17 ms·
Heavy Recruitment of Chinese Students Sows Discord on U.S. Campuses
- pigpaws 11y agoyou mean the business of education is following the money and not focusing on spoiled American students who want their cake and eat it too? Follow the money. Education is a business model, no matter the economic model of the country.
- duaneb 11y ago> Education is a business model This is from a country that pioneered universal public education. This attitude disgusts me—the exact same arguments apply to health insurance companies. It's a social good with immense effect on our society, and yet we still attempt to drain money from our neighbors to justify its existence. This is the type of attitude that allows an elite upper class and inspires Trump-esque populist angst. The economy should never be the country's primary concern but balanced with all the citizens' needs.
- pigpaws 11y agoThen it seems that you are easily disgusted. You let me know when the "tenured" professors decide to give up their $150k salaries with months-long "sabbaticals". The "Education System" is basically the "Liberal's" version of the MIC.
- duaneb 11y ago> You let me know when the "tenured" professors decide to give up their $150k salaries with months-long "sabbaticals". The vast majority of professors make crap money (unless you're a research prof or work at an elite liberal arts college). Sabbaticals are often for a full year. The problem with education has nothing to do with the wage of the professors—we already can't afford to pay them what they're worth. > The "Education System" is basically the "Liberal's" version of the MIC. I can't understand this sentence. What did anything you have to say do with anything I had to say?
- pigpaws 11y agofirst, define "crap money". Professors work 8-9 months out of the year. for most, their jobs are protected (tenure), which doesn't exist in the real world. Lets not even get into the educational closed-loop many exist in. (3rd-Century Romanian literature will always be 3rd-Century Romanian Lit.) The problem with education has everything to do with the money the schools have, how they get it and what they do with it - including pay for professors and janitors alike. When the Gov't started giving out 'free money' for student loans, the cost of education went up. why? not because the staff is virtuous and the presidents are moral stalwarts. Its because everyone wants a new car and a flat screen, 4k TV. http://www.nber.org/chapters/c13711.pdf http://www.nber.org/chapters/c13711.pdf I mentioned the MIC because you brought up politics and class differences re: the FACT that education is a business model. like anything else, it is led around by it nose (money). While I can not say that its the best model, i can say I'm not going to pay for someone's X-year degree(s) in 3rd-Century Romanian literature - nor should I be forced to - that is the very opposite of Liberty. Harvard has a $36 BILLION endowment and yet the costs keep going up. WHY? Education SHOULD be one of those things we look up to in society, but unless there is better motivating factor to do so, it will not happen. But then, who says formal education is the ONLY way to get educated? http://www.usnews.com/education/best-colleges/the-short-list-college/articles/2015/10/06/10-universities-with-the-largest-endowments http://www.usnews.com/education/best-colleges/the-short-list... http://money.cnn.com/2016/01/27/pf/college/largest-college-endowments/ http://money.cnn.com/2016/01/27/pf/college/largest-college-e...
- vorg 11y agoLooks like the U.S. is now copying what Canada, Australia, and New Zealand started doing around 1990. Not only do they get the international education dollars, but they also get their residential property market going up again, with the flow on effects on rents and house prices. Expect the U.S. laws to change to make it easier for international students to get a job in the U.S. and eventually stay permanently, just like what happened in Canada, Australia, and NZ.
- whybroke 11y ago> ...they also get their residential property market going up... Of all the problems the US faces, excessively _low_ housing costs is not one of them. Indeed, if the effect would be to raise housing costs then this alone would be a reason to rethink the policy.
- vorg 11y agoThe effect will be to raise housing costs because that profits people who invest in houses. Voters want to get a job, borrow to buy a house, then sell it at a huge gain so they can retire early. U.S. voters are just like those in Canada, Australia, and New Zealand, and since the 2008 crash, will vote to restrict housing supply via zoning laws and boost buyer and renter supply via international students, and the flow-on effects in immigration and tourism -- students who graduate want to get a job and stay, and their families back home will come visit them -- just like what happened in Canada, Australia, and New Zealand.
