15 ms·
Venture Capital’s Answer to High-Priced Housing: Dorms for Grown Ups
- GarvielLoken 11y agoPaywall
- anexprogrammer 11y agoHit the "web" link at top to google and go around paywall
- fblp 11y agoThe links on Google don't go around the paywall. At least on mobils
- withdavidli 11y agoDid for me. On Android, chrome. This is weird. Several times now I have either bypassed the paywall or got hit with it clicking the title link on different posts. Anyone know what's up with this?
- nxzero 11y agoPlease just post the link, thanks.
- rtkwe 11y agoThose have stopped working for me for some reason. On both my personal computer and my work laptop that would be coming out from the company proxy.
- FLUX-YOU 11y agoOpen private browsing window to: http://www.wsj.com/articles/venture-capitals-answer-to-high-priced-housing-dorms-for-grown-ups-1458034201 http://www.wsj.com/articles/venture-capitals-answer-to-high-...
- Apocryphon 11y agoLooks like this article was reprinted already http://www.efinancialnews.com/story/2016-03-15/venture-capitals-answer-to-high-priced-housing-dorms-for-grown-ups http://www.efinancialnews.com/story/2016-03-15/venture-capit...
- anexprogrammer 11y ago"The wager is that 20-something residents moving to new cities will pay a premium" I may be stupid, but how is charging a premium an answer to high prices? Most will do what they've always done - house or apartment share.
- w1ntermute 11y agoThe VC model necessitates throwing things that seem insane but have huge potential against the wall and seeing what sticks. On the off chance that they're right, everyone involved will profit handsomely.
- SixSigma 11y agoGood idea. Bathrooms are under utilized, same for kitchens. But it's a nightmare sharing with people who are strangers without some sort of authority to appeal to for noise / filth / shitty behaviour. EDIT: seems people disagree. Well I've spent 2 years as a mature student living in that exact sort of housing in two different places. One with en-suite and one with shared bathroom. Getting stuff clean and not having noise are constant irritations. Good luck getting the 6 friends sharing a dorm below you to keep the noise down.
- ta0967 11y agoi suspect people disagree with the "good idea" part, not the "nightmare" one.
- SixSigma 11y agothey should try being me
- touristtam 11y agoSure but it is the same challenge that exist with Road Congestion, Public Transport and countless of other services where there is a recurrent rush of influx at precise time. Trying sharing the same bathroom with three other adult working 9-5, whom aren't your friend or family members.
- SixSigma 11y agoYep, that was my point. From experience I would say a room + en-suite bathroom is the only way to stay sane. The grind of the kitchen wears you down. Where I am now my roommate cleans his plate when he is preparing his next meal so there is always one dirty plate on the side in the kitchen. The stovetop always has bits of food on it. One gets tired of saying "Can you not?" because it is petty and you become a pain in the ass. I've stayed in plenty of hostels too. People there will leave what they can get away with but the occasional member of staff is enough to keep things in check. I would be all for this kind of living arrangement if the "can you not" was externalised to an authority figure to whom you could complain anonymously. I also sleep with foam earplugs in. Thank goodness for health and safety at work :) The noise isn't enough to warrant real complaint - just people living and having fun. I guess plenty of people live with that. My actual home is silent so when I'm on the road I notice the bustle.
- zaro 11y agoAnd here is another statement to confirm that no matter what sector VC is "reinventing", "disrupting" or "whatever is the latest buzzword" greed always comes first. I live in 2 km² mansion, but you know guys I have these nice dorms for you to squeeze in...
- forgetsusername 11y agoI'm not usually one to appeal to classism, but it did make me laugh that Mr. Zuckerberg is buying up neighbouring properties around his multi-million dollar mansion, so as not to be disturbed by people in the vicinity. Meanwhile, Facebook employees are jammed into 200 square-foot dormitories.
- pests 11y agoThat is not all the details. Someone wanted to buy and then resell his neighbor's home with a selling point of living next to Zuckerberg. Zuckerberg also rents the houses back to the original owners. http://www.businessinsider.com/mark-zuckerberg-buys-4-homes-for-privacy-2013-10 http://www.businessinsider.com/mark-zuckerberg-buys-4-homes-...
- CaptSpify 11y agoAlso, to be fair, Zuckerberg is likely a high-risk target from a security perspective. Famous and Rich? There's gotta be someone who wants to leverage that
- jsprogrammer 11y ago>Zuckerberg also rents the houses back to the original owners. Sounds like a twisted reverse mortgage scheme where you get to pay rent on your old property as well. Is this what is called financial innovation?
