, and we doubled the capacity too. Bonuses for everyone I doubt that. The people running the system don't decide how many inmates they get or how many beds they have. They put people where they have to put them. And they have to deal with this kind of fallout. They're doubling up because they don't have room to do anything else. There's probably a memo that went up the chain saying "This is a bad idea. We really shouldn't do it." If it made their jobs easier, guards would be perfectly happy with 1300 sq ft hot-tub-equipped town house cells. They're government employees, after all. But nobody wants a prison in his town. For most people, inmates are out of sight, out of mind and that's the way they like it. That is the problem.
- ljf 11y agoAre they all government employees? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_prison https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_prison
- gozur88 11y agoDid you read the article?
- ljf 11y agoI did indeed... I was questioning why you thought this was exclusive to state controlled prison and suggesting the issue was with those drawing a govt paycheque rather than the whole machine.
- jessaustin 11y agoFrom where do the paychecks come at private prisons? OP was talking about people who work for the government, whether those are subcontractors or GS-5's.
- clort 11y ago> They're doubling up because they don't have room to do anything else then they shouldn't admit them. You know, I've been all over the world and in many third world countries as many people who can get on the bus, just get on the bus. The driver allows it because he gets a dollar for everybody who gets on. In my rich western nation, there is a number posted high up near the ceiling. This number is the number the bus is licenced to carry, and the bus driver gets paid an hourly wage for driving the bus about. When there are too many people at the bus stop, he says he can't allow them on as he would lose his job and he drives away. The potential passengers have to wait for the next bus, or walk. This causes angst amongst the populace who complain to the bus company, or the local government which may effect change. In the USA, it seems, when more and more prisoners are served on a prison, they just take them and cram them into smaller and smaller spaces.. because they get paid for each one and there is no rule against it. The prison should be licensed for a certain number of inmates, and if more prisoners turn up then they should NOT be accepted (under pain of losing their license), and they would remain in the custody of the persons bringing them. That would quickly cause a problem where the local police were too busy babysitting prisoners to go out in the streets and find more for the courts to convict, and THAT is when the populace will suffer angst and demand some change.
- sgt101 11y agoWhat would you do in response to the stated fact of "162% occupancy" ? Where are they supposed to put the 62% ? This isn't a tech company hot desking staffers or pulling in home workers to save money. These are people sitting on a powder keg - I wonder why any of them do it and the best two responses I can come up with is that either no one will ever give them any other job or alternatively that they are doing their best to do good as they see it. I think option 1 is a clear product of having a situation like 162% we should thank the heavens above (and the people concerned) for option 2. I doubt that there's a penny of bonus money in play.
- jMyles 11y ago> What would you do in response to the stated fact of "162% occupancy" ? Where are they supposed to put the 62% ? I'm not sure I understand all of your comment, but the answer to this part is clear: release them and another 80% on top of them. Almost nobody (statistically speaking) in prison actually belongs there. > I wonder why any of them do it > I doubt that there's a penny of bonus money in play. You have discounted mental illness as an explainer. Some people who work in "corrections" exhibit signs of serious psychopathy, and the job seems to be a way of self-medicating.
- sgt101 11y ago>I'm not sure I understand all of your comment, but the answer to this part is clear: release them and another 80% on top of them. Almost nobody (statistically speaking) in prison actually belongs there I was flagging the challenge faced by administrators forced to deal with overcrowding. They do not have the mandate or authority to release any of their wards, but if they did I broadly agree with your approach. I would argue that there are numbers of people who should be in prison, but I agree that the USA and UK appear to incarcerate vastly more people than necessary. >You have discounted mental illness as an explainer. Some people who work in "corrections" exhibit signs of serious psychopathy, and the job seems to be a way of self-medicating. I am biased as my mother worked as a prison officer for a while and I met some of her work mates. They did not appear to be divergent from the population. I am sure that there are some people in the prison administration system who are evil or mad, there are people like that in all organisations, but I doubt that they have the sway that is being attributed to them in the OP. Evil and madness on the part of prison staff is not responsible for the great part of the suffering inflicted by the system.