- whybroke 11y agoNot just speculating land owners but also the financial institutions profiting from issuing mortgages whose influence on policy is obviously enormous. And while loosening zoning laws wouldn't hurt, there has not been any radical increase in such laws over the last 20 years, certainly not across the whole nation. Yet housing prices have sky rocketed over the same period, even in areas where zoning is lax. So, while it may help some, a real solution is evidently not going to be as facile as some re-zoning.
- jorgecurio 11y agoMaybe in Murica. Selling ovaries, shooting porno videos, sex work, stripping. These are the opportunities available to young American students. If they were in Germany, they would've gotten into a good tradeship or university all paid for without having to succumb to transgressive career choices just so they can support themselves through an expensive and horribly faulty notion that education is a business just like trading stocks.
- aianus 11y ago> succumb to transgressive career choices just so they can support themselves through an expensive and horribly faulty notion that education is a business just like trading stocks. Or, you know, you could borrow the money to study and then get a high-paying job in NYC or SF, pay it all back in less than three years, and enjoy low taxes for the rest of your 40 year career. The U.S. system is polarizing, for better (if you're lucky / don't fuck up) or for worse.
- jorgecurio 11y agoborrowing money means you need credit which lot of young adults don't have. don't assume everyone else has the same options as you.
- Armisael16 11y agoYou asserted that no one had good options. You're pretty clearly wrong.
- jorgecurio 11y agocompared to university students in Germany and France? please tell me a German university student who sold their ovaries or body to fund their education. oh thats right it's all paid for. lets not forget the quarter of a million dollar student loans that they will be forced to pay for. Pretty sure that's nothing couple years of work and all paid for right? seriously America is too ghetto for university students, you have to literally fend for your self while in Europe the state recognizes the value in investing in university students through a national program. After all, much of the innovation comes from such institution. Maybe not so far America since they import all of the talent anyways starting from WW2 days also explains why startup founders are overwhelmingly are immigrants. There just isn't enough American students from American universities thriving apart from exclusive ivy league lucky sperm club (being a navajo or hispanic applicant certainly helps) while barring Asian Americans because the 'yellow peril' is taking over the campus.
- elevenfist 11y agoThen they should be taxed like businesses. Higher education has a responsibility that includes not catering to cheaters because they pay more. Universities can lower their costs, this is a cash/land grab where public resources are likeky being burned for some administrator's gain.
- ones_and_zeros 11y agoTake note fellow engineers: There is an effort from our industry, our government and our educational institutions to bring in more foreign students and keep them here. They are cheaper than you and will always be younger than you.
- saint_fiasco 11y agoAre they more competent than you? If they are not, you have little to worry about. If they are, they deserve your job.
- hvs 11y agoThey don't have to be more competent if they are cheaper. Assuming that companies always hire the "best" for the job is naive.
- saint_fiasco 11y agoThat they don't hire the best individual doesn't mean they don't hire the best team. Sometimes the cheap inexperienced developer is the best investment and you are not. In that situation the cheap inexperienced guy deserves the job and you don't. If the company makes a mistake, that is, they think they need a cheap inexperienced guy when in fact they need a 100% American-born-and-raised engineer, that company will be outcompeted by the ones who better know what they need.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- hvs 11y agoYes, if people were reducible to a specific set of data points and the world worked on perfect knowledge and optimally efficiently, that would be true.
- ones_and_zeros 11y ago> Are they more competent than you? no.[0] It's purely a money thing. I don't fault our industry, I do fault our government for bending over backward for them. Besides, I'd rather our industry and government focus on filling those classrooms with Americans and hiring Americans first. But it's a self fulfilling prophecy and I just want to start a conversation because I think that this "career" may not be the best if you are at all capable. [0] http://www.epi.org/publication/bp356-foreign-students-best-brightest-immigration-policy/ http://www.epi.org/publication/bp356-foreign-students-best-b...
- huac 11y agoForeign students being bad at English is a concern - it's a disservice to the international students, teachers, and other students if a substantial subset of students can't participate effectively.
- imglorp 11y agoAnd also to the students they TA.
- tnecniv 11y agoI've had group projects where I couldn't communicate effectively with half of my team.