- ChuckFrank 11y agoI work next to their brand new WeLive on Mission in SF. And from where I sit, I see trouble. 1. Similar models are popping up all over the city, including the much more sophisticated Panoramic just up a block. Beds starting at $1500. Yes Beds. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3LI0tqVmGtI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3LI0tqVmGtI 2. They built the Panoramic in the time it took WeLive to do their interior improvements. And when they were working on it, it was just a skeleton crew. The whole time I was thinking ... how are they financing the building? This is insane. 3. WeLive has a main floor common space, where they've had two? events since they opened. Both were modestly attended, but certainly had a college dorm feel to it. Not anything anyone over 30 would be interested in. 4. There appears to be value-added services in the common area, a cafe, a juice bar, etc, but I hardly see it used. 5. They continue to putter around the building, putting a whole new set of scaffolding up, taking it down, putting it up again, doing some painting, taking the taping down, putting it up again, and I wonder ... what on earth are they doing? They had a year to get this right, what's the hold up. 6. Compared to the huge number of apartments going in across the street -- 1900? WeLive is a ghost town. http://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/S-F-planners-back-bold-original-vision-for-6845780.php http://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/S-F-planners-back... (ps. the Trinity has major problems going in to this as well. I see it as a huge bungle for the Planners. But I am waiting to see what the Market Street retail looks like. If it's anything like the Mission Street side, it'll keep that side of Market dead.) So, in short, WeLive is some capital intensive problems, that a lot of smart people are trying to solve, just up the block and across the street, and nothing I see puts WeLive ahead of these guys. Especially when landlords stop leasing to them at .5x, so that they can turn around and dormify the building and get 2x for it. Not with Panorama and Trinity right there.
- ssharp 11y ago> 4. There appears to be value-added services in the common area, a cafe, a juice bar, etc, but I hardly see it used. Value added? Maybe, I guess. It's really just another way to drain more money from the tenants in the name of convenience. Dorm room too small for a coffee maker? Just pay $4 per cup in our handy cafe. I wonder where the threshold is for people who would live in a situation like this. Is living in SF such a necessity? If you're consumed most of the day with your startup to begin with, how much of the city's culture are you really going to take in? Especially if you're in one of these dorms, where they drop a cafe and juice bar right in the building "so you never have to leave!"
- efaref 11y agoPerhaps companies like Apple can get tips on worker dormitories from their business partners in asia: http://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2012/10/inside-foxconn-3-some-dormitories/263900/ http://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2012/10/ins...
- lior9999 11y agoYou mean every single company building electronics in China? "Companies like Apple" includes effectively every single company making electronics at a large scale.
- Retric 11y agoUPDATE: I am hearing from many people in America, "this looks tough." I am hearing from many people who have seen other Chinese factories, "this looks pretty good." More on this too -- and while I'm saving "what it all means" comments for later, I'll say that I've seen enough other Chinese factories, rural schools, villages and so on to recognize that these are on the higher end of the spectrum. It might seem bad, but Foxconn is actually one of the better choices for outsourcing in terms of working conditions. People in the US sometimes chose situations like that simply to send more money home. PS: Or for the extreme version, hot bunking is still a thing for US subs. Where people on different shifts use the same bed. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hot_racking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hot_racking With more than one crew member assigned to a rack, it is possible that a crew member returning from a duty shift will lie down on a rack immediately after it is vacated by another crew member about to start a shift. The rack is therefore said to be "hot", that is, still warm from the vacating crew member's body heat. The term could also apply to individuals who get into the rack right off of duty without showering and smelling like a "hot" mess.
- S4M 11y agoNow I see why VC funded startups don't like to hire remote workers.
- puppetmaster3 11y agoTop comment on the article: FRANK DEUTSCHMANN "Ah, the return of the rooming house - a fitting capstone for the Obama presidency. Yeah, he caused that."
- cafard 11y agoI didn't know the rooming house had gone away, for one thing. For another, this sounds less like the boarding house my father lived in than the group houses my friends I lived in. Obama wasn't born in my father's boarding house days, and I don't think he was out of college when I lived in group houses.
- theinternetman 11y agoCalling this dystopian is giving it too much credit, it's just plain grim.
- knughit 11y agoFunny how people call college dorm living "the best time of your life" but post-college is "grim"
- iamnothere 11y agoThey usually call college "the best time of your life," not dorm living. Most college kids don't stay in dorms past their freshman year, and the ones that do don't have nearly as much fun as the ones who find off-campus accommodations. (Dorms in many schools, especially state schools, often forbid alcohol.)
