8 ms·
I'm always surprised at the lack of enthusiasm for VR and AR on HN. Is there something specific about this vertical that makes it lackluster for this crowd? I
by AndrewKemendo 11y ago
I'm always surprised at the lack of enthusiasm for VR and AR on HN. Is there something specific about this vertical that makes it lackluster for this crowd?
I get cynicism and all that but given how much HN users talk about on demand delivery, CRM tools etc... things that are relatively boring in comparison, and the massive growth in the VR/AR industry I don't get the lack of discussion.
- seivan 11y agoI think Wii is to blame. We were tricked into believing what would be full featured motions ended up just being wiggling your wrist instead of your thumbs. I'm hopeful though.
- duaneb 11y agoIt's not entirely clear how to exploit VR/AR yet—you're asking people to wear dorky headgear for what people perceive as a gaming experience. I kind of view it as gyroscopic controls—weren't they the future? Turns out they're awkward and ill-suited for many types of gameplay.
- georgemcbay 11y ago"It's not entirely clear how to exploit VR/AR yet" Well, other than the obvious, if not often publicly discussed, use (porn).
- duaneb 11y agoI know this is bandied about a lot, but I imagine you'd hit uncanny valley pretty damn fast in a way that's difficult to overcome. I'll believe it when I see the MVP.
- Karunamon 11y agoNot with real porn that's been shot with the right equipment. ..Don't ask how I know this.
- wpietri 11y agoIs there a reason to think this will be a high-revenue use case? Most cinema is about careful, fine-grained control of the viewer's attention, so I think porn has all of the same challenges that movies do. It's just not clear those will translate to a medium where the user has POV control. But I think VR has it worse in a few ways. One, people just don't consume that much porn. I know people who will spend 20-40 hours a week playing video games, so $500-1000 on hardware is not an unreasonable spend. But for porn? Two, previous technologies that have benefited from porn have also increased access. VCRs, DVDs, and home computers made it easier for people to get both a larger volume of porn and access to material suited to their specific tastes. Each has also reduced cost of distribution. VR, though, has to compete with the Internet's existing cornucopia of free and low-cost porn. VR will always have a much smaller and more expensive selection. Three, a bunch of VR distribution will be tightly controlled. You can bet that Sony's not going to be selling any porn, for example. We live in the age of app stores, so I expect a variety of entities to try to control VR distribution channels. If they succeed, it may make VR porn a very small market.
- oliyoung 11y agoPlastic instruments, motion controllers, Power Gloves™ … it could be a fad (I don't think it will be) but I think the collective excitement about a “revolutionary new gaming interface" has been burnt too many times and people aren't buying into it yet. It's also not a hype-train you can really invest in unless you experience it for yourself, and not a whole many people have … yet.
- jdietrich 11y agoWe're in the hype peak between tech demo and consumer release. There's plenty for the gaming news sites to speculate about, but not much of substance to discuss. We know what the Oculus Consumer Edition and the HTC Vive will look like, so we won't learn anything new until they're out in the wild. I believe the general attitude is "we're interested, but we're not going to get too excited until we've got real hardware in our hands and there's some meaningful content available".
- bane 11y agoIn my case: a) neither are new or revolutionary, I've been following VR for literally 20+ years, and it's been around in various forms for decades longer b) despite not being new or revolutionary, real solid use-cases for the technology hasn't really been found outside of "better stereoscopic presentation and head tracking for games" c) lots of the mistakes that were made in the first several rushes to 3d are obviously about to be made again d) to "do it right" (e.g. not using it as a fancy 3d-tv strapped to your head) requires lots of expensive equipment and facilities (space to move around in). People will have to make investments in completely changing not only their computing equipment, but even likely dedicating an entire empty room to the endeavor. e) all the fancy 3d use-cases that aren't in b) above are almost all better handled through existing user I/O schemes an awful lot of the stuff we're hearing sounds like yet another version of Mall Quest (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=94mwUGCkkg0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=94mwUGCkkg0) f) it's expensive, I mean seriously. Unless you're meeting minimum system specs in some way, you're looking at $1000+ minimum buy-in on the low-side. I can buy lots of other entertainment crap for $1000 and probably get better dollar/time ratios. g) it's still incredibly immature. There's at least 3-5 different major incompatible systems bouncing around. To fully participate in all this means costs for f) are x3-x5. It's not that I'm down on it. When I see VR/AR things, I think "that's cool" and think it'd be interesting to play a game for a couple hours (max) in VR-land. VR has always been cool and interesting. But the obvious downsides to the tech far outstrip any conceivable upside.
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoI think the thing that is new is that it's becoming accessible to the masses. PCs and Smartphones were certainly only for the "rich" to begin with but it quickly moved downmarket. This PSVR news is moving that downmarket accessibility faster for VR than happened in the PC market at a minimum. Your other points are spot on though, which is why I (and basically everyone else) thinks that the VR market has a cap, whereas the AR market really doesn't - at least until neural interfaces come along.
- moron4hire 11y agoIf you've been following VR for 20+ plus years, then why do you have no clue what your talking about?