- spacehome 11y agoI think it's great that colleges are preparing our young people for the challenges they'll be facing in the workforce.
- bsilvereagle 11y agoThat's the problem, colleges aren't supposed to be workforce preparation. They're supposed to be a place of higher learning. If students/TAs/professors can't communicate, learning and intellectual discussion (the entire point of a university) isn't occurring.
- Zigurd 11y agoHumor vs. HN. Humor loses.
- spacehome 11y agoI agree with you 100%, but my comment was a joke.
- autotune 11y agoThat's the problem, HackerNews comments aren't supposed to be humorous. They're supposed to be a place of higher discussion. If users/mods/OPs can't be serious, learning and intellectual discussion (the entire point of HackerNews) isn't occurring.
- ams6110 11y agoSome of these Chinese kids also come with an incredible amount of money. I look around our local campus and see kids driving McLarens, Ferraris, Lamborghinis, Maseratis, Bentleys, Audi R8s, it's like the set of a Top Gear episode and without exception the drivers are young Chinese. You've always seen the occasional BMW or Merc at the Greek houses but these cars are insane.
- 3327 11y agoYeah go to harvard square on a sunday and is Maserati's and 22 yearold's. No offense against them but I mean in all fairness if I was 22 and my dad gave me a ferrari I wouldn't turn it down. Reputation wise though what type of people will they become? Humble down to earth and kind people?
- gammarator 11y agoHarvard students _have_ always been noted for their humility... /s
- namelezz 11y agoLOL. Where did you get that?
- protomyth 11y agoThis is the primary reason since Chinese students have money and pay jacked up tuition (2x or more than in-state). What exactly is the incentive not to recruit? Heck, to ND's shame Dickinson State University went even further and sold bogus degrees. Money is a heck of incentive.
- hkmurakami 11y agoIt's sort of the rationale that Ivy schools have always had in accepting a student following a generous "gift" by their parents. Even as students we figured "well I guess getting a brand new Chemistry building in exchange for giving up one out of the 1000 seats we have in our class isn't such a bad deal." Truly a "portfolio of students"
- pnathan 11y agoI generally would like to see a more patriotic (real patriotism: none of this flags and hoo-rah silliness) approach to student recruitment and scholarships on campuses. I believe American schools can produce excellent students. I think the US has some very high-class aspirations and values, and care should be taken to preserve them and to grow practices such as tenure and free speech which let the best of US values flourish. Having a heavy mix of people from places with other aspirations and values will dilute this system. Of course: the language issue is a big deal. I've had fellow-students that couldn't speak or understand a word of verbal English - in graduate school!!! But their written was adequate. I don't believe they should have been accepted - they should have been kindly redirected to their national universities. Most international students don't have this issue, of course! Most are very fluent in English, even if they have an accent. One very tangible aspect of the situation is that international students often pay cash and are charged out the ying-yang to attend. Perhaps if our fine federal government mandated public universities have equal costs for national and international students, universities wouldn't feel quite so incentivized to attract the (often extremely talented!) international students.
- vkou 11y agoThis sounds like a good idea - perhaps it could be pushed even further - why can't we do more to discourage students from attaining out-of-state universities? Admitting a heavy mix of people from places like Missouri and Alabama will dilute the wonderful high-class aspirations and values that you see in a place like California, New York, or Washington.
- alphydan 11y agoWell, there are terrible neighbourhoods in California. And for Texan universities, some of the locals have accents. I would restrict it good neighbourhoods and well spoken gentlemen/women. This should avoid all the dilution. /s
- bilbo0s 11y agoI think you missed his point. In places like Alabama, nearly everyone will have an accent. The implication being that anyone with a southern accent, which can be difficult to understand, would cause what you are terming "dilution". I don't know? My own belief is that making New Yorkers go to school with people from Alabama provides an additional dimension to the education for all concerned. I believe there is value in it. Reasonable people are free to disagree of course.