- themoonbus 11y agoIt isn't that complicated to figure out... it seems pretty obvious to me that people's life priorities change as they get older.
- bjconlan 11y agoThe return of the flophouse... hopefully after the .com-2.0 crash maybe the homeless in SF will have a place to call home again.
- hoodoof 11y agoBut not for the royalty.... err sorry VC's.
- jarman 11y ago>coliving experiments in big cities, targeting young adults I think layman translation of this marketing bullshit is "barrack" http://i.imgur.com/UB56u0G.jpg http://i.imgur.com/UB56u0G.jpg
- talideon 11y agoOr better yet: tenement.
- masklinn 11y agoI don't know, don't tenements generally have "familial unit" rooms? The rooms are shared, but usually not with strangers or on a large scale. Barracks or "worker dormitories" fit better.
- dalke 11y agoI like your "worker dormitories". Alternatives include rooming house, single room occupancy (SRO), flophouse, communal apartment, and cohousing, depending on the details.
- USANEEDSHELP 11y agoSlave quarters
- cheriot 11y agoI've lived in houses with up to 4 other people. When I travel, I frequently use hostels. This sounds like an interesting concept if executed well. The main reason I eventually moved into a two bedroom apartment was more to have a better location and nicer place than to get away from people. How many resources do we waste on underutilized space? The US is more extreme here than any other country I've heard of.
- randomgyatwork 11y agoI've always preferred my own space, even when I lived with 3 other people I was in the basement by myself.
- ilaksh 11y agoReplace suburbs with smaller plots and just accept there is a density limit. Take advantage of video conferencing to merge areas. http://tinyvillages.org http://tinyvillages.org
- cookiecaper 11y agoIn most places, suburbs are not the problem. There is plenty of land open for sprawl and with modern telecommute technologies, there's no need to clog up the roadways with traffic. TinyVillages looks like a well-meaning concept but it neglects the key reasons suburbs exist: people really like having a lot of space to themselves. Things that ignore what people actually want usually don't do well.
- knughit 11y agoPeople are locally rational about preferences, but are horrid at global optimization. That's the root of every social problem.
- 13thLetter 11y agoUnfortunately, having wise thought leaders globally optimize people has a terrible track record.
- ilaksh 11y agoYou are ignoring the big issue of over-priced urban centers. In cities people live in apartments happily. So not everyone needs a large home. There is plenty of room for suburban sprawl, but many cities desperately need an alternative to large houses and suburbs. I have provided it. You and others are not able to recognize it because it is actually a novel idea.
- cookiecaper 11y agoSome people may live in apartments happily forever, but most humans intend to pair off and reproduce at some point or another. Units like this may be suited to the types of people who already live in dorms, but on top of the fact that people prefer to have a lot of space, they're not a good solution to the type of housing that's needed to accommodate most human families over the long term. That means the populations that rent will be transient, making it even less desirable as no real sense of continuity or community history will exist there. Now there are 3 big factors working against it: it's too small to start with, it won't accommodate people as they form families, and because of 1 and 2, it will have a high turnover rate, which makes for disinterested and fatigued neighbors. It doesn't work. As many other commenters in this thread have indicated, this is not a new idea by any means. There are many examples of tiny units and condensed urban spaces all over the world, and they're not popular.
- alanmeaney 11y agoA bit like the problem dating apps have, the more successful you are, the more churn you create. Once a group of friends come together they'll get a house share of their own instead of sharing with strangers. Probably be cheaper too. Have they modeled for high churn rates in their already thin margins? A premium service leaves your very vulnerable to the tide going out on disposable income. The co-living space will be left with higher long term leases they can no longer service. I really want to figure out a way to short services like WeWork at a 16b valuation.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoSpeaking of dating apps, the worst part about dorm life was hearing people have sex or making sure your roommate knows not to walk in when they see a sock on the door. If I were single and working 80 hours a week so my boss's boss can make billions on an IPO while I end up with barely enough to afford a Bay Area house, then maybe I would consider these arrangements for a little while. But instead I have a girlfriend and we value certain things more than money.
- yarou 11y ago> Speaking of dating apps, the worst part about dorm life was hearing people have sex or making sure your roommate knows not to walk in when they see a sock on the door. Wait, what? I always thought the sock on the door was the signal to join in.
- rm_-rf_slash 11y agoThat was if the sock was under the door. You were one of those roommates, weren't you?