- potatolicious 11y agoI think VR and AR (especially AR) has largely failed to prove why anyone should care. And keep in mind this is coming from someone who backed the original Rift DK and is looking forward to getting the final Rift. There really hasn't been much in VR-land that isn't just a cool tech demo. "Hey you can walk through this virtual world and it's like you're actually there!" - yep, sure is cool, but then what? Both VR and AR are at the stage where we have the technology to make whiz-bang cool tech demos that are legitimately technically impressive, but are not real products the masses actually want. Worse, we know we don't have any real killer applications of this tech, so we're branding a lot of these tech demos as products, which only generates more disappointment in the field. At a previous job we hacked around for a bit with a Google Glass - which isn't real AR, but certainly has similarities. We never could figure out anything real to do with it. Everyone had tons of ideas for cool tech demos, but the only things they accomplished were being cool and making you feel like you're in a sci-fi movie. We could never come up with anything that was truly a lot of value. Right now VR and AR feel like very early motion pictures - I'm talking about the period between its invention and the development of cinema. We're still at the stage where it's a novelty trotted around like a circus act, and curious people pay a penny to view a 5-second loop of something dumb. Motion pictures obviously found a real place with real substance and lasting demand - VR and AR are struggling to do the same.
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoGreat points. It is interesting to me how little "slack" people developing wholly new technologies get. Even among tech people. It ends up being "meh, it's ok but - doesn't work yet" when I would have expected more "I know how I could improve this to get it to my expectations." Quite frankly I think this is due in large part to how much most companies hype it. It's tricky though, because if you don't hype things - anything really, you never catch anyone's attention - and this applies to all things unfortunately. Even wikipedia had a shitload of hype in the early days.
- daheza 11y agoThis is related to an issue I am trying to solve. I want to know if its possible to make an application that will make some task more efficient for people in VR rather than on a 2d screen. I am having difficulty finding ideas that are more involved than just using the space in vr as an infinite 2d screen. Even with an infinite 2d screen though we have issues in vr because text is not very legible. I am at GDC right now seeing if I can get ideas based off the games people are making.
- wpietri 11y agoPersonally, I can't tell yet the extent to which this is a novelty technology. Stereoscopic 3D has a 150-year history [1] of people saying, "This will change everything!" and then being wrong. Maybe this is finally its time, but maybe not. This will definitely sell a bunch of units just because everybody wants to check it out. But I think we still don't know the extent to which this will become useful or necessary. Will this be another Google Glass or Segway, meaning basically a flop? Is it a smartphone in 2002, meaning that it's interesting but will take another couple generations to really find a mass market? Or is this the next color television, where it will pretty quickly become the dominant content and device model? I'm sure full-immersion experience will be something we get to eventually. But if this isn't somebody's first rodeo, they may reasonably question whether this time 3D will really live up to the hype. [1] Truly! E.g., the Brewster Stereoscope, which sold 250,000 units in the 1850s. Or the ViewMaster. Or 1950s anaglyph 3D. Or the VR of the 90s. Or 3D television, which was the next big thing for a CES or two, and has since vanished.
- Balvarez 11y agoThe lack of enthusiasm and vision here is amazing to me. VR will change how we online shop, how we create and visualize models, build architecture, check out far away places, hold teleconferencing, buy homes, watch movies, watch sports and learn. It's going to be big. Gaming is a small tip of the iceberg. VR is going to deliver and it's going to deliver big IMHO.
- Theodores 11y agoApart from 640x480, what has changed for the product since 1995: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YbNUIwi5F6g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YbNUIwi5F6g The new interest in VR headsets has all the same predictions and the same problems. Ultimately it is about creating a new platform, getting the convergence of content, consumer demand and quality product. The people in the above video had a great product and a compelling gaming experience even if not so well demonstrated in the video. But they were unable to create a market for their product. Despite going way beyond 640x480 none of the other problems with the original product have been addressed. Sure things may be lighter, faster, better, however these are incremental improvements on things that were not hard. VR also doesn't cut he mustard for intangible things. For instance, a lot of people like looking at real, actual people, hard that it may be to believe. So you are not going to have a 'cyber bar' or 'cyber library' where people are immersed in VR rather than the world around them. No amount of 'tech' is going to make people that like looking at people (and being looked at) want to wear VR in any social situation. It is tempting to say that the mighty interest from 'newbies' to VR is going to result in everything magically sorted out and for everyone to get the wonders of VR. Whatever Facebook touch turns to gold, right? One can trust that they have the business model that eluded everyone else, plus the perfect timing into the market and the network effects to somehow make VR a day to day essential thing. But no, they still face the same challenges (albeit not 640x480) as were faced in 1995. Creating a wonderful VR headset is one thing, creating wonderful VR games is something else, inventing some must have VR application would be amazing. Even if these things can be done, to create a new platform/content delivery system is something much harder and none of the fundamental UX matters can be resolved.
- AndrewKemendo 11y agoYou know sometimes it's as simple as "a large group of people are ready for it." Whatever Facebook touch turns to gold, right? Except Facebook is less than 1/4 of this market.
- rodgerd 11y ago> I'm always surprised at the lack of enthusiasm for VR and AR on HN. "Less storage than a Nomad. Lame."
- dagw 11y agoI've been attending conferences talking about the awesome applications of VR and AR for 10 years or so and even then it was a 'mature' research topic. I remember playing in a VR-CAVE as an undergrad years before that and listening to presentations about how this technology will be 'everywhere' in just a few years. I've seen (and worked for) companies invest stupid amounts of money in cutting edge setups only to have them collect dust. I'm just fatigued and disillusioned I guess, and just don't really believe any more. Wake me when it is more than a neat, yet niche, gaming peripheral. ...All that being said, I'm definitely planning on buying a VR headset, as a neat, yet niche, gaming peripheral.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoIn VR you are literally strapping a black box onto your face.