- HillaryBriss 11y agoIt's roughly a one for one replacement policy at the flagship campuses. For every out-of-state student attending UCLA/Berkeley/CalPoly*, an in-state student has been displaced. California policy makers must assess the risk that California resident taxpayers simply lose their willingness to support these institutions or to support tax increases to support these institutions. Maybe the existing trend to accept additional "full freight out of state" students is a sign that California residents have already lost their appetite for higher-ed supporting tax increases, a sign that the system has no choice but to start selling these class slots to the highest bidders.
- hackuser 11y ago> California policy makers must assess the risk that California resident taxpayers simply lose their willingness to support these institutions or to support tax increases to support these institutions. The problem is the reverse: Taxpayers in many states, including CA IIRC, have been cutting funding to higher education. They want "smaller government" and tax cuts. As a result, the universities have to find other sources of income, including higher tuition and more out-of-state and foreign students.
- HillaryBriss 11y agoYeah, I guess it depends on how you account for spending and the will of the voter base. California's governor has indeed proposed increased funding in recent years: "Gov. Jerry Brown unveiled his proposed state budget at a press conference in Sacramento on Thursday, providing about $350 million to the UC system in additional funding for the 2016-17 fiscal year." http://www.dailycal.org/2016/01/12/gov-browns-2016-17-budget-proposal-ensures-increased-funding-uc/ http://www.dailycal.org/2016/01/12/gov-browns-2016-17-budget...
- gonyea 11y agoThis is the result of the federal government (congress) abdicating its responsibility during the recession. They allowed state budget cuts to affect education, and to this day schools are doing everything they can to bridge the gap from overseas students. The great recession didn't just create a lost generation from un/under employment among millennials. It also denied many access to an education at all, and saddled the rest with mountains of debt.
- hackuser 11y ago> This is the result of the federal government (congress) abdicating its responsibility Is it Congress or the many citizens who insist on tax cuts and vote to defund higher ed? Many of the same people ridicule higher education. If we want higher education available to all, we have to pay for it. > during the recession It happened before and after the recession; it's not really a consequence of the Great Recession. The GOP has pushed these policies for decades.
- shas3 11y agoUmm, no. The opportunity exists because the economies of India and China are growing, and the elites of those countries emphasize education. Whether governments cut their budgets or not, universities will grab such an opportunity with both hands. To me, it appears like the budget cuts are just a pretext. Do a thought experiment for me: Assume that the government never cut university budgets. Yet the universities are competing with each other and need money to out compete. China and India come along, with lots of rich kids. This is like finding a 10-dollar note on the sidewalk. Of course they'll pick it up. There are a few things these universities are doing: 1. tie up with local universities (NYU Abu Dhabi, CMU China, etc.), 2. encourage more applications from abroad. Other than the cultural friction, etc. I don't see any reason why universities pursuing foreign students is immoral or unethical. They already do this at some level by courting out-of-state student fans via strong/popular sports programs, etc. Edit: CMU-Sun Yat Sen tie up: https://jie.cmu.edu/ https://jie.cmu.edu/ Bigger list here: http://www.pbs.org/now/shows/420/foreign-campuses.html http://www.pbs.org/now/shows/420/foreign-campuses.html
- handedness 11y ago
- hackuser 11y ago> School administrators and teachers bluntly say a significant portion of international students are ill prepared Isn't that a problem with admissions?
- frandroid 11y agoAdmissions know what they're doing, i.e. following administrative policies of letting foreign students paying fully jacked-up tuition no matter what.
- elevenfist 11y agoPublic universities (and private universities with some public missions like mit) are becoming more like private corporations, for the benefit of the administrators first. International students pay more. Edit: I am not generalizing to all international chinese students, nor do I know how uncommon or common my perspective is, but this is what I experienced among undergrad and graduate international chinese students where I was studying in the US. More importantly, universities should not be allowing this sort of behavior in the first place. I'm surprised that this article didn't bother to present anyone else's perspective (the other students, more faculty, people who live near college campuses. More than discord, I bore witness to many international Chinese students instances demonstrating a lack of basic morals. Rude to waiters, aggressively driving around pedestrains, not bothering to pick up trash, no qualms about abusing or destroying resources or cleaning up after themselves. Pushing people off sidewalks. Cheating on tests, homework, sneering and trying to bullshit their way out of it. Large cheating rings. I've seen so much shit from international chinese students, not kicking them out or punishing them for what they did negatively impacted everyone's college experience, and will continue to dilute the reputation of my degree.