- rboyd 11y agoI thought this was going to be about the Draper University of Heroes [1], which looks like a competing space for wantrepreneurs fond of close-quarters living spaces. That one looks even more prestigious, but apparently you also have to take an oath to gain entry. Maybe a great option if you're within the age limit (18-28) and you're long on dreams but short on self-respect. Seriously VCs, what are you guys thinking? These poor kids. [1] http://blog.sfgate.com/pender/2013/07/28/tim-drapers-boarding-school-for-heroes-in-san-mateo/ http://blog.sfgate.com/pender/2013/07/28/tim-drapers-boardin...
- downandout 11y agoUnlike traditional investments in the real-estate sector, which tends to be a slow-growth market with moderate returns, financial backers including Fidelity Investments and consumer-focused venture-capital fund Maveron are betting on hyper-fast expansion and startup-like profit. "Startup-like profit"? So they plan to lose money for as long as investors will continue to write them checks?
- kordless 11y agoIf I had to hazard, the profit being referring to is the type where the company has profit potential on razor thin margins and requires massive cash infusions to grow it to numbers where the margins are substantial and support an exit. As long as those "curves" work for those who have money, their money will flow. I've hypothesized that technology bubbles are created by injecting large amounts of stored work (causality) into a system. Stock market, dotcom bubble, Bitcoin, fuses in your breaker box, etc. In some cases, this stored work allows for the creation of trust channels. These trust channels are not always trustworthy. Consider poker games. I no longer trust VCs because I think their "game" is driven by a very small set of limited partner's desire to make even more money than they already have or need. That they are willing to stuff a whole generation into a dorm on the "ifs and buts" of an exit is ridiculous. This "gotta have more" strategy isn't holistic and isn't scalable. When it pops, it's going to be messy. Bootstrap it. Move home, if you must. Move to to a cheap Asian country and build your dream. Whatever you do, do it with your eyes open and your mind free of dissonance. And remember, profit puts you in charge, not them.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- kordless 11y agoGiven sites have started blocking people from reading the story, even if you Google the title, I think we should stop posting links to them. I can't read the article, and if someone else posts the content here, that's not a tenable solution.
- mstade 11y agoSo, what you're saying is the hippies were on to something? Legalized pot and communal living – what a time to be alive!
- masklinn 11y agoWell the difference is that hippies were interested in communal living for the communal aspect, VCs are because they can't quite go full capsule[0] yet. If these pan out, I expect the next frontier will be capsule TEU[1] on rust buckets in the bay. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capsule_hotel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capsule_hotel [1] http://capsulecontainer.com/capspace.html http://capsulecontainer.com/capspace.html
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- yolesaber 11y agoPeople associated with the hippie movement / sympathetic to its ideals have made massive, massive contributions to the history of personal computing. Check out https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/What_the_Dormouse_Said https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/What_the_Dormouse_Said That being said, both legalized weed and communal living are perfect examples of how counterculture ideas can become co-opted and corrupted by establishment greed.
- acheron 11y agoPeople associated with the hippie movement / sympathetic to its ideals have made massive, massive contributions to the history of personal computing. As the old joke goes, "the two biggest things to come out of Berkeley are LSD and Unix. This is probably not a coincidence."
- yolesaber 11y agoTwo of my favorite things :)
- djb_hackernews 11y agoThis is related to a concept I've been thinking about for a while due to some trends I've seen in Boston. Suppose you work for Acme Co. Acme Co is a multi national conglomerate. - One of Acme Cos subsidiaries operates the public transportation you use to get to work (The commuter trains in MA are operated by a private company) - One of Acme Cos subsidiaries owns the building you live in (this is particularly interesting because the trend in Boston has been for real estate investment trusts to buy up large swaths of smaller multi family homes for their portfolio, homes that were typically used as owner occupied means of wealth generation) - One of Acme Cos subsidiaries is the energy supplier you pay for electricity - One of Acme Cos subsidiaries is the cable company you pay for TV and internet - One of Acme Cos subsidiaries is the insurance company you use for your car/property/health insurance - One of Acme Cos subsidiaries is the charter school network you send your kids to - etc Anyone else see this trend? What's the end game?
- percept 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Company_town https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Company_town
- theklub 11y agoI think there are coal companies that did this at one point. I could be wrong but I think it ended when some people died.
- al2o3cr 11y agoSounds like a "corporate arcology" from science fiction.
- protomyth 11y agoThey might as well build the Renraku Arcology and get it over with. As a bonus, it fits in with the recent AI theme.