- ken47 11y agoI wish I could downvote this blatant racism.
- elevenfist 11y agoWell, perhaps I should make it clear that this was how the vast majority of international chinese undergraduate and graduate students I encountered behaved. I have a few friends who were kinder, but I'd argue it's a cultural difference where those that I encountered valued human life and fairness far less than I ever expected.
- aidenn0 11y agoMaybe American students have gotten better since I attended college, but when I was there I saw American students do all of those things.
- hackuser 11y agoAnother view of foreign students: Study Abroad as a Path to Equity and Justice https://medium.com/the-development-set/study-abroad-as-a-path-to-equity-and-justice-f5b902e8f13 https://medium.com/the-development-set/study-abroad-as-a-pat...
- hackuser 11y agoThe article says, in many ways, that cross-cultural integration is difficult. But if it wasn't difficult, it wouldn't be an important experience for everyone, foreign and domestic. In other words, the article merely restates the problem. The real question is how to do it more effectively.
- hkmurakami 11y agoIt's like your typical NYT bestseller business nonfiction book: present a problem and explain it well, but not offer any tangible solutions.
- HelloRipley 11y agoI teach Intro to Computer Science to (mostly) economics majors. I currently have four Chinese students (out of 45 total), all of whom go through the right motions. They sit in the front of the class, they ask questions after lecture, etc... The types of things your mother would tell you to do so the professor "knows your name". All four exhibit a significant language barrier. Although... I don't think that is the only thing hampering their performance. I personally know how hard it can be to learn in a different language environment (I took a university class held in Finland and it was tough to say the least). Luckily, it was a math class and I was able to eke out good marks. At the risk of sounding cynical, and not wanting to paint a picture of all Chinese students, I get the vibe from mine that they are really just there to get a degree, not to learn AT ALL. Hey... so are many of my WASPy students, let's not kid ourselves. But it's something about the way my Chinese kids want accommodation solely by going through the motions, as if just showing up to class and sitting up front guarantees you an A. I just don't see the real effort on their behalf.
- debrangy 11y agoDo you have any actual examples of their poor academic behaviour, or are you just speculating? Because it sounds like you're singling them out for being Chinese right now.
- Gustomaximus 11y agoIn Australia international students, a large proportion from China have built a reputation on endemic cheating. There is also culpability on the institutional side as universities allow them through degrees with different set of standards as the uni's appreciate full fee paying international students vs subsidised government paid national students. I met my wife, a foreigner at an Australian uni and she absolutely recognised her preferred treatment as a personal anecdote; A quick Google shows this example article. Many more if you want to research this topic yourself vs imply someone is simply being racist: http://www.smh.com.au/national/education/academics-accuse-universities-of-addiction-to-international-students-and-their-cheating-20141112-11lbdi.html http://www.smh.com.au/national/education/academics-accuse-un... And I get what you're saying, and I'm not trying to tar all international students as doing this. More so it's a good topic to discuss, to stop this behavior and protect the reputation and achievement of those students that do work hard and truly earn their degree and other academic accolades. But at least at Australian universities this is a massively widespread problem, which uni's dont want to seem to deal with and it would not surprise me if this was more international. Edit: Spelling
- graycat 11y agoHow come families in China are able to pay full US tuition in US dollars, with a Ferrari or not? Now China has more rich people than the US?
- SolaceQuantum 11y agoChina has 4x the amount of people as USA. I'm going to assume yes, probably, there are more "rich" people (able to afford a Ferrari for their college student studying in a foreign country) in China than the US. There are more /people/ in China than the US.
- graycat 11y agoBut China is supposed to be a poor country?
- ropiku 11y agoThe average citizen is poorer. That doesn't mean that in absolute numbers there aren't more people who can afford an expensive education.
- skuhn 11y agoChina, like many countries but more significantly than most, has a wealth distribution gap. The richest 1% of the country own 33% of the wealth. Now consider how many people live in China (1.3bn) and how many people fit into that 1% (13.5m). That's a lot of families who can afford standards of living greatly different from the averages in rural China. They may also have various incentives to spend that money outside of China rather than build up local institutions for their children to attend. In theory this cash influx is good for foreign educational institutions, but only if they are smart about the money they take and how they factor it in and spend it. I'm not really convinced they are being smart, but time will tell.
- graycat 11y agoSure, but I was reluctant to conclude that in a Communist, or recently Communist, country the wealth distribution could so quickly be so extreme.
- Cookingboy 11y agoI moved to the U.S. at the age of 14, from Shanghai. Since then I've done a pretty solid job integrating into the American culture (not much a choice, not exactly that many international students in my Dallas suburb high school), got an undergrad degree, made many friends. I now see myself as half American half Chinese. I spend more time on Reddit than I do on Weibo, and I use Facebook a lot more than WeChat. I can still write Chinese business emails and my favorite authors are Jinyong and John Irving. My half-brother, who came to the U.S. at the age of 18, is a totally different story. He's smarter than I am, being a math olympiad competitor and got himself an internship at Google as a Freshman and all that jazz. However I noticed that he's done a much poorer job at integrating with the American culture. He doesn't browse Reddit, or HackerNews, or TechCrunch, even though he's into tech and startups. He loves Anime but watches them subbed in Chinese. He watches Chinese streaming sites instead of Netflix. As a 20 year old he doesn't know most of the popular memes on western social sites. He doesn't use Facebook, at all. Some of that has to do with personal motivation, as in why would I go out and make friends with Americans when 20% of my high school classmates are now in the same Ivy-League school as I am? Some of that is due to technology advancement. Due to the internet it's very easy to live in a personal bubble of your preferred language, culture, and acquiantences, even if it's 10000 miles away from home. He doesn't know whether he even wants to stay in the U.S. after graduation, and I'm sure he literally feels much more at home when he goes back to China. The last factor may also be the state of the Chinese economy. Early immigrants came with the impression that "if you wanna make it, you have to participate in the American rat race", but in the case of my brother and his friends, they are interested in tech startup, but they have very little interest in the Silicon Valley tech scene. Due to family connections and other backgrounds they think they can do something much more meaningful if they move back to China and raise money and achieve success. Just 10 years ago that kind of thought is unthinkable. Personally I don't want to see American colleges, which I think are still on average the best in the world, to just turn into diploma mills. I really wish that these young Chinese students can grasp the opportunity and actually learn about some of the deeper culture of the country they are (temporarily) staying in. The world economy is only going to become more intertwined, we need more people who can bridge the gaps.
- induscreep 11y ago
- ru55 11y agoI've had dozens of Chinese students in my classes and graduate rotations. I'm in a technical field and it's a competitive program, and I don't think I've ever encountered a student who couldn't cut it in terms of doing the rigorous work required. On the whole, my Chinese students have been as good or better than their local peers, which is true of most foreign national students: kids who have busted their asses to navigate the difficult academic, bureaucratic, and cultural hurdles to succeeding in an overseas university are typically self-selecting for aptitude and a good work ethic. That said, I've also found a massively higher level of barefaced cheating, including things like copying and pasting code that previous students had inadvisably put on github, and that after I specifically said I'm aware of the existence of that code and will check for it. Or homework answers that are perfectly correct - if you were answering the homework given to a previous quarter's version of the class, rather than the current version with changes to the specifics. Or looking up answers on smartphones in the middle of a test, and then attempting to ignore the fact that they had been caught. And it isn't just the cheating: it's the indignation when confronted about it. It's almost never denial, but rather something along the lines of "I did this because I have a lot of work to do. Just don't worry about it this time, I won't cheat on the next one." It's especially upsetting because the kids aren't incapable of doing the work, they just seem to think that's it's totally acceptable to cheat their way through classes when they feel like it. While it's no more noble or allowable for kids who are in over their heads and unable to do the work cheat, it's at least somewhat understandable. Cheating out of some combination of arrogance and indifference is far more alien to me. There's a second major problem very specific to Chinese students, that I assume is related to the first: shocking lack of English language skills. I say shocking because these are students who have theoretically scored very high on the SAT or GRE. While I'm in a technical field, we still insist on at least decent verbal scores plus high TOEFL scores for admissions, and yet I regularly get students who have major trouble parsing even very simple written English instructions. I've never noticed the same issue with students from other Asian countries, so I have always wondered if there's some "system" for Chinese students, consisting of either outright cheating on the standardized tests or else some rote memorization techniques that result in acceptable test scores but little-to-no actual English learning. I'm not a crazy outlier in my department, most faculty who aren't either in or hope to be in leadership positions that require lots of under-the-table footsies with the administration have voiced similar concerns. The administration can't get enough of those inflated foreign tuitions, though, so they aren't likely to do anything substantive on the issue. They've tried to do outreach to get the point across that cheating, both before and after entry to the university, is not acceptable behavior, but from everything I've seen it's water off a duck's back. Finally, I'm not some closet racist who wants to bring back the lily white college campuses of the bad old days. As I noted, foreign students are, on a whole, much more studios and less likely to take their education for granted when compared to domestic students. And "on a whole" in this case includes Chinese students! The problem isn't that Chinese students (or students of any nationality) are inherently bad: it's that we are sorely lacking in tools to adequately evaluate them for admissions and to get them to understand and respect academic integrity rules.
- cat-dev-null 11y agoAs a somewhat high-performing student (not necessarily child prodigy but close) in China, how easy/hard is it to get tuition help? Does it require family money/connections (private sources) or are the govt programs which help substantially (public sources)? Are they grants / loans or have other "strings" (obligations) attached?
- strathmeyer 11y agoThe problem is when your university can't find you a job utilizing your degree yet hires foreigners on H1B visas to do such work on campus. How are we supposed to feel about that??
- YeGoblynQueenne 11y agoFull disclosure: I'm a Greek immigrant in an English-speaking country (the UK), working and studying part-time in an English-speaking workplace and university. I parse this article as a very typical pair of complaints: a) There's too many foreigners here. b) Their English is bad. On (a) the population of China is 1.3 billion, the world population is 7.4, so one out of every 7 people on the planet is Chinese. You should expect there to be more foreign people from China than anywhere else, outside China. It should be surprising if there aren't. The same goes for India: its population is 1.2 billion. And, surprise-surprise, you hear the same complaints about Indians, particularly in IT workplaces, but also in universities. Note that because everyone else has less than 1 billion population, there's less than one of every other ethnicity for each Chinese and Indian person, so the stand-out effect is even more pronounced. So, not any serious complaint here, just people who haven't looked at the numbers and think they live in a different historical period where international travel was harder. As to (b) I personally find this distasteful. Everyone else except native English speakers has even worse trouble communicating in English with non-native English speakers, yet you don't hear as many complaints about it. I have trouble getting what Chinese students are saying in English, as they have trouble getting what I say in English. Well, duh. Human communication is a bitch. If there is a God, he's got a lot to account for with the Tower of Babel malarky and whatnot. But listen, this is how communication works: you meet the other person halfway. You have to make as much of an effort to understand what the other person is saying as they have to, to make sure you do. That's true even when you both speak the same language natively. It's amazing -no, it's a bloody miracle- that we can communicate at all. Anyone who's studied human languages is struck dumb by the mind-boggling improbability of it. It's crazy that we can even get our point across with a lot of effort, let along effortlessly. So yeah, quit complaining and just learn to understand what others are saying, in spite of the language barrier. That's what an educated human does.
- Shaanie 11y agoThe difference is that in American universities English is the primary language, and if you can't communicate in English then you shouldn't be attending somewhere where English communication is required. I disagree with your assertion that I should have to make as much of an effort to understand them as they have to, when they are the ones visiting another country. I wouldn't attend a Chinese university without making sure I can effectively communicate in Chinese (or whatever language is used there), and I expect the same courtesy from other people.
- cmuuuuuu 11y agoThis is the most xenophobic thread I've seen on hacker news. A very significant portion of my program is international and we have no problems. Smartest people I've had the pleasure of working with and no barriers.
- Chris2048 11y agoTherefore any conflicting experience at other universities must be incorrect?