- Delmania 11y agoThat we are very bad at remembering our history. Another post mentions the company town. As a resident of Rochester, NY, I can not help but think of the housing developments that were built by Kodak for employees in the company's height. Being completely dependent on a single company like this for everything is not something I'd want to be a part of. Not unless the company had a strong commitment to its employees. My grandfather was a clothes washer repairman for many years, but eventually, his job became obsolete. In today's economy, the company would have "thanked him for his life" and then seen him to the door like a robber. In his case, the company invested in training him for another position. Without a strong commitment, this situation sets up a dependence that reduces a person's ability to handle transitioning when he leaves the company.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- joekrill 11y agoI can't read this article because it's behind a paywall. Does this mean these dorms are owned by the employer in the same way a school owns the dorms that students live in? What happens when the employee is fired/let go? Now they are out of a job AND have no place to live?
- roymurdock 11y agoNo, the dorms are owned and operated by real-estate companies and startups such as Maveron (Common), Stage 3 (Ollie), Open Door, and WeLive. If you click on "web" next to "flag" and "past", you'll be able to access an unpaywalled version of the article by clicking through the first link.
- BatFastard 11y agoInteresting, appears to be exactly the same link. But if you click on the one from the WSJ after clicking on web, you get to read it.
- joekrill 11y agoAh, thanks for the clarification. Clicking through to web doesn't work for me anymore. Even if I open in an incognito window, it won't let me read the whole thing.
- cybette 11y agoIn Finland, there's an initiative called "A home that fits", letting young adults stay cheaply in the homes for the elderly: http://edition.cnn.com/2016/01/21/europe/helsinki-seniors-home-oman-muotoinen-koti/ http://edition.cnn.com/2016/01/21/europe/helsinki-seniors-ho...
- fapjacks 11y agoYes, but that has a decidedly Scandinavian twist of putting young people together with wise village elders. It has a kind of sheen of hopefulness that we just don't see in the States (because -- as clearly demonstrated with this dorm idea -- apparently profit here is worth cramming adults into Soviet-style people storage with value-add juice bars).
- Aeolos 11y agoThis is actually an amazing idea on so many levels. Everyone wins in this model: improved quality of life for the elderly, better housing for young people than they could afford on their own, improved density for city planners, increased social cohesion.
- nathan_f77 11y agoUnbelievable, I had exactly the same idea a few months ago. To live in a retirement home for a year as a young person, and spend time getting to know the residents, while also going to work at a regular job. I thought it could also make an awesome story for a book or a documentary.
- klunger 11y agoThanks to the paywall, I cannot read this article. But, it seems like VC's have rediscovered that cutting edge Victorian technology, the boarding house. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boarding_house https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boarding_house
- ash 11y ago> Thanks to the paywall, I cannot read this article. Click "web" link below this thread title to open up Google search. Then follow the first link.
- bluehazed 11y agoThis doesn't seem to work anymore for a good number of people.
- bbradley406 11y agoI've noticed that it won't work for most sites (for me, in Chrome at least) unless I open the web link in an incognito window. I assume it's related to cookies / referrer in some way
- Eric_WVGG 11y agoI’ve been trying to figure out some kind of way to get out of New England every winter — I have wicked bad seasonal affect disorder, and lack the kind of funds to do a long term AirBnB or hotel. If this is available for short periods, I would totally try it.
- jackcosgrove 11y agoI wanted to live in a dorm after college mainly for the social aspects, but now that I am in my thirties it would be miserable. I care more about peace and quiet, being settled, and privacy than about mobility or socializing. That said I think there's definitely a market for this, although there are apartment buildings in certain cities that are mostly filled with young college grads and I don't see how that's different. If competing on cost, then there's definitely a market for this. I would worry about the safety and quality of such living arrangements, though. Buildings like this were built many years ago called single-room occupancy (SRO) residences. They eventually became havens for vagrants and other hard-luck elements. As a result, SRO residences were outlawed in many cities.
- im_down_w_otp 11y agoUm, most Soviet-era apartment buildings in Russia are setup like this. Many isolated bedrooms sharing a shower-room/bathroom and a kitchen. I have to give it to VC's in the Bay Area. If anybody can take Soviet-style housing arrangements and sell them as "the next big thing", it's these guys. I mean, it's terrible. But it is impressive.
- zavi 11y agoOnly because it's Soviet-style doesn't mean it's bad.
- im_down_w_otp 11y agoIt's not seen as a boon or benefit there. It's how you live when you have no money. Having lived in one, I don't recommend it.
- knughit 11y agoThe dorms are a partial solution, not the problem. Urban living means sense living. The best bet is to go for comfortable dense living.
- rtpg 11y agoYou can have dense apartments with your own bathroom. I guess this is all a bit of a broken record but Tokyo has all the same potential problems as SF (Namely earthquakes), yet somehow has no housing shortage despite being denser. It's all a manmade issue. Accepting this is acting as if there's no reasonable solution of just building normal apartments on more land. But of course that runs into social barriers.
- ethbro 11y ago> I mean, it's terrible. But it is impressive. ... Terribly {im|op}pressive?
- medymed 11y ago
- shoyer 11y agoAnyone else bothered by the misleading chart "Rent as a percentage of income, people age 22-34"? It claims 78% for San Francisco and 65% for New York, which is absurd considering that people pay taxes. I suspect the graphic is really showing the ratio of "median rent in San Francisco" to "median income income in San Francisco for people aged 22-34", which is much less meaningful (though it does say something about how expensive housing is). Does anyone have actual statistics on the percentage of income that young people pay on rent, i.e., "median ratio of rent to income for people aged 22-34 in San Francisco"?
- a_c_s 11y agoAs a percentage of take home pay, those figures are quite plausible at least for NYC. Looks like StreetEasy agrees, putting the figure at 58.4% for all renters: http://streeteasy.com/blog/new-york-city-rent-affordability/ http://streeteasy.com/blog/new-york-city-rent-affordability/
- runamok 11y agoI'd assume it's a percentage of net income. If the median 1 bedroom apartment is $3000 and that is ~80% of net income that means they make $3750 a month which is 45k per year net. Gross would be about 70k. That seems ballpark correct. That means they have $750 a month for food, transportation, school loans, etc. If you don't have a car and your company provides weekday dinner and public transportation it's probably doable but clearly a terrible idea...
- cookiecaper 11y agoHey VCs, I have another idea for you: spread out a little. I'd have to get paid a completely ridiculous sum of money before I'd be willing to move to San Francisco. People are over it. This country is massive and has plenty of open land. The U.S. is the 3rd largest country by land area (behind Russia and Canada), but excepting Alaska, virtually all of our land is quite habitable, something neither Russia nor Canada can say. There is no reason anyone here should be paying $4k/mo to live in a tiny apartment. On top of that, California is one of the worst states for business in the country. There are ~40 states that have a totally untapped pool of resources including people, housing and land and a business-friendly legislature. Get out there and use them. And developers, push back against companies that want to enforce an SV-centric working methodology.
- pcl 11y agoThe U.S. is the 3rd largest country by land area (behind Russia and Canada), but excepting Alaska, virtually all of our land is quite habitable. That got me wondering: where does the US sit if Alaska is excluded? Turns out that Alaska is about 663,000 square miles (or 1.7 million square kilometers), which moves the US from #3 to #5, below China and Brazil. Ranking: http://www.geohive.com/earth/area_top50.aspx http://www.geohive.com/earth/area_top50.aspx Other interesting land area: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_use_statistics_by_country https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_use_statistics_by_country
- ebiester 11y agoThis is always bizarre to me. California is the biggest economy as a state in the country. As such, for as many people say it's "bad for business," there are a lot of businesses choosing it for a destination.
- cookiecaper 11y agoCalifornia is the most populous state in the country; it has about 12 million more people than the next-biggest state (Texas). In general, people aren't really actively choosing it as much as they're either a) already there and using it by default or b) forced to be there to more easily access the market of almost 40 million people that reside there. This is in fact the only reason that California can afford to mistreat business owners -- they have a great deal of leverage. However, tech hubs are draws in and of themselves, and they could easily be located in friendlier states. People will come out to them.
- codeonfire 11y agoThis new idea is old as time https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boarding_house https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boarding_house
- Apocryphon 11y agoIn a better world, micro-units and housing structures like this would be affordable housing for homeless people. Those with means would not have to resort to this, and the needy would be off the streets.
- Semiapies 11y agoHow about sanely responding to price signals by looking for places other than San Francisco and the like to set up shop in? If your response to the situation is this, why should anyone take your business seriously?
- Animats 11y agoThe favelas of tomorrow.
- supergeek133 11y agoEvery time something like this comes up I keep asking.. which will happen first: 1) People with ideas will start refusing to move to that area, because of expense. 2) The capital will FINALLY start seeking other locations where they get more output for their funding. 3) With #2 the capital can come from SF, but allow the company to 'live' outside the valley, or even outside the state. I've been seeing recent articles comparing the dying/aging VC scenes of Austin, Seattle, etc. I just don't get why the head isn't being removed from the sand on this. It feels like when a founder gets funded their first concern is living expenses and food, not "how many people can I hire". It's getting crazy, it's a race to the bottom it feels like.
- eldavido 11y agoI think the endgame here is having the business end of your company near capital/partners/customers and the operational/R&D end in a lower-cost area. I'm all for moving to a lower-cost area, but you can't deny the huge benefits that come from being near hundreds of funding sources and partners that SF/SV of today offers. In time I believe innovation will follow the innovators (not the money guys) but that day isn't today.
- Maro 11y agoThis is already happening for SV startups founded by foreigners/1st gen. It's much cheaper to keep engineering in India or E.Europe, save about 50-75%. I worked at Prezi, founded by Hungarians, and 2/3 of the company is in Budapest, with a smaller office with mngmnt/marketing/finance in SF. I believe GoodData (founder is from Czech Rep. I believe) is doing something similar.
- crispyambulance 11y agoI am skeptical that anyone will "disrupt" the low-cost housing market while make anything remotely close to an ROI that a VC expects. 20-somethings are miserable enough already, no need to commoditize their misery.
- Spooky23 11y agoThis is insane. You could literally live palatially in any of a number of different locales for a fraction of the cost. I probably make half of what I could make in SFO, but my cost of living is 80% less. I've never lived in SFO, but I've visited. It's a really nice place. But not nice enough to need this sort of nightmare. When the economy yo-yos, these will turn into nasty SRO units for crazy/addicted people and blight the neighborhoods. I can't believe the zoning people let this go through. It took NYC years and years to clean these types of units up.
- Laaw 11y agoAnyone have additional/alternative sources for this article? I like to read as many perspectives as possible.
- rogersmith 11y agoEven better startup idea, concentrate people into camps, make them pay with labor pm if you want to be CMO on this one
- dang 11y agoWe've banned this account for repeatedly breaking the HN guidelines. If you don't want it to be banned, you're welcome to email hn@ycombinator.com and give us reason to believe that you'll only post civil, substantive comments in the future.
- rogersmith 11y agoI understand HN needs to be a safe space so people don't get triggered. I will try to refrain from posting anymore opinions that might be contradicting the herd's worldview.
- Apocryphon 11y agoI've always wondered if there's something inherently collegiate to the culture of tech, at least in SV startup culture. The veneration of youth, the alpha geek posturing, religious wars over languages/platforms/methodologies, work benefits being things like onsite bars and foosball tables, and the gender issues. I'm not saying that the media hysteria is accurate, but it seems like for whatever reason, software seems to have more of an arrested development culture than say, electrical engineering. Or other scientific and technological industries. Could it be because software has a lower bar of entry, and with many young programmers starting work during college, right out of college, or dropping out entirely to start their own companies, there's less social development and growth than in other fields? In any case, having dorms be the solution to the housing crisis seems to fit with that college culture.
- fapjacks 11y agoMy personal opinion is that it has to do with the kind of people starting and running the companies (startups) that hire programmers in the first place. Company culture, after all, obeys the law of gravity like most things in a company. And I think it would be a useful exercise to study the source of the culture propagated in the stereotype you mention.
- Apocryphon 11y agoGiven that the last few iterations of the computing revolution (Gates & co. to the Steves for PCs, Page & Brin to Zuckerberg for the web) have been shaped by bachelor university students or dropouts, all of whom embodied the code-until-burnout all-nighter lifestyle, I see what you mean. It's not just the people starting the companies- it's the people who started the fields!
- chtujdd 11y agoWelcome to late stage capitalism, please enjoy your stay! It's truly wonderful how the financial industry makes their money by inflating the price of things we need to live, through the mechanism of speculation, and then turns around to offer dystopian "solutions" like this.
- eldavido 11y agoI think 10 yrs of zero interest rate policy by the Fed has as much to do with it as the "financial industry". I, for one, can't wait for a return to a more normal 2-3% fed funds rate. It'll give pensioners a chance at a reasonable retirement, and bring house prices down a bit, but we won't get it until the fed starts to see a bit of inflation.
- SwellJoe 11y agoI have a wide variety of reactions to this. Some positive, some negative. On the whole, I think it is approaching the problem from the wrong direction. In order of appearance in my brain: 1. So the infantilization (or at least very long childhood) of tech workers, that began with ball pits and video games and three meals a day served in the office, is complete. Tech workers may never become autonomous, functioning, adults at this rate. 2. This sounds kinda nice, actually. But, only for like a week. Then I would hate everyone I share a bathroom and kitchen with. I'm too old for room mates. 3. Oh! That's what's bugging me. Subtle age discrimination. People with families cannot possibly live in these things. People with families cannot possibly afford to live in actual housing in SF. So, older folks are pushed out of valley tech companies, without ever having to make ugly hiring decisions based on age. Younger workers are cheaper and will stay at the office longer hours (probably not more productive by doing so, but that's more difficult to measure). So, yeah, this fits with what I know of the way a lot of VCs think about the problem of tech workers, as cogs in a money printing machine. This is a more efficient cog storage unit that happens to provide additional features, like filtering out older workers and people who want lives outside of work. And, back to why this is approaching the wrong side of the problem: NIMBYs in SF and surrounding high rent areas keep housing prices astronomically high, by preventing construction of dense new housing. All of the valley has single family homes everywhere. Very tall buildings for housing are practically unheard of.
- TTPrograms 11y agoIf younger workers live there then there's less demand for apartments, which should reduce costs for families too. Not that I'd want to live there, but older workers might still stand to benefit.
- Aeolos 11y agoThe demand for apartments would not lessen, given that almost everyone would prefer to live in a real apartment rather than a Nerd Storage Facility.
- e40 11y agoI was thinking the same thing. For the just-out-of-college, it might be a nice thing. For a short while. Save up for a house while you're there and have the benefits of the high density of young people.
- mathattack 11y agoIn Japan's 1980s real estate bubble Corporate Dorms were a thing too. The major difference was that they were company-specific. As long as the locations can be reused for other housing, I'm perfectly happy to watch VCs invest money in the area. More housing stock is good. If investors make money, great. If they lose money, that's part of the risk. If the price point is wrong, the place will go belly up, someone will buy it out of bankruptcy and make a go of it at a lower price point. SF will never have a shortage of young people in dire need of cheaper housing.
- BadassFractal 11y agoModern day SV-style programmers are basically factory workers that exist in really nice conditions.
- pnut 11y agoWhite collar sweat shop.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoMy favorite quote from the story: "Variants include rooming houses, boardinghouses and single-room occupancy hotels, all of which offered housing for new arrivals and others in the working class, often with common facilities like shared bathrooms and in some cases ground-floor dining rooms." Think about that for a moment. This isn't a new idea, it is a recurrence of an idea that existed before when there was a huge gap between the "working class" and the "middle class". Think about all of the variables that make the system work that way, first you have to have a weak enough government that a small number of people can shut down the production of market rate housing, then you have to have a growing income disparity that can "freeze out" and separate the existing housing that spans the gap. If I were a city supervisor I'd see the success of "rooming houses" as a failure of city management.
- Johnie 11y agoNYC recently changed regulations around apartments to allow for Micro Apartments. It reflects the changing demand from millennials (ownership vs rent, suburb vs urban) http://www.nytimes.com/2015/11/22/realestate/leasing-begins-for-new-yorks-first-micro-apartments.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2015/11/22/realestate/leasing-begins-...
- moistgorilla 11y agoI can't wait to live in a tenement with my coworkers and getting my daily rations of soylent and coffee from a dispenser in the wall.
- mason240 11y agoWhen I moved out of home I was renting a small, 1BR basement apartment for $200/mo (in 2002). "Real" 1BR apartments in my area were going for 3x that. I'm pretty lucky in hindsight to have landed that place, there really are not that many basic rentals like that available. Being able to live so cheaply really helped me accelerate my life situation (I wasn't even a student then and was literally starting from nothing).
- nathan_f77 11y ago> to live in what is essentially an upscale college dorm or a retirement home for the young. I take offense at this sentence. The author is criticizing co-living arrangements as if they were only for the young and poor, or the elderly who can't take care of themselves. I think human connection is the key to happiness, and I hate the idea that a responsible adult must live alone, or only with their SO and family. I think living in a community can make life so much better. Whether that's a dorm at college, a retirement home, a coliving space in an expensive city, or an eco-friendly housing project where families live together and share common areas. They're all great. Don't bring in this ridiculous stigma against a new idea, when people living in the suburbs don't even know their own neighbors.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoFor some of us, the dorm life wasn't rainbows and sunshine. We were the ones who moved 'off-campus' as soon as possible. I'm sure there're better arrangements, but once burned twice